Mineral Resources Limited v Vlajsavljevich

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   MINERAL RESOURCES LIMITED -v- VLAJSAVLJEVICH [2023] WASC 415

CORAM:   ACTING MASTER MCDONALD

HEARD:   2 AUGUST 2023

DELIVERED          :   31 OCTOBER 2023

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2127 of 2022

BETWEEN:   MINERAL RESOURCES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

MILE VLAJSAVLJEVICH

Defendant


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Interlocutory applications - Application to set aside an order for the examination of recipient of a summons - Applicant not heard prior to order made - Whether in the interests of justice - Whether compliance with subpoena - Application to set aside subpoena - Fishing - Legitimate forensic purpose - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Application to set aside examination order allowed; Further examination order made
Application to set aside subpoena allowed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : R Young SC
Defendant :

No appearance

Applicant : D Sibtain SC & S Pack

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Bennett
Defendant :

Adam Rosser Commercial Law

Applicant : Harmers Workplace Lawyers

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Bell Group NV v Aspinall (1998) 19 WAR 561

Comcare v John Holland Rail Pty Ltd (No 5) [2011] FCA 622

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Saraceni [2013] WASC 115

Commonwealth of Australia v Albany Port Authority [2006] WASCA 185

Girgis v Poliwka [No 4] [2018] WASC 321

Griffith v Ricketts (1849) 7 Hare 229; 68 ER 122

Hancock Prospecting Pty Ltd v Hancock [2013] WASC 290

Hongkong Xinhe International Co Ltd v Bullseye Ltd [2021] WASC 212

Hongkong Xinhe International Investment Co Ltd v Bullseye Mining Ltd [No 4] [2021] WASC 287

Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8

Palmer v Citic Ltd [No 6] [2023] WASC 188

Penn‑Texas Corp v Murat Anstalt (No 2) [1964] 2 QB 647

Popovic v Panagoulias [2014] WASCA 86

Re Potter; Ex parte Coppin [2013] WASC 462

Re Sinanovic's Application [2001] HCA 40; (2001) 180 ALR 448

Ryan Nominees Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2003] WASCA 134

Savcor Pty Ltd v Cathodic Protection International APS [2005] VSCA 213; (2005) 12 VR 639

Taylor v Taylor (1979) 143 CLR 1

Thomas v SMP (International) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] NSWSC 870

Trade Practices Commission v Arnotts Ltd (No 2) [1989] FCA 340; (1989) 21 FCR 306

Wilkshire v Commonwealth (1976) 9 ALR 325

Table of Contents

1.     Summary

2.     Pleadings

3.     Background to the making of the Examination Order

3.1      March subpoena

3.2      Examination Order

4.     Application to set aside the Examination Order

4.1      The applicant's submissions

4.2      The plaintiff's submissions

4.3      Preliminary issues arising from the parties' positions

4.3.1      Was the Examination Order made ex parte?

4.3.2      If the Examination Order was not ex parte, was it a case management direction which can be set aside?

4.3.3      Is the Examination Order an interlocutory order which the court has inherent power to revisit and discharge?

4.4      Should the Examination Order be set aside?

4.4.1      Was the Examination Order made in respect of proceedings for contempt?

4.4.2      Were less…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mineral Resources Limited v Vlajsavljevich and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASC 415
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mineral Resources Limited, the plaintiff, sought to examine Steven Pigozzo, the defendant, regarding his compliance with a subpoena in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The subpoena required the defendant to produce documents relating to correspondence between himself and the plaintiff and another party, Mr Cazgir, within specified dates. The defendant advised that he had no documents to produce, but the plaintiff alleged non-compliance and sought to examine the defendant. The defendant resisted and sought to be heard prior to any examination order being made. The court had to decide whether the order for examination was in the interests of justice, given the defendant was not heard beforehand, and whether the defendant's non-compliance with the subpoena warranted the examination.

The court found that the Examination Order was not in the interests of justice as the defendant was not heard before the order was made. The court considered the principle that parties should be heard before an order is made that may have significant consequences for them. The court also noted that the defendant had cooperated with the subpoena process and had provided a reasonable explanation for his non-compliance. The court held that the Examination Order was not necessary to ensure compliance with the subpoena and that the defendant's non-compliance did not warrant the examination. The court also found that the plaintiff's application to set aside the subpoena was a fishing exercise and did not serve a legitimate forensic purpose.

The court set aside the Examination Order and made no orders as to costs. The court emphasised that the defendant's non-compliance with the subpoena did not warrant the examination and that the principle of fairness required the defendant to be heard before such an order was made. The court also noted that the plaintiff's application to set aside the subpoena was not warranted and that the defendant had cooperated with the subpoena process. The court held that the Examination Order was not in the interests of justice and that the defendant's non-compliance did not warrant the examination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Background to the making of the Examination Order By the March subpoena, the applicant was required to produce '[d]ocuments recording correspondence' between him and the defendant from 1 January 2017 to 10 July 2020, other than emails sent or received from email addresses with specified domains, as well as documents recording correspondence between him and Mr Cazgir (within the same date range and subject to the same exception).[10][10] Affidavit of Lauren Margaret Brouwer-French affirmed on 7 July 2023 (Ms Brouwer-French's first affidavit) [15], Attach 'LBF-3'. The applicant through his solicitors advised that he had no documents to produce in response to the subpoena.[11][11] Ms Brouwer-French's first affidavit [16], Attach 'LBF-4'. On 2 June 2023, the plaintiff filed a letter and minute of proposed orders with the court seeking the following order:[12]Pursuant to Order 36B rule 12 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971, alternatively the inherent jurisdiction of the Court, Mr Steven Pigozzo attend the Supreme Court of Western Australia, on a date to be fixed, to be examined by the plaintiff regarding his compliance with [the March subpoena].[12] Ms Brouwer-French's first affidavit [25]; Attach 'LBF-12'. The application was supported by an affidavit of Ms Gina Nofal sworn on 1 June 2023 (Ms Nofal's affidavit), which was read at the hearing of this application without objection[13] and from which the following chronology is derived:[13] ts 36.(a)the applicant was served with the March subpoena on 24 March 2023, the day it was issued by the court;[14](b)on 18 April 2023, the applicant's solicitors wrote to the court advising that they were instructed by their client that he had no documents to produce pursuant to the March subpoena;[15](c)on 1 May 2023, the plaintiff's solicitors wrote to the applicant's solicitors, alleging that the applicant had failed to comply with the subpoena and that the plaintiff's solicitors had evidence of email correspondence that should have been produced;[16](d)on 4 May 2023, the applicant's solicitors responded rejecting the assertion of a failure to comply and reiterating that the applicant had no documents to produce in response; contending that the email cited as an example of proof of non‑compliance was to an email address with a domain expressly excluded by the terms of the March subpoena; and, advising that the applicant had conducted a further review of his records for correspondence within the scope of the March subpoena and confirming he had no documents to produce;[17](e)on 5 May 2023, the plaintiff's solicitors responded maintaining that the applicant's position as to his compliance was wrong and that he had failed to comply; disputing the accuracy of the applicant's position regarding the email cited as proof of non‑compliance; and advising that if the applicant failed to comply, the plaintiff intended to 'make an application for Mr Pigozzo to be committed for contempt for his refusal and failure to comply with an order of the Court …';[18](f)on 10 May 2023, the applicant's solicitors responded by letter advising that to the extent that there were any documents within the scope of the March subpoena, the applicant 'no longer has them, as his email system deleted emails (other than those manually archived) that were more than 12 months old';[19](g)on 17 May 2023, the plaintiff's solicitors sent an email advising that the plaintiff intended to apply for leave to examine the applicant on his compliance with the March subpoena;[20] and(h)on 25 May 2023, the applicant's solicitors sent an email advising that any proposed application to examine him would be resisted, and that he sought to be heard.[21]

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.