Merri Creek Quarry Pty Ltd v Foletta

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read
82 CLR 347

MERRI CREEK QUARRY PROPRIETARY FOLETTA

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Local Government (Vict.)-By-law-Prohibition of quarrying operations within H. C. OF

municipality unless with consent of council-Exception of operations in connec- tion with works commenced before a certain date-Quarry existing before that date extended thereafter to adjoining land-Local Government Act 1928 (No. 3720) (Vict.), S. 197 (1) (xviii).*

A municipal by-law prohibited quarrying operations within the municipality except with the consent of the council, but it was subject to a proviso that it should not apply to operations in connection with works commenced before 4th January 1911. After that date the defendant acquired from a quarry- master land in the municipality on which quarrying and work associated therewith had been carried on regularly from a time prior to that date and also adjoining land on which there had been no quarrying prior to 4th January 1911. The adjoining land had been the property of a stranger until, at a time after 4th January 1911, the defendant's predecessor in title purchased it and extended the face of the quarry into it. The defendant, without the The Local Government Act 1928

by-law prohibiting such operations (Vict.) provided, by S. 197 (1), that

shall not apply to any such by-laws may be made for any muni-

operations in connection with works cipality

for the purposes

commenced before " 4th January 1911. following

(xviii) Prohibiting

(See now Local Government Act 1946 regulating or controlling quarrying or

(No. 5203), S. 197 (1) (xxxv) (a), blasting operations, provided that any

82 CLR 348

consent of the council, continued the quarrying operations on the adjoining

Held that the quarrying operations on the adjoining land were in connection QUARRY

with the works which had been commenced on the former block of land before 4th January 1911 and the defendant, therefore, had not contravened the by-law.

Decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria (Barry J.) reversed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Victoria.

In a court of petty sessions of Victoria Merri Creek Quarry Pty. Ltd. was charged, on the information of Harold Walter Foletta, that between 1st September 1949 and 28th April 1950 it carried on quarrying operations on land in the city of Brunswick without the written consent of the council of the municipality of Brunswick contrary to a by-law of the municipality.

The by-law, which was made under S. 197 (1) (xviii) of the Local Government Act 1928 (Vict.), provided, SO far as material: Except with the written consent of the council no person shall within the city of Brunswick carry on any quarrying provided that the provisions of this paragraph shall not apply to quarrying

operations in connection with commenced before " 4th January 1911.

It appeared that the defendant company was incorporated under the law of Victoria in 1927. It acquired title to a block of land within the municipality of Brunswick on which its predecessors in title had been regularly conducting quarrying operations and work associated therewith from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Merri Creek Quarry Pty Ltd v Foletta and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1951] HCA 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Supreme Court of Victoria concerning a municipal by-law prohibiting quarrying operations without council consent. The appellant, Merri Creek Quarry Pty Ltd, was charged with contravening this by-law by conducting quarrying on land adjoining its original quarry site without consent. The by-law contained a proviso exempting operations connected with "works commenced before 4th January 1911." The Supreme Court had overturned a magistrate's decision that dismissed the charge, finding the appellant guilty.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the quarrying operations conducted by the appellant on the adjoining land constituted "operations in connection with works commenced before 4th January 1911," thereby falling within the proviso and exempting them from the by-law's consent requirement. The dispute hinged on the interpretation of "works commenced" and whether the extension of quarrying activities onto land not owned by the original quarry operators prior to the specified date disqualified those operations from the exemption.

The High Court, allowing the appeal, reasoned that the term "works" in the context of quarrying encompassed the entire enterprise and its natural development, including lateral expansion. The Court held that the proviso was intended to allow for the continuation and extension of existing quarries, and that limiting the exemption to operations on land owned at the commencement date would render the proviso ineffective. The physical connection and continuity of the quarrying operations, regardless of land ownership changes after the commencement date, were sufficient to establish that the operations on the adjoining land were in connection with the works commenced before 4th January 1911. Consequently, the High Court set aside the Supreme Court's order and restored the magistrate's decision dismissing the charge.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established