FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Modh v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs
[2000] FCA 1865MIGRATION – test whether relocation not prevented by Convention reason is an error of law
Franco-Buitrago v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 1525
Perampalan v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (1999) 84 FCR 274
Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259RAHUL KUMAR MODH v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
N 1151 OF 2000GYLES J
SYDNEY
18 DECEMBER 2000
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
N 1151 OF 2000
BETWEEN:
RAHUL KUMAR MODH
APPLICANTAND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENTJUDGE:
GYLES J
DATE OF ORDER:
18 DECEMBER 2000
WHERE MADE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal made on 16 October 2000 be set aside and remitted to that Tribunal to be dealt with according to law.
2.Respondent pay costs of the applicant.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
N 1151 OF 2000
BETWEEN:
RAHUL KUMAR MODH
APPLICANTAND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT
JUDGE:
GYLES J
DATE:
18 DECEMBER 2000
PLACE:
SYDNEY
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
This is an application for an order of review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), which, on 16 October 2000, affirmed the decision of the delegate of the respondent, the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, to refuse an application for the grant of a protection visa. The application as filed did not contain any particulars. On about 8 December 2000 the respondent’s solicitor (and my associate) received from counsel, who had given some advice to the applicant, a proposed amended application and submissions. The applicant, who appeared unrepresented, adopted what had been forwarded by counsel. The respondent does not consent to the amendment proposed, but does not put forward any prejudice if it is granted. In these somewhat unusual circumstances, I granted leave to amend the application in accordance with the draft included in MFI 1 and the argument proceeded on that footing. I also indicated that I would have regard to the submissions which had been forwarded as, in effect, those of an amicus. My acquiescence in what has occurred in this case should not be taken as any precedent for the future.
The grounds of the amended application are as follows:
“1. In making the decision the subject of this application, the procedures that were required by s 430 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) to be observed in connection with the making of the decision were not observed, which constituted a reviewable error under s 476(1)(a) of the Act.
Particulars
(a)The Tribunal failed to make a finding about whether the Applicant was unable to relocate to other parts of India because his father would require him to work…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Modh v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] FCA 1865
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the Tribunal did not adequately address the issue of relocation within India, as it failed to make a finding about whether the applicant was unable to relocate due to his father's expectation that he would work in the family grain business. The court held that the Tribunal's reasoning on this issue was flawed because it incorrectly stated that the reasons for being unable to relocate must "link the applicant's claim to the Convention." The court further held that the Tribunal erred in its interpretation of the law when it considered the applicant's fear of persecution, stating that it was not sufficient to find that the protection offered was on a non-discriminatory basis; there must also be a positive finding that there are mechanisms capable of offering protection at all. Given these errors, the court concluded that the decision should be set aside and remitted to the Tribunal for reconsideration, ensuring that the separate questions for consideration were correctly addressed. The court also ordered that the respondent pay the costs of the applicant.
The final orders of the court were that the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal made on 16 October 2000 be set aside and remitted to that Tribunal to be dealt with according to law. Additionally, the respondent was ordered to pay the costs of the applicant. The court's decision highlights the importance of correctly addressing and interpreting the relevant legal principles in refugee status determinations, particularly in relation to issues such as relocation and state protection.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal made on 16 October 2000 be set aside and remitted to that Tribunal to be dealt with according to law.
2. Respondent pay costs of the applicant.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: GYLES J
The grounds of the amended application are as follows:“1. In making the decision the subject of this application, the procedures that were required by s 430 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) to be observed in connection with the making of the decision were not observed, which constituted a reviewable error under s 476(1)(a) of the Act.Particulars(a)The Tribunal failed to make a finding about whether the Applicant was unable to relocate to other parts of India because his father would require him to work in the family grain business.(b)The Tribunal failed to make a finding about whether there had been a sustained or systematic failure of state protection in relation to Muslim-Hindu clashes in the Applicant’s state, nor whether any lack of protection was such as to indicate that India was unable or unwilling to discharge its duty to establish and operate a system for protection against persecution.2. The decision involved an error of law, being an error involving an incorrect interpretation of the applicable law.Particulars(a)The Tribunal, in considering whether the Applicant was able to relocate within India rejected his reasons for being unable to relocate (or some of them) on the basis that those reasons “do not link the applicant’s claim to the Convention”. This involved an error of law. It is not part of the test for whether a person can reasonably relocate that each reason that prevents such relocation is a Convention reason.(b)The Tribunal, in considering whether the Applicant had a well-founded fear of persecution, considered that his fear was not well-founded because there “is no reason the authorities will not offer the applicant the same protection they offer any other citizen of India”. This is the wrong test. It is not sufficient to find that the protection offered is offered on a non-discriminatory basis; there must also be a positive finding that there are mechanisms capable of offering protection at all.”It will be seen that there is a symmetry between the particulars of each ground. The applicant, who is of the Hindu faith, fears that if he has to go back to his home in India he will be subject to violence between the Hindu and Muslim communities. He comes from a town in Gujrab state where, apparently, the ratio of Hindu to Muslim is 50:50 and the police consist of representatives of each. The applicant’s father is a prominent businessman, and a member of the Hindu community in his home town. RELOCATION The Tribunal held that, even if the applicant’s claims are accepted:“… even if rioting occurs in his home town other parts of India are relatively peaceful, especially for a person like the applicant who is part of the large Hindu majority in India.Persons, like the applicant, who have the means to travel to Australia and are young, mobile, single, with work experience in Australia and healthy, can live in Mumbai, Calcutta, Delhi or other Indian destinations. Such destinations are feasible, at least as temporary havens, until the tensions in the home town subside. The applicant speaks Hindi, the language of the majority in India and some English as well as his regional language. I am satisfied that he will not encounter serious harm for a Convention reason in living elsewhere in India. He found work in Australia without apparent difficulty. The applicant is educated and his qualifications are easily transportable in India. He transferred university without difficulty and there is no Convention restriction of his ability to relocate to his new university town or any other place. My findings are supported by the fact that when away from home as a student he did not encounter any difficulty in other parts of India.The applicant claims he is not talented, has no work experience in India and that he has no money so it would be too difficult for him to set himself up in India. The applicant claims he will be required by his father to work in the family grain business and this is a further reason he cannot relocate to another part of India. However, these reasons do not link the applicant’s claim to the Convention. I am satisfied that he will not encounter difficulty upon return to India for any Convention reason.I am satisfied relocation is a reasonable and feasible option for the applicant. I do not accept that he is at risk in every part of India or [sic] do I accept that the applicant will face persecution for a Convention reason should he relocate. I am satisfied that any chance of harm if the applicant is away from his home town is remote. I am satisfied that he would only come to harm in Hindu Muslim violence if he was in the wrong place at the wrong time and as such his fear of persecution is not well-founded.” (emphasis added)