Milburn v National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

Milburn and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 4928 (20 December 2018)

Division:National Disability Insurance Scheme Division

File Number(s):       2018/2133

Re:Richelle Milburn

APPLICANT

National Disability Insurance AgencyAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal: Deputy President J W Constance 

Date:20 December 2018

Date of written reasons:        8 February 2019

Place:Sydney

DECISION:For the reasons given orally at the conclusion of the hearing of this matter, the Tribunal decides that:

1.the reviewable decision made 8 November 2017 is set aside;

2.the matter is remitted to the Respondent for reconsideration in accordance with the following direction in relation to the statement of supports in Ms Milburn’s plan current as at the date of this decision;

3.IT IS DIRECTED that Ms Milburn’s current plan be amended to include the following supports from and including the date of the commencement of the plan:

i.transport to and from Ms Milburn’s appointments with her General Practitioner on 12 occasions per calendar year;

ii.transport to and from 16 Specialist medical appointments each calendar year;

iii.transport to and from Ms Milburn’s appointments with her Psychologist on 12 occasions per calendar year;

iv.transport to and from Ms Milburn’s appointments with her Physiotherapist on 12 occasions per calendar year;

v.transport to and from a gymnasium at Sutherland Leisure Centre once per week;

vi.transport to and from Cronulla shopping precinct (or similar) twice per week;

vii.funding for a support person to accompany Ms Milburn to all appointments with health professionals;

viii.funding for a support person on visits to a local shopping centre twice per week for a period of up to two hours on each occasion in substitution for that previously provided;

ix.funding for house cleaning assistance for a period of 260 hours per year in substitution for that previously provided;

x.funding for assistance with meal preparation for 156 hours per year in substitution for that previously provided;

xi.funding for assistance to attend social activities for 468 hours per year in substitution for that previously provided;

xii.funding for the provision of three pairs of bifocal glasses (including one pair of sunglasses) with prism lenses;

xiii.funding for the provision of support by a personal trainer at the gym attended by Ms Milburn for one hour per week.

..............[sgd]..........................................................

J W Constance
Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – whether supports are reasonable and necessary – transport and associated carer services – singing lessons – transport and accommodation to visit family – remedial massage – bifocal glasses with prism lenses – specially compounded prescription medicine – Turner Syndrome – Borderline Personality Disorder – fibromyalgia – arthritis – macular degeneration – decision set aside

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

CASES

KLMN and National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] AATA 1815

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308

Young and National Disability Insurance Agency [2014] AATA 401

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

WRITTEN REASONS FOR DECISION

Oral reasons given 20 December 2018

8 February 2019

A.    INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Milburn has been a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Milburn v National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 4928
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Ms Milburn against the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding the inclusion of certain supports in her NDIS plan. Ms Milburn, who suffers from multiple significant medical conditions resulting in serious disabilities, sought to have various supports funded under the Scheme, including music therapy, gym membership and personal training, transport and accommodation for family visits, remedial massage, bifocal glasses with prism lenses, specially compounded prescription medicine, and an increase in her transport and community support budget. The NDIA had refused to include these requested supports in her plan.

The primary legal issue before the court was to determine which of the supports claimed by Ms Milburn were "reasonable and necessary" within the meaning of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (the Act) and the relevant Rules and Guidelines. This required the court to consider whether each proposed support would assist Ms Milburn to pursue her goals and aspirations, facilitate her social and economic participation, represent value for money, be effective and beneficial, take into account what could reasonably be expected from informal networks, and be most appropriately funded by the NDIS rather than other systems.

The court's reasoning involved a detailed assessment of each claimed support against the criteria for "reasonable and necessary" supports as stipulated in section 34 of the Act. The court noted that all conditions under section 34 must be satisfied for each support. In relation to transport and associated carer services, the court considered evidence suggesting that the existing "on-call" service provided by Nonabel Transport, managed by an individual without relevant qualifications, was not structured to provide value for money or promote independence. The court also considered expert recommendations for an occupational therapist to conduct a community transport assessment to implement independent transport strategies.

Ultimately, the reviewable decision of the NDIA was set aside. The court substituted a new decision to include some, but not all, of the requested supports in Ms Milburn's NDIS plan, based on its assessment of which supports met the statutory criteria for being reasonable and necessary.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, the reviewable decision will be set aside. In substitution, a decision will be made to include in Ms Milburn's current plan some, but not all, of the requested supports.B. BACKGROUND Ms Milburn is 45 years old. She suffers from several significant medical conditions which have caused her very serious disabilities. By letter of 7 April 2017,[3] Ms Milburn was accepted as a participant in the Scheme.[3] Exhibit R1 at 31. Immediately prior to her acceptance into the Scheme, Ms Milburn was provided support under a New South Wales scheme.[4] I have been informed by the Solicitors for the Agency that, for this reason, the Agency’s letter of acceptance did not specify the disabilities in respect of which Ms Milburn was accepted as a participant in the Scheme. On this basis, I have considered all of the disabilities about which Ms Milburn has given evidence in determining which of the supports claimed are properly classified as “reasonable and necessary.”[5] It was not contended on behalf of the Agency that I should proceed otherwise.[4] Exhibit R1 at 9.[5] Confirmation of the conditions from which Ms Milburn suffers is to be found in Exhibit R1 at 22.Ms Milburn's claims for supports Ms Milburn claims that the following supports should be included in her plan as each of them is “reasonable and necessary” and, therefore, should be funded under the Act:a.Description: Music therapyPlan category: Improved daily livingFrequency: One 1 hour session per weekCost: $125 for one session, 52 weeks per yearTotal cost: $6,500b.Description: Gym membership and personal trainingPlan category: Improved daily livingFrequency: Annual membership, personal training twice a weekCost: $6,943 (incl membership of $850 pa)c.Description: Transport and accommodation to visit familyPlan category: Improved daily livingFrequency: One visit per year to Sunshine Coast for one week, one visit per year to Batemans Bay for one weekAccommodation: $1075 (Sunshine Coast); $665 (Batemans Bay)Transport: $358-$740 (flights - Sunshine Coast); $791.70 (shuttle - Batemans Bay)d.Description: Remedial massagePlan category: Improved daily livingFrequency: Once per week, 1 hour a weekCost: $90 per session, 52 weeks per yearTotal cost: $4,680e.Description: 3 pairs of bifocal glasses with prism lensesPlan category: Assistive technologyPair one: $734.00Pair two: $1,017.00Pair three: $564.95 (sunglasses)Total cost: $2,315.95f.Description: Medications specially compounded for allergiesCategory: Core supports (consumables)Cost: $297.34 a month Total annual cost: $3,568.08g.Description: Increase in budget for transport and community supportPlan category: Core supportsCost: Core support budget increases to $85,000 for 12 months.[6]The Agency has refused to include these supports in Ms Milburn’s plan.[6] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 20 July 2018 at [1].C. OUTLINE OF SCHEME AND RELEVANT PRINCIPLES In written submissions, the Solicitor for the Agency set out various provisions of the Act, Rules and Guidelines which provide the framework for determining the matters in dispute in this application. I am grateful for the assistance of these submissions, which form the basis of the content of this Part.Preparation of a participant’s plan

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Ms Smith recommended that, based on Ms Milburn’s needs, support be funded for transport for medical appointments and for shopping and practical assistance with these activities.[37] [37] Exhibit T3.Evidence of Ms Curdie-Evans In relation to transport to appointments Ms Curdie-Evans reported:This has ensured that Ms Milburn attends all medical, domestic and instrumental activities of daily living (Centrelink, Court, banks) and self-care (grooming and hairdressing) which is reasonable as a whole. However, the use of 1 on 1 transport is increasing and there is [sic] no functional and social reasons as to why this should occur (other than to attend medical appointments). The use of transport resources as noted previously has not had clear constraints and enabled an increased dependence on 1 on 1 services rather than increasing mainstream independence. The use of transport services on an on call basis and without structure will not in its structural program allow value for money and is not reasonable.[38][38] Exhibit R7 at 17. The alternative proposed by Ms Curdie-Evans is:Intervention by an Occupational Therapist to complete a community transport assessment and to implement an independent transport with Ms Milburn. This will support Ms Milburn (in conjunction with her psychologist) to increase independence in the community over a designated period of time. It will also provide clear boundaries on the usage of 1 on 1 transport.These uses of Taxi/Uber will be significantly greater in value for certain transport arrangements. These have been detailed below.Community transport options could be revisited and would be an alternate options for travel to family/or accommodation.[39] [39] Exhibit R7 at 17.Discussion I understand that Ms Milburn’s dismissive and, at times, aggressive approach to experts who express views contrary to those held by her may often be a consequence of the several medical conditions from which she suffers. This was evident during the hearing. Nevertheless, all participants in the NDIS are subject to the Act, and to the Supports Rules made thereunder. As a decision-maker under the Act, the Tribunal is similarly constrained. The support to be provided to Ms Milburn by way of transport and associated care has been the major issue in this application. Nonabel Transport is a registered provider under the Act. The company has provided Ms Milburn transport and assistance for appointments and shopping as well as other activities in which Ms Milburn is engaged and which she finds beneficial in dealing with her many significant disabilities. Between December 2017 and the hearing of this application in September 2018, Nonabel Transport provided Ms Milburn with what appears to have been an “on-call” transport and carer service. The decisions to provide such services, as and when requested by Ms Milburn, were made by Ms ElEssraoui, the Operations Manager. Ms ElEssraoui has no professional qualifications or training to enable her to assess the needs of Ms Milburn or to determine the appropriate manner in which those needs should be met, if they are to be met at all. Ms ElEssraoui told the Tribunal that she is unaware if her supervisor, or anyone else in the organisation, is relevantly qualified.[40] [40] Transcript, 13 September 2018, at 106 and 109.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Subsection 33(5) provides:(5) In deciding whether or not to approve a statement of participant supports under subsection (2), the CEO must: (a) have regard to the participant's statement of goals and aspirations; and (b) have regard to relevant assessments conducted in relation to the participant; and (c) be satisfied as mentioned in section 34 in relation to the reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded and the general supports that will be provided; and (d) apply the National Disability Insurance Scheme rules (if any) made for the purposes of section 35; and (e) have regard to the principle that a participant should manage his or her plan to the extent that he or she wishes to do so; and (f) have regard to the operation and effectiveness of any previous plans of the participant. Matters of which the decision-maker must be satisfied in relation to the funding or provision of supports Subsection 34(1) provides:(1) For the purposes of specifying, in a statement of participant supports, the general supports that will be provided, and the reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded, the CEO must be satisfied of all of the following in relation to the funding or provision of each such support: (a) the support will assist the participant to pursue the goals, objectives and aspirations included in the participant's statement of goals and aspirations; (b) the support will assist the participant to undertake activities, so as to facilitate the participant's social and economic participation;(c) the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support; (d) the support will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial for the participant, having regard to current good practice; (e) the funding or provision of the support takes account of what it is reasonable to expect families, carers, informal networks and the community to provide; (f) the support is most appropriately funded or provided through the National Disability Insurance Scheme, and is not more appropriately funded or provided through other general systems of service delivery or support services offered by a person, agency or body, or systems of service delivery or support services offered: (i) as part of a universal service obligation; or (ii) in accordance with reasonable adjustments required under a law dealing with discrimination on the basis of disability. It is to be noted that all of these conditions must be satisfied in relation to each support. In McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency the Federal Court said:Therefore, what is entered in a plan as a support becomes a determinative factor in the administration of the scheme. As the respondent submitted, by s 33(3), supports may be generally described or may be specifically identified. Either way, the function being performed on review by the Tribunal is to approve, vary of modify the supports as set out in a participant plan. In performing that function, the Tribunal must have regard to the matters set out in s 33(5), and form its satisfaction in accordance with s 34.[16][16] [2017] FCA 308 at [85].National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In written submissions, the Solicitor for the Agency set out various provisions of the Act, Rules and Guidelines which provide the framework for determining the matters in dispute in this application. I am grateful for the assistance of these submissions, which form the basis of the content of this Part.Preparation of a participant’s plan The Chief Executive Officer of the Agency is required to facilitate the preparation of a participant’s plan.[7] The plan must include:·the participant’s statement of goals and aspirations; and ·a statement of participant supports prepared with the participant and approved by the Chief Executive Officer.[8]It is to be noted that the statement of goals and aspirations is a statement by the participant and does not require the approval of the Chief Executive Officer. The statement of participant supports must specify the reasonable and necessary supports (if any) that will be funded under the Scheme.[7] Section 32 of the Act.[8] Section 33 of the Act. The provisions of the Act giving the participant alone the right to state his or her goals and aspirations and at the same time requiring the Chief Executive Officer to work with the participant to prepare the statement of supports, and then to approve those supports which will be funded, “strikes a balance between two of the Act’s objects:(a)the need to enable people with disability to exercise choice and control in the pursuit of their goals and the planning and delivery of their supports, and(b)the facilitation of a nationally consistent approach to the access to, and planning and funding of, supports for people with disability.”[9][9] Written Submissions of the Respondent dated 28 September 2018 at [8]; the objects of the Act are set out in section 3 of the Act.Implementing a plan The plan comes into effect once the Chief Executive Officer has received the participant’s statement of goals and aspirations and approved the statement of participant’s supports.[10][10] Section 37(1) of the Act. Money received by or on behalf of a participant must be spent in accordance with the participant’s plan.[11] An amount paid under the Scheme in respect of reasonable and necessary supports funded in accordance with a participant’s plan is referred to in the Act as the “NDIS amount.”[12][11] Section 46(1) of the Act.[12] Section 9 of the Act.The objects of the Act The objects of the Act set out in section 3 make particular reference to the purpose of providing reasonable and necessary supports. Subsection (3)(1) provides, in part:The objects of this Act are to:…(c) support the independence and social and economic participation of people with disability; and (d) provide reasonable and necessary supports, including early intervention supports, for participants in the National Disability Insurance Scheme launch; and (e) enable people with disability to exercise choice and control in the pursuit of their goals and the planning and delivery of their supports; and (f) facilitate the development of a nationally consistent approach to the access to, and the planning and funding of, supports for people with disability; and (g) promote the provision of high quality and innovative supports that enable people with disability to maximise independent lifestyles and full inclusion in the community; and (ga) protect and prevent people with disability from experiencing harm arising from poor quality or unsafe supports or services provided under the National Disability Insurance Scheme; and (h) raise community awareness of the issues that affect the social and economic participation of people with disability, and facilitate greater community inclusion of people with disability;…