McNally v Essenhaven P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: McNally v Essenhaven P/L [2001] QCA 452
PARTIES: PETER ROBERT McNALLY
(plaintiff/respondent)
v
ESSENHAVEN PTY LTD (ACN 010 448 405)
(defendant/appellant)
FILE NO/S: Appeal No 3167 of 2001
DC No 38 of 2000
DIVISION: Court of Appeal, Brisbane
PROCEEDING: General Civil Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Maryborough

DELIVERED ON: 23 October 2001
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARING DATE: 19 September 2001
JUDGES: Thomas  and Williams JJA, Douglas J
Judgment of the Court
ORDER: Appeal allowed – Set aside that part of the judgment of the District Courts of 9 March 2001 that ordered the defendant to pay to the plaintiff the sum of $83,475.41 and in lieu give judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant in the sum of $51,375.41. 
Order that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal to be assessed.

CATCHWORDS:

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTION FOR TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – LOSS OF EARNINGS AND EARNING CAPACITY – EXPENSE FLOWING FROM PLAINTIFF’S INABILITY TO WORK – GENERALLY – the respondent was a fruit tree picker injured at work because of the appellant’s negligence – whether the learned trial judge erred in his assessment of damages for past and future loss of earning capacity.

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – NON-PECUNIARY DAMAGE – PAIN AND SUFFERING – whether the learned trial judge erred in his assessment of the nature of the respondent’s injuries suffered.

COUNSEL: J S Miles for appellant
S J Given for respondent
SOLICITORS: Bradley & Company for appellant
Watling Roche for respondent
  1. THE COURT:  This is an appeal from an assessment of damages in a master/servant action by a judge of District Courts.

  1. The respondent to the appeal was working as a fruit tree trimmer and picker when injured at work on 11 May 1998.  He was then aged 54 years and was aged 57 years at the time of judgment on 9 March 2001.

  1. The only challenges made on the appeal are to the learned trial judge’s assessment of damages for past and future loss of earning capacity, and to certain findings regarding the nature of injuries suffered.  His Honour awarded sums of $20,000 and $40,000 respectively for past and future economic loss.

  1. It is necessary to set out some of the history of the plaintiff’s employment before coming to those questions.  First of all it was not in contention at the trial that the respondent suffers from an “enormous and premature” inherent degenerative condition of his spine.  Furthermore, it was proved that he had sustained a previous workplace injury whilst working for another employer some ten years earlier in July 1988.  Subsequent to that injury he was out of work and in receipt of a disability support pension for about seven years, until around mid 1995.

  1. He then worked as a farm labourer on a tomato plantation where his work included tomato picking.  He did…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McNally v Essenhaven P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QCA 452
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved McNally, the appellant, and Essenhaven P/L, the respondent. The respondent was a fruit tree picker who sustained injuries due to the appellant's negligence. The dispute centred on the assessment of damages awarded to the respondent for both past and future loss of earning capacity, as well as non-pecuniary damages for pain and suffering. The District Court had previously awarded the respondent $83,475.41, a decision the appellant contested on the grounds of incorrect assessment by the trial judge.

The court was required to determine whether the trial judge had erred in his assessment of damages for past and future loss of earning capacity. This included evaluating the respondent's ability to work post-injury and the associated financial implications. Additionally, the court had to examine the trial judge's assessment of the nature of the respondent's injuries and the appropriate compensation for the pain and suffering endured. The appeal challenged the quantification of damages, specifically questioning whether the awarded amount was excessive or inadequate.

The court found that the trial judge had indeed erred in his assessment. The judge had overestimated the extent of the respondent's future loss of earning capacity and had not adequately accounted for the respondent's pre-existing medical conditions that could impact his ability to work. Furthermore, the court determined that the assessment of non-pecuniary damages did not reflect the actual extent of the respondent's pain and suffering. The court concluded that the total award of $83,475.41 was excessive and reduced the amount to $51,375.41, considering the respondent's diminished capacity and pre-existing conditions.

In light of the findings, the appeal was allowed, and the original judgment was set aside. The court ordered that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal, which would be assessed. The new judgment mandated that the respondent pay the appellant $51,375.41 in lieu of the previously awarded sum.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal allowed – Set aside that part of the judgment of the District Courts of 9 March 2001 that ordered the defendant to pay to the plaintiff the sum of $83,475.41 and in lieu give judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant in the sum of $51,375.41.

Order that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal to be assessed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.