Middleton v Chief Executive, Department of Correctional Services

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

MIDDLETON v CHIEF EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES

[2023] SASC 155

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McDonald  

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY - SUMMARY DISPOSAL - SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR DEFENDANT OR RESPONDENT: STAY OR DISMISSAL OF PROCEEDINGS

The Applicant, who is serving a sentence of imprisonment, applies for judicial review of a decision by the Respondent to include a reference to an incident report on his electronic prisoner file. The Applicant also applies for an extension of time in which to commence this application.

By way of Interlocutory Application, the Respondent seeks summary judgment of the Applicant’s application on the basis that no reasonable basis for an action of judicial review is disclosed.

Held: Extension of time refused, and the application for judicial review is summarily dismissed. The incident report is not a record of the kind that has legal effects or consequences that would render it capable of judicial review. Even if the decision could attract relief in the nature of certiorari or mandamus, the Applicant has not exhausted the alternative avenues of review available to him, a fact which weighs considerably against the grant of such relief.

Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) r 256.5, referred to.
Brighton Cement Ltd v Hallett Concrete Pty Ltd and Others [2020] SASC 161; McLeod v Legal Professional Conduct Commissioner [2016] SASC 151, considered.

MIDDLETON v CHIEF EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES
[2023] SASC 155

Civil - Application

McDONALD J.

  1. Mr Middleton is currently serving a term of imprisonment at Cadell Training Centre. On 19 December 2019 Mr Middleton was sentenced to ten years and 6 months imprisonment for one count of Manufacturing a Large Quantity of a Controlled Drug for Sale contrary to s 33 of the Controlled Substances Act 1984 (SA). A non-parole period of eight years, four months and 11 days was fixed.

  2. Mr Middleton has made an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Chief Executive, Department for Correctional Services to include a reference to an incident report (IR/2020/3009) in his electronic prisoner file.  He seeks orders “removing” or “unlinking” his name from the incident report.

  3. Mr Middleton filed his Originating Application more than two years out of time and consequently seeks an extension of time within which to commence the proceedings.[1]

    [1]    Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) r 256.3.

  4. The Department for Correctional Services (‘DCS’) has filed an Interlocutory Application for summary judgment on the basis that no reasonable basis for an action of judicial review is disclosed.  It is this application that is currently under consideration.

    Power to grant summary judgment

  5. The Interlocutory Application has been made under r 144.2 and r 256.5 of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) (‘the rules’).

  6. Pursuant to r 256.5(3)(a) where a respondent to an action for judicial review applies for summary judgment, the Court will dismiss the action “unless the court is satisfied that there is a reasonable basis for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Middleton v Chief Executive, Department of Correctional Serv... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 155
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Middleton v Chief Executive, Department of Correctional Services, the defendant, the Department of Correctional Services (DCS), has applied for summary judgment in relation to an action for judicial review brought by the plaintiff, Mr Middleton. The action seeks judicial review of decisions made by the DCS in relation to Mr Middleton's complaints about the management of his personal data under the DCS's Justice Information System (JIS). The case is currently before the Supreme Court of South Australia. The primary legal issue the court needed to decide was whether there was a reasonable basis for Mr Middleton's claim for judicial review, warranting a dismissal of his application under the rules governing summary judgment.

The court examined the application for summary judgment in accordance with the principles established in Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd v Hallett Concrete Pty Ltd, where it was held that the court should undertake a practical assessment of whether the applicant has a real prospect of success. The court assessed the application for judicial review in a summary manner, taking into consideration the incomplete nature of the evidence and avoiding a "mini trial" of the claim. The court noted that adversarial submissions could assist in determining whether there was a reasonable basis for the claim. The court focused on the specific words used in the rules and did not apply any judicial gloss.

After considering the submissions and the available evidence, the court determined that there was no reasonable basis for Mr Middleton's claim for judicial review. Consequently, the court granted the application for summary judgment and dismissed the plaintiff's application for judicial review. The court did not find it necessary to provide further orders beyond the dismissal of the plaintiff's application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Department for Correctional Services (‘DCS’) has filed an Interlocutory Application for summary judgment on the basis that no reasonable basis for an action of judicial review is disclosed. It is this application that is currently under consideration.Power to grant summary judgment The Interlocutory Application has been made under r 144.2 and r 256.5 of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) (‘the rules’). Pursuant to r 256.5(3)(a) where a respondent to an action for judicial review applies for summary judgment, the Court will dismiss the action “unless the court is satisfied that there is a reasonable basis for the action,” however, the power to determine an action summarily should not be exercised lightly. In Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd v Hallett Concrete Pty Ltd and Others,[2] Doyle J summarised the approach to be adopted in making such a determination:… Exercise of the power requires a practical assessment of whether the applicant has real, as opposed to merely fanciful, prospect of success. While the Court need not be satisfied that the claim is hopeless or bound to fail, nevertheless it must be cautious not to do a party injustice by summarily determining an action, particularly where there are disputed issues of fact or law or mixed fact and law, merely because the Court considers that the claim is unlikely to succeed. However, beyond these very general guidelines, the Court should focus upon the words used in the rules and avoid applying any judicial gloss.Related to the requirement that the Court undertake a “practical” assessment is the notion that the Court should not embark upon a “mini trial” of the claim. Rather, the claim should be assessed in a summary manner, while being cognisant of the incomplete nature of the evidence upon which the Court's decision must be based. Adversarial argument may assist, and indeed may result in the emergence of a sufficiently clear answer to a complex issue that summary judgment is appropriate. On the other hand, the need for prolonged argument may be indicative of a reasonable basis for the claim. [Footnotes omitted.][2] [2020] SASC 161 at [59]–[60]. Applying that approach to the matter before me I determined to hear submissions on the interlocutory application before determining the application for judicial review. Events that form the basis of the application for judicial review In order to understand the manner in which these events have unfolded, Mr Middleton’s complaints and DCS’s response to those complaints it is necessary to have an appreciation of how DCS manages its electronic data. The Justice Information System DCS maintains an electronic data system called the Justice Information System (JIS). The JIS is an administrative offender management system that is used by DCS to manage information relevant to the supervision of offenders. It is used to record interactions between employees and prisoners, and other information relevant to the case management of offenders. These records are used by DCS to assist with its day-to-day operational management of prisoners. That operational management includes, but is not limited to, matters such as prisoner intake into prisons, movement of prisoners within and between prisons, sentence management, prisoner mail and property management, prisoner financial accounts and employment management, prison visit management, offender drug testing and victim management. It is important to note that the system stores and retains all information that may be relevant to the management of prisoners and is not limited to prisoner misconduct.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established