[2014] AATA 820
Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION File Number
2013/4115
Re
Milton Jones
APPLICANT
And
Civil Aviation Safety Authority
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal Senior Member Bernard J McCabe
Date 31 October 2014 Place Brisbane The decision under review is set aside. The Tribunal decides in substitution that the applicant’s flight crew licences will be suspended until he obtains certification in relation to the matters referred to in paragraph 107 of these reasons. The suspension will not take effect until 28 days after the date of this decision.
........................................................................
Senior Member Bernard J McCabe
CATCHWORDS
CIVIL AVIATION – Cancellation of flight crew licences – Incidents occurred during filming of television series – Duty with respect to the safe navigation and operation of an aircraft – Fit and proper person – Discretion to vary, suspend or cancel – Cancellation not appropriate – Decision under review set aside and substituted – Flight crew licences suspended until applicant obtains further certification to acquire necessary knowledge and decision-making skills for those licences.
LEGISLATION
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 41(2); 43(5C)
Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth) r 2; 5.88; 5.121; 42U; 138; 149; 151; 157; 206; 225; 230;
250; 269; 282Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 3A; 9A; 20A; 20AB; 27(2)
Civil Aviation Order 20.11 - Emergency & life saving equipment & passenger control in
emergencies
Civil Aviation Order 20.16.3 - Air service operations - Carriage of persons
Civil Aviation Order 29.6 - Air service operations - Helicopter external sling load operations
Civil Aviation Order 29.10 - Air service operations - Aircraft engaged in aerial stock mustering
operations - Low flying permission
Civil Aviation Order 95.7 - Exemption from the provisions of the Civil Aviation Regulations
1988 - Helicopters
Civil Aviation Order 95.7.2 - Exemption of helicopters engaged in rappelling sling load or
winching operations from compliance with certain flight manual limitations
CASES
Quadrio and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2011] AATA 709
Rich v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2004) 220 CLR 129
REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member Bernard J McCabe
31 October 2014
Milton Jones holds flight crew licences that include a private helicopter pilot licence.
At least he did, until the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) cancelled them after reviewing footage shot in the course of a reality television series based on the life of
Mr Jones, his family and employees on Coolibah Station in the Northern Territory.
The show – called Keeping up with the Joneses – featured a number of activities and incidents that CASA says are in breach of the rules and regulations applicable to helicopter pilots. CASA cancelled Mr Jones’s licences on the grounds referred to in regulation 269(1)(c) and (d) of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth) (CAR).
Mr Jones has asked the Tribunal to review the cancellation decision.
At the hearing, CASA referred to a series of incidents or matters depicted in the television program that provided a basis for regulatory action against Mr Jones.
Mr Jones, for his part, conceded he made a number of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Milton Jones and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] AATA 820
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that while Mr Jones’s use of the helicopter for filming purposes did breach certain regulations, the specific incident involving the crocodile egg harvesting was staged and did not pose an actual safety risk. However, the court was concerned about the broader approach to regulation and Mr Jones's lack of clarity regarding the appropriate approvals for his operations. The court concluded that a suspension of Mr Jones’s licences was warranted to ensure he obtained the necessary certifications to demonstrate his competence and adherence to safety regulations. The suspension was set to take effect 28 days after the decision, allowing Mr Jones time to obtain the required certifications. If he could provide the necessary certifications before the suspension was due to commence, his licences would not be suspended.
The decision set aside the previous determination and substituted it with a suspension of Mr Jones’s flight crew licences until he obtained certification in relation to the matters outlined in the reasons for the decision. This outcome aimed to ensure that Mr Jones would not operate an aircraft until he demonstrated the requisite knowledge and decision-making skills required for his licences. The court’s decision emphasised the importance of adhering to civil aviation regulations and maintaining the high standards of safety and fitness expected of licensed flight crew members.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
I note the applicant expressly denied he was operating under the Albatross AOC when he was harvesting crocodile eggs: see applicant’s closing submissions at [38]. If the NAH AOC was relied upon, it raises a question over whether that company’s operations are being conducted in accordance with its AOC as it should not have allowed a private pilot to undertake aerial photography work. Confusion on this point is symptomatic of an approach to regulation that needs to be addressed. I am inclined to accept CASA’s argument that there has been a failure on Mr Jones’s part to demonstrate he held an AOC with appropriate approvals, but I am troubled by the uncertainty over the arrangements in any event. Sling operations during crocodile egg harvesting There was a good deal of evidence surrounding Mr Jones’s use of the helicopter to harvest crocodile eggs. The crocodile egg harvest in question was shown in the first series of Keeping up with the Joneses. It provided moments of high drama. The helicopter with Mr Jones at the controls hovered over a crocodile nest. The shots of and from the helicopter were cut with footage of an agitated crocodile. One of Mr Jones’s employees was lowered into the nest on an external sling – a length of rope that hung from a point on the belly of the helicopter. He was armed with a stick and a radio. Once on the ground, he worked quickly to uncover the nest and retrieve the eggs that were placed in a crate. The employee’s anxious glances towards the undergrowth made clear – and the voice-over breathlessly confirmed – that the large, angry crocodile lurked close by, ready to attack. But then came relief: the employee was lifted from the scene with the crate of eggs and carried off by Mr Jones in the helicopter. The aircraft appeared to fly away over the tree tops with Mr Jones at the controls and the employee dangling on the end of the sling. The incident was staged. There was no crocodile nearby. The eggs were placed there before the cameras rolled. Mr Jones explained in his evidence that it was the wrong time of year for crocodile egg harvesting, so it was necessary to pretend. He justified the role-play for the cameras by saying it accurately represented the way he harvested crocodile eggs. There is an issue over the practice of carrying a person on a sling under a Robinson R22 helicopter. CAR 151 prohibits a pilot using the aircraft to pick up persons or objects without prior written authority, and in accordance with any conditions attached to that authority. CAR 151 does not distinguish between flights conducted for commercial or private activity. CAR 250(1A) prohibits the pilot in command from allowing a person to be carried on anything attached to the aircraft, although CASA may give permission for a person to be carried underneath (or anywhere else) on a particular flight or kind of flight (CAR 250(2)). Any permission may be subject to conditions: CAR 250(3). Mr Jones has an approval to engage in commercial sling load operations pursuant to Civil Aviation Order 29.6. CASA says that approval does not extend to carrying a person in a sling: it points out the sling load provisions in CAO 29.6 refer to carriage of an object, not a person. It also says the approval under CAO 29.6 is limited to commercial operations conducted under an AOC, whereas the mock crocodile egg harvest was conducted as part of private operations. The discussion of sling load operations in CAO 95.7.2 also refers to objects without qualification. Mr Jones says a person is an object, and there is no contravention.