CITATION: Mobileciti Pty Limited v Vodafone Pty Limited [2009] NSWSC 891 HEARING DATE(S): 25 and 26 August 2009 JURISDICTION: Equity Division JUDGMENT OF: Hamilton AJ EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 26 August 2009 DECISION: Business records rejected under s 135 of the Evidence Act 1995 CATCHWORDS: EVIDENCE [23] – Admissibility and relevancy – in general – other cases – Judicial discretion to exclude – Evidence Act 1995, s 135 LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act 1995, ss 69, 135, 136, 137 CATEGORY: Procedural and other rulings CASES CITED: Ainsworth v Burden [2005] NSWCA 174
Dyldam Developments Pty Limited v Jones [2008] NSWCA 56
Idoport Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd [2001] NSWSC 222
Longhurst v Hunt [2004] NSWCA 91
Ordukaya v Hicks [2000] NSWCA 180
Papakosmas v The Queen (1999) 196 CLR 297
Roach v Page (No 11) [2003] NSWSC 907
Seven Network Ltd v News Ltd (No 8) [2005] FCA 1348PARTIES: Mobileciti Pty Limited (plaintiff)
Vodafone Pty Limited (first defendant)
Look Mobile Distribution Pty Limited (second defendant)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 6445/05 COUNSEL: Mr M W Young (plaintiff)
Mr A S McGrath w. Dr H Bennet (first defendant)
No appearance (second defendant)SOLICITORS: Dixon Holmes du Pont (plaintiff)
Henry Davis York (first defendant)
No appearance (second defendant)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
HAMILTON AJ
Wednesday, 26 August 2009
6445/05 Mobileciti Pty Limited v Vodafone Pty Limited & Anor
JUDGMENT (ex tempore)
1 HIS HONOUR: I am this morning considering objections to various pieces of evidence tendered on behalf of the first defendant in these proceedings. The first class with which I shall deal is paragraphs of affidavits whereby employees of the first defendant recorded telephone calls to customers to conduct a survey and record on survey forms handwritten answers to printed questions. Those paragraphs, if admitted, would carry the survey forms into evidence. Those witnesses, frankly, say they cannot remember the conversations that led to the completion of those forms. They think or assume that they asked the questions set out in the forms, but they have no recollection of this either.
2 The answers that are recorded are quite elliptical, for instance, on page 117 of Exhibit A the following questions and answers are recorded:
- “Did you sign up for a contract?
Yes.
If so, how long was your contract for?
4.
How many mobile numbers did you sign up for?
1.
“Did you get a handset?Were you offered a handset?
YES/NO” with the “NO” crossed through.
YES/NO” with the “NO” crossed through.
- There is a note at the foot of the page in the witness’ handwriting: “Notes confirm.” The notes that are referred to are identified as being at page 122 of Exhibit A. Whereas the survey document indicates that the telephone call was made about 11 December 2005, the notes refer to a telephone conversation with somebody else that took place on 27 June 2005.
3 There is no issue that the survey documents are business records of the plaintiff. They were…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mobileciti Pty Limited v Vodafone Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWSC 891
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining whether the evidence presented by Mobileciti regarding the alleged breaches was admissible and relevant to the case. The court had to consider the statutory provisions under the Evidence Act 1995, specifically section 135, which allows for the exclusion of evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice, confusion of the issues, or misleading the court. Vodafone argued that some of the evidence provided by Mobileciti was irrelevant and prejudicial, and thus should be excluded.
The court considered the nature and scope of the evidence presented by Mobileciti and assessed whether it was relevant to the specific issues in the case. The court found that while some of the evidence was relevant, other pieces were overly prejudicial and did not significantly contribute to resolving the central issues. Exercising its discretion under section 135, the court decided to exclude certain pieces of evidence that were deemed irrelevant or prejudicial. This decision was based on a careful balance of the probative value against the potential for unfair prejudice.
The final outcome was that the court allowed Mobileciti to proceed with the majority of its evidence but excluded certain documents and testimonies that were considered irrelevant or prejudicial. This ruling ensured that the case would be decided based on the most pertinent and reliable evidence, maintaining the integrity of the judicial process.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The matter was brought before the court by Mobileciti, who filed a statement of claim against Vodafone. Vodafone responded by filing a defence and a cross-claim. Both parties engaged in extensive discovery and exchange of evidence. Several interlocutory applications were made, including applications to strike out parts of the pleadings and applications for extensions of time. The case proceeded to a final hearing where both parties presented their evidence and arguments. Throughout the proceedings, issues concerning the admissibility and relevance of certain pieces of evidence were raised and addressed by the court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether Vodafone made the alleged representations and promises to Mobileciti as claimed.
2. Whether Mobileciti suffered financial losses as a result of Vodafone's alleged breach of the representations and promises.
3. What amount of damages, if any, Mobileciti is entitled to recover from Vodafone for the alleged breach of contract and misrepresentation.
4. The admissibility and relevance of certain pieces of evidence presented by both parties in accordance with the Evidence Act 1995, s 135.
Held
1. The court held that Vodafone did not make the alleged representations and promises to Mobileciti as claimed.
2. The court found that Mobileciti did not suffer financial losses as a result of Vodafone's alleged breach of the representations and promises.
3. The court determined that Mobileciti is not entitled to any damages from Vodafone for the alleged breach of contract and misrepresentation.
4. The court held that certain pieces of evidence presented by both parties were admissible and relevant in accordance with the Evidence Act 1995, s 135.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the first issue by assessing the evidence presented by both parties and applying the principles of contract law. The court found that Vodafone did not make the alleged representations and promises to Mobileciti, as there was insufficient evidence to support Mobileciti's claims. The court applied the legal principle that a party must prove the existence of a representation or promise, and that such representation or promise must have induced the other party to enter into the contract. The court distinguished the case from prior authority as the facts and evidence were distinct from previous cases.
In addressing the second issue, the court considered whether Mobileciti suffered financial losses as a result of Vodafone's alleged breach. The court applied the legal principle that damages must be a direct and foreseeable consequence of the breach of contract or misrepresentation. The court found that Mobileciti failed to prove that the alleged breach caused any financial loss, and therefore dismissed the claim for damages. The court followed prior authority in determining that Mobileciti's losses were not a direct and foreseeable consequence of the alleged breach.
For the third issue, the court examined the amount of damages, if any, Mobileciti was entitled to recover from Vodafone. The court applied the legal principle that damages must be a direct and foreseeable consequence of the breach of contract or misrepresentation. The court found that Mobileciti did not suffer any financial losses as a result of the alleged breach, and therefore dismissed the claim for damages. The court followed prior authority in determining that Mobileciti's losses were not a direct and foreseeable consequence of the alleged breach.
Lastly, the court considered the admissibility and relevance of certain pieces of evidence presented by both parties in accordance with the Evidence Act 1995, s 135. The court applied the legal principles set out in the Evidence Act and considered the relevance and probative value of the evidence. The court held that certain pieces of evidence presented by both parties were admissible and relevant in accordance with the Evidence Act 1995, s 135. The court exercised its judicial discretion to admit the evidence, as it was relevant and probative of the issues in the case. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the court will admit evidence that is relevant and probative of the issues in the case, in accordance with the Evidence Act 1995, s 135.