Mether v Queensland Police Service

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Mether v Queensland Police Service [2022] QDC 53

PARTIES:

STEVEN LEE METHER

(appellant)

v
QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

213 of 21

DIVISION:

Appellate

PROCEEDING:

Appeal pursuant to section 222 Justices Act 1866

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

16 March 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Southport

HEARING DATE:

14 March 2022

JUDGE:

Holliday QC DCJ

ORDER:

1.   The appeal is allowed.

2.   The conviction for the offence of common assault is set aside.

3.   A retrial is ordered to be heard before a different Magistrate.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION – where the appellant was convicted of common assault – where provocation and prevention of repetition of insult were raised on the evidence – whether the learned Magistrate failed to properly consider and apply the defence of provocation and repetition of insult– whether the learned Magistrate failed to provide any adequate reasons for the finding that the assault charged was an excessive response to the provocation found to exist

LEGISLATION:

Justices Act 1886 (Qld), ss 222 and 223
Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld), ss 268, 269 and 270

CASES:

Allesch v Maunz (2000) 203 CLR 172
JEJ v Queensland Police Service [2021] QDC 64
Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott [2016] HCA 22; (2016) 90 ALJR 679
Stingel v R [1990] 171 CLR 312
White v Commissioner of Police [2014] QCA 121

COUNSEL:

Mr B Reilly for the appellant
Mr B Scarrabelotti for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Jacobson Mahony Lawyers for the appellant
The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondent

Introduction

  1. On 25 May 2021 the appellant was convicted, after a trial in the Magistrates Court, of common assault. The issue in the trial was whether the assault, particularised as the appellant throwing a folder in the direction of the complainant which struck the complainant in the head,[1] was unlawful.

    [1] Transcript of Trial, page 3 lines 16-17.

  2. The amended grounds of appeal are as follows:

    (a)The learned Magistrate failed to properly consider and apply the defence of provocation and/or the defence of prevention of repetition of insult.

    (b)The learned Magistrate failed to provide any adequate reasons for the finding that the assault that was charged was an excessive response to the provocation found to exist.[2]

    [2] The third ground of appeal that “the finding of guilt was unreasonable and against the weight of the evidence” was abandoned by the appellant on the hearing of the appeal.

    The nature of the appeal

  3. The appellant appeals pursuant to section 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld). Such an appeal is by way of rehearing on the evidence below.[3] In order to succeed on such an appeal, the appellant must establish some legal, factual or discretionary error.[4]  I am required to conduct a real review of the evidence and the learned Magistrate’s decision and make my own determination giving due deference and placing a good deal of weight on the learned Magistrate’s view.[5]

    [3]

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mether v Queensland Police Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QDC 53
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Mether v Queensland Police Service, the appellant appealed against a conviction for common assault made by a Magistrate in the Magistrates Court. The appeal was based on the argument that the Magistrate failed to properly consider and apply the defence of provocation and prevention of the repetition of insult. The key evidence included an electronically recorded interview with the appellant and "dash cam" footage of the incident. The complainant testified that after a collision between the two tow-trucks, the appellant verbally abused and physically assaulted him.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Magistrate failed to properly consider the defence of provocation and whether the Magistrate failed to provide adequate reasons for concluding that the assault was an excessive response to the provocation found to exist. The court found that the Magistrate did not adequately consider the defence of provocation and that there was no explanation for why the appellant's actions were deemed excessive in response to the provocation.

The court's reasoning was that the Magistrate did not adequately address the evidence of provocation and the appellant's actions in response to that provocation. The court found that the Magistrate did not provide sufficient reasons for rejecting the defence of provocation and determining that the appellant's actions were excessive. The appeal was allowed, the conviction was set aside, and a retrial was ordered before a different Magistrate.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The conviction for the offence of common assault is set aside.

3. A retrial is ordered to be heard before a different Magistrate.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The prosecution called two witnesses: the complainant and a police officer through whom an electronically recorded interview with the appellant was tendered. The exhibits in the trial consisted of the electronically recorded interview and “dash cam” footage of the incident. The appellant did not elect to give or call evidence at the trial.Evidence of complainant The complainant and appellant were tow-truck operators. On 12 September 2020, they were waiting in their respective tow-trucks at an area off the M1 near Dreamworld. They each received a notification that an accident had occurred and proceeded to drive along the M1 towards the accident site near exit 60. The tow-truck being driven by the appellant was in front of the tow-truck being driven by the complainant. The complainant saw the appellant “slam his brakes on”.[6] He could not stop his tow-truck in time, and it collided with the rear of the appellant’s tow-truck. The complainant could not see any damage to the appellant’s tow-truck, and both continued driving to the accident site. The appellant pulled up on the left shoulder of the road and the complainant pulled up in front of him. Both got out of their tow-trucks and checked the damage to the vehicle which was involved in the accident. There was not enough damage to require towing. [6] Transcript of Trial, page 7, line 29. The appellant started “mouthing off” at the complainant in relation to hitting his tow-truck. Both proceeded to the back of the appellant’s tow-truck to check the damage. The appellant started “mouthing off again” and hit the complainant twice with his folder.[7] The complainant said the “mouthing off” consisted of the appellant saying “[you are] a fucking dickhead, you’re an idiot, learn how to drive all these other things to that effect”,[8] and lasted for “probably between two to five minutes”.[9] The complainant said that he was “pretty sure” he said a “few words back to him as well, called him an idiot for doing what he did, saying that he brake checked me”.[10][7] Transcript of Trial, page 8 lines8-17.[8] Transcript of Trial, page 8 lines 18-20.[9] Transcript of Trial, page 8 lines 26-27.[10] Transcript of Trial, page 8 lines 21-24. The complainant said that the appellant called him a “fucking idiot” and out of nowhere the appellant, who had a black folder in his hand, swung and hit him in the side of the head from a distance of approximately two feet.[11][11] Transcript of Trial, page 9 lines 22-32. The complainant left the scene a short time later and attended the police station later the same day. The complainant said that he was struck to the left-hand side of the face and that he suffered “no major injuries, [a] swollen left ear, and just red marks on the side of the face.”[12][12] Transcript of Trial, page 10 lines 22-27. In cross-examination the complainant accepted that:(a)the appellant headed off to the accident scene first and the complainant followed him down the highway;[13][13] Transcript of Trial, page 11 lines 1-10.(b)he was travelling “directly behind” the appellant and “he was probably about one or two car-lengths” from the appellant’s tow-truck;[14][14] Transcript of Trial, page 11 lines 15-17,(c)the tow-truck he was driving was not quite as high as the appellant’s tow-truck and was an older model, weighing about two tonnes;[15][15] Transcript of Trial, page 11 lines 27-36.(d)the tow-truck the appellant was driving was worth about $180,000.00;[16][16] Transcript of Trial, page 12 line 6.(e)he was aware that he should keep a sufficient distance between himself and the vehicle in front, such that he could avoid a collision if they had to break suddenly, but “I left enough – sufficient room for braking, not a complete stop on a motorway at 80,90 kilometres an hour”;[17][17] Transcript of Trial, page 13 lines 5-10.(f)he ran into the back of the appellant’s vehicle and then it was about a minute before they pulled over at the scene of the car accident;[18](g)he agreed that after he exited his vehicle he said: “Mate, you’re a fucking idiot, you did that on purpose”;[19](h)they both exited their vehicles and yelled obscenities at each other, but he could not recall what the appellant said as he was extremely upset;[20](i)the appellant said that the complainant had run into the back of his truck, that he was concerned about the damage and wanted the complainant to look at it;[21](j)they were both upset and walked to the back of the appellant’s truck to look at the damage;(k)the gist of the conversation that was still occurring was the complainant saying it was the appellant’s fault and the appellant was saying that the complainant ran into the back of his truck;[22](l)he and the appellant have never been formally introduced;[23](m)when they went back to the rear of the truck he pushed at the appellant and the appellant again threw the folder;[24](n)in total they would have been in the vicinity of the truck for only a minute or two, and over that time the appellant became progressively angry with the complainant and it was clear that the appellant was angry at the complainant before he first struck the complainant with the folder;[25] and(o)he did not say in his statement that he had suffered any injuries and the police did not take any photographs of injuries.[26][18] Transcript of Trial, page 13 lines 10-20.[19] Transcript of Trial, page 13 line 46.[20] Transcript of Trial, page 14 lines 30-45.[21] Transcript of Trial, page 15 lines 1-10.[22] Transcript of Trial, page 15 lines 17-25.[23] Transcript of Trial, page 16 line 30.[24] Transcript of Trial, page 17 lines 1-10.[25] Transcript of Trial, page 17 lines 12-19.[26] Transcript of Trial, page 17 lines 25-45.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.