Millar v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Millar v Commissioner of Police [2024] QDC 114

PARTIES:

ANDREW JOHN MILLAR
(appellant)

v

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
(respondent)

FILE NO:

3468/23

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Appeal pursuant to s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld)

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane Magistrates Court

DELIVERED ON:

8 August 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

3 June 2024

JUDGE:

Richards DCJ

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL – APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION  – where the appellant was convicted of public nuisance after a summary trial – whether the decision was against the weight of the evidence – whether the summary proceeding was affected by fraud and fabricated evidence by the prosecution – whether the elements of the offence were made out – whether evidence needed by defence was destroyed by the prosecution

LEGISLATION:

Criminal Code Act 1899 ((Qld)

Justices Act 1886 (Qld)

Summary Offences Act 2005 (Qld)

CASES:

Austin v Commission of Police [2022] QDC 230

Coleman v Power & Ors [2004] 220 CLR 1

Couchy v Birchley [2005] QDC 334

Gallagher v The Queen [1986] 160 CLR 392

Green v Ashton [2006] QDC 008

House v The King [1936] 55 CLR 499

Kaporonovski v R [1973] 133 CLR 209

Kris v Tramacchi [2006] QDC 305

Police v Christie [1962] NZLR 1109

COUNSEL:

The Appellant appeared in person

L Kerr for the Respondent

SOLICITORS:

The Director of Public Prosecutions for the Respondent

Introduction

  1. The appellant was convicted of public nuisance after a summary trial in the Brisbane Magistrates Court.  He was fined $650, and a conviction was recorded.  He has appealed that conviction on the following grounds:

    1.   The decision was against the weight of the evidence.

    2.   The proceeding was affected by fraud and fabricated evidence by the prosecutor.

    3.   The elements of the offence were not made out.

    4.   Evidence needed by defence was destroyed by prosecution.

    Facts

  2. The Crown case was that on 19 July 2022, the appellant was in the Supreme Court Library.  Also in the library on that day was a woman called Emma Thompson. Brendan Copley, an employee of the Supreme Court Library, was working at the time when he was asked to call security by a woman.[1]  Mr Copley, in cross-examination, agreed that Emma Thompson had said to him, “Did you hear what he said to me?” and  he said he did not hear Mr Millar say anything to Ms Thompson but saw him walking with some papers, and it looked like he was going back to sit at a table.[2] The appellant, in his evidence, said he was talking on the phone in the library when Ms Thompson came up to him and, from about 10 metres away, told him off for talking.  He waved her away and did not engage with her. He sat down and finished his conversation, and within a short time the officers came up to him.[3]

    [1] T1-26, l 25

    [2] T1-31, l 35

    [3] T1-124, l 10-17

  3. The security control room received a phone call…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Millar v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QDC 114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Millar v Commissioner of Police, the appellant was convicted of public nuisance after a summary trial in the Brisbane Magistrates Court. He was fined $650 and a conviction was recorded. The appeal against this conviction was based on four grounds: the decision was against the weight of the evidence, the proceeding was affected by fraud and fabricated evidence by the prosecutor, the elements of the offence were not made out, and evidence needed by the defence was destroyed by the prosecution.

The appeal grounds were assessed by examining the effect on the fairness of the trial of the loss of CCTV evidence and the failure to call Emma Thompson as a witness. The appellant argued that a miscarriage of justice occurred because footage from cameras positioned outside the lift on the 12th floor was not disclosed. However, the court found that the footage should have been disclosed but there was no evidence of deliberate concealment or deletion. The court also found that there was no fabricated evidence or fraud by the prosecution, despite the numerous adjournments during the trial. The elements of the offence of public nuisance were also assessed, but it was determined that they were made out in this case.

The appeal was dismissed, with the court finding that the conviction was properly made and there were no grounds for overturning it.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant was convicted of public nuisance after a summary trial in the Brisbane Magistrates Court. He was fined $650, and a conviction was recorded. He has appealed that conviction on the following grounds:1. The decision was against the weight of the evidence.2. The proceeding was affected by fraud and fabricated evidence by the prosecutor.3. The elements of the offence were not made out.4. Evidence needed by defence was destroyed by prosecution.Facts The Crown case was that on 19 July 2022, the appellant was in the Supreme Court Library. Also in the library on that day was a woman called Emma Thompson. Brendan Copley, an employee of the Supreme Court Library, was working at the time when he was asked to call security by a woman.[1] Mr Copley, in cross-examination, agreed that Emma Thompson had said to him, “Did you hear what he said to me?” and he said he did not hear Mr Millar say anything to Ms Thompson but saw him walking with some papers, and it looked like he was going back to sit at a table.[2] The appellant, in his evidence, said he was talking on the phone in the library when Ms Thompson came up to him and, from about 10 metres away, told him off for talking. He waved her away and did not engage with her. He sat down and finished his conversation, and within a short time the officers came up to him.[3] [1] T1-26, l 25[2] T1-31, l 35[3] T1-124, l 10-17 The security control room received a phone call at about 9.30 am in the morning, and they were advised there was an altercation in the library on Level 12. Jennifer Wright and Kent Sharman, both Senior Protective Service Officers, went to the library, spoke with the librarian and they were pointed towards two individuals that were believed to be involved in the altercation[4]. Officer Sharman spoke with the appellant, and Officer Wright said that she spoke with Emma Thompson. [I note Officer Wright’s evidence differs from Mr Copley, who said no-one spoke to Ms Thompson until after the altercation and after Mr Millar left the library]. In relation to the interaction between the appellant and the security officers, Mr Copley said there was a lot of shouting going on from both sides, and most of the library would have been able to hear the raised voices.[5] The security officers asked the appellant for his name and indicated they would remove him from the library if he refused to give his name. [4] T1-43, ll22-27[5] T1-38, l 10. What happened thereafter is reasonably uncontroversial in terms of the sequence of events. The appellant indicated he would leave the library. He was not detained at any stage. He walked out of the library, and the three security guards (by now Officer Bryant was also in the library) followed him to the lift area. Mr Millar pushed the lift button to go down. He entered the lift, followed by Bryant, then Sharman, then Wright. As Wright entered the lift, he said, “I basically responded to something she said to me in the lift in the same manner in which she spoke to me, which unfortunately that footage is now not available and that’s it. I didn’t attempt to strike her in anyway. I just basically communicated back to how she was communicating to me.”[6][6] T124, l 35.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The appeal grounds overlap in some respects. I propose to deal with them by examining firstly the effect on the fairness of the trial of the loss of CCTV evidence and failure to call Emma Thompson as a witness and secondly the elements of the offence of public nuisance and whether they were made out in this case. The missing evidence The appellant maintains a miscarriage of justice occurred because there was a failure to disclose footage from cameras positioned outside the lift on the 12th floor of the court building. It was generally accepted that there were security cameras positioned in the waiting area outside the lifts on the 12th level. There was no suggestion that those cameras were not working. Officer Wright, who downloaded the CCTV images that were tendered in the trial, gave evidence[15] that she checked the camera that sits over the foyer in the lifts, and she believed she had downloaded that footage and had attached it to a folder in the USB that she supplied to police. Constable Baker gave evidence that he went to the court building and collected a USB stick and downloaded it onto a disk[16]. At the trial, the disk did not contain footage of the foyer outside the lift on Level 12. It is submitted by the appellant that this failure to disclose the footage amounts to a fatal error in this case because disclosure of that footage would have shown the aggression to which he was subjected by the security officers and would have justified his actions in the lift.[15] T1-57, l 25.[16] Exhibit 4 I accept that the CCTV footage of the foyer area outside the lift on Level 12 should have been disclosed. It is not clear what happened to that footage. Officer Wright thought the footage had gone to the police officer. The police officer maintains that he downloaded whatever he received to the disk and the footage is not on the disk. The original USB was never produced. The appellant maintains that this has been deliberately concealed. That submission does not allow for human error. I do not accept the argument advanced by the appellant that the evidence has been deliberately concealed or deleted. If the footage was being deliberately concealed, then it seems unlikely that Officer Wright would have given evidence that she thought she had downloaded it and sent it to the police. The footage has either not been downloaded or has not been transferred to the disk. The appellant has submitted that there was fraud or fabricated evidence by the prosecution. There were a number of adjournments during the trial for the prosecutor to obtain further instructions in relation to the existence or otherwise of the CCTV footage from the foyer of the 12th floor outside the lifts and in relation to a statement being taken from Emma Thompson. The prosecutor conveyed the information he was given to the court, but there is no basis upon which to draw a conclusion that the information that was placed before the court was fabricated. The evidence given by Constable Baker was to the effect that he has given all the material he had to the court; he could not contact Emma Thompson and, although he searched for her details, he was unaware whether he even had the correct contact details for the Emma Thompson that was present in the library on the day in question.