Military Compensation and Rehabilitation Commission v Wall

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Military Compensation and Rehabilitation Commission v Wall [2004] FCA 1711

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – error of law – compensation claim by veteran – veteran suffered cerebrovascular accident (CVA) and ischaemic heart disease (IHD) – one factor causative of the CVA and IHD was smoking – veteran commenced smoking during his army service – whether Administrative Appeals Tribunal failed to properly consider the relationship between the veteran’s ailments and his performance of his duties as a member of the Defence Force – no basis for concluding that the Tribunal failed to consider the required relationship – finding that ailments arose out of performance of duties a finding available on facts before the Tribunal – no error of law demonstrated – appeal dismissed

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – irrelevant consideration – reference by the Tribunal to guidelines and legislation relating to veterans’ entitlements as distinct from the compensation legislation – the Tribunal was entitled to have regard to such material – in any case, the Tribunal did not base its finding upon the material – ground not made out

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 44(1)
Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees’ Act) 1971 (Cth) s 7, 7(2), 27, 29(1)
Commonwealth Employees’ Compensation Act 1930 (Cth) s 4(1), 4A(2)
Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004 (Cth)
Military Rehabilitation and Compensation (Consequential and Transitional Provisions) Act 2004 (Cth)
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988 (Cth) s 4, 5, 5(2), 7(2), 29(2)(f), 124(1), 124(1A), 124(2), 144(3)
Veterans’ Affairs Legislation Amendment (Budget and Compensation Measures) Act 1997 (Cth)
Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) s 8(6), 9(7), 120

Barratt v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2004] AATA 1141 cited
Collector of Customs v Pozzolanic Enterprises Pty Ltd (1993) 43 FCR 280 applied
Commissioner for Railways (NSW) v Scott (1959) 102 CLR 392 considered
Commonwealth of Australia v Fernie (1999) 23 SR(WA) 12 cited
Kavanagh v Commonwealth (1960) 103 CLR 547 applied
Commonwealth v Quince (1944) 68 CLR 227 considered
Commonwealth v Wright (1956) 96 CLR 536 considered
Maunder v Commonwealth (1983) 76 FLR 341 cited
Millwood v Comcare [2004] AATA 116 considered
Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 applied
R v Australian Stevedoring Industry Board; Ex parte Melbourne Stevedoring Co Pty Ltd (1953) 88 CLR 100 applied
Repatriation Commission v Tuite (1993) 39 FCR 540 cited
Commonwealth v Carter (1965) 7 FLR 223 cited
Wall v Comcare [2004] AATA 229 referred to

MILITARY COMPENSATION AND REHABILITATION COMMISSION v BARRY WALL
NSD 457 OF 2004

HELY J
22 DECEMBER 2004
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 457 OF 2004

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

BETWEEN:

MILITARY COMPENSATION AND REHABILITATION COMMISSION
APPELLANT

AND:

BARRY WALL
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

HELY J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 DECEMBER 2005

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The appeal be dismissed with costs.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Military Compensation and Rehabilitation Commission v Wall and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 1711
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Military Compensation and Rehabilitation Commission v Wall was a case before the court concerning a claim made by Mr Wall for compensation under the Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 for a cerebrovascular accident (CVA) that occurred in 1989. Mr Wall argued that his CVA was a result of his smoking habit, which he developed during his military service. The dispute centred around whether the smoking habit, which contributed to the CVA, arose out of or in the course of his military employment.

The legal issues before the court included determining the scope of the term 'arising out of' in the context of Mr Wall's military service and whether the military environment, including the stress and social norms associated with it, could be considered a contributing factor to his smoking habit. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the smoking habit was a direct consequence of his military service or merely a personal choice exacerbated by the environment.

In addressing the case, the court considered the evidence presented by Mr Wall, including his claims about the conditions of his enlistment and the social environment of the military that encouraged smoking. The court also reviewed the medical opinions regarding the contribution of smoking to Mr Wall's CVA and the onset of his ischaemic heart disease (IHD). The Tribunal had found that Mr Wall's military service was responsible for creating the smoking habit, a finding that Comcare contested. The court found that the Tribunal's determination was within its purview and did not constitute an error of law, despite differing from previous decisions. The court concluded that the Tribunal's interpretation of the facts was reasonable and that the appeal should be dismissed.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the appeal with costs. The court determined that the appeal did not present a valid ground for overturning the Tribunal's decision and upheld the Tribunal's findings on the causation of Mr Wall's smoking habit and its connection to his military service.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Clearly enough, the CVA was not an injury suffered ‘in the course of’ Mr Wall’s employment by the Commonwealth, as this ‘injury’ occurred about 30 years after the termination of that employment. The words ‘out of’ import causation: Kavanagh v Commonwealth (1960) 103 CLR 547 at 558 (Fullagar J).The evidence before the Tribunal Mr Wall said he started smoking after enlistment. He had never smoked before that time. He said he was placed in an environment where smoking was the norm. Mr Wall said that, at the time of his medical examination for enlistment (20 October 1953), he reported a history of a broken right arm. Mr Wall said that, had he been properly examined, he would not have been passed as Class A1 medically fit. His right arm condition caused him stress in the performance of guard duties which he found difficult, and he commenced to smoke. He also referred to other conscripts smoking; to smoking being an aspect of social life during his National Service; and to the Army being an environment that encouraged smoking (AB 89). He said that service life contains many potential links to smoking, such as stress, peer pressure, availability and boredom. At the end of his 90 day camp, he was smoking about 20-30 cigarettes a day. Mr Wall’s claim was disallowed by Comcare on the basis that while the Army may have tolerated smoking, that was reflective of the general population’s attitude towards cigarette consumption at the time. Comcare also said that smoking was not required in the performance of duties by the Australian Defence Force, but was rather a matter of personal choice. Dr Michael Burns is a consultant physician who produced a report that was part of the evidence before the Tribunal. In his report, Dr Burns expressed the opinion that heavy cigarette smoking was a significant factor contributing to Mr Wall’s IHD, the onset of which was in 1987, and noted that Mr Wall took up smoking during his period of National Service in the Army. Dr Burns also expressed the opinion, apparently based on Mr Wall’s claimed history of pain in the right elbow caused by rifle drills in the Army, that the stress of doing those drills caused Mr Wall to commence and become addicted to cigarette smoking. According to another doctor, Dr O’Rourke, Mr Wall’s first symptoms of cardiac disease were on 20 July 1987, when he first sought medical treatment from his local practitioner and Belmont Hospital; and Mr Wall’s first CVA occurred in May 1989. Dr O’Rourke attributed Mr Wall’s IHD and cerebrovascular accident to a number of factors, including his smoking habit. He did not agree with Dr Burns’ opinion that military service conditions contributed significantly to the taking up and continuation of Mr Wall’s smoking habit.The Tribunal’s reasoning The Tribunal noted that there is no dispute that Mr Wall’s smoking habit was a contributing factor to his IHD and CVA, but further noted that the question to be asked was whether Mr Wall’s military service, in particular his full time service, was responsible for creating the smoking habit. The Tribunal posed as the question for its determination (see Wall v Comcare [2004] AATA 229 at [13]):‘The real question in this matter is whether the Applicant’s smoking habit can be said to have arisen out of or in the course of his employment (s 4 of the 1988 Act) or whether his employment was a contributing factor (s 29 of the 1971 Act).’

Decision

Reasons for decision

HELY J
For the reasons earlier given, this submission fails. It erroneously assumes that there is a necessary distinction between Mr Wall’s military service, and the performance of duties as a member of the Defence Force. In Commonwealth v Carter (supra) Smithers J said in the context of the 1930 Act (at 227):‘In this business the Air Force is specifically concerned with the training and general development of its personnel in mind and body and its orders to airmen reach into their lives in many respects not touched by an ordinary employer whose business is to produce goods or services for profit. This it does by way of authority. It is the service which determines and supplies what he is to wear, how he will cut his hair, where he may go when on duty or stand-down, what he is to eat or drink, whether he will walk or run, whether he will fetch or carry or indulge in recreation, and in what kind of recreation and when such recreation shall be taken.’The performance of duties as a member of the Defence Force includes obedience to orders in relation to a wide range of matters.Conclusion It was for the Tribunal to decide the facts, and to determine issues of causation. The Tribunal did so, and in a way which differs from the approach adopted by differently constituted Tribunals in Millwood (supra), and Barratt v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2004] AATA 1141. But that does not mean that the Tribunal in the present case committed an error of law. Rather, it took a view of the facts which would not necessarily have been taken by all persons who may have been called upon to decide that question. The appeal should be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HELY J