Menso v Commonwealth Bank of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Menso v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2016] QCA 188

PARTIES:

MARIO JOHN MENSO
(applicant)
v
COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA
ACN 123 123 124
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 7177 of 2016
DC No 1777 of 2015

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Stay of Execution

ORIGINATING COURT:


District Court at Brisbane – Unreported, 26 May 2016

DELIVERED ON:

21 July 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

20 July 2016

JUDGE:

Morrison JA

ORDERS:

1.   The application for a stay is refused.

2.   The applicant must pay the respondent’s costs, of and incidental to the application, to be assessed.

3.   The execution of the warrant of execution is stayed until 4 pm on 9 August 2016.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – STAY OF PROCEEDINGS – GENERAL PRINCIPLES AS TO GRANT OR REFUSAL – where the applicant borrowed money from the respondent Bank and secured repayment by granting a mortgage over real property – where the respondent commenced proceedings against the applicant, seeking recovery of possession on the basis that there had been a default in repaying the loan – where a summary judgment application was granted in the District Court brought by the respondent against the applicant – the District Court judge dismissed the applicant’s counterclaim and other applications and ordered that the respondent recover possession of the mortgaged land, and judgment for the debt – where an enforcement warrant has been issued and is due to be executed on 26 July 2016 – where the applicant contends that the orders of the learned primary judge should be stayed – whether a stay of proceedings should be granted

Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corp Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 685, cited
Cook’s Construction Pty Ltd v Stork Food Systems Australasia Pty Ltd [2008] 2 Qd R 453; [2008] QCA 322, followed
Croney v Nand [1999] 2 Qd R 342; [1998] QCA 367, cited
Raschilla v Westpac Banking Corporation[2010] QCA 255, cited
Williams v Chesterman[1992] QCA 198, cited

COUNSEL:

The applicant appeared on his own behalf
K Gothard for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

The applicant appeared on his own behalf
Gadens Lawyers for the respondent

  1. MORRISON JA:  In 2005 Mr Menso borrowed from the Commonwealth Bank and secured repayment by granting a mortgage over real property in both his name and that of his then partner, Ms Bos.

  2. In May 2015 the Bank commenced proceedings against Mr Menso and Ms Bos, seeking recovery of possession of the mortgaged land on the basis that there had been default in repaying the loan, which had been called up.

  3. On 26 May 2016 the District Court granted a summary judgment application brought against Mr Menso by the Commonwealth Bank.  At the same time it dismissed Mr Menso’s counterclaim, and other applications brought by Mr Menso.

  4. The relevant orders were that the Bank recover possession of the mortgaged land, and judgment for the debt, in the sum of $204,369.82, plus interest.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Menso v Commonwealth Bank of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QCA 188
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr Menso, had borrowed money from the Commonwealth Bank of Australia and secured repayment by granting a mortgage over his real property. The Bank commenced proceedings seeking recovery of possession due to a default in repaying the loan. The District Court granted a summary judgment application brought by the Bank against Mr Menso, dismissed his counterclaim and other applications, and ordered that the Bank recover possession of the mortgaged land and judgment for the debt. An enforcement warrant has been issued and is due to be executed on 26 July 2016. Mr Menso contends that the orders of the primary judge should be stayed. The appeal against the primary judgment was dismissed by the Queensland Court of Appeal.

The appeal court was required to determine whether a stay of proceedings should be granted. The court needed to consider the prospects of success of the appeal, the prejudice to the parties if the stay was granted or refused, and the additional time Mr Menso needed to remove his property from the land.

The appeal court found that no error had been identified in the primary judge's decision. The court concluded that none of Mr Menso's claims had any realistic prospect of success to overturn the judgment given below. The proposed appeal lacked any substantive merit. The court considered that the prejudice to Mr Menso from the refusal of a stay did not reach the level that warranted the Court's discretion being exercised that way. The court also found that Mr Menso should be given a short extra period of time to remove himself from the property, rather than face the storage costs that would be incurred if the property is removed by the sheriff.

The appeal court refused the application for a stay, ordered Mr Menso to pay the Bank's costs of and incidental to the application, and stayed the execution of the warrant of execution until 4 pm on 9 August 2016.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for a stay is refused.

2. The applicant must pay the respondent’s costs, of and incidental to the application, to be assessed.

3. The execution of the warrant of execution is stayed until 4 pm on 9 August 2016.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

No error on the part of the learned primary judge has been identified.Conclusion as to prospects of success In my view none of the claims raised by Mr Menso has any realistic prospect of succeeding to overturn the judgment given below. Mr Menso’s proposed appeal lacks any substantive merit.Prejudice Mr Menso contended that the loss of his property was prejudice that outweighed anything that the Bank might suffer if a stay was granted. True it is that the property will probably be lost to Mr Menso if recovery of possession continues. I say “probably” because Mr Menso made vague claims that there was a finance proposal in the wings, and it may come to fruition in the next week. No doubt if Mr Menso could offer enough, the Bank would likely rather avoid the exercise of selling. However, there is an extant judgment, after a hearing going to the merits of Mr Menso’s possible defences to the Bank’s claim. The Bank has been held out from full recovery for some years and the debt is mounting with no imminent repayment by Mr Menso. Further, there are no real prospects of success in the proposed appeal. For the reasons set out in paragraphs [8] to [12] above the lack of any such merit is a powerful factor in favour of refusing the stay. An additional factor is that the Bank is financially sound, so that if Mr Menso obtains a money judgment against the Bank, there is reason to think it will be met. In my view the prejudice to Mr Menso from the refusal of a stay does not reach the level that warrants the Court’s discretion being exercised that way.Removal of property The warrant of execution is due to be enforced on 26 July 2016, about five days away. Mr Menso submitted that he needed more time than that to remove his possessions and property from the land. Instances of the type of thing that was said to cause difficulty were: two demountable buildings on sleds, a deconstructed 250m2 steel shed, various pieces of unspecified equipment, a bus currently sitting on stands, and nine pigs kept for personal consumption. Mr Menso points out that the loss of his driver’s licence impedes his ability to move the possessions easily or in a timely way. He says he only discovered on Friday 15 July that the licence had been suspended, but that it was suspended some weeks ago. The Bank resists any further grant of time but does not identify any prejudice that would flow from a short extension of time in respect of the execution of the warrant. It is true that Mr Menso could have taken steps before this to remove the property. But no doubt he considered he had prospects on the stay application, and it can be argued that he was entitled to wait and see what the outcome of that might be. It is also true that in mid-June 2016 Mr Menso applied for a stay of the execution of the warrant, and that was refused by Dorney DCJ. However, at least two things have changed since then, namely the appeal proceedings and the loss of Mr Menso’s licence. Given the loss of his driver’s licence, I consider that Mr Menso should be given a short extra period of time to remove himself from the property, rather than face the storage costs that would be incurred if the property is removed by the sheriff. In the circumstances the execution of the warrant will be stayed until 9 August 2016, allowing two weeks longer than the proposed execution date.Disposition

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established