Microsoft Corporation v CPL Notting Hill Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Microsoft Corporation v CPL Notting Hill Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 144

Appeal from: Microsoft Corporation v Notting Hill Pty Ltd (No 7) [2022] FedCFamC2G 590
File number(s): NSD 1126 of 2022
Judgment of: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 22 February 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for a stay of execution of certificates of taxation pending determination of appeal – where stay granted due in part to respondents’ earlier inability to pay damages awarded – where stay granted dissolved upon delivery of judgment – where no evidence of improved financial circumstances – application granted.
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 41.03
Cases cited:

Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 685

Powerflex Services Pty Ltd v Data Access Corporation (1996) 67 FCR 65

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Copyright and Industrial Designs
Number of paragraphs: 38
Date of hearing: 22 February 2023
Counsel for the Appellants Mr A Fox SC
Solicitor for the Appellants Harris & Company
Counsel for the Respondents Mr C H Truong KC with Mr C Thompson
Solicitor for the Respondents Henley Legal

ORDERS

NSD 1126 of 2022
BETWEEN:

MICROSOFT CORPORATION

First Appellant

MICROSOFT PTY LTD

Second Appellant

MICROSOFT REGIONAL SALES CORPORATION

Third Appellant

AND:

CPL NOTTING HILL PTY LTD

First Respondent

WEI LI

Second Respondent

CPL DISTRIBUTION PTY LTD (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

BURLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 FEBRUARY 2023

Upon the Appellants undertaking to pay the costs included in the Certificate of Taxation issued in this proceeding on 7 August 2020, totalling $211,040.79, and interest accrued thereon, within 28 days of determination of the Appellants’ appeal or otherwise being directed to do so:

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Execution on the costs in each of the following certificates of taxation is stayed pending the determination of the Appellants’ appeal (or further order of the Court): -

(a)Certificate of Taxation dated 7 August 2020 in the sum of $211,040.79 in favour of the Respondents (in Proceeding NSD 1736 of 2018).

(b)Certificate of Taxation dated 14 August 2020 in the sum of $20,700 in favour of the Appellants (in Proceeding NSD 1438 of 2017).

2.The Appellants are released from compliance with their undertaking to the Court given on 29 September 2020 in Proceeding NSD 1736 of 2018.

3.The Respondents pay the Appellants’ costs of and incidental to the interlocutory application filed by the Appellants on 19 December 2022.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BURLEY J:

1.                 INTRODUCTION

  1. The appellants, Microsoft Corporation, Microsoft Pty Ltd and Microsoft Regional Sales Corporation (collectively, Microsoft), by interlocutory application filed on 19 December 2022, seek a stay of execution of certain certificates of taxation pending the determination of an appeal from a decision of a judge of the Federal Circuit and Family Court (Division 2) given in Microsoft Corporation v CPL Notting Hill…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Microsoft Corporation v CPL Notting Hill Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Microsoft Corporation has filed an application for a stay of execution of certificates of taxation pending the determination of its appeal against the orders of the Federal Circuit Court. The CPL parties oppose the application. The appeal relates to a decision in which the Federal Circuit Court found that the CPL parties had infringed copyright, engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct, and infringed registered trademarks, leading to an award of damages and costs. The matter has a lengthy background involving multiple hearings and appeals. The current application arises from the taxation of costs in favour of both parties, with Microsoft seeking a stay of the CPL parties' certificate and the CPL parties opposing this.

The legal issues before the court involved whether the stay should be granted based on the principles of fairness and the balance of convenience. The court considered the history of the case, including the inability of the CPL parties to pay the damages awarded previously, the terms of the stay previously granted, and the financial positions of both parties. The court also assessed whether Microsoft had demonstrated a proper basis for a stay that would be fair to all parties, taking into account the risk of assets being disposed of and the merits of the appeal.

The court found that the principles for granting a stay applied, particularly given the risk that the appeal could be rendered nugatory without a stay. The court granted the stay, noting that there was no evidence of improved financial circumstances of the CPL parties. The stay was granted on terms that Microsoft would be released from its earlier undertaking and that the CPL parties would pay Microsoft's costs of the interlocutory application.

In summary, the court granted the stay of execution of the certificates of taxation pending the determination of Microsoft's appeal, released Microsoft from its earlier undertaking, and ordered the CPL parties to pay Microsoft's costs of the interlocutory application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Execution on the costs in each of the following certificates of taxation is stayed pending the determination of the Appellants’ appeal (or further order of the Court): -

(a) Certificate of Taxation dated 7 August 2020 in the sum of $211,040.79 in favour of the Respondents (in Proceeding NSD 1736 of 2018).

(b) Certificate of Taxation dated 14 August 2020 in the sum of $20,700 in favour of the Appellants (in Proceeding NSD 1438 of 2017).

2. The Appellants are released from compliance with their undertaking to the Court given on 29 September 2020 in Proceeding NSD 1736 of 2018.

3. The Respondents pay the Appellants’ costs of and incidental to the interlocutory application filed by the Appellants on 19 December 2022.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Microsoft relies on two affidavits of Alvin Ng, Solicitor of 19 December 2022 and 8 February 2023. The CPL parties rely on an affidavit sworn by Ms Li. 2. BACKGROUND The background of the matter is lengthy but can be summarised briefly as follows, based on the contents of two decisions made in this court, being CPL Notting Hill Pty Ltd v Microsoft Corporation (No 2) [2019] FCA 223 (O’Callaghan J) (CPL 1) and CPL Notting Hill Pty Ltd v Microsoft Corporation [2020] FCA 1399 (O’Callaghan J) (CPL 2). In May 2016, Microsoft brought a proceeding in the Federal Circuit Court, as it was then known, making various allegations against the CPL parties concerning the reproduction of the software on new computers sold by CPL Notting Hill. It brought claims for infringement of copyright, misleading and deceptive conduct and infringement of registered trade marks. The claims against Ms Li and Mr Wang were based on allegations that they were the sole directors of each of the corporate respondents and were involved in their day-to-day management. On 29 August 2018, on the third day of trial and immediately upon completion of oral closing submissions by counsel, Judge Street delivered ex tempore reasons and made orders that the respondents pay damages of over $2.5 million plus interest and granted declaratory relief. Shortly thereafter, the respondents appealed and applied for a stay of the primary judge’s orders pending the hearing. As recited in CPL 2 at [20], one reason for the seeking the stay was that the CPL parties could not pay the damages awarded. This conclusion was based on affidavits given by Ms Li and Mr Wang, each dated 19 September 2019, in which each deposed to their financial circumstances and the financial circumstances of CPL Notting Hill and CPL Distribution respectively. An interim stay was granted on 26 September 2018. On 4 October 2018, the court ordered by consent that the stay be extended until the determination of the appeal upon the CPL parties giving a number of undertakings, including that Mr Wang pay $1,208,418.54 into the trust account of Microsoft’s solicitors, which he did. The appeal was heard by O’Callaghan J on 4 and 5 February 2019. On the second day of the appeal, Mr Richard Cobden SC, senior counsel for Microsoft, conceded that it was appropriate that the appeal be allowed. As described by his Honour, the concession was properly made, as there were “myriad reasons why the appeal was bound to be allowed and the matter remitted to be reheard by another judge”: CPL 1 at [4]. The Court ordered Microsoft to pay the costs of the appeal. It is those costs as taxed that give rise to the present application. The retrial was conducted before a different judge of the Federal Circuit Court in the period from 19–23 August 2019 and on 16 December 2019. On 7 August 2020, CPL’s costs of the appeal were taxed by a judicial registrar at $211,040.79 (CPL certificate of taxation). The CPL parties demanded payment. On 25 August 2020, Microsoft filed an interlocutory application seeking a stay, pursuant to r 41.03 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), of the CPL certificate of taxation and also a stay of a certificate of taxation that it had obtained in respect of a costs order in its favour in the amount of $20,700 (Microsoft certificate of taxation).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The CPL parties submit that there is no evidence from Microsoft in the present application as to the amount of damages it would likely receive if its appeal succeeds such as to warrant any inference that CPL would be unable to pay any judgment that may be obtained. They submit that the burden rests with Microsoft to satisfy the Court that it should be released from its unconditional undertaking given to the Court. Had Microsoft intended, at the time that it gave the undertaking, to preserve its capacity to vary its terms in the event that it was dissatisfied with the result in the second trial, it ought to have foreshadowed that to O’Callaghan J. Finally, it submits that whilst the global financial standing of Microsoft is not in dispute, it is a foreign corporation. Microsoft has adduced no evidence of Microsoft Australia Pty Ltd’s financial position. If the Court does grant a stay, the CPL parties contend that it should be on terms that Microsoft pays the costs outstanding into Court or into a trust account of CPL’s lawyers as a condition of that stay.3.2 Consideration The parties agree that the principles set out by the Court in CPL 2 in granting the stay are also applicable in the present circumstances. The Court there referred to Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 685, which concerned stays pending appeal. In that case, Kirby P, Hope and McHugh JJA held as follows (at 694-695; see also Powerflex Services Pty Ltd v Data Access Corporation (1996) 67 FCR 65 at 66 (Burchett, Heerey and Whitlam JJ)):In our opinion it is not necessary for the grant of a stay that special or exceptional circumstances should be made out. It is sufficient that the applicant for the stay demonstrates a reason or an appropriate case to warrant the exercise of discretion in his favour.There are other principles to be kept in mind. The onus is upon the applicant to demonstrate a proper basis for a stay that will be fair to all parties. The mere filing of an appeal will not, of itself, provide a reason or demonstrate an appropriate case, nor will it discharge the onus which the applicant bears. The Court has a discretion whether or not to grant the stay and, if so, as to the terms that would be fair. In the exercise of its discretion, the Court will weigh considerations such as the balance of convenience and the competing rights of the parties before it. Where there is a risk that if a stay is granted, the assets of the applicant will be disposed of, the Court may, in the exercise of its discretion, refuse to grant a stay. Sometimes as a condition of the grant of a stay, where funds are available, a court will impose on the applicant the payment of the whole, or part, to the judgment creditor. Even where no order is made for the payment of part of a verdict, it is not at all unusual for the Court, in the exercise of its discretion, to grant a stay on terms that the appellant give to the judgment creditor security in terms defined by the Court as appropriate to the fair adjustment of the rights of the parties.…Two further principles can be mentioned. The first is that where there is a risk that the appeal will prove abortive if the appellant succeeds and a stay is not granted, courts will normally exercise their discretion in favour of granting a stay. Thus, where it is apparent that unless a stay is granted an appeal will be rendered nugatory, this will be a substantial factor in favour of the grant of a stay. Secondly, although courts approaching applications for a stay will not generally speculate about the appellant's prospects of success, given that argument concerning the substance of the appeal is typically and necessarily attenuated, this does not prevent them considering the specific terms of a stay that will be appropriate fairly to adjust the interest of the parties, from making some preliminary assessment about whether the appellant has an arguable case.(Citations omitted.)