FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Gilmour [2010] FCA 1390
Citation: MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Gilmour [2010] FCA 1390 Parties: MG CORROSION CONSULTANTS PTY LTD (ACN 084 715 177) v MALCOLM STEWART GILMOUR and SOLA-KLEEN PTY LTD (ACN 009 059 607) File number: WAD 256 of 2010 Judge: GILMOUR J Date of judgment: 26 November 2010 Catchwords: COURTS AND JUDGES – apprehended bias – adverse findings as to credit made in a related judgment – whether reasonable apprehension of bias - recusal Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 181–183, 237, 247A Cases cited: Antoun v R (2006) 224 ALR 51 cited
Concrete Pty Ltd v Parramatta Design & Developments Pty Ltd (2006) 229 CLR 577 referred to
Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2000) 205 CLR 337 applied
Johnson v Johnson (2000) 201 CLR 488 referred toLivesey v New South Wales Bar Association (1983) 151 CLR 288 applied
Smits v Roach (2006) 227 CLR 423 referred to
Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd (2007) 61 ACSR 583 referred to
Vinciguerra v MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd (2010) 79 ACSR 293 referred toDate of hearing: 8 and 26 November 2010 Place: Perth Division: GENERAL DIVISION Category: Catchwords Number of paragraphs: 21 Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr D H Solomon Solicitor for the Plaintiff : Solomon Brothers Counsel for the Defendants: Mr K A Dundo Solicitor for the Defendants: Q Legal
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
WAD 256 of 2010
BETWEEN: MG CORROSION CONSULTANTS PTY LTD
(ACN 084 715 177)
PlaintiffAND: MALCOLM STEWART GILMOUR
First DefendantSOLA-KLEEN PTY LTD (ACN 009 059 607)
Second Defendant
JUDGE:
GILMOUR J
DATE OF ORDER:
26 NOVEMBER 2010
WHERE MADE:
PERTH
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The proceeding be referred to the WA District Registrar for re-assignment to another Judge of the Court.
2. Costs be in the cause.
Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
WAD 256 of 2010
BETWEEN: MG CORROSION CONSULTANTS PTY LTD
(ACN 084 715 177)
PlaintiffAND: MALCOLM STEWART GILMOUR
First DefendantSOLA-KLEEN PTY LTD (ACN 009 059 607)
Second Defendant
JUDGE:
GILMOUR J
DATE:
26 NOVEMBER 2010
PLACE:
PERTH
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
The defendants made an oral motion on 8 November 2010 that I recuse myself in this proceeding on the grounds of apprehended bias. Following argument on that day and on 26 November 2010 I acceded to the motion and made orders that the proceeding be referred to the WA District Registrar for re-assignment to another judge of the Court and for costs to be in the cause. These are my reasons for so ordering.
BACKGROUND
Mr Alberto Vinciguerra owned 30 of the 100 ordinary shares issued in MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd (MGCC). The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read MG Corrosion Consultants Pty Ltd v Gilmour and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] FCA 1390
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court concluded that the defendants had not established a reasonable apprehension of bias, and that the judge was not required to recuse themselves. The Court further found that the defendants' application was an abuse of process, and that the defendants' actions were intended to delay the proceedings. As a result, the Court ordered that the proceeding be referred to the WA District Registrar for re-assignment to another judge of the Court, and that costs be in the cause.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The proceeding be referred to the WA District Registrar for re-assignment to another Judge of the Court.
2. Costs be in the cause.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
I now set out paras [33]-[46] of my reasons for judgment where those findings are set out in context: 33. Mr Harradine and Mr Byfield were appointed as directors of the defendant for the purpose of acting as independent directors in conducting an independent investigation with no involvement by Mr Gilmour. Their asserted independence was, understandably, a matter of central importance given Mr Gilmour’s personal interest in the matters complained of by the plaintiff. 34. The defendant asserted, by a letter from its then solicitors, Wojtowicz Kelly, dated 21 April 2008 that “Mr Harradine is not in any way related to Sola-Kleen Pty Ltd or Malcolm Gilmour”. However, Mr Harradine and Mr Gilmour are the directors and only shareholders of Power Savers International (Australia) Pty Ltd. This was evidenced by annexure “CSW-2” to the affidavit sworn by Christopher Stephen Williams on 15 May 2008 that Mr Harradine was appointed as a director of that company in 1998. Mr Gilmour’s and Mr Harradine’s involvement in Power Savers International was not disclosed by the defendant either in the Wojtowicz Kelly’s letter or otherwise or by Mr Gilmour or Mr Harradine in their affidavits. 35. Mr Harradine swore a supplementary affidavit on 16 May 2008. It is not expressly stated to be in response to Mr Williams’ affidavit. Mr Harradine, in para 2 of this affidavit said that he did not disclose information pertaining to his directorships or interest in companies other than the defendant and Sola-Kleen because he did not believe that they had any material effect on how he exercised his judgment in his role as a director of the defendant. Mr Harradine’s personal opinion in this respect is not to the point. He swore his affidavit in a context where his independence was being questioned by the plaintiff and he, in effect, was asserting his independence. “Independence” in that context plainly was meant to convey his independence from Mr Gilmour. It cannot mean merely that he has no financial interest in the outcome of this application or the foreshadowed litigation or that he has no legal or beneficial interest in the defendant. The Wojtowicz Kelly letter of 21 April 2008 said that Mr Harradine was “not in any way” related to Sola-Kleen or Mr Gilmour. This was no off-hand remark. It was an unequivocal statement made in response to a letter from the plaintiff’s solicitors dated 17 April 2008 included in which the “independence” of Mr Harradine was questioned. It pointed out that Mr Harradine was until 2003 the defendant’s accountant and that he had recently been issued with one “A” class share in the defendant. 36. The issue of the share was not explained by the defendant’s then solicitors in its letter of 21 April 2008 although it was later explained in Mr Harradine’s affidavit of 14 May 2008 that he was issued the share to enable the defendant’s board to have a quorum in the event that the plaintiff failed to attend a meeting of the defendant’s members. In addition to asserting that Mr Harradine had no relationship with Mr Gilmour, the letter of 21 April 2008 stated “If you have any evidence to the contrary, please provide it to us”. Such evidence ought to have been provided by each of Mr Gilmour and Mr Harradine. Plainly enough it was not. Mr Harradine is a professional accountant. I would expect that he is familiar with the concept of independence in the present context. Indeed he asserts as much in his affidavit sworn on 14 May 2008. 37. The excerpt I have quoted from the letter of 21 April 2008 was less than forthright. This is not a criticism of Wojtowicz Kelly as I infer that the letter was written on the basis of less than forthright instructions. Mr Harradine, for his part, in his affidavit sworn on 14 May 2008 made no mention of this relationship with Mr Gilmour although he referred to the fact that he had held a number of public and proprietary company directorships in Australia and overseas during his career. He did not explain his involvement with Mr Gilmour in Power Savers International in his supplementary affidavit of 16 May 2008 or at all. He should have done so.38. Mr Gilmour, in his affidavit sworn on 16 May 2008 referred to Mr Harradine’s affidavit sworn on 15 May 2008. I take this to be a mistaken reference to Mr Harradine’s affidavit of 16 May 2008. He said he had nothing further to add to what Mr Harradine had said. Again he too failed to say anything at all about Power Savers International. I regard the failure to mention his involvement with Mr Harradine in Power Savers International as demonstrating, on the part of Mr Gilmour, a lack of candour on the issue of Mr Harradine’s asserted independence upon which the defendant has placed so much reliance in this application.39. In my opinion, an explanation was called for both from Mr Gilmour and Mr Harradine in the circumstances of this application. I infer that any such explanation by Mr Gilmour and Mr Harradine would not have supported the assertion that Mr Harradine is independent of Mr Gilmour. Accordingly, it is not merely the fact of the relationship but the failure of both Mr Gilmour and Mr Harradine to mention it in their affidavits sworn prior to Mr Williams’ affidavit of 15 May 2008 or, when exposed in Mr Williams’ affidavit, to explain it, which leads me to conclude not only that Mr Harradine is not independent but is, to the contrary, partisan towards the defendant and Mr Gilmour. …41. Mr Harradine, in his affidavit sworn on 14 May 2008 deposed that he had received the financial records of the defendant for the financial years 2003 to 2007 inclusive. He said that as a result of what he had been told by Mr Armenti that the management fees paid by the defendant to Sola-Kleen were fees for its use of Sola-Kleen’s premises, equipment and staff. Mr Harradine, himself an accountant, proceeded to give reasons as to why, in his opinion, these management fees were, in effect, reasonable. 42. Mr Ruthven, contrary to the position taken by Mr Harradine, concluded that a number of impugned expenses, including a significant portion of the management fees that were paid, were overstated. In particular, Mr Ruthven concluded that, between 2003 and 2007, the management fees paid by the defendant to Sola-Kleen were overstated by an amount of $382,027. These conclusions are at such odds with the opinion of Mr Haradine expressed by him after his review of the defendant’s financial records that they add to my view that Mr Harradine in relation to this matter ought not be regarded as independent and objective. 43. The Ruthven Report concluded that although management fees payable to Sola-Kleen were overstated other expenses had been understated, in an amount almost equal to that in which expenses had been overstated, resulting in the defendant’s net profit being understated during the period from 2001 to 2007 in an amount of $45,013. 44. However, given the view I have reached as to Mr Harradine’s lack of independence and moreover his lack of candour in his affidavit I give little weight to the findings in the Ruthven Report for present purposes. This casts no adverse shadow upon the late Mr Ruthven. I am simply, for present purposes not prepared to accept that he was fully instructed with all relevant material for the purpose of preparing his report. 45. Mr Ruthven did not perform any separate verification validation or audit of information and documents produced to him for the purposes of his report, by the defendant, Sola-Kleen, Mr Gilmour and Mr Armenti. 46. The defendant made no closing submissions in reply to these criticisms of the lack of independence of Mr Harradine. CONSIDERATION