Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Menso

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

[2016] QCA 319

COURT OF APPEAL

FRASER JA

Appeal No 7177 of 2016
DC No 1777 of 2015

COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA  Respondent/Applicant
ACN 123 123 124

v

MARIO JOHN MENSO  Appellant/Respondent

BRISBANE

TUESDAY, 29 NOVEMBER 2016

JUDGMENT

FRASER JA:  This is an application for security for costs of this appeal.  The appeal is, or purports to be, an appeal against a decision of a judge in the District Court, who I will describe as the primary judge, on 24 May 2016.  I will briefly mention the most relevant aspects of the chronology.

In May 2015, the respondent filed a claim in the District Court claiming a sum of about $160,000 as the outstanding balance of a loan and recovery of possession of the appellant’s land, which was secured by mortgage in favour of the respondent for the repayment of the loan.  The appellant filed a notice of intention to defend and counter-claim in June 2015.

In April 2016, the respondent filed an application for summary judgment on its claim and against the appellant on his counter-claim.  In May 2016, the appellant filed two applications: one which sought orders that the matter proceed to trial and another, which sought leave to amend his defence and for a stay of the proceedings in the District Court.

On 24 May 2016, the primary judge granted the respondent summary judgment against the appellant in respect of the respondent’s claim and the appellant’s counter-claim and the primary judge dismissed the appellant’s applications.

On 21 June 2016, an enforcement warrant was issued to the District Court for the enforcement of the orders made by the primary judge.  On 14 July 2016, the appellant filed an appeal in this Court, which was out of time, and an application to stay enforcement of the primary judge’s decision pending the appeal.

On 21 July 2016, Justice Morrison dismissed the appellant’s application for a stay.  That decision is Menso v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2016] QCA 188. On 11 August 2016, the respondent obtained possession of the appellant’s land which was the subject of the mortgage.

On or about 14 October 2016, the appellant filed an outline of argument in the appeal and it appears that this was served on the respondent on or about 24 October 2016.  The present application, the respondent’s application for security for costs, was filed on 31 October 2016.

An important consideration in considering whether security for costs on appeal should be granted concerns the financial position of the appellant.  In Natcraft Pty Ltd v Det Norske Veritas & Anor [2002] QCA 241, Justice Jerrard observed that, where an appellant is without funds or assets, this factor is important and provides what this Court has described as a persuasive reason for ordering security for costs. I note, in that respect, that the respondent has adduced affidavit evidence which is uncontradicted and which suggests that the value of the security property is insufficient to fund the repayment of the whole of the outstanding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Menso and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QCA 319
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal, Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Menso, involved a claim by the bank for the recovery of a debt and possession of land secured by a mortgage. The appellant, Mario John Menso, filed a notice of intention to defend and counter-claim. The bank applied for summary judgment and the appellant sought to proceed to trial and amend his defence. The primary judge granted the bank's application, dismissing the appellant's claims and counter-claims, and dismissed the appellant's applications. The appellant filed an appeal, which was out of time, and an application for a stay of enforcement. Justice Morrison dismissed the stay application, and the bank enforced the primary judge's orders, obtaining possession of the land. The bank then applied for security for costs of the appeal.

The key legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the appellant should be ordered to provide security for the respondent's costs of appeal. The Court considered the appellant's financial position, his prospects of success on appeal, and whether there had been any unreasonable delay in bringing the application for security for costs. The Court noted that the appellant had lost on the merits in the District Court and had an unmeritorious appeal. The Court concluded that the factors weighed in favour of ordering security for costs.

The Court ordered the appellant to provide security for the respondent's costs of appeal in the sum of $30,000 by a specified date. The Court also stayed the appeal until the security was provided and ordered the appellant to pay the respondent's costs of the application. The Court refused the appellant's application to compel the respondent to disclose documents.

In summary, the Court of Appeal held that the appellant should be ordered to provide security for the respondent's costs of appeal given the appellant's impecuniosity, lack of prospects of success, and the fact that he had already lost on the merits in the District Court. The Court ordered security of $30,000 and stayed the appeal until that security was provided.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established