Monarch Advisory Group Pty Ltd (in liquidation) v Puxty (Costs)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Monarch Advisory Group Pty Ltd (in liquidation) v Puxty (Costs) [2025] FCA 697

File number: NSD 951 of 2020
Judgment of: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 26 June 2025
Catchwords: COSTS – application for costs to be paid on an indemnity basis – where applicant had partial success at trial – where cross-claimants had partial success at trial – where offer of compromise and Calderbank offer made – whether offeror achieved a more favourable result at trial than the terms of the offer of compromise – application for indemnity costs dismissed – costs awarded on a party and party basis commensurate with success at trial
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 43

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 25.01, 25.14

Cases cited:

Basetec Services Pty Ltd v Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd (No 8) [2017] FCA 258

Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333

Caporaso Pty Ltd v Mercato Centrale Australia Pty Ltd (Costs) [2025] FCAFC 29

Ezy-Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited v Microm Nominees Pty Limited (No 4) [2025] FCA 411

Monarch Advisory Group Pty Ltd v Puxty (No 4) [2025] FCA 534

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 29
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr D Mahendra
Solicitor for the Applicant: Madison Marcus Law Firm
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr V Bedrossian SC and Ms S Erian
Solicitor for the Respondents: Edge Legal Group

ORDERS

NSD 951 of 2020
BETWEEN:

MONARCH ADVISORY GROUP PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)

Applicant

AND:

BRETT JAMES PUXTY

First Respondent

FRANCIS COGGAN

Second Respondent

ODYSSEY ADVISORY SERVICES PTY LTD

Third Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

BRETT JAMES PUXTY (and another named in the Schedule)

First Cross-Claimant

AND:

MONARCH ADVISORY GROUP PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)

Cross-Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

26 JUNE 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The respondents are to pay 60% of the applicant’s costs of the amended statement of claim filed on 4 February 2022.

2.The cross-respondent is to pay 20% of the cross-claimants’ costs of the amended statement of cross claim filed on 27 February 2023.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MARKOVIC J:

  1. On 23 May 2025 I made orders requiring the parties to provide draft orders to my Associate following publication of reasons including on the question of costs.  If the parties could not agree on the form of orders to be made, they were to provide short submissions together with their respective proposed orders: see Monarch Advisory Group Pty Ltd v Puxty (No 4) [2025] FCA 534.

  2. Thereafter the parties provided their proposed orders and submission in support.  The area of disagreement between the parties is in relation to costs of the proceeding.  The parties have agreed that I should determine the questions of costs on the papers.  Accordingly, these reasons…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Monarch Advisory Group Pty Ltd (in liquidation) v Puxty (Cos... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 697
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Monarch Advisory Group Pty Ltd (in liquidation) applied for indemnity costs against Puxty and others in the Federal Court of Australia. The applicant had partial success in the proceeding, while the cross-claimants also achieved partial success in their cross-claim. Both parties made offers of compromise and Calderbank offers, which were not accepted by the other party. The court was required to decide whether the offeror achieved a more favourable result at trial than the terms of the offer of compromise and whether indemnity costs were appropriate under the circumstances.

The court found that the offer of compromise included a term that the cross-claim be dismissed with no order as to costs. However, the cross-claimants enjoyed some success on the cross-claim, so the applicant did not achieve a more favourable result following the hearing on the cross-claim. The court exercised its broad discretion under s 43 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and ordered that the respondents are to pay 60% of the applicant’s costs of the amended statement of claim on the ordinary basis and that the applicant is to pay 20% of the cross-claimants’ costs of the amended cross-claim on the ordinary basis.

The court dismissed the applicant's application for indemnity costs and ordered that the respondents are to pay 60% of the applicant’s costs of the proceeding on the ordinary basis and that the applicant is to pay 20% of the cross-claimants’ costs of the cross-claim on the ordinary basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondents are to pay 60% of the applicant’s costs of the amended statement of claim filed on 4 February 2022.

2. The cross-respondent is to pay 20% of the cross-claimants’ costs of the amended statement of cross claim filed on 27 February 2023.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Thirdly, the offer of compromise included a term that the cross claim be dismissed with no order as to costs. In fact, the cross claimants enjoyed some success on the cross claim so that Monarch did not achieve a more favourable result following the hearing on the cross claim.CONCLUSION It follows from the above that the respondents are to pay 60% of Monarch’s costs of the proceeding on the amended statement of claim on the ordinary basis and that Monarch is to pay 20% of the cross claimants’ costs of the amended cross claim on the ordinary basis. I will make orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As to its claim for costs, Monarch submits that, notwithstanding that it did not press its claims under the Australian Consumer Law, being Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (ACL) and its claims under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the relevant facts giving rise to those claims were the same as those relied on by it in relation to the claim on which it was successful. They contend that the claims that were not pressed were substantially legal arguments that arose from the same factual substratum and, to the extent that other facts may have supported those claims, they were of no material significance. In support of that submission, Monarch relied on an analysis of the affidavits filed by the parties which categorised the evidence by reference to the issue to which it went. The result of that analysis was that the evidence was either for background, concerned the restraint clauses in the employment agreements between Monarch and each of Messrs Puxty and Coggan, concerned the issue of consent raised by the respondents by way of defence and cross claim or went to damages. Monarch submits that on any proper analysis of the evidence, submissions and time taken at the trial it is abundantly clear that the focus of the proceeding was on Monarch’s primary claim that Messrs Puxty and Coggan had breached the restraint clauses in their respective employment agreements with Monarch. It contends that Odyssey did not take any active role in the proceeding in that the respondents relied on evidence given by Messrs Puxty and Coggan and Odyssey was simply their alter ego. Monarch submits that the vast majority of the proceeding was focussed on two issues: first, the respondents’ contention that Monarch had consented to Mr Puxty continuing to service a group of clients; and secondly, the reasonableness of the restraints. It says that it was successful on both issues. In relation to the cross-claim, Monarch submits that the primary focus of that claim was Mr Puxty’s contention that an agreement had been reached that he would be entitled to take back those clients he had referred to Monarch if the arrangement with Madison Marcus did not eventuate, an issue which had a significant overlap with the first issue referred to in the preceding paragraph, and on which the cross-claimants did not succeed. It was not in dispute that ordinarily costs follow the event. Applying that rule, I would make an order that the respondents pay Monarch’s costs of the proceeding and that Monarch pay the cross claimants’ costs of the cross claim. However, s 43 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) confers a broad discretion on the Court in relation to costs, which is not subject to any limitations and is only confined to the extent that the subject matter, scope and purpose of the Federal Court Act indicates otherwise and by the obligation imposed by s 37M(3) of the Federal Court Act to exercise the power in a way that best facilitates the just resolution of disputes according to law and as quickly, inexpensively and efficiently as possible: see Caporaso Pty Ltd v Mercato Centrale Australia Pty Ltd (Costs) [2025] FCAFC 29 (Katzmann, Wheelahan and Hespe JJ) at [16].