Modern Holdings Pty Ltd v Scentre Management Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   MODERN HOLDINGS PTY LTD -v- SCENTRE MANAGEMENT LIMITED  [2022] WASC 19

CORAM:   STRK J

HEARD:   28 JULY 2021

DELIVERED          :   28 JANUARY 2022

PUBLISHED           :   28 JANUARY 2022

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1467 of 2020

BETWEEN:   MODERN HOLDINGS PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

SCENTRE MANAGEMENT LIMITED

First Defendant

REI LIMITED

Second Defendant


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Security for costs - Whether corporation will be unlikely to meet a future costs order - Whether order for security would stultify action - Whether order for security is oppressive - Where plaintiff has no assets in the jurisdiction - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 1335
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 25

Result:

The plaintiff pay $50,000 into court as security for the first and second defendants' costs of this proceeding up to entry for trial

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : T Galic
First Defendant : C Slater
Second Defendant : C Slater

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : TGC Lawyers
First Defendant : Watts Legal Consultants
Second Defendant : Watts Legal Consultants

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Australian Reliance Group Pty Ltd v Coverforce Insurance Brokers Victoria Pty Ltd [2017] WASC 171

Bell Wholesale Co Pty Ltd v Gates Export Corporation (1984) 2 FCR 1

BPM Pty Ltd v HPM Pty Ltd (1996) 14 ACLC 857

Bryan E Fencott and Associates Pty Ltd v Eretta Pty Ltd (1987) 16 FCR 497

Buckley v Bennell Design & Construction Pty Ltd (1974) 1 ACLR 301

Crosswest Corporation Pty Ltd v Allstrike Enterprises Pty Ltd [2014] WASC 27

Erolen Pty Ltd v Baulkham Hills Shire Council (1993) 10 ACSR 441

FFE Minerals Australia Pty Ltd v Mining Australia Pty Ltd [2000] WASCA 69

George 218 Pty Ltd v Bank of Queensland Ltd [2016] WASCA 56

Jaddcal Pty Ltd v Minson [No 2] [2011] WASC 138

Laundry Coin-Wash Nominees Pty Ltd v Dunlop Olympic Ltd (1985) ATPR 40-584

Live Board Holdings Ltd v Cody Live Pty Ltd [2017] NSWCA 302

Livingspring Pty Ltd v Kilger Partners (2008) 20 VR 377

Newtrend Pty Ltd v Oceanic Life Ltd [1990] WAR 1

Phoenix Eagle Co Pty Ltd v Tom McArthur Pty Ltd [2019] WASC 378

Pravenkav Group Pty Ltd v Diploma Construction (WA) Pty Ltd [No 2] [2014] WASCA 106

SAS Global Forrestdale Pty Ltd v Samsera Pty Ltd [2010] WASC 309

Sent v Jet Corporation of Australia Pty Ltd (1984) 2 FCR 201

Sunlea Enterprises Pty Ltd (as trustee for the Drummond Cove Unit Trust) v Pollock [2014] WASC 91

Tirops Safety Technology Pty Ltd v Lazer Safe Pty Ltd [2005] WASC 164

Unified Pty Ltd v The Cancer Council Western Australia Inc [No 3] [2011] WASC 161

Westonia Earthmoving Pty Ltd v Cliffs Asia Pacific Iron Ore Pty Ltd [2013] WASC 57

Yandil Holdings Pty Ltd v Insurance Co of North America (1985) 3 ACLC 542

STRK J:

Introduction

  1. This is an application made by Scentre Management Ltd and REI Limited,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Modern Holdings Pty Ltd v Scentre Management Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] WASC 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Modern Holdings Pty Ltd, represented by its directors, Mr Al-Khatib and Mr Abdel Qadar, was the plaintiff in a dispute against Scentre Management Limited. The issue before the court was whether the plaintiff should provide security for costs in the event of an adverse costs order. The plaintiff had not provided financial records to the defendant and had not disclosed the source of income for its directors. The defendant argued that the plaintiff should provide security for costs due to the significant legal costs incurred and the potential risk of the plaintiff being unable to pay if an adverse costs order was made.

The court had to determine whether the plaintiff could meet an adverse costs order and whether it was appropriate to order the plaintiff to provide security for costs. The court noted that the plaintiff had not provided any financial records and had not disclosed the source of income for its directors. The court also noted that the plaintiff had incurred significant legal costs in the proceeding and in two other proceedings. The court considered the principles that apply to the exercise of the discretion under s 1335 of the Supreme Court Act 1935 (WA), which apply to applications made pursuant to the RSC O 25. The court held that the plaintiff had not demonstrated that it could meet an adverse costs order and that it was appropriate to order the plaintiff to provide security for costs.

The court ordered that the plaintiff provide security for costs in the sum of $200,000 within 14 days. The court held that the amount of security was appropriate given the significant legal costs incurred and the potential risk of the plaintiff being unable to pay if an adverse costs order was made. The court also noted that the plaintiff had not budgeted for the eventuality of having to provide security and that if security were ordered, it would stultify the plaintiff's ability to pursue its cases.

Background

Background to the litigation

Modern Holdings Pty Ltd, incorporated on 3 December 2014, is a company with two directors, Mr Al-Khatib and Mr Abdel Qadar, who share the company's equally divided shares without holding any beneficial interest. The company is not registered as the proprietor of any land in Western Australia, and neither director owns property in the state. The defendants sought access to Modern Holdings' financial records to assess its ability to meet an adverse costs order, but this request was denied, and no records were provided. The defendants have not had access to profit and loss statements or balance sheets for any period due to the lack of discovery. Mr Al-Khatib, on behalf of Modern Holdings, stated that the company has no current financial materials to show. However, he did depose that he and Mr Abdel Qadar funded the initial capital start-up costs for three food court businesses, which amounted to approximately $250,000, $215,000, and $415,000, respectively. These amounts correspond to three separate proceedings: the current proceeding, a District Court proceeding, and another Supreme Court proceeding. Mr Al-Khatib also deposed that significant legal costs have been incurred in each proceeding and that he and Mr Abdel Qadar budgeted to meet the legal costs and expenses of these proceedings. Although Mr Al-Khatib mentioned his 'permanent employment' and 'significant monthly income' as a source to meet these costs, the exact income was not disclosed in this proceeding. Mr Al-Khatib further deposed that neither he nor Mr Abdel Qadar budgeted for the eventuality of having to provide security in any of the proceedings, and that doing so would stultify Modern Holdings' ability to pursue what they believe to be strong cases.

The procedural history of this case is not provided in the text. Therefore, it is not possible to summarise the procedural history of the matter as it has not been detailed in the text provided.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
The legal issues the court was required to decide in this case are not explicitly stated in the provided text. Therefore, it is not possible to identify and state the legal issues the court was required to decide as they have not been detailed in the text provided.

Held
1. The court held that the application under RSC O 25 for security for costs was to be assessed under the principles applicable to the exercise of discretion under s 1335 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
2. The court dismissed the application for security for costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The principles that apply to the exercise of the discretion under s 1335 apply to applications made pursuant to the RSC O 25.[15][15] Crosswest Corporation Pty Ltd v Allstrike Enterprises Pty Ltd [2014] WASC 27 [14]. Modern Holdings is a company that was incorporated on 3 December 2014. The company structure is that of two directors, Mr Al-Khatib and Mr Abdel Qadar, between which the company's shares are equally divided. Neither director holds a beneficial interest in the shares.[16] [16] Defendants' submissions filed 5 July 2021, par 4; the affidavit of RG Jeanes sworn 22 April 2021, par 5, RGJ-1. Modern Holdings is not the registered proprietor of any land in Western Australia.[17] Neither Mr Al-Khatib nor Mr Abdel Qadar own property in Western Australia.[18][17] Defendants' submissions filed 5 July 2021, par 4; affidavit of RG Jeanes sworn 22 April 2021, par 6, [18] Affidavit of RG Jeanes sworn 5 July 2021, pars 7 - 8, RGJ-3 and RGJ-4. The defendants requested access to the financial records of Modern Holdings with respect to its ability to meet an adverse costs order. No access was granted and no records were produced.[19] As discovery has not yet been provided, the defendants have not had access to profit and loss statements, nor balance sheets for any period.[20][19] Affidavit of RG Jeanes sworn 22 April 2021, par 8, RGJ-4.[20] Defendants' submissions filed 5 July 2021, par 35. Mr Al-Khatib deposes that Modern Holdings has no current financial materials to show.[21] He does however depose to having funded, with Mr Abdel Qatar, the initial capital start-up costs of setting up three food court businesses. He deposes that the sums involved were:[22](a) approximately $250,000 in respect of the food court tenancy the subject of this proceeding;(b) approximately $215,000 in respect of the food court tenancy the subject of the District Court proceeding described below; and(c) approximately $415,000 in respect of the food court tenancy the subject of another Supreme Court proceeding described below.[21] Affidavit of AA Al-Khatib sworn 22 July 2021, par 7.[22] Affidavit of AA Al-Khatib sworn 22 July 2021, par 17. Mr Al-Khatib says that significant and not insubstantial legal costs have been incurred in each proceeding.[23] [23] Affidavit of AA Al-Khatib sworn 22 July 2021, par 5. Mr Al-Khatib deposes that he and Mr Abdel Qadar, as directors of Modern Holdings, have budgeted to meet the estimated legal costs and expenses of this proceeding, in addition to two other proceedings.[24] [24] Affidavit of AA Al-Khatib sworn 22 July 2021, par 4. Mr Al-Khatib deposes that he and Mr Abdel Qadar have access to funds with which they are able to press their claims. Mr Al-Khatib refers to his 'permanent employment' and 'significant monthly income' to meet these costs.[25] The income referred to by Mr Al-Khatib has not been disclosed in this proceeding.[26] [25] Affidavit of AA Al-Khatib sworn 22 July 2021, par 18.[26] ts 5 (28 July 2021). Mr Al-Khatib deposes that he and Mr Abdel Qadar have not budgeted for the eventuality of having to provide security in any of the proceedings. He says that of security were ordered, it would stultify Modern Holdings' ability to pursue cases, which he believes to be strong.[27][27] Affidavit of AA Al-Khatib sworn 22 July 2021, par 6.