Mohr-Edgar v Legal Aid Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

INDUSTRIAL COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Mohr-Edgar v Legal Aid Queensland [2023] ICQ 025

PARTIES:

SANDRA MOHR-EDGAR

(appellant)

v
LEGAL AID QUEENSLAND

(respondent)

FILE NO:

C/2020/20

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

DELIVERED ON:

1 November 2023

HEARING DATE:

5 and 9 February 2021

MEMBER:

Davis J, President

ORDERS:

1.    Within 14 days, the respondent produce to the appellant:

(a)  a copy of any written submissions made by it in review ER 314484;

(b)  a copy of preliminary assessment ER 314609.

2.    Within 14 days, the respondent shall file and serve upon the appellant an affidavit sworn by a responsible officer of the respondent deposing to whether the following records are in the possession or control of the respondent:

(i)   Internal calls received on 8 May 2018 by Jessica Dean from Nicky Davies or any Legal Aid HR staff member.

(ii)  Calls on 9 May 2018 between Jessica Dean and Lyndi Hawkings-Guy between 8.30 am and 10.00 am.

(iii) Calls on 8 October 2018 between Jessica Dean and Lyndi Hawkings-Guy from 12.00 pm until 8.45 am on 9 October 2018

3.   The appeal is otherwise dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES – DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS – where the appellant made claims against her employer and other employees of discrimination – where the complaints were referred to the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (QIRC) – where the appellant sought disclosure against Telstra – where the appellant sought disclosure against the employer – where some disclosure was given by the QIRC – where some disclosure was refused –  where the appellant appealed against the refusal – whether documents were relevant to the appellant’s claims – whether disclosure should otherwise be given

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, s 164A, s 166
Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 407, s 424, s 557, s 558, s 563, s 564, s 565, s 566, s 567
Industrial (Tribunals) Rules 2011, r 46, r 58, r 64B
Legal Aid Queensland Act 1997, s 41

CASES:

Allesch v Maunz (2000) 203 CLR 172; [2000] HCA 40, cited
Application by Brenda Atkinson to search and take copies of documents [2001] ICQ 30; (2001) 167 QGIG 182, cited
CDJ v VAJ
(1998) 197 CLR 172; [1998] HCA 67, cited
Coal and Allied Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Industrial Relations Commission (2000) 203 CLR 194; [2000] HCA 47, cited
Dhanhoa v The Queen (2003) 217 CLR 1; [2003] HCA 40, cited
DJL v Central Authority (2000) 201 CLR 226; [2000] HCA 17, cited
Hawkins Road Transport Pty Ltd v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia, Union of Employees [1999] QIC 20; 161 QGIG 108, cited
Mercantile Mutual Custodians Pty Ltd v Village/Nine Network Restaurant & Bars Pty Ltd [2001] 1 Qd R 276; [1999] QCA 276, followed
Mohr-Edgar v State of Queensland (Legal Aid Queensland) (No 2) [2020] QIRC 185, related
NQEA Australia Pty Ltd v Dare (No 2); NQEA Australia Pty Ltd v Dare (No…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mohr-Edgar v Legal Aid Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ICQ 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mohr-Edgar v Legal Aid Queensland concerned a claim for discrimination brought by Mohr-Edgar against her employer, Legal Aid Queensland, and other employees. The dispute reached the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (QIRC), which was tasked with overseeing the discovery process. Mohr-Edgar sought access to certain documents held by Legal Aid, including internal communications and call records, which she argued were relevant to her claims. The QIRC granted some disclosure but refused others, leading Mohr-Edgar to appeal the refusals. The legal issues before the court were whether the documents in question were relevant to the appellant's claims and whether disclosure should be granted. The court found that while the appeal was limited to errors of law or jurisdiction, the Industrial Commissioner's determination regarding Legal Aid's possession of certain documents stood. The court ordered Legal Aid to produce specific documents and to file an affidavit confirming the existence of certain call records. The appeal was otherwise dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 14 days, the respondent produce to the appellant:

(a) a copy of any written submissions made by it in review ER 314484;

(b) a copy of preliminary assessment ER 314609.

2. Within 14 days, the respondent shall file and serve upon the appellant an affidavit sworn by a responsible officer of the respondent deposing to whether the following records are in the possession or control of the respondent:

(i) Internal calls received on 8 May 2018 by Jessica Dean from Nicky Davies or any Legal Aid HR staff member.

(ii) Calls on 9 May 2018 between Jessica Dean and Lyndi Hawkings-Guy between 8.30 am and 10.00 am.

(iii) Calls on 8 October 2018 between Jessica Dean and Lyndi Hawkings-Guy from 12.00 pm until 8.45 am on 9 October 2018

3. The appeal is otherwise dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Firstly, while there is power to admit fresh evidence,[13] the appeal is limited to grounds of error of law or jurisdiction.[14] As observed in Turay v Workers’ Compensation Regulator:[15]“[52] Construing the 2016 IR Act as a whole, and giving meaning to all provisions,[16] s 567 provides that when the Court is hearing grounds of appeal limited to errors of law or jurisdiction,[17] the Court receives the record below and any further evidence by leave. Receipt of the evidence is for the purpose of discerning error of law or jurisdiction, not for determining whether factual findings were soundly made, and not for determining whether inferences which were drawn were open.” (emphasis added)[13]Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 567(2).[14]Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 557(1).[15][2023] ICQ 013.[16]Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355 at [69].[17]Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 557(1). The Industrial Commissioner found that Legal Aid did not have the document. There is presently no evidence to the contrary. At best, if the new evidence is accepted on appeal, there is a prospect that at some point some evidence may be discovered which contradicts Legal Aid’s assertion that they do not have the document. If such evidence emerges, then (subject to relevance, which I need not decide now) Ms Mohr-Edgar might seek further disclosure. Such evidence will not show that the QIRC erred. It acted on the evidence before it. In the meantime, the new evidence is not relevant to any issue on appeal in relation to the documents in categories a. and b. Its admission should not be allowed. Further, as the finding that Legal Aid does not have the document is not one that can be disturbed on appeal, the Industrial Commissioner’s determination must stand. Document c. - Legal Aid’s submissions in review ER 314484 By application lodged with Legal Aid on 17 December 2018, Ms Mohr-Edgar sought access to documents held by Legal Aid. A decision notice in response to that application was given to Ms Mohr-Edgar on 7 February 2019. A review of that decision was sought. In the course of that review, both Ms Mohr-Edgar and Legal Aid made submissions. The external review became known as ER 314484. In her attendance notice to produce, Ms Mohr-Edgar sought production of various documents the subject of ER 314484. She now only seeks production of the submissions made by Legal Aid on the review. It was common ground before the QIRC and on appeal that the Legal Aid response is likely to include an explanation of the subject matter of the communication of 9 May 2018. In the investigation of Ms Mohr-Edgar’s complaint, Legal Aid maintain that the subject matter of any conversation on 9 May 2018 was in relation to client files. Ms Mohr-Edgar says that it was a conversation about moving her. In the QIRC, the notice was set aside as regards the documents sought in relation to ER 314484. This was for two reasons:1.The request was too wide and therefore was a “fishing expedition”.[18]2.The documents were not relevant to a fact in issue.[19][18]Mohr-Edgar v State of Queensland (Legal Aid Queensland) (No 2) [2020] QIRC 185 at [71] and [76].[19]At [69]-[74].

Decision

Reasons for decision

I shall order that within fourteen days a responsible officer of Legal Aid shall swear and file an affidavit deposing to whether the following records are in the possession or control of Legal Aid:1.Internal calls received on 8 May 2018 by Jessica Dean from Nicky Davies or any Legal Aid HR staff member.2.Calls on 9 May 2018 between Jessica Dean and Lyndi Hawkings-Guy between 8.30 am and 10.00 am.3.Calls on 8 October 2018 between Jessica Dean and Lyndi Hawkings-Guy from 12.00 pm until 8.45 am on 9 October 2018.Conclusions and orders Ms Mohr-Edgar has had partial success and should obtain orders. Otherwise, the appeal ought to be dismissed. It is ordered:1.Within 14 days, the respondent produce to the appellant:(a)a copy of any written submissions made by it in review ER 314484;(b)a copy of preliminary assessment ER 314609.2.Within 14 days, the respondent shall file and serve upon the appellant an affidavit sworn by a responsible officer of the respondent deposing to whether the following records are in the possession or control of the respondent:(i)Internal calls received on 8 May 2018 by Jessica Dean from Nicky Davies or any Legal Aid HR staff member.(ii)Calls on 9 May 2018 between Jessica Dean and Lyndi Hawkings-Guy between 8.30 am and 10.00 am.(iii)Calls on 8 October 2018 between Jessica Dean and Lyndi Hawkings-Guy from 12.00 pm until 8.45 am on 9 October 2018.3.The appeal is otherwise dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established