Millar v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Millar v Commissioner of Police [2025] QCA 113

PARTIES:

MILLAR, Andrew John
(applicant)
v
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

CA No 185 of 2024
DC No 3468 of 2023

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave s 118 DCA (Criminal)

ORIGINATING COURT:


District Court at Brisbane – [2024] QDC 114 (Richards DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

24 June 2025

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

16 April 2025

JUDGES:

Bradley JA and Burns and Ryan JJ

ORDER:

The application for leave to appeal is refused.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – WHEN APPEAL LIES – FROM DISTRICT COURT – BY LEAVE OF COURT – where the applicant was found guilty after trial in the Magistrates Court of public nuisance contrary to s 6 of the Summary Offences Act 2005 (Qld) – where the applicant appealed to the District Court pursuant to s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld) on grounds which included that the decision was against the weight of the evidence and that evidence needed by the defendant was destroyed by the prosecution – where the District Court judge dismissed the appeal – where the applicant applies for leave to appeal pursuant to s 118(3) of the District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld) from the District Court on the grounds that the decision was against the weight of evidence, the decision was affected by fraud, and the court invented evidentiary reasons not submitted by either party – whether there is a reasonable argument that there is an error to be corrected – whether leave to appeal is necessary to correct a substantial injustice

Criminal Code (Qld), s 268, s 269
Summary Offences Act 2005 (Qld), s 6
Vagrants, Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931 (Qld), s 7AA (repealed)

Austin v Commissioner of Police [2022] QDC 230, cited
McDonald v Queensland Police Service [2018] 2 Qd R 612; [2017] QCA 255, cited

COUNSEL:

The applicant appeared on his own behalf
S J Muir for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

The applicant appeared on his own behalf
Director of Public Prosecutions (Queensland) for the respondent

  1. THE COURT:  The applicant was convicted of the offence of public nuisance[1] after a trial in the Magistrates Court in October 2023.  The applicant was fined $650 and a conviction was recorded.  The applicant appealed against his conviction to the District Court.  His appeal was dismissed on 8 August 2024.  He seeks this Court’s leave to appeal against that dismissal.  For the reasons which follow, the application for leave to appeal is refused.

    [1]Section 6 of the Summary Offences Act2005.

    The particulars of the offence

  2. The particulars of the public nuisance offence were contained in a document which was provided to the applicant ahead of the trial and to the Magistrate at trial.  Relevantly, it read (paragraphs numbers added for ease of reference):

    (i)It will be alleged that on the [19th day of July 2022], the defendant Andrew John MILLAR was within the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Millar v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QCA 113
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Millar v Commissioner of Police, the applicant, after being found guilty of public nuisance in the Magistrates Court, sought to appeal the decision to the Supreme Court, following the dismissal of his appeal to the District Court. The applicant argued that the decision was against the weight of the evidence, that evidence needed by the defendant was destroyed by the prosecution, and that the court invented evidentiary reasons not submitted by either party. The central issue for the court was whether there was a reasonable argument that there was an error to be corrected, and whether leave to appeal was necessary to correct a substantial injustice.

The court found that the District Court judge approached the appeal correctly and dismissed it by reviewing the trial evidence, considering the differences between the evidence of the librarian and PSO Wright about whether Wright spoke to Ms X, and discussing the applicant’s evidence about the events leading up to the incident in the lift. The court observed that the missing CCTV footage, which the applicant claimed would have shown the aggression of the PSOs and justified his behaviour, could not have provided a defence for the applicant as it would not have revealed what was said and therefore did not show verbal harassment. The court concluded that the applicant had not raised a defence and upheld the conviction based on the existing evidence.

The court then considered the application for leave to appeal the decision of the District Court, noting that leave to appeal from the District Court would usually only be granted where the appeal is necessary to correct a substantial injustice, and there is a reasonable argument that there is an error to be corrected. The court found that the applicant had not established that he had suffered a substantial injustice or that there had been a misapplication of the law or a misunderstanding of the evidence leading to his conviction, warranting the granting of leave. The court ultimately refused the application for leave to appeal.

The orders of the court were that the application for leave to appeal is refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application for leave to appeal is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

With respect to the “false” evidence allegedly given by Wright about Ms X: Ms X was not called at trial. However, she provided the applicant with an affidavit for the purposes of his appeal to the District Court in which she said that she had been in the library when the PSOs spoke to the applicant but they did not speak to her. For what it is worth, the librarian did not see a PSO speak to Ms X before they spoke to the applicant.The applicant’s evidence and his “defence” Before the Magistrate, the applicant gave evidence that he had been on his mobile phone in the Supreme Court Library discussing an issue about court transcripts. He was due to appear in court at 10 am that day, self-represented. Ms X, a member of the public who was also in the library, told him off about talking on the phone. He waved her away and completed his call. The next thing he knew, Wright and another PSO entered the library. Other evidence at trial established that, after her interaction with the applicant, Ms X asked the librarian to call courts’ security. The librarian made the call and told security that there had been “an altercation” in the library. Officers Wright and Sharman responded to the call and, when they got to the library, the librarian pointed out Ms X and the applicant to them. A little later, Wright called Bryant to the library to assist. Returning to the applicant’s evidence, he said (emphasis added):“Wright kept calling me “Mate, we’ve got a complaint that you have assaulted someone, mate”. And I said, “I haven’t assaulted anyone.” And she said, “Okay, well we’ve got an alleged assault. Anything you want to say about that?” all that sort of stuff. And I said, “Look, I haven’t assaulted anyone.” I didn’t see her stop and talk to Ms [X] at all. They just walked straight around from the librarian’s desk and came to me because I could see up the thing. And they demanded an identification, which I couldn’t actually give because I didn’t have a licence on me. And I think we had an exchange about demanding my name and what’s the power and that, and I said “I’ve got caught [sic] so I’m going to go” and they said, “Okay, that’s fine with us. Happy with that.” and at that point in time there was three officers and they basically walked within about 20 centimetres from me, around me, all the way from my desk to the lifts and when I was waiting to get in the lift because – it probably took a good 30 seconds because it takes a while for the lift to come up to the 12th floor because – and Ms Wright was continuing to sort of talk to me in a derogatory manner calling me “mate” and staring at my face and saying stuff and just sort of stirring the pot. And it just basically got to, it affected me too much. So that once – as they said they hopped in the lift close to me and I basically responded to something she said to me in the lift in the same manner which she spoke to me, which unfortunately that footage is now not available. And that’s it. So they said I didn’t attempt to strike her in any way. I just basically communicated back how she was communicating to me. And then you’ve seen the rest …”

Decision

Reasons for decision

The learned District Court judge asked the applicant what the missing footage would have shown. He said (from the bar table) that it would have shown the threatening behaviour of the PSOs. Her Honour asked what they did which was threatening. The applicant said, “They were standing around me, tilting their heads and all at me, and talking to me in the same manner that I --- It was like a trident … there was three of them, so between the 360 degrees, you would say they were equidistant, 120 each. From memory, probably inside of a foot from me, tilting in towards me and talking to me in negative ---”. Her Honour asked the applicant what the PSOs were saying. He said it went from his head a month later and he was not going to make something up: but it was threatening and menacing. He claimed that the conduct of the PSOs was worse than his conduct. Her Honour asked the applicant how that would make him not guilty. He said there was a defence of provocation. When told there was not, he said there was a defence of mental anguish. He said he had been badgered by Wright, who made up the allegation of assault. The PSOs followed him closely, stood over him, and talked to him in a threatening manner. But the footage was missing. He argued, in effect, that in the absence of that evidence, his trial was not fair.The decision of the District Court judge The District Court judge approached the applicant’s appeal correctly.[3] In dismissing it, her Honour considered the trial evidence, noting the difference between the evidence of the librarian and PSO Wright about whether she spoke to Ms X. Her Honour discussed the applicant’s evidence about what went on while he and the three PSOs were waiting for the lift and what he and the PSOs said about how closely they were following him.[3]An appeal by way of re-hearing conducted by a District Court Judge under sections 222 and 223 of the Justices Act 1886 is a re-hearing in the sense of a review of the record of the proceedings before the Magistrate, and of fresh evidence admitted by leave. In this case, the fresh evidence was in the form of an affidavit by Ms X. Her Honour stated that Ms X’s affidavit was of little relevance apart from its relevance to the accuracy of Wright’s evidence that she spoke to Ms X in the library. Her Honour referred to the missing CCTV footage and the applicant’s arguments that the footage would have shown the aggression of the PSOs and justified his behaviour in the lift. Her Honour accepted that the missing CCTV footage should have been disclosed but she did not accept that it had been deliberately destroyed. Nor did she accept that there was fraud or fabrication involved in the information or evidence around it being missing. At [22] of her reasons, the learned District Court judge identified the “real question” in relation to the missing footage, namely, whether it could have provided a defence for the applicant. Her Honour was prepared to accept that it would have shown the security officers following him very closely, with Wright as close to him as he was to her in the lift. It would not have revealed what was said (the footage had no sound) so her Honour made no finding that Wright was verbally harassing the applicant. But, her Honour observed, the question was, even if Wright had verbally harassed the applicant, whether the actions of the security officers prior to their entering the lift could result in a defence to a charge of public nuisance.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In concluding that the applicant had not raised a defence, her Honour referred to Austin v Commissioner of Police [2022] QDC 230. In that case, Austin challenged his conviction for public nuisance on the basis that he had been: “Provoked by Council giving my rates notice to police without a warrant. Major conflict of interest”. The conviction was upheld by Allen KC DCJ on the basis that it was not a defence to, nor excuse for, public nuisance that the defendant believed he was entitled to act as he did because of the unlawful conduct of the council; and that the appellant’s contention that his behaviour might be excused for such a reason was misguided and wrong in law.Consideration Leave to appeal a decision of the District Court, sitting in its appellate jurisdiction, will usually only be granted where the appeal is necessary to correct a substantial injustice, and there is a reasonable argument that there is an error to be corrected. Leave to appeal is not given lightly: an applicant will have already had the benefit of two judicial hearings.[4][4]McDonald v Queensland Police Service [2018] 2 Qd R 612 at [39]. The applicant elaborated on and expanded upon his grounds of appeal at the oral hearing before this Court, asserting a variety of errors in fact finding and in the application of the law. However, this Court’s review of the evidence given at the trial before the Magistrate supports the conclusion that the applicant was properly convicted of the offence of public nuisance. There is no basis for concluding that the applicant’s conviction was unreasonable. The applicant has not established that he has suffered a substantial injustice or that there has been a misapplication of the law or a misunderstanding of the evidence leading to his conviction, warranting the granting of leave. The applicant does not contest his behaviour in the lift, which was captured clearly on the CCTV footage tendered at trial. Nor is he challenging the evidence that he got very close to Wright’s face and called her “mate”. In his evidence before the Magistrate, in his submissions to her, in his appeal to the District Court judge, and in his application for leave to this Court, the applicant’s primary focus has been on what occurred before he and the PSOs entered the lift. His argument has been, in effect, that he is not guilty of the offence of public nuisance because he was “provoked” to act as he did – not in the section 268/269 of the Code sense (he now understands that that defence does not apply) but, to use his words, in the sense of their conduct “getting on top of him” or causing him “mental anguish”: driving him to act as he did. To put his position in the language of potential legal defences to summary criminal conduct: as the applicant sees it, he has a reasonable excuse for his conduct; and he has been concerned that he is unable to independently prove how the PSOs behaved towards him in the lift foyer (to make out his “defence”) because that CCTV footage has been lost.