Mercantile Mutual Insurance (Australia) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mercantile Mutual Insurance (Australia) Limited [2002] FCA 1278

CORPORATIONS LAW – solvent schemes of arrangement proposed in England for Australian insurance company and each of four Dutch insurance companies in combination – identical Scheme proposed in Australia, in so far as it relates to Australian insurance company – each company a member of same international insurance corporate group – schemes designed to accelerate crystallisation and satisfaction of reinsurance claims pending or anticipated against proponents of schemes otherwise – claims unlikely to be finalised for some considerable future time – potential mutual advantages to all parties concerned to crystallise liability of insurers for and quantification of those reinsurance claims earlier than would otherwise occur in the normal course – approval to be sought to all schemes in High Court of Justice in England – whether scheme meeting to take place in England in respect of Australian insurance company should be ordered in Australia as well as in England – whether explanatory statement for schemes should be approved by the Court upon the application of Australian company – order made for convening meeting of scheme creditors of Australian company in England and for approval of explanatory statement relating thereto – certain Corporations Regulations excluded from application.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 411(1), 412(1)(a) and 1319
Corporations Regulations (generally)
Companies Act 1985 (UK) s 425

Re Sandhurst (1991) 9 ACLC 62 applied
Re Triden Contractors Ltd (1993) 30 NSWLR 615 applied
Sovereign Life Assurance Company v Dodd (1892) 2 QB 573 cited
Re Hawk Insurance Co Ltd [2001] 2 BCLC 480 cited
Re Glendale Land Development Ltd (In Liq) (1982) 7 ACLR 171 cited
Re Garner Motors Ltd [1937] 1 All ER 671 cited
Isles v Daily Mail Newspaper Ltd (1912) 14 CLR 193 cited
Re Bulong Nickel Pty Ltd [2002] WASC 226 applied
Re International Harvester Co of Australia Pty Ltd [1953] VLR 66 applied

MERCANTILE MUTUAL INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED

IN THE MATTER OF MERCANTILE MUTUAL INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED

N 3052 of 2002

CONTI J
SYDNEY
17 OCTOBER 2002


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 3052 OF 2002

IN THE MATTER OF MERCANTILE MUTUAL INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED

BETWEEN:

MERCANTILE MUTUAL INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED ACN 35 000 456 799
  APPLICANT

JUDGE:

CONTI J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 OCTOBER 2002

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to section 411(1) of the Corporations Act, there be convened by the Plaintiff ("MMIA") a meeting ("the Scheme Meeting") of the Scheme Creditors (as defined) of MMIA in respect of their Scheme Liabilities (as defined) ("the MMIA Scheme Creditors") for the purpose of considering and, if it is thought fit, approving a scheme of arrangement (with or without modification) ("the Scheme") proposed to be made between MMIA and the MMIA Scheme Creditors, being the Scheme substantially in the form of a draft, a copy of which is part of Exhibit "A3".

2.The Scheme Meeting be advertised once in "The Australian Financial Review" and "The Australian" by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mercantile Mutual Insurance (Australia) Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 1278
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mercantile Mutual Insurance (Australia) Limited, represented by their legal team, sought orders from the Federal Court of Australia to facilitate the implementation of a scheme of arrangement for the resolution of their financial liabilities. The primary focus of the application was to convene meetings of the scheme creditors to consider and potentially approve the proposed scheme. The Court was required to decide on several legal issues, including whether to grant specific orders to ensure the proper conduct of the creditors' meetings, and whether certain regulations under the Corporations Regulations should apply to the meetings, with particular exceptions for consistency with the conduct of a related meeting.

The Court found that the submissions made by Mercantile Mutual Insurance were well conceived and should be upheld. It was determined that there was no valid reason to reject the proposed orders, which included convening the creditors' meeting, specifying the location and timing, and outlining the procedural rules to be followed. The Court also agreed to apply certain regulations to the meetings, with specified exceptions to maintain procedural consistency across multiple related meetings. The Court based its decision on established legal principles and precedents, notably those outlined by Santow J in Re NRMA Insurance Ltd (No. 1) and Emmett J in Central Pacific Minerals NL.

In light of the findings, the Court made several orders to facilitate the scheme of arrangement. These included convening the creditors' meeting, specifying the location and date, and detailing the procedural rules for the meeting, such as the requirement for a quorum and the method for resolving disputes regarding claim values. The Court also approved the explanatory statement and set the next hearing date for the approval of the scheme. The orders were designed to ensure that the scheme of arrangement could proceed smoothly and in accordance with the legal requirements.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to section 411(1) of the Corporations Act, there be convened by the Plaintiff ("MMIA") a meeting ("the Scheme Meeting") of the Scheme Creditors (as defined) of MMIA in respect of their Scheme Liabilities (as defined) ("the MMIA Scheme Creditors") for the purpose of considering and, if it is thought fit, approving a scheme of arrangement (with or without modification) ("the Scheme") proposed to be made between MMIA and the MMIA Scheme Creditors, being the Scheme substantially in the form of a draft, a copy of which is part of Exhibit "A3".

2. The Scheme Meeting be advertised once in "The Australian Financial Review" and "The Australian" by an advertisement in the form or to the effect of annexure "A" hereto, such advertisement to be published on or before 30 October 2002.

3. The Scheme Meeting be held at The Chartered Insurance Institute, Insurance Hall, 20 Aldermanbury, London EC2V 7HY, United Kingdom on 11 December 2002, commencing at approximately 11.00 am (London Time).

4. Mr Dan Yoram Schwarzmann or, failing him, Mr Mark Charles Batten, be the Chairman of the Scheme Meeting.

5. The Scheme Meeting can resolve to be adjourned.

6. At the Scheme Meeting, the MMIA Scheme Creditors, present and entitled to vote thereat, in person or by proxy or by an attorney under power, shall constitute a quorum.

7. Regulations 5.6.12 to 5.6.36A of the Corporations Regulations will apply to the Scheme Meeting, except that Corporations Regulations 5.6.12(4), 5.6.12(5), 5.6.12(6), 5.6.12(7), 5.6.13A, 5.6.13B, 5.6.14A, 5.6.14B, 5.6.15, 5.6.16, 5.6.17, 5.6.19(3), 5.6.20, 5.6.21, 5.6.22, 5.6.23, 5.6.24, 5.6.26, 5.6.27, 5.6.28, 5.6.29, 5.6.32, 5.6.33, 5.6.34, 5.6.36A, will not apply.

8. On or before 7 November 2002, there be sent to:

(a) the MMIA Scheme Creditors; and

(b) brokers, agents and intermediaries of the MMIA Scheme Creditors in respect of the Scheme Liabilities (as defined),

by airmail, post or courier addressed to each of the relevant addressees of the MMIA Scheme Creditors and the relevant brokers (as defined in the scheme) documents copies of which have been tendered in these proceedings and which is contained in Exhibit "A3", being documents substantially in the form of or to the effect of the following:

(a) important notice;

(b) table of contents and the key dates and expected timetable;

(c) key definitions;

(d) a letter from a director of each of MMIA and the Dutch companies;

(e) the Explanatory Statement, containing:

(i) the background to MMIA and the Dutch companies;

(ii) summary of the Scheme;

(iii) various appendices, being:

A. a list of documents available for inspection;

B. summary balance sheet of MMIA and the Dutch companies as at 31 December 2001;

C. curriculum vitae of the Scheme Advisers, the Scheme Actuary, the Scheme Adjudicators and the Substitute Scheme Adjudicators;

D. Estimation Methodology Paper;

E. details of the Permanent Injunction Order under section 304 of the United States Bankruptcy Code;

F. a list of the directors of MMIA and the Dutch companies;

G. a list of the companies whose business forms part of the Scheme (so far as MMIA is concerned;

H. a diagrammatical representation of the company structure of The Seven Provinces;

(f) the Scheme;

(g) a notice of meeting for each of MMIA and the Dutch companies; and

(h) a form of proxy and voting form in respect of each of MMIA and the Dutch companies.

9. The notice of meeting be settled in the form, or substantially in the form, of the notice of meeting which is part of Exhibit "A3".

10. The voting form and form of proxy be settled in the form, or substantially in the form, of the forms which are part of Exhibit "A3".

11. The voting form may be lodged by facsimile provided that the faxed voting form and the documents referred to in the voting form or accompanying the voting form are received by PricewaterhouseCoopers, Plumtree Court, London, EC4A 4HT, United Kingdom for the attention of Mark Jones not later than 48 hours before, and the originals of these documents are received no later than 7 days after, the Scheme Meeting.

12. The following procedure for resolving any disputes as to the value of claims for the purpose of voting at the Scheme Meeting apply:

(a) the Chairman of the Scheme Meeting will have a discretion to determine what he considers to be a fair and reasonable value to be attributed to a Scheme Liability for the purpose of voting at the Scheme Meeting;

(b) the Chairman of the Scheme Meeting will also have the power to reject a Scheme Liability for voting purposes, in whole or in part, if he considers that it is not fair and reasonable or to attribute a value of one US Dollar to it; and

(c) in the event of a dispute, the Chairman's decision will be final and binding, subject to any right of appeal in law and, where possible, he will notify his decision on valuation for voting purposes to the relevant Scheme Creditor before the Scheme Meeting.

13. Pursuant to section 411(1) of the Corporations Act, the Explanatory Statement for the Scheme, a copy of which forms part of the documents tendered in these proceedings which is Exhibit "A3", be approved.

14. The Proceedings be stood over to 20 December 2002 at 10.15 am for the hearing of any application to approve the Scheme.

"A"

CORPORATIONS ACT 2001 OF AUSTRALIA

NOTICE OF MEETING

MERCANTILE MUTUAL INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED

(ABN 35 000 456 799)

Notice is hereby given that by order made on 17 October 2002, the Federal Court of Australia has directed that a meeting of the Scheme Creditors (as defined in the scheme of arrangement referred to below) of the Company be held on 11 December 2002, commencing at 11.00 am (London Time). The Scheme Creditors are defined in the Scheme as being creditors of the Company in respect of certain discontinued international reinsurance business written by the Company on or before 1 January 1985 or written by certain predecessor companies and transferred to the Company on or before 30 September 1998. All Scheme Creditors are requested to attend at such place and time either in person or by proxy.

The purpose of the meeting is to consider, and if thought fit, agree to a scheme of arrangement (with or without modification) proposed between the Company and the Scheme Creditors.

Scheme Creditors may vote in person at the meeting or may appoint another person, whether a Scheme Creditor or not, as their proxy to attend and vote in their place.

Any Scheme Creditor may obtain a copy of the proposed scheme of arrangement, the Explanatory Statement required to be furnished pursuant to the Corporations Act and the voting form and form of proxy, by collecting the same personally at the Company's offices at Level 13, 347 Kent Street, Sydney in the State of New South Wales, 2000 between the hours of 9.00 am and 5.00 pm on each weekday excluding public holidays until and including 11 December 2002 (Australian Eastern Summer time), or they may be obtained from Mark Jones, PricewaterhouseCoopers, Plumtree Court, London, EC4A 4HT, United Kingdom during normal business hours before 11 December 2002 (London time).

Date: October 2002

MERCANTILE MUTUAL INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED

S.S. ROUVRAY

Company Secretary

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

CONTI J
Lastly, MMIA has submitted that an order should be made to the effect that regulations 5.6.12 to 5.6.36A of the Corporation’s Regulations to the Australian Act apply to the Scheme, except for those regulations to be identified in the draft Short Minutes of Order produced by MMIA. Rule 2.15 of the Corporation Law Rules provides in that regard as follows:“Subject to the Law, these Rules and any direction of the Court to the contrary, regulations 5.6.12 to 5.6.36A of the Corporations Regulations apply to meetings ordered by the Court.”Those exceptions so identified are sought for the reason that the Scheme creditors’ meetings for all five companies are to be conducted in London in accordance with a common procedure, and that therefore there should be procedural consistency with the conduct of the MMIA Scheme meeting. The submission is clearly well conceived. Upon that basis, MMIA has further sought directions from the Court as set out in paragraph 12 of the Order. I see no good reason why the Court should not make an order in those terms pursuant to s 1319 of the Corporations Act 2001.Conclusion In my opinion, the contentions which have been advanced by Senior Counsel on behalf of MMIA are soundly conceived and should be upheld and carried into effect and that the Scheme of Arrangement, so far as it relates to MMIA, should proceed for consideration at the appropriate time for consideration by the Scheme creditors of MMIA. I therefore propose to make orders to the effect set out in the Draft Short Minutes submitted, and to publish these Reasons for Judgment at the same time, when formally requested by the legal representatives for MMIA. In proposing to make those orders, I have taken into account the principles enunciated by Santow J in Re NRMA Insurance Ltd (No. 1) (2000) 156 FLR 349 and Emmett J in Central Pacific Minerals NL [2002] FCA 239, which need not be restated.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: CONTI J

Full text does not contain this section.