FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Metro Business Centre Pty Ltd v Centrefold Entertainment Pty Ltd (No 2)
[2017] FCA 1250
File number: NSD 1489 of 2016 Judge: RARES J Date of judgment: 8 August 2017 Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2, Australian Consumer Law s 18
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) s 88
Federal Court Rules 2011 Pt 25, r 25.01
Cases cited: Dukemaster Pty Limited v Bluehive Pty Limited [2003] FCAFC 1
Metro Business Centre Pty Ltd v Centrefold Entertainment Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1249
NMFM Property Pty Limited v Citibank Limited (No 2) (2001) 109 FCR 77
Date of hearing: 8 August 2017 Date of last submissions: 10 August 2017 Registry: New South Wales Division: General Division National Practice Area: Intellectual Property Sub-area: Trade Marks Category: No Catchwords Number of paragraphs: 26 Counsel for the Applicants and Cross-Respondents: Mr J O’Sullivan Solicitor for the Applicants and Cross-Respondents: Streeterlaw Counsel for the Respondents and Cross Claimant: Mr C Wood Solicitor for the Respondents and Cross-Claimant: Hopgood Ganim Lawyers ORDERS
NSD 1489 of 2016 BETWEEN: METRO BUSINESS CENTRE PTY LIMITED (ACN 096 429 882)
First Applicant
SEXY ENTERTAINMENT PTY LIMITED (ACN 163 680 108)
Second Applicant
AND: CENTREFOLD ENTERTAINMENT PTY LIMITED (ACN 151 972 986)
First Respondent
MATTHEW PRENDERGAST
Second Respondent
AND BETWEEN: CENTREFOLD ENTERTAINMENT PTY LIMITED (ACN 151 972 986
Cross-Claimant
AND: METRO BUSINESS CENTRE PTY LIMITED (ACN 069 492 882 (and others named in the Schedule)
First Cross-Respondent
JUDGE:
RARES J
DATE OF ORDER:
8 AUGUST 2017
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.Pursuant to s 88(1)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), the Register of Trade Marks be rectified by cancelling the registration of the trade mark comprising the word CENTREFOLD with registration number 1695466 (“Mark”) in respect of all goods or services in respect of which it is registered and by removal of the entry of the Mark as being an entry wrongly made on and having wrongly remained on the Register of Trade Marks;
2.Save as set out in order 1 above, the amended originating application and amended statement of claim be otherwise dismissed;
3.The amended notice of cross-claim and amended statement of cross-claim be dismissed.
4.The first respondent and cross-claimant pay the applicants’ and cross-respondents’ costs of the proceeding and the cross-claim except to the extent that the applicants would not have incurred any such costs had the second respondent not been a party.
5.The applicants pay the costs occasioned by the joinder of the second respondent as a party to the extent that his participation increased the costs that would otherwise have been payable by the first respondent in connection with its conduct of the proceeding.
6.Streeterlaw, as solicitors for the applicants, be authorised to release forthwith to the applicants or their nominee the sum of $110,000 held in a controlled moneys account maintained by Streeterlaw in the name of CG Trading…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Metro Business Centre Pty Ltd v Centrefold Entertainment Pty... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FCA 1250
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues the court had to resolve were whether the defendants were liable for trade mark infringement and passing off, and if so, what remedies were appropriate. A significant part of the dispute also involved the question of costs, particularly whether the plaintiffs were entitled to indemnity costs based on the defendants' alleged unreasonable rejection of settlement offers made outside the formal court rules.
The court found that the defendants were not liable for trade mark infringement or passing off. In terms of costs, the court held that the plaintiffs were not entitled to indemnity costs based on the without-prejudice offers they had made to the defendants. The court reasoned that for such an order to be made, the offer must represent a real compromise and the defendant must have acted unreasonably in rejecting it. The court concluded that the defendants were not unreasonable in rejecting the settlement offers as they did not contain a basis for why the plaintiffs would necessarily succeed in the litigation. Consequently, the court denied the plaintiffs' request for indemnity costs and instead ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiffs' costs of the proceeding, subject to certain exceptions.
The final orders of the court included the cancellation of the trade mark registration, dismissal of the amended originating application and statement of claim, and dismissal of the amended notice of cross-claim and statement of cross-claim. Additionally, the court ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiffs' costs, with specific provisions for costs related to the joinder of a second defendant. The court also authorised the release of a sum held in a controlled moneys account as security for costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Pursuant to s 88(1)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), the Register of Trade Marks be rectified by cancelling the registration of the trade mark comprising the word CENTREFOLD with registration number 1695466 (“Mark”) in respect of all goods or services in respect of which it is registered and by removal of the entry of the Mark as being an entry wrongly made on and having wrongly remained on the Register of Trade Marks;
2. Save as set out in order 1 above, the amended originating application and amended statement of claim be otherwise dismissed;
3. The amended notice of cross-claim and amended statement of cross-claim be dismissed.
4. The first respondent and cross-claimant pay the applicants’ and cross-respondents’ costs of the proceeding and the cross-claim except to the extent that the applicants would not have incurred any such costs had the second respondent not been a party.
5. The applicants pay the costs occasioned by the joinder of the second respondent as a party to the extent that his participation increased the costs that would otherwise have been payable by the first respondent in connection with its conduct of the proceeding.
6. Streeterlaw, as solicitors for the applicants, be authorised to release forthwith to the applicants or their nominee the sum of $110,000 held in a controlled moneys account maintained by Streeterlaw in the name of CG Trading Pty Limited, the third applicant, as security for the responents’ costs in this proceeding.
THE COURT NOTES THAT:
7. It is an agreed fact between the parties that: “In the period September 2012 to May 2015, the First Respondent conducted activities in every state of Australia except Tasmania”;
8. The Applicants contend that the “activities” referred to in notation 7 above did not include the provision of adult themed services until February 2014 at the earliest (being the date the Second Respondent redirected traffic from the www.xxxprincess.com.au website to the www.centrefoldentertainment.com.au website); and
9. It is an agreed fact between the parties that the First Respondents’ website at www.centrefold-entertainment.com.au using the words “Centrefold Strippers” that appears at pages 420 to 459 of the Library of Documents was published by the Respondents during the period from 25 to 31 October 2016.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case reached the court following an originating application filed by Metro and CG to cancel the registration of Centrefold's "CENTREFOLD" trade mark. Centrefold responded with a cross-claim, seeking damages for alleged defamatory publications by Metro and CG. The matter proceeded through various applications and amendments to the pleadings, including the joinder of a second respondent, Mr. Prendergast. Several offers to settle the matter were made by Metro through without prejudice correspondence. The court considered these offers in the context of determining costs. Ultimately, the court decided in favour of Metro and CG, ordering the cancellation of Centrefold's trade mark registration and dismissing Centrefold's cross-claim. The court also made orders regarding the costs of the proceeding.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the registration of the trade mark "CENTREFOLD" should be cancelled in respect of all goods or services for which it is registered.
2. Whether the amended originating application and amended statement of claim should be dismissed in part or in full.
3. Whether the amended notice of cross-claim and amended statement of cross-claim should be dismissed.
4. What orders should be made regarding the costs of the proceeding, including any indemnity costs.
Held
1. Pursuant to s 88(1)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), the registration of the trade mark "CENTREFOLD" in respect of all goods or services for which it is registered is cancelled, and the entry of the Mark as being wrongly made and remaining on the Register of Trade Marks is removed.
2. Save as set out in holding 1 above, the amended originating application and amended statement of claim are dismissed.
3. The amended notice of cross-claim and amended statement of cross-claim are dismissed.
4. The first respondent and cross-claimant is to pay the applicants’ and cross-respondents’ costs of the proceeding and the cross-claim, except to the extent that the applicants would not have incurred such costs had the second respondent not been a party. The applicants are to pay the costs occasioned by the joinder of the second respondent as a party to the extent that his participation increased the costs that would otherwise have been payable by the first respondent. Streeterlaw, as solicitors for the applicants, is authorised to release forthwith to the applicants or their nominee the sum of $110,000 held in a controlled moneys account maintained by Streeterlaw in the name of CG Trading Pty Limited, the third applicant, as security for the respondents’ costs in this proceeding.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The principles are well settled on which the Court will order a party to pay costs on an indemnity basis when the successful party has made an offer to settle the proceeding other than under rules of court, such as Pt 25 of the Federal Court Rules. The offer must be one that amounts to a real compromise and the losing party must have acted unreasonably, in the circumstances facing that party at the time of the offer: Insight SRC IP Holdings Pty Limited v Australian Council for Educational Research Limited (No 2) [2013] FCAFC 73 at [7]-[9] per North, Rares and Robertson JJ. The mere making of an offer and its non-acceptance, followed by a result more favourable to the offeror, does not lead automatically to an order for payment of costs on an indemnity basis: Dukemaster Pty Limited v Bluehive Pty Limited [2003] FCAFC 1 at [7]-[9] per Sundberg and Emmett JJ. As they said, ordinarily, such an offer ought to contain a statement of the reasons of the offeror as to why the offeree will fail in the litigation, citing what Lindgren J had said in NMFM Property Pty Limited v Citibank Limited (No 2) (2001) 109 FCR 77 at 98 [87]-[88]. Indemnity costs – consideration Here, the 5 December 2016 offer that the Metro parties repeated on 7 December 2016, after Entertainment’s rejection on 6 December 2016, and again on 22 December 2016, following Mr Prendergast’s joinder, was open until 2 January 2017. That offer represented a real comprise and gave Entertainment, and later, it and Mr Prendergast, the option of receiving a substantial payment for the transfer of the registered trade mark or a walk away position. The question is whether Entertainment, or, after 15 December 2016, it and Mr Prendergast, was or were unreasonable to reject any or each of the 5, 7 and 22 December 2016 offers, or the 26 May 2017 offer. While the letter of 7 December 2016 explained that the Metro parties would be likely to incur substantial costs, presumably in early January 2017 and following, in order to prepare their evidence, none of the offers articulated a basis upon which the Metro parties argued that the Entertainment parties necessarily would fail. No doubt the parties had joined issue in the pleadings and understood their respective positions, but, in my opinion, there was nothing unreasonable, in all of the circumstances, in Entertainment or the Entertainment parties continuing to proceed in the litigation despite the offers. With the benefit of hindsight, it could be said that Entertainment and Mr Prendergast would have done well to have accepted one of the December 2016 offers and walked away. However, the use of without prejudice, except as to costs, offers in contradistinction to the facility offered by Pt 25 of the Rules, and its analogues in other courts, creates a well-known and real distinction between entitlements to costs. As the Entertainment parties pointed out, there was a substantive difference of $80,000 between the 5 and 6 December 2016 offers. Had the Metro parties made an offer under Pt 25 in terms of the offer contained in the 5 December 2016 offer, then or subsequently, they may have been presumptively entitled to an order that Entertainment or the Entertainment parties pay their costs on an indemnity basis. But, in seeking to proceed on the basis of an offer in without prejudice correspondence, the Metro parties had the burden, and in my opinion failed, to demonstrate that it was unreasonable for Entertainment and or Mr Prendergast to have refused any of those offers while both parties were seeking to compromise on what may be seen to be commercial bases.