| IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA | Not Restricted |
AT MELBOURNE
COMMON LAW DIVISION
S CI 2005 10156
| JOHN MONTCLARE | Plaintiff |
| v | |
| METLIFE INSURANCE LIMITED (ACN 004 274 882) and RIVKIN DIRECT INSURANCE AGENCIES PTY LIMITED (ACN 073 632 292) | Defendants |
---
JUDGE: | GINNANE J |
WHERE HELD: | Melbourne |
DATE OF HEARING: | 4 August 2015 (Written submissions 14 & 21 August 2015) |
DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 16 October 2015 |
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: | Montclare v Metlife Insurance Ltd (No 2) |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2015] VSC 574 |
---
COSTS – Plaintiff’s unsuccessful life insurance claim – Plaintiff successful on some issues – First defendant’s offer of compromise – Offers treated as Calderbank offers – Whether indemnity costs should be ordered – Whether costs orders should be made in respect of issues – Role of second defendant – Whether necessary for second defendant to take part in proceeding – Undertaking by second defendant – Open offer by second defendant – Costs of second defendant – Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005 r26.02
---
APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Plaintiff | Mr P Bingham | Maurice Blackburn |
For the First Defendant | Mr J J Gleeson QC and Mr B Jellis | Norton Rose Fulbright |
| For the Second Defendant | Mr A Cox | Pointon Partners |
HIS HONOUR:
On 25 June 2015, I delivered judgment finding that the first defendant, (Metlife), had established that it was entitled to avoid the contracts of insurance that Citicorp Life entered into with Mr Montclare. I stated that the proceeding was dismissed.[1]
On 4 August 2015, I heard argument about costs and subsequently received written submissions, the last of which was dated 21 August 2015.
Metlife’s submissions
Metlife sought a special costs order against Mr Montclare because he did not accept its offer of compromise dated 22 February 2011 by which it and the second defendant, (Rivkin), jointly offered to compromise the proceeding by payment of $560,000.00 to him. The offer was signed by the solicitors for both defendants. The offer was open for acceptance by Mr Montclare for 14 days after service. It was expressed to be served in accordance with Rule 26.02 of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005.
Metlife sought an order that Mr Montclare pay its costs on a party-party basis until the date that offer of compromise was served and, thereafter, on an indemnity costs basis.
Metlife conceded that r 26(11)(2) in its form prior to amendment in 2013 applied to the offer of compromise. But that rule did not say what the cost consequences were if a plaintiff did not accept the offer and was then wholly unsuccessful in the proceeding. Those are the present circumstances.
Metlife submitted that in those circumstances, the offer should be treated as a Calderbank offer. Authority of this Court[2] supports that approach and I will apply it.
[2]The plaintiff relied on Foster v Galea (No 2) [2008] VSC 331 [6]-[8].
The Calderbank principles were discussed in Hazeldene’s Chicken Farm…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Montclare v Metlife Insurance Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] VSC 574
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether indemnity costs should be awarded to Montclare despite his failure to obtain a declaration on the disability claim, the appropriateness of ordering costs in respect of specific issues, and the necessity of the second defendant's involvement in the proceedings. The court also had to determine if the second defendant's conduct warranted any costs being awarded against it, particularly considering its open offer and undertakings.
The court found that while Montclare did not succeed in obtaining the declaration of total and permanent disability, he was successful on certain issues, such as the invalidity of a non-disclosure clause in the policy. The court deemed the first defendant's offer of compromise as a Calderbank offer, which influenced the costs order. The court held that indemnity costs were not appropriate given the partial success. It also ruled that costs should be awarded in respect of specific issues, considering the nature and importance of each issue. Regarding the second defendant, the court concluded that its involvement was necessary and that it should bear its own costs, as well as contribute to the costs of the first defendant, due to its open offer and undertakings.
The final orders included a declaration that Montclare was not totally and permanently disabled under the policy, but he was awarded costs for the issues on which he succeeded. The second defendant was ordered to pay its own costs and contribute to the first defendant's costs, reflecting the court's assessment of its role and conduct in the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi