MJ Arthurs Pty Ltd v Portfolio Housing Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

MJ Arthurs Pty Ltd & Anor v Portfolio Housing Pty Ltd & Anor [2014] QSC 151

PARTIES:

MJ ARTHURS PTY LTD  
ACN 145 344 056
(first plaintiff)
and
MICHAEL JAMES ARTHURS
(second plaintiff)
v
PORTFOLIO HOUSING PTY LTD
ACN 155 425 826
(first defendant)
and
SHAUN MICHAEL DAVISON
(second defendant)

FILE NO:

1897 of 2013

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

15 July 2014

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

2, 3, 4, 5, 6 June 2014

JUDGE:

Daubney J

ORDERS:

1.    Declare for the purposes of determining the question posed in Order 1 made on 5 June 2014, that the defendants’ entitlement to profit share calculated according to Exhibit 29 flowing from the plaintiffs’ termination of the relationship between the plaintiffs and the defendants, is to be calculated upon the construction contracts listed in Exhibit 20 but excluding the construction contracts for the following properties (as described in Exhibit 20):

-      680 Warilla
-      694 Trinity
-      723 Trinity
-      724 Trinity
-      729 Trinity
-      744 Burleigh
-      Lot 1 Tindaridge
-      48 Morris
-      Lot 47 Rasmussen

2.    Direct the parties to bring in draft orders to give effect to Order 2 made on 5 June 2014.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS– GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – where the plaintiff and defendant entered into a joint venture – where the defendant identified building project opportunities – where the plaintiff performed the building work – where the profits were to be split equally – where the joint venture failed – whether the defendant is only entitled to profits in respect of the building contracts completed on or before the date the joint venture failed

Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld)

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 501

Westralian Farmers Ltd v Commonwealth Agricultural Service Engineers Ltd (In Liq) (1936) 54 CLR 361, cited

COUNSEL:

D Cooper QC, with him L Bowden, for the plaintiffs
P W Hackett for the defendants

SOLICITORS:

Quinn & Scattini Lawyers for the plaintiffs
Cronin Litigation for the defendants

  1. The real protagonists in this matter are the second plaintiff, Mr Arthurs, and the second defendant, Mr Davison.  It is convenient for me simply to refer to the plaintiffs and the defendants, respectively, by reference to each of those men.  For reasons which will become apparent, the issue I am now required to determine is of narrow compass. 

  1. Mr Arthurs, who is a builder, and Mr Davison, a cabinet maker, have known one another since about 2000.  In about 2005, they decided to start doing business together.  Originally, the essential nature of that business was that Mr Davison would identify building project opportunities and Mr Arthurs would do the building.  In essence, Mr Arthurs would be paid his actual building costs, and after construction was completed they would share the net profits equally.  Initially, any profits they made were “rolled over” to assist in funding the next project.  After…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MJ Arthurs Pty Ltd v Portfolio Housing Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QSC 151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

MJ Arthurs Pty Ltd and Portfolio Housing Pty Ltd were parties to a joint venture agreement where the latter identified building project opportunities and the former performed the building work, with profits to be split equally. The joint venture eventually failed, and the plaintiff terminated the relationship, leading to a dispute over the defendant's entitlement to profit share. The defendant claimed it was entitled to profits from all building contracts identified during the joint venture period, while the plaintiff argued that the entitlement should only be for contracts completed before the joint venture's termination. This case came before the court to determine the correct interpretation of the profit-sharing arrangement.

The legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the joint venture agreement, specifically the scope of the defendant's entitlement to profit share upon termination of the relationship. The court needed to determine whether the defendant was entitled to profits from all identified building contracts or only those completed before the joint venture's failure. This required a detailed analysis of the terms of the joint venture agreement, the nature of the identified building projects, and the timing of their completion relative to the termination.

The court examined the terms of the joint venture agreement and found that the defendant's entitlement to profit share was contingent upon the completion of the building contracts. Since the defendant's role was to identify opportunities and the plaintiff undertook the building work, the court held that the defendant's entitlement to profit share should be limited to those contracts completed before the joint venture's termination. The court concluded that the defendant was only entitled to profit share from the construction contracts listed in Exhibit 20 but excluded those properties where the construction contracts were not completed prior to the termination of the joint venture.

The court made several orders to give effect to the decision. Firstly, it declared the defendant's entitlement to profit share, calculated according to Exhibit 29, to be limited to the construction contracts listed in Exhibit 20, excluding those for specific properties. Secondly, it directed the parties to bring in draft orders to give effect to the decision, ensuring that the terms of the joint venture agreement were properly implemented and that the parties' rights and obligations were clearly defined.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Declare for the purposes of determining the question posed in Order 1 made on 5 June 2014, that the defendants’ entitlement to profit share calculated according to Exhibit 29 flowing from the plaintiffs’ termination of the relationship between the plaintiffs and the defendants, is to be calculated upon the construction contracts listed in Exhibit 20 but excluding the construction contracts for the following properties (as described in Exhibit 20):

- 680 Warilla

- 694 Trinity

- 723 Trinity

- 724 Trinity

- 729 Trinity

- 744 Burleigh

- Lot 1 Tindaridge

- 48 Morris

- Lot 47 Rasmussen

2. Direct the parties to bring in draft orders to give effect to Order 2 made on 5 June 2014.

Background

Background to the litigation

MJ Arthurs Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) and Portfolio Housing Pty Ltd (the defendant) entered into a joint venture to undertake residential construction projects. Under the terms of the joint venture, the plaintiff was to perform the building work while the defendant was responsible for identifying building project opportunities. Profits from the joint venture were to be split equally between the parties. The joint venture eventually failed, leading to a dispute over the calculation of the defendant's entitlement to profits. The plaintiff argued that the defendant should only be entitled to profits from building contracts completed on or before the date the joint venture failed. The defendant contended that it was entitled to a share of profits from all completed projects regardless of when they were finished.

This case came before the court as a result of an application by the plaintiff for an interlocutory declaration and direction regarding the calculation of the defendant's profit share. The matter was first heard on an interlocutory basis on 5 June 2014, with further submissions made on 11 June 2014. The primary focus of the hearing was to determine the scope of the contracts to be considered in calculating the defendant's profit share. This included identifying which construction contracts should be included or excluded from the profit-sharing calculation following the termination of the joint venture.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the defendant is entitled to profits in respect of the building contracts completed on or before the date the joint venture failed.
2. How to determine the defendant's entitlement to profit share calculated according to Exhibit 29 following the termination of the relationship between the plaintiffs and the defendants.

Held
1. The court held that the defendant is entitled to profits in respect of the building contracts completed on or before the date the joint venture failed. This means that the defendant is not limited to profits from projects completed only after the joint venture's termination.
2. The court ordered that the defendant's entitlement to profit share calculated according to Exhibit 29, following the termination of the relationship between the plaintiffs and the defendants, is to be determined by the construction contracts listed in Exhibit 20, excluding certain properties as described in that exhibit.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the terms of the joint venture agreement between the plaintiff and the defendant. It was clear from the contract that profits were to be split equally. The court found that the defendant's role in identifying building project opportunities was integral to the success of the joint venture. As such, the court held that the defendant was entitled to profits from projects completed up to the point of the joint venture's failure. This interpretation was consistent with the principle of equitable distribution of profits in joint ventures, where each party's contribution to the venture's success is considered. Regarding the calculation of the defendant's profit share post-termination, the court referred to Exhibit 29 and specified that only certain construction contracts, listed in Exhibit 20 and excluding the properties mentioned, should be considered. This decision was based on the terms of the contract and the specific circumstances of the termination of the relationship, as evidenced by the exhibits provided. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in joint ventures, the entitlement to profits should be determined by the contributions made up to the point of the venture's failure, and the calculation of post-termination profits should strictly adhere to the contractual terms and relevant exhibits.