Mithril Resources Ltd, in the matter of Mithril Resources Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mithril Resources Ltd, in the matter of Mithril Resources Ltd [2023] FCA 1177

File number: QUD 352 of 2023
Judgment of: DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 5 October 2023
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – Scheme of Arrangement – application under s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to convene a meeting to consider a scheme of arrangement – relevant considerations to the exercise of the Court’s power to order a meeting – orders made
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth)

Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Amcom Telecommunications Limited, in the matter of Amcom Telecommunications Limited [2015] FCA 341

Amcor Limited, in the matter of Amcor Limited [2019] FCA 346

Asaleo Care Limited, in the matter of Asaleo Care Limited [2021] FCA 406

Associated Advisory Practices Limited, in the matter of Associated Advisory Practices Limited (No 2) [2013] FCA 979

Blackmores Limited, in the matter of Blackmores Limited [2023] FCA 624

Chesser Resources Limited, in the matter of Chesser Resources Limited [2023] FCA 1021

Chevron (TAPL) Pty Ltd v Chevron Australia Pty Ltd, in the matter of Chevron (TAPL) Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 220

DDH1 Limited, In the matter of DDH1 Limited [2023] FCA 982

EcoBiotics Limited, in the matter of EcoBiotics Limited [2017] FCA 643

Essential Metals Limited, in the matter of Essential Metals Limited [2023] FCA 240

Re APN News & Media Ltd (2007) 62 ACSR 400

Re Arthur Yates & Co Ltd (2001) 36 ACSR 758

Re Centro Retail Ltd (in its capacity as responsible entity of Centro Retail Trust) [2011] NSWSC 1321

Re Compania de Electricidad de la Provincia de Buenos Aires Ltd [1980] Ch 146

Re Crusader Ltd [1996] 1 Qd R 117

Re CSR Ltd (2010) 183 FCR 358

Re DuluxGroup Ltd (2019) 136 ACSR 546

Re ResApp Health Ltd [2022] NSWSC 1014

Re Rural Press Ltd (2007) 61 ACSR 373

Re SFE Corporation Ltd (2006) 59 ACSR 82

Re Vita Group Ltd (2023) 165 ACSR 576

Re Wesfarmers Ltd; Ex parte Wesfarmers Ltd [2018] WASC 308

Rusina Mining NL, in the matter of Rusina Mining [2010] FCA 517

Security Matters Limited, in the matter of Security Matters Limited [2023] FCA 19

SRG Limited, in the matter of SRG Limited [2018] FCA 1092

Staging Connections Group Limited, in the matter of Staging Connections Group Limited [2015] FCA 1012

Tesserent Limited, in the matter of Tesserent Limited (First Scheme Hearing) [2023] FCA 969

ThinkSmart Limited, in the matter of ThinkSmart Limited [2022] FCA 1314

Verdant Minerals Ltd, in the matter of Verdant Minerals Ltd [2019] FCA 556

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 66
Date of hearing: 6 September 2023
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Mr D Jardine of HopgoodGanim Lawyers

ORDERS

QUD 352 of 2023

IN THE MATTER OF MITHRIL RESOURCES LTD ACN 099 883 922

MITHRIL RESOURCES LTD ACN 099 883 922

Plaintiff

ORDER MADE BY:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mithril Resources Ltd, in the matter of Mithril Resources Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1177
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mithril Resources Ltd filed an application in the Federal Court seeking to convene meetings of its shareholders and optionholders to consider and potentially approve a scheme of arrangement under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The key legal issues before the court involved determining the appropriate procedures for convening and conducting the meetings, ensuring proper notice and documentation were provided to all relevant parties, and confirming the content and distribution of the scheme booklet. The court needed to weigh the requirements of the Act against the practicalities of executing such meetings in a manner that ensured all participants had a reasonable opportunity to engage with the proposed arrangements.

The court addressed the legal issues by setting out detailed orders for convening the meetings, including the specific procedures for notice, the format and content of the scheme booklet, and the voting processes. The court emphasised the need for the scheme booklet to be clear and accessible, with provisions for correcting minor errors and updating factual information. The orders also specified the role of the chairperson in conducting the meetings and reporting the outcomes. The court recognised the importance of flexibility in accommodating last-minute changes to the meeting arrangements, provided that all participants remained adequately informed.

In its decision, the court granted the application, issuing comprehensive orders that outlined the process for convening and conducting the meetings. The orders mandated specific timelines for the distribution of notices and the submission of proxies, and they prescribed the format for the scheme booklet and its distribution. The court also appointed Stephen Layton, or Clair Newstead-Sinclair if he was unavailable, as the chairperson of the meetings, granting him broad discretion to manage the proceedings.

The court's orders ensured that Mithril Resources Ltd could proceed with its meetings in accordance with the law, while also accommodating the practical needs of its shareholders and optionholders. The detailed provisions aimed to facilitate an orderly and fair process for considering the proposed scheme of arrangement.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act):

(a) the Plaintiff convene and hold:

(i) a meeting of the holders of fully paid ordinary shares (Shareholders) (Share Scheme Meeting), for the purpose of considering, and if thought fit, approving, a scheme of arrangement (with or without modifications) proposed to be made between the Plaintiff and the Shareholders (Share Scheme), being the scheme in substantially the same form as is set out in Annexure C of the scheme booklet (Scheme Booklet) in Annexure NJR-1 to the affidavit of Nicole Jane Radice filed on 5 September 2023 (Third Radice Affidavit);

(ii) a meeting of the holders of Class A Options and Class B Options (Optionholders) (Option Scheme Meeting), for the purpose of considering, and if thought fit, approving, a scheme of arrangement (with or without modification) proposed to be made between the Plaintiff and the Optionholders (Option Scheme), being the scheme in substantially the same form as is set out in Annexure E of the Scheme Booklet,

(together, the Scheme Meetings);

(b) the Scheme Meetings be held as follows:

(i) the Share Scheme Meeting be held at 9:00 am AEDT on Friday, 13 October 2023 at Level 4, 96-100 Albert Road, South Melbourne VIC 3205;

(ii) the Option Scheme Meeting be held at the later of 10:00 am AEDT or the conclusion of the Share Scheme Meeting on Friday, 13 October 2023 at Level 4, 96-100 Albert Road, South Melbourne VIC 3205;

(c) the Scheme Booklet, which contains the explanatory statement required by s 412(1)(a) of the Act, in Annexure NJR-1 of the Third Radice Affidavit be approved for distribution to Shareholders and Optionholders (together, the Securityholders), subject to:

(i) correction of any minor typographical or grammatical errors and final typesetting and formatting and page numbering;

(ii) any minor amendments required or approved by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) for registration under s 412(6) of the Act;

(iii) the correction or update of any relevant date references, interests held by shareholders of the Plaintiff or Newrange Gold Corp, issued capital or last trading prices, or other references to figures and dates; and

(iv) any other amendments approved by the Court.

2. Subject to these orders and pursuant to s 1319 of the Act, the Scheme Meetings be:

(a) convened, held and conducted in accordance with the provisions of Part 2G.2 of the Act that apply to members of a company and the provisions of the Plaintiff’s constitution, provided at Annexure JSS-1 to the affidavit of John Stewart Skeet affirmed on 1 September 2023 (Skeet Affidavit), that are not inconsistent therewith and that apply to meetings of members;

(b) convened using a notice of scheme meeting:

(i) for the Share Scheme Meeting, in substantially the form contained in Annexure G of the Scheme Booklet, which is contained in Annexure NJR-1 to the Third Radice Affidavit (with any necessary amendments as contemplated above) (Notice of Share Scheme Meeting);

(ii) for the Option Scheme Meeting, in substantially in the form contained in Annexure H of the Scheme Booklet, which is contained in Annexure NJR-1 to the Third Radice Affidavit (with any necessary amendments as contemplated above) (Notice of Option Scheme Meeting);

(c) held and conducted pursuant to the arrangements for attending, participating and voting described in:

(i) for the Share Scheme Meeting, the Notice of Share Scheme Meeting, including in respect of the effect of a Shareholder’s attendance at the Share Scheme Meeting on a proxy or attorney appointment by that Shareholder (Shareholders Meeting Arrangements);

(ii) for the Option Scheme Meeting, the Notice of Option Scheme Meeting, including in respect of the effect of an Optionholder’s attendance at the Option Scheme Meeting on a proxy or attorney appointment by that Optionholder (Optionholders Meeting Arrangements),

(together the Meeting Arrangements),

and in accordance with the provisions of Part 2G.2 of the Act, and

(d) convened, held and conducted as if r 2.15 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) (Rules) does not apply.

3. Pursuant to s 1319 of the Act:

(a) Mr Stephen Layton, or failing him, Ms Clair Newstead-Sinclair, be the chairperson of each of the Scheme Meetings (Chairperson) and report the result of each of the Scheme Meetings to this Court;

(b) the Chairperson of the Scheme Meetings have power to adjourn or postpone the Scheme Meetings in the Chairperson's absolute discretion, for such time that the Chairperson thinks appropriate, to a time and place advised by the Chairperson;

(c) at the Share Scheme Meeting:

(i) three Shareholders entitled to vote, present in person or by proxy or by an attorney under power, or by a corporate representative (if applicable), shall constitute a quorum;

(ii) each Shareholder, present and entitled to vote, be entitled to one vote for each fully paid ordinary share in the capital of the Plaintiff that the Shareholder is registered as holding as at 7:00 pm AEDT on 11 October 2023;

(iii) voting on the resolution on whether to approve the Share Scheme is to be conducted by way of a poll (declared by the Chairperson).

(d) at the Option Scheme Meeting:

(i) three Optionholders entitled to vote, present in person or by proxy or by an attorney under power, or by a corporate representative (if applicable), shall constitute a quorum;

(ii) each Optionholder, present and entitled to vote, be entitled to vote for each Class A Option and Class B Option of the Plaintiff that the Optionholder is registered as holding as at 7:00 pm AEDT on 11 October 2023 according to their value (based on the preferred value described in the Independent Expert’s Report in Annexure A of the Scheme Booklet);

(iii) voting on the resolution on whether to approve the Option Scheme is to be conducted by way of a poll (declared by the Chairperson).

4. The board of the directors of the Plaintiff shall have the power to approve for lodgement on the Plaintiff’s ASX announcements platform announcements regarding corrections, clarifications or changes to the arrangements for the Scheme Meetings where, in the board’s discretion, such corrections, clarifications or changes are necessary to ensure that Securityholders as a whole will have a reasonable opportunity to participate in the Scheme Meetings, and such announcements will be taken to be sufficient notice of any corrections, clarifications or changes to the Meeting Arrangements provided they are made on or before 13 October 2023 and are explained by the Chairperson at the commencement of the Scheme Meetings.

5. Subject to registration of the Scheme Booklet with ASIC pursuant to s 412(6) of the Act, the Plaintiff shall, on or before 12 September 2023, despatch the Scheme Booklet substantially in the form approved in order 1(c) above to each of the Shareholders registered on the Plaintiff's register of members at 7:00 pm AEDT on 7 September 2023 and each of the Optionholders registered on the Plaintiff’s register of optionholders at 7:00 pm AEDT on 7 September 2023, by sending:

(a) in the case of each Shareholder:

(i) who has nominated an email address for the purpose of receiving shareholder communications (Email Shareholder), an email substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-21 (with the correction or update of any relevant date references to reflect the dates in the Scheme Booklet), with such email to contain website links accessible by the Email Shareholder which enable the Email Shareholder to:

A. access and download the Scheme Booklet; and

B. complete and lodge their proxy form for the Share Scheme Meeting online; and

C. access a letter substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-20;

(ii) who has expressly elected to receive shareholder communications by post (Postal Shareholders), using the methods of service set out in order 6 below:

A. a letter substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-20;

B. a copy of the Scheme Booklet;

C. a proxy form in respect of the Share Scheme Meeting substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-17;

D. a reply paid envelope addressed to the Mithril Registry; and

(iii) who is not an Email Shareholder or Postal Shareholder, using the methods of service set out in order 6 below:

A. a letter substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-15 with such notice to contain:

a. the address of a website and associated QR Code which enables those Shareholders to access and download the Scheme Booklet;

b. the address of a website which enables those Shareholders to access, complete and lodge their proxy form for the Share Scheme Meeting online; and

B. a letter substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-20;

C. a proxy form in respect of the Share Scheme Meeting substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-17; and

D. a reply paid envelope addressed to the Mithril Registry.

(b) in the case of each Optionholder:

(i) who has nominated an email address for the purpose of receiving communications (Email Optionholder), an email substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-21 (with the correction or update of any relevant date references to reflect the dates in the Scheme Booklet), with such email to contain website links accessible by the Email Optionholder which enable the Email Optionholder to:

A. access and download the Scheme Booklet; and

B. complete and lodge their proxy form for the Option Scheme Meeting online; and

C. access a letter substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-20;

(ii) who has expressly elected to receive communications by post (Postal Optionholders), using the methods of service set out in order 6 below:

A. a letter substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-20:

B. a copy of the Scheme Booklet;

C. a proxy form in respect of the Option Scheme Meeting substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-18;

D. a reply paid envelope addressed to the Mithril Registry; and

(iii) who is not an Email Optionholder or Postal Optionholder, using the methods of service set out in order 6 below:

A. a letter substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-16 with such notice to contain:

a. the address of a website and associated QR Code which enables those Optionholders to access and download the Scheme Booklet;

b. the address of a website which enables those Optionholders to access, complete and lodge their proxy form for the Option Scheme Meeting online; and

B. a letter substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-20;

C. a proxy form in respect of the Option Scheme Meeting substantially in the form annexed to the Skeet Affidavit as Annexure JSS-18;

D. a reply paid envelope addressed to the Mithril Registry.

6. The Plaintiff shall despatch the documents identified in order 5(a)(ii); 5(a)(iii); 5(b)(ii) and 5(b)(iii) above:

(a) to each Securityholder who has a registered address in Australia, by ordinary prepaid post; and

(b) to each other Securityholder who has a registered address outside Australia, by prepaid international airmail or air courier.

7. If it comes to the attention of the Plaintiff that any email despatched in accordance with order 5(a)(i) or 5(b)(i) results in the return of a receipt or notice that the email was undeliverable, then, in respect of that Securityholder, the Plaintiff will forthwith thereafter despatch the documents identified in order 5(a)(iii) (for Shareholders) and 5(b)(iii) (for Optionholders) using the method of service set out in order 6.

8. Despatch of the documents referred to above, in accordance with the terms of the orders above, shall be taken to be sufficient notice of the Scheme Meetings.

9. The time by which:

(a) the Shareholders must return their Share Scheme Proxy Form (or lodge an electronic proxy in respect of the Share Scheme) is 9:00 am AEDT on 11 October 2023;

(b) the Optionholders must return their Option Scheme Proxy Form (or lodge an electronic proxy in respect of the Option Scheme) is 10:00 am AEDT on 11 October 2023.

10. The Plaintiff is to give notice of the hearing of its application pursuant to s 411(4) of the Act, and that notice of the hearing of an application pursuant to subs 411(4)(b) of the Act for orders approving the Scheme is to be published once in “The Australian” newspaper by an advertisement substantially in the form of Annexure A to these orders, with such advertisement to be published on or before 16 October 2023, and the Plaintiff is to be otherwise exempted from compliance with r 3.4 of the Rules.

11. The proceeding be adjourned to 10:15 am AEST on 20 October 2023, for the hearing of an application to approve the Share Scheme and the Option Scheme.

12. These orders be entered forthwith.

13. The Plaintiff have liberty to apply upon giving 24 hours’ notice to ASIC.

a

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established