McMillan v Toledo Enterprises International Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

CORPORATIONS - interlocutory application - appointment of provisional liquidator - appointment of receiver and manager - whether affairs of the company conducted unfairly within the meaning of s260 Corporations Law - whether just and equitable that a provisional liquidator be appointed within the meaning of s461(k) Corporations Law - appropriate relief - whether receiver and manager should be appointed rather than provisional liquidator where the company has entered a potentially profitable contract

Corporations Law s260 s461

Morgan v 45 Flers Avenue Pty Limited (1986) 10 ACLR 692
Wayde v New South Wales Rugby League Limited 180 CLR 490
Zephyr Holdings Pty Limited v Jack Chia (Australia) Limited (1988) 14 ACLR 30
Re Dalkeith Investments Pty Limited (1984) 9 ACLR 247
McGuire v Ralph McKay Limited & Ors (1987) 12 ACLR 107
Whitehouse v Carlton Hotel Pty Limited (1987) 162 CLR 285
Ebrahimi v Westbourne Galleries Limited [1973] AC 360

KEVIN CAMPBELL McMILLAN v TOLEDO ENTERPRISES INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD
No. NG3605 of 1995
Beazley J
15 November 1995
Sydney

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
  )    No. NG3605 of 1995
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY )
  )
GENERAL DIVISION                 )

BETWEEN:KEVIN CAMPBELL McMILLAN

Applicant

AND:TOLEDO ENTERPRISES INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD

First Respondent

HRISTO ILIEV

Second Respondent

JOSEPH GOLUBINSKY

Third Respondent

CORAM:BEAZLEY J

PLACE:    SYDNEY
DATE:     15 November 1995

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BEAZLEY J:    This is an interlocutory application for the appointment of a receiver and manager of the assets and business of the first respondent, Toledo Enterprises International Pty Ltd (Toledo) and for certain other injunctions relating to the conduct of the affairs of Toledo.

Corporate structure
Toledo was incorporated in about December 1994, the corporate name deriving from a business name, Toledo Enterprises, under which the applicant (McMillan) carried on a business unassociated with the present proceedings.  Toledo's issued capital comprises three A class (voting) shares and six B class shares.   The second respondent, Hristo Iliev, (Iliev) holds two of the A class shares and four of the B class shares.  McMillan owns one A class share and one B class share.  Another B class share is owned by McMillan's wife.  Both Iliev and McMillan have contributed substantial funds by way of loan capital to Toledo.  

The submarine venture
In about 1993, McMillan became interested in finding a Russian submarine for the purposes of public exhibition in Australia. In early 1994, he commenced negotiations with the Russian Department of Spetsvneshtechnika (Spets) for the acquisition of a submarine.  In about May 1994, he entered into an option to purchase a submarine from Spets.  In June 1994, McMillan, in the name of his business, Toledo Enterprises, entered into an agreement with Rosvooroushenie (ROS)- formerly Spets - for the lease and purchase of a Russian Foxtrot submarine.

After some difficulties in finalising which submarine would be acquired under the lease and sale agreement, agreement was reached with ROS for the supply of a submarine named "Pluto".   McMillan subsequently renamed the submarine "Scorpion".

As the costs of repairs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McMillan v Toledo Enterprises International Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] FCA 911
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In McMillan v Toledo Enterprises International Pty Ltd, the applicant, Kevin Campbell McMillan, sought the appointment of a receiver and manager of the assets and business of Toledo Enterprises International Pty Ltd (Toledo). The respondents, Hristo Iliev and Joseph Golubinsky, opposed the application. The dispute arose from the breakdown of the business relationship between McMillan and Iliev, who were the two directors of Toledo. The company had entered into a potentially profitable contract with the Australian National Maritime Museum for the exhibition of a Russian submarine. However, the relationship between McMillan and Iliev had deteriorated, with McMillan alleging that he had been denied access to the company's books, excluded from major decision-making, and treated unfairly. The court found that there was a serious question to be tried on the claim under section 260 of the Corporations Law, which allows for relief in cases of unfair conduct. The court also found that the balance of convenience lay in favour of granting relief. The court held that the appropriate relief was the appointment of a receiver and manager to protect the potential profitability of the contract with the Maritime Museum.

Background

Background to the litigation

Kevin Campbell McMillan, one of the shareholders and directors of Toledo Enterprises International Pty Ltd (Toledo), applied for an interlocutory appointment of a receiver and manager of Toledo's assets and business. McMillan alleged that he had been excluded from the management of the company and denied access to the company's books. Toledo had entered into a potentially profitable contract with the Australian National Maritime Museum for the exhibition of a Russian submarine named "Scorpion." The submarine had been acquired by Toledo through an agreement with Rosvoorouzhenie (ROS), formerly Spets. The company's affairs had been managed by Hristo Iliev, the other major shareholder, who had allegedly restricted McMillan's access to the company's finances and denied him access to the company's books. Iliev had also purportedly appointed Joseph Golubinsky as a director without McMillan's knowledge or consent. Toledo had allegedly experienced financial difficulties and was in need of funds to complete the submarine project and honor its contract with the Maritime Museum.

This case is an interlocutory application heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The application was initially for the appointment of a provisional liquidator of Toledo. During the hearing, McMillan amended his application to seek the appointment of a receiver and manager instead. The application was based on sections 260 and 461(k) of the Corporations Law, alleging unfair conduct and the just and equitable ground for winding up the company.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the affairs of the company were conducted in a manner that was oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to McMillan within the meaning of s260 Corporations Law.
2. Whether it was just and equitable that a provisional liquidator or a receiver and manager be appointed within the meaning of s461(k) Corporations Law.
3. Whether the proposed fundraising was oppressive or unfairly prejudicial within the meaning of s260 Corporations Law.
4. Whether the appointment of Golubinsky as a director on 18 October 1995 was valid and, if not, what consequences it had for McMillan.
5. Whether Iliev was the de facto chairman of Toledo, and what rights that would give him under the company's Articles of Association.

Held
1. The court held that the affairs of the company were conducted in a manner that was oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to McMillan within the meaning of s260 Corporations Law.
2. The court held that it was just and equitable that a provisional liquidator or a receiver and manager be appointed within the meaning of s461(k) Corporations Law.
3. The court held that the proposed fundraising was oppressive or unfairly prejudicial within the meaning of s260 Corporations Law.
4. The court held that the appointment of Golubinsky as a director on 18 October 1995 was not valid and that this had immediate and adverse consequences for McMillan.
5. The court did not decide whether Iliev was the de facto chairman of Toledo and what rights that would give him under the company's Articles of Association.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered various factors in reaching its decisions. The conduct of the company's affairs was deemed oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to McMillan due to his exclusion from decision-making, denial of access to company books, and lack of consultation on major decisions such as the alteration of the contract with the Maritime Museum. The proposed fundraising scheme was seen as potentially unfair, given McMillan's offers to secure the necessary funds and Iliev's insistence on raising the funds himself. The appointment of Golubinsky as a director was held to be invalid, as there was no proper meeting held to pass the resolution, and Iliev did not have the authority to act as chairman. The breakdown in the relationship between McMillan and Iliev, coupled with the company's urgent need for funds to fulfill its contract with the Maritime Museum, led the court to conclude that it was just and equitable to appoint a provisional liquidator or a receiver and manager. The potential profitability of the contract with the Maritime Museum weighed in favor of appointing a receiver and manager to protect the company's interests.