Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Zitoni

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Zitoni [2000] FCA 1225

MIGRATION –refugees – application for protection visa – respondent a citizen of Algeria and supporter of political party which later became a terrorist organisation – respondent imprisoned for imputed political opinion and tortured – respondent's farm and houses confiscated by army after his departure – later after respondent had left Algeria for Indonesia respondent claimed to have come to the attention of the Algerian authorities who confiscated a false Algerian passport – Refugee Review Tribunal made no findings on these matters but held that the respondent would not be treated differently from a person who might have left the country for economic reasons and who had no political profile – whether failure by Tribunal to make finding on material questions of fact and to refer to the evidence on which those findings were made – whether Tribunal impliedly made adverse findings on factual issues – role of appellate court in cases where decision appealed from involves a question of materiality involving a degree of evaluation or impression discussed.

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 430(1)(c) and (d), 476(1)(a)

Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Singh [2000] FCA 845 followed

Xu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 168 ALR 621 not followed
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf [1999] FCA 1681 followed

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Kandasamy [2000] FCA 67 cited
SW Hart & Co Pty Ltd v Edwards Hot Water Systems (1985) 159 CLR 466 at 478 cited

Eagle Homes Pty Ltd v Austec Homes (1998) 87 FCR 415 at 439-440 and 440-443 cited
S & I Publishing v Australian Surf Life Saver Pty Ltd (1998) 88 FCR 354 at 359-361 cited

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS v AHMED ZITONI

W87 of 2000

FRENCH, HILL and WEINBERG JJ
1 SEPTEMBER 2000

PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

W87 OF 2000

On appeal from a single Judge of the Federal Court of Australia

BETWEEN:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
APPLICANTAPPELLANT

AND:

AHMED ZITONI
RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

FRENCH, HILL and WEINBERG JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

29 AUGUST 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeallication be dismissed.

2.The appellant pay the respondent’s costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

W87 OF 2000

On appeal from a single Judge of the Federal Court of Australia

BETWEEN:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
APPELLANT

AND:

AHMED ZITONI
RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

FRENCH, HILL and WEINBERG JJ

DATE:

1 SEPTEMBER 2000

PLACE:

SYDNEY PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:

  1. At the hearing of this appeal the Court dismissed the appeal without calling upon the respondent.  It now publishes its reasons.

  2. The Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs, (“the Minister”) appeals to the fFull Court of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Zitoni and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1225
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Zitoni, the applicant, Mr. Zitoni, a national of Algeria, appealed against the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal which found that he did not qualify as a refugee under the 1951 Refugee Convention. The Tribunal determined that Mr. Zitoni did not face a well-founded fear of persecution if he returned to Algeria, and accordingly, he did not meet the criteria for refugee status. The court was required to decide whether the Tribunal's decision was correct and whether Mr. Zitoni qualified as a refugee.

The court examined the evidence presented to the Tribunal, including Mr. Zitoni's claims of past persecution and fear of future persecution. The Tribunal found that Mr. Zitoni had been a low-level supporter of the Islamic Salvation Front (FIS) but not a member. Although he was arrested and imprisoned for providing assistance to the FIS, his release was due to the authorities being either satisfied that he had no significant links with the FIS or that his punishment was intended to deter him from providing any further assistance. The Tribunal also considered evidence from Dr. Sadiki, who opined that if Mr. Zitoni was not known to the regime or his asylum application, he faced no threat to his life or freedom. The court concluded that the Tribunal's decision was not erroneous, as Mr. Zitoni did not demonstrate a well-founded fear of persecution if he returned to Algeria.

The court further found that Mr. Zitoni's fear of being treated with suspicion by the Algerian authorities due to his flight from Algeria was speculative and not sufficient to qualify as a well-founded fear of persecution. The Tribunal's conclusion that Mr. Zitoni faced no potential harm that was Convention-related during the five years he was in Algeria was supported by the evidence. Additionally, the Tribunal's finding that Mr. Zitoni's absence from Algeria and the fact that a return would require him to indicate where he had been would probably arouse suspicion that he had sought asylum in another country was also supported by the evidence.

Accordingly, the court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the appellant pay the respondent's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeallication be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr. Zitoni, an Algerian national, arrived in Australia on 18 February 1999 claiming asylum. He had left Algeria due to fears of harm from the Algerian authorities and terrorists in his home country. He claimed that his flight from Algeria would lead to treatment with suspicion by the authorities. Mr. Zitoni was a low-level supporter of the Islamic Salvation Front (FIS) until it was banned, according to the Tribunal's findings. The Tribunal did not find him to be a member of FIS, although it accepted that he might have been arrested and imprisoned for providing assistance to FIS. The Tribunal concluded that his release from prison was likely due to the authorities either being satisfied that he had no significant links with FIS or that his punishment was meant to deter him from providing any assistance to FIS in the future.

The Tribunal had "serious reservations" about Mr. Zitoni's claim that his door was knocked on a nightly basis, but even if this happened, the Tribunal found that it did not indicate involvement of FIS or Algerian authorities. The Tribunal noted that Mr. Zitoni had moved to Oran thereafter and that nothing had happened to him then. It also concluded that in the five years after his release from prison, he faced no potential harm that was Convention-related. The Tribunal rejected Mr. Zitoni's claim that he had come to the attention of the Algerian authorities while in Indonesia, but accepted that his absence from Algeria and the fact that a return would require him to indicate where he had been would probably arouse suspicion that he had sought asylum in another country.

Mr. Zitoni's claim for refugee status was rejected by the delegate, and he appealed this decision to the Refugee Review Tribunal. The Tribunal's decision was then appealed to the Federal Court of Australia, which was subsequently appealed to the High Court of Australia. The High Court allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the Tribunal for reconsideration. The Tribunal reconsidered the matter but ultimately dismissed the appeal, leading to the current appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ultimately he managed to find another boat to depart Indonesia and come to Australia, where he arrived on 18 February 1999. He said that he feared harmd from the Algerian authorities and the terrorists in his own country. He claimed that his flight from Algeria meant that he would be treated with suspicion by the authorities.The Tribunal decision The Tribunal found Mr Zitoni was a low level supporter of FIS until it was banned. It did not find he had been a member as Mr Zitoni claimed. It accepted that it was possible that he was arrested and imprisoned for providing FIS with assistance but found that his release occurred because the authorities:“… were either satisfied that he had no significant links with FIS or, as he indicated himself, that his punishment was to deter him from providing any assistance to FIS at all.” The Tribunal expressed “serious reservations” in regard to his claim that his door was knocked on a nightly basis but even if this happened the Tribunal found that this did not indicate either that it was brought about by members of the FIS or ofby the Algerian authorities. The Tribunal noted that Mr Zitoni had moved to Oran thereafter and that nothing had happened to him then. It made no reference to the fact that he claimed that he had lived under there under an assumed name there in conditions rather like a self imposed gaol. Although the failure to make findings on these matters was not the subject of the present appeal they arguably were likewise material in the relevant sense, for the false identity may well have explained (if accepted) why Mr Zitoni did not come to the attention of the Algerian authorities in this time. The Tribunal noted also that it was unusual that if Mr Zitoni was in fear he would remain living for so long a time in one area two locations. It concluded that in the five years which elapsed from his release infrom prison he faced no potential harm that was Convention related. It turned then to the period of time Mr Zitoni was in Indonesia. The Tribunal rejected Mr Zitoni’s claim that he had come to the attention of the Algerian authorities while he was in Indonesia. It accepted, however, that his absence from Algeria and the fact that a return would require him to indicate where he had been “would probably arouse the suspicion that he had sought asylum in another country.” The central thesis of this part of the Tribunal’s reasons lay in evidence from a Dr Sadiki of the Centre for Middle Eastern and Central Asian Studies, of the Australian National University. Dr Sadiki had provided the following opinion to the delegate whose decision was under review:“… if the unsuccessful applicant is neither known to the regime nor is his or her asylum application he or she categorically face no threat to their life or freedom…Should the state have information on re turning asylum seekers, especially those of no history of political opposition, Islamist affiliation, or criminal activities, some irritations, I should imagine, can be expected. But that can be expected of tax dodgers, drug dealers, or other types of criminals returning to their homelands anywhere in the world. Asylum is not always about politics; it has economic motivations. This latter category does not necessarily invite state suspicion or retaliation. Hundreds of thousands of Algerians, whose remittances are a major sources of hard currency for the state in addition to oil, can be interpreted as living in a quasi state of “asylum”. Since ‘asylum’, to a point, convey the notion of protection, in this case, from economic hardship. This is perhaps a little far-fetched but I see no problem with Algerian seekers of asylum, which more often than not is motivated by economic concerns, returning home without being retaliated against by the state….”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Once in Indonesn authorities After arriving in Indonesia he was housed in a migration detention centre in Jakarta. In March 1998 he attempted to reach Australia via Christmas Island but was unsuccessful. He was returned to Indonesia and put into a was returned to the detention centre. He said that the Indonesian authorities informed the Algerian authorities who visited the detention centre and confiscated the false Algerian passport he which held. He claimed to have been followed by Algerian authorities when he sought to visit the UNHCR officials in Jakarta and a mosque and complained to the UNHCR about this orally and in writing. He sought asylum and resettlement from UNHCR. His claim was rejected and was under appeal at the time he left Indonesia. Between 2 and 9 November 1998 he said that he with two other Algerians and other asylum seekers staged a “sit- in” protest in the UN compound demanding re-settlement as refugees.. Ultimately he managed to find another boat to depart Indonesia and come to Australia, where he arrived on 18 February 1999. He said that he feared harmd from the Algerian authorities and the terrorists in his own country. He claimed that his flight from Algeria meant that he would be treated with suspicion by the authorities.The Tribunal decision The Tribunal found Mr Zitoni was a low level supporter of FIS until it was banned. It did not find he had been a member as Mr Zitoni claimed. It accepted that it was possible that he was arrested and imprisoned for providing FIS with assistance but found that his release occurred because the authorities:“… were either satisfied that he had no significant links with FIS or, as he indicated himself, that his punishment was to deter him from providing any assistance to FIS at all.” The Tribunal expressed “serious reservations” in regard to his claim that his door was knocked on a nightly basis but even if this happened the Tribunal found that this did not indicate either that it was brought about by members of the FIS or ofby the Algerian authorities. The Tribunal noted that Mr Zitoni had moved to Oran thereafter and that nothing had happened to him then. It made no reference to the fact that he claimed that he had lived under there under an assumed name there in conditions rather like a self imposed gaol. Although the failure to make findings on these matters was not the subject of the present appeal they arguably were likewise material in the relevant sense, for the false identity may well have explained (if accepted) why Mr Zitoni did not come to the attention of the Algerian authorities in this time. The Tribunal noted also that it was unusual that if Mr Zitoni was in fear he would remain living for so long a time in one area two locations. It concluded that in the five years which elapsed from his release infrom prison he faced no potential harm that was Convention related. It turned then to the period of time Mr Zitoni was in Indonesia. The Tribunal rejected Mr Zitoni’s claim that he had come to the attention of the Algerian authorities while he was in Indonesia. It accepted, however, that his absence from Algeria and the fact that a return would require him to indicate where he had been “would probably arouse the suspicion that he had sought asylum in another country.”