Markaboui and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

Markaboui and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 1632 (8 June 2021)

Division:National Disability Insurance Scheme Division

File Number(s):      2017/7729

Re:Fouady Markaboui  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J W Constance

Date:8 June 2021

Place:Sydney

The reviewable decision made 8 November 2017 is set aside and the matter is remitted for reconsideration with the recommendation that the National Disability Insurance Agency fund an assessment of the suitability of hydrotherapy for Ms Markaboui’s condition and the likely cost of the treatment should it be found to be suitable.

...............................[SGD].........................................

Deputy President J W Constance

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary supports – voice and composition classes – hydrotherapy – education related expenses – spinal muscular atrophy – therapeutic value – value for money – application of National Disability Insurance Scheme Rules – where Tribunal not satisfied the requested voice classes will be effective and beneficial to the Applicant having regard to current good practice – where Tribunal not satisfied composition classes most appropriately funded through the Scheme – where Tribunal satisfied assessment of suitability of hydrotherapy appropriate – where Tribunal not satisfied educational expenses most appropriately funded through the Scheme – decision set aside and remitted

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ss 33, 34

CASES

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308

Milburn and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 4928

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013, r 3.1, 3.2, 3.3, 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, 7.1, 7.2, 7.3, 7.15, 7.16

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J W Constance

8 June 2021

A.   INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Markaboui has been a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme since May 2016. The Scheme was established by the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) and is administered by the National Disability Insurance Agency.

  2. Ms Markaboui is 51 years old. She suffers from Spinal Muscular Atrophy, a rare disease which has caused her complete loss of muscle control of her limbs, except for some movement in her right finger and thumb. Ms Markaboui lives alone and is totally dependent on carers to meet her needs.

  3. Fortunately, several issues previously in dispute between Ms Markaboui and the Agency have been resolved through the Tribunal’s alternative dispute resolution processes. However, there are three supports which Ms Markaboui is seeking to have funded by the Agency which remain in dispute:

    ·voice and composition classes;

    ·hydrotherapy; and

    ·education related expenses.

    Ms Markaboui says that the supports she claims are reasonable and necessary and, therefore, should be funded under the Act. These claims will be set out in detail later in these reasons.

  4. Ms Markaboui is asking the Tribunal to review the Agency’s decision made on 8 November 2017.[1] I will refer to this decision as the reviewable decision.

    [1] Exhibit R1 at 8.

  5. For the reasons which follow, the reviewable decision will be set aside and the matter will be remitted with a recommendation that the Agency fund…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Markaboui and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1632
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Ms Markaboui against a decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding the provision of supports under her NDIS plan. The dispute centred on whether certain requested supports, specifically voice and composition classes, hydrotherapy, and education-related expenses, were reasonable and necessary within the framework of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS).

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine whether the NDIA's decision to refuse funding for voice and composition classes, and education-related expenses, was correct. It also needed to consider the appropriateness of funding for hydrotherapy. The core legal issues revolved around the application of sections 33 and 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) and the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth), particularly the criteria for determining whether supports are "reasonable and necessary."

The Tribunal applied the principles outlined in section 34 of the Act, which mandates that for a support to be funded, it must assist the participant to pursue their goals, facilitate social and economic participation, represent value for money, be effective and beneficial having regard to current good practice, and not be more appropriately funded through other systems. The Tribunal found that while hydrotherapy assessment was appropriate, it was not satisfied that the requested voice and composition classes would be effective and beneficial, nor that composition classes were most appropriately funded through the NDIS. Similarly, it was not satisfied that education-related expenses were most appropriately funded by the Scheme.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision and remitted the matter to the NDIA for reconsideration of the supports in accordance with its findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Ms Hilder explained the nature of the training she provided to Ms Markaboui:We worked on breathing, we worked on use of what we call diaphragmatic breathing in singing, which means we’re concentrating on a greater use of the thorax area in the breathing, greater development of muscles in that area, and we started to also work a little bit on the throat work which is that we have quite a lot of muscles in the throat that we need to be using in a very specific way as singers.[17][17] Transcript, 5 March 2020 at 32.Evidence of Ms Millikan, Occupational Therapist Ms Millikan assessed Ms Markaboui in late 2018 or early 2019 and provided a report dated 31 January 2019.[18] Ms Millikan gave evidence at the hearing.[18] Exhibit R2 at 41. In relation to Ms Markaboui’s request for singing and composition lessons, Ms Millikan reported:Ms Markaboui has a strong goal to attend voice classes at the Joan Sutherland Performing Arts Centre at Penrith. Her goals are to participate in voice classes, with subsequent goal to participate in composition and recording. She considers that this would be a good use of the Social/Recreation part of an NDIS Plan. From an occupational therapy point of view benefits include respiratory exercise and strengthen of diaphragm and throat and also contributes towards increasing Ms Markaboui’s social activity and opportunities to meet new people and make friends. To participate Ms Markaboui would require use of a reliable accessible vehicle (accessible taxi), a suitable experienced support worker, accessible bathroom (preferable an adult change facility) and location and space to have a break (quiet area). All her usual scheduled assistance (such as drinks, medications etc) would need to factored into the time away. Considerable research and preparation, plus a trial run of travel and access, would need to occur prior to Ms Markaboui being able to enrol in classes.[19][19] Exhibit R2 at 41. Ms Millikan gave the following evidence at the hearing:·she was unaware whether vocal physiotherapy (by a trained physiotherapist) is available as a sub-speciality in Australia;·she was unaware whether singing lessons and vocal physiotherapy offered the same benefits to an individual;·she was unaware whether there are ways of improving respiratory function other than by singing;·a Physiotherapist can provide respiratory exercises;·Ms Markaboui will need to be assessed by a Physiotherapist to determine her suitability for exercises to strengthen her diaphragm and throat;·as an Occupational Therapist she seeks to find meaningful tasks that people want to do in order to improve function;·before Ms Markaboui attended the Performing Arts Centre it will be necessary to assess the environment to determine if it is suitable for her.[20][20] Transcript, 5 March 2020 at 18-20.Report of Associate Professor Madill, Speech Pathologist/Voice Specialist Associate Professor Madill provided a report dated 27 July 2020[21] and gave evidence.[21] Exhibit R2 at 119.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Subsection 33(5) provides:(5) In deciding whether or not to approve a statement of participant supports under subsection (2), the CEO must: (a) have regard to the participant's statement of goals and aspirations; and (b) have regard to relevant assessments conducted in relation to the participant; and (c) be satisfied as mentioned in section 34 in relation to the reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded and the general supports that will be provided; and (d) apply the National Disability Insurance Scheme rules (if any) made for the purposes of section 35; and (e) have regard to the principle that a participant should manage his or her plan to the extent that he or she wishes to do so; and (f) have regard to the operation and effectiveness of any previous plans of the participant. Matters of which the decision-maker must be satisfied in relation to the funding or provision of supports Subsection 34(1) provides:(1) For the purposes of specifying, in a statement of participant supports, the general supports that will be provided, and the reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded, the CEO must be satisfied of all of the following in relation to the funding or provision of each such support: (a) the support will assist the participant to pursue the goals, objectives and aspirations included in the participant's statement of goals and aspirations; (b) the support will assist the participant to undertake activities, so as to facilitate the participant's social and economic participation;(c) the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support; (d) the support will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial for the participant, having regard to current good practice; (e) the funding or provision of the support takes account of what it is reasonable to expect families, carers, informal networks and the community to provide; (f) the support is most appropriately funded or provided through the National Disability Insurance Scheme, and is not more appropriately funded or provided through other general systems of service delivery or support services offered by a person, agency or body, or systems of service delivery or support services offered: (i) as part of a universal service obligation; or (ii) in accordance with reasonable adjustments required under a law dealing with discrimination on the basis of disability. It is to be noted that all of these conditions must be satisfied in relation to each support. In McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency the Federal Court said:Therefore, what is entered in a plan as a support becomes a determinative factor in the administration of the scheme. As the respondent submitted, by s 33(3), supports may be generally described or may be specifically identified. Either way, the function being performed on review by the Tribunal is to approve, vary of modify the supports as set out in a participant plan. In performing that function, the Tribunal must have regard to the matters set out in s 33(5), and form its satisfaction in accordance with s 34.[12][12] [2017] FCA 308 at [85].National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I acknowledge submissions of the Solicitor for the Agency in an earlier application to the Tribunal[2] setting out the various provisions of the Act, Rules and Guidelines which provide the framework for determining the matters in dispute in this application. I am grateful for the assistance of those submissions, which form the basis of the content of this Part.[2] See Milburn and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 4928.Preparation of a participant’s plan The Chief Executive Officer of the Agency is required to facilitate the preparation of a participant’s plan.[3] The plan must include:·the participant’s statement of goals and aspirations; and ·a statement of participant supports prepared with the participant and approved by the Chief Executive Officer.[4]It is to be noted that the statement of goals and aspirations is a statement by the participant and does not require the approval of the Chief Executive Officer. The statement of participant supports must specify the reasonable and necessary supports (if any) that will be funded under the Scheme.[3] Section 32 of the Act.[4] Section 33 of the Act. The provisions of the Act giving the participant alone the right to state his or her goals and aspirations and at the same time requiring the Chief Executive Officer to work with the participant to prepare the statement of supports, and then to approve those supports which will be funded, “strikes a balance between two of the Act’s objects:(a)the need to enable people with disability to exercise choice and control in the pursuit of their goals and the planning and delivery of their supports, and(b)the facilitation of a nationally consistent approach to the access to, and planning and funding of, supports for people with disability.”[5][5] Milburn and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 4928 at [11]; the objects of the Act are set out in section 3 of the Act.Implementing a plan The plan comes into effect once the Chief Executive Officer has received the participant’s statement of goals and aspirations and approved the statement of participant’s supports.[6][6] Subsection 37(1) of the Act. Money received by or on behalf of a participant must be spent in accordance with the participant’s plan.[7] An amount paid under the Scheme in respect of reasonable and necessary supports funded in accordance with a participant’s plan is referred to in the Act as the “NDIS amount.”[8][7] Subsection 46(1) of the Act.[8] Section 9 of the Act.The objects of the Act The objects of the Act set out in section 3 make particular reference to the purpose of providing reasonable and necessary supports. Subsection 3(1) provides, in part:The objects of this Act are to:…(c) support the independence and social and economic participation of people with disability; and (d) provide reasonable and necessary supports, including early intervention supports, for participants in the National Disability Insurance Scheme launch; and (e) enable people with disability to exercise choice and control in the pursuit of their goals and the planning and delivery of their supports; and (f) facilitate the development of a nationally consistent approach to the access to, and the planning and funding of, supports for people with disability; and (g) promote the provision of high quality and innovative supports that enable people with disability to maximise independent lifestyles and full inclusion in the community; and (ga) protect and prevent people with disability from experiencing harm arising from poor quality or unsafe supports or services provided under the National Disability Insurance Scheme; and (h) raise community awareness of the issues that affect the social and economic participation of people with disability, and facilitate greater community inclusion of people with disability;…