McMillan Investment Holdings Pty Ltd v Morgan

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

McMillan Investment Holdings Pty Ltd v Morgan [2023] FCAFC 9   

Appeal from: Morgan v Sydney Allen Manufacturing Pty Limited (In Liquidation) [2021] FCA 1669
File number: NSD 1376 of 2021
Judgment of: YATES, BEACH AND MARKOVIC JJ
Date of judgment: 16 February 2023
Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY — appeal against making of a pooling order under s 579E(1) of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – whether primary judge erred in finding that s 579E(1)(b)(iv) applies – where primary judge satisfied that alleged chose in action was “particular property” capable of being “used” for the purposes of s 579E(1)(b)(iv) – where alleged chose in action was a joint right to sue held by second and third respondents to the appeal – where joint right came into existence after second and third respondents sold a business allegedly carried on jointly by them – where primary judge found a connection between alleged chose in action and a future undertaking carried on jointly by second and third respondents – whether time should be extended to permit the respondents to rely on a notice of contention to support the judgment below – appeal allowed
Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 43

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 439C, 553, 553D, 579, 579E, 601AD, 601AE, 601AH

Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) regs 5.6.47, 5.6.48, 5.6.49, 5.6.50, 5.6.54, 5.6.63, sch 2

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 36.24

Cases cited:

5G Developments Pty Ltd (in liq) v Massie [2021] FCA 791

Brodyn Pty Ltd v Dasein Constructions Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 1230

Capocchiano v Young [2013] NSWSC 879

Donoghue v Russells (A Firm) [2021] FCA 798

Ex parte Leung (1986) 9 FCR 518

Johnston v McGrath [2005] NSWSC 1183; 195 FLR 101

Morgan v Sydney Allen Manufacturing Pty Limited (In Liquidation) [2021] FCA 1669

Promoseven Pty Ltd v Markey, in the matter of Bluechip Development Corporation (Cairns) Pty Ltd (in liq) (recs and mgrs apptd) [2013] FCA 1281

Re Australian Hotel Acquisition (in liq) [2011] NSWSC 1374

Re Galaxy Media Pty Ltd(recs and mgrs apptd) (in liq) [2001] NSWSC 917; 167 FLR 149

Re Lombe [2011] NSWSC 1536; 87 ACSR 84

Re Mendonca; Ex parte Commissioner of Taxation (1969) 15 FLR 256

Re St Gregory’s Armenian School Inc [2015] NSWSC 1465; 109 ACSR 27

Re Vassis; Ex parte Leung (1986) 9 FCR 518

Re Watch Works Australia Pty Ltd (in liq); Ex parte Frances [2020] WASC 6

Sands Contracting Pty Ltd v Cant [2021] FCA 638

Selim v McGrath [2003] NSWSC 927; 177 FLR 85

Sons of Gwalia Ltd (admin apptd) v Margaretic [2005] FCA 1305; 55 ACSR 365

Tanning Research Laboratories Inc v O’Brien [1990] HCA 8; 169 CLR 332

Theophile v Solicitor-General [1950] AC 186

Westpac Banking Corp v Totterdell (1998) 20 WAR 150; 29 ACSR 448

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 252
Date of hearing: 20 May 2022
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McMillan Investment Holdings Pty Ltd v Morgan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCAFC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McMillan Investment Holdings Pty Ltd appeals against the orders of Yates J that Sydney Allen Printers Pty Ltd and Sydney Allen Manufacturing Pty Ltd be a pooled group. The respondents defend the orders and seek an extension of time to rely on a proposed notice of contention. McMillan Investment Holdings Pty Ltd opposes the extension of time. The appeal concerns the making of a pooling order under s 579E(1)(b)(iv) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). McMillan Investment Holdings Pty Ltd contends that the primary judge erred in finding that s 579E(1)(b)(iv) was satisfied in relation to Sydney Allen Printers Pty Ltd and Sydney Allen Manufacturing Pty Ltd. The primary judge was satisfied that a joint right to sue held by Sydney Allen Printers Pty Ltd and Sydney Allen Manufacturing Pty Ltd was a "particular property" capable of being "used" for the purposes of s 579E(1)(b)(iv). The primary judge also found a connection between the alleged chose in action and a future undertaking carried on jointly by Sydney Allen Printers Pty Ltd and Sydney Allen Manufacturing Pty Ltd. The appeal court found that the primary judge was correct in his approach to s 579E(1)(b)(iv) and in his findings. The appeal was allowed and the orders made by the primary judge were set aside. The respondents’ application to extend time to file a notice of contention was refused. The respondents were ordered to pay McMillan Investment Holdings Pty Ltd’s costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The respondents’ application to extend time within which to file their proposed notice of contention be refused.

3. Orders 3, 4 and 5 made on 2 December 2021 in the proceeding below be set aside.

4. The respondents pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.

5. In the absence of the parties reaching agreement as to the costs of the proceeding below:

(a) the appellant file and serve written submission on the question of those costs (limited to 3 pages) within 7 days of the making of this order;

(b) the respondents file and serve written submissions in answer (limited to 3 pages) within a further 7 days;

(c) the appellant file and serve any written submissions in reply (limited to 2 pages) within a further 7 days; and

(d) the question of costs of the proceeding below be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondents in this appeal defend the making of the pooling order under s 579E(1)(b)(iv). They also seek to support the pooling order on the basis of s 579E(1)(b)(ii). To this end, they seek an order extending the time in which to file a notice of contention advancing subpara (ii) as an additional basis on which the pooling order can be made. An extension of time is required because, pursuant to r 36.24 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the notice of contention should have been filed within 21 days after the notice of appeal was served. The notice of appeal was served on 31 December 2021. The notice of contention should have been filed by 4 February 2022. MIH opposes time being extended.BACKGROUND The following facts are based substantially on the primary judge’s findings. Prior to 2013, SAP and SAM operated a colour printing business from rented premises in Rydalmere. In about late 2013, the business relocated to Condell Park. At the time of the move, about 80 staff were employed by SAP in the business. SAM owned, or had rights over, expensive and substantial printing presses. It had also provided security over certain of its assets. The security included security for credit facilities which certain suppliers of materials (necessary for the printing work to be done) had provided. The business operated on the basis that, while SAM owned the equipment used in the business, SAP did all the printing work. To this end, SAP ordered supplies for the business using the credit facilities that SAM had created. SAP also paid the suppliers. The internal accounts between SAP and SAM included entries under which, notionally, SAP paid the creditors on behalf of SAM. As the primary judge explained it, SAM did not receive any, or any sufficient, remuneration or return from SAP for providing the machinery and credit facilities which enabled SAP to conduct the business. On the other hand, the two companies’ accounting records showed that, as at 7 April 2016, SAM owed SAP over $1 million. In about May 2014, MIH became involved in the provision of finance to, or in having some form of financial relations with, the companies. Mr Morgan alleges that MIH and its principals, Robert McMillan and his daughter Julie-Anne McMillan, became involved in the management of SAP and SAM. Indeed, Mr Morgan alleges that Mr McMillan and Ms McMillan became shadow directors of SAP and SAM. On 27 March 2015, MIH, SAP, and SAM entered into a finance facility (the MIH facility) under which SAP and SAM were described as “the borrower”. Clause 3.6 of the MIH facility was to the effect that SAP and SAM were jointly liable for all amounts due in respect of the “secured money”, representing the “principal money” and all interest accrued on the principal money but which has not been added to it. On 7 April 2016, Mr Morgan and Geoffrey Davis were appointed as joint and several administrators of SAP. On the same day, they were also appointed as joint and several liquidators of SAM.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I agree with what Yates J has written on this topic and would refuse the extension of time sought.Conclusion In summary, I would allow the appeal and agree in the orders proposed by Yates J. On 2 December 2021 orders were made pursuant to s 601AH of the of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for the reinstatement of the third respondent, Sydney Allen Manufacturing Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) (SAM), the appointment of the first respondent, John Maxwell Morgan, as SAM’s liquidator and pursuant to s 579E(1) of the Corporations Act that the second respondent, Sydney Allen Printers Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) (SAP) and SAM be a pooled group: see Morgan v Sydney Allen Manufacturing Pty Limited (In Liquidation) [2021] FCA 1669 (referred to as Reasons). The appellant, McMillan Investment Holdings Pty Ltd, appeals from those orders. In particular it contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the statutory precondition in s 579E(1)(b)(iv) of the Corporations Act was satisfied in relation to SAP and SAM so as to enliven the Court’s jurisdiction to proceed to consider whether to make the order that SAP and SAM be a pooled group. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) is named as the fourth respondent. It did not participate in the appeal. As a preliminary matter, I note that by its notice of appeal McMillan seeks to have all of the orders made on 2 December 2021 set aside. That is so because, at least at the time the notice of appeal was filed, it understood that the reason for making the order reinstating SAM was the pooling order. That is, if no pooling order was to be made then the reinstatement of SAM served no purpose. However, by the time of the hearing of the appeal that position had seemingly changed in that SAP and SAM had commenced the proceeding contemplated by Mr Morgan at the time of the hearing before the primary judge and described at [179] below. Thus, in the event that McMillan is successful in setting aside the order made by the primary judge pursuant to s 579E(1) of the Corporations Act, it does not follow that the balance of the orders, going to the reinstatement of SAM, ought to be set aside. They are not the subject of any ground of appeal and there is utility in them remaining on foot. Mr Morgan, SAM and SAP (collectively respondents) have filed and served a notice of contention on which they seek leave to rely. They contend that the primary judge refrained from finding whether SAM and SAP were jointly liable to McMillan for one or more debts or claims and that his Honour should have found that they were so jointly liable. McMillan opposes the grant of leave and, if leave is granted, the relief sought in the notice of contention. BACKGROUND The following facts are, for the most part, taken from the Reasons. SAP and SAM operated a colour printing business, initially from premises in Rydalmere and, from about late 2013, from premises in Condell Park. From at least the time that SAP and SAM moved the printing business to Condell Park: (1)the business had about 80 staff, all of whom were employees of SAP;(2)SAM owned, or had rights over, printing presses manufactured by, among others, Heidelberg Graphic Equipment Limited; and (3)SAM had provided security over certain of its assets to Heidelberg and other suppliers of material, namely BJ Ball Pty Limited and KW Doggett & Co Pty Ltd. Those companies subsequently entered into a form of merger and became Ball & Doggett Pty Ltd.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 2 December 2021 orders were made pursuant to s 601AH of the of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for the reinstatement of the third respondent, Sydney Allen Manufacturing Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) (SAM), the appointment of the first respondent, John Maxwell Morgan, as SAM’s liquidator and pursuant to s 579E(1) of the Corporations Act that the second respondent, Sydney Allen Printers Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) (SAP) and SAM be a pooled group: see Morgan v Sydney Allen Manufacturing Pty Limited (In Liquidation) [2021] FCA 1669 (referred to as Reasons). The appellant, McMillan Investment Holdings Pty Ltd, appeals from those orders. In particular it contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the statutory precondition in s 579E(1)(b)(iv) of the Corporations Act was satisfied in relation to SAP and SAM so as to enliven the Court’s jurisdiction to proceed to consider whether to make the order that SAP and SAM be a pooled group. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) is named as the fourth respondent. It did not participate in the appeal. As a preliminary matter, I note that by its notice of appeal McMillan seeks to have all of the orders made on 2 December 2021 set aside. That is so because, at least at the time the notice of appeal was filed, it understood that the reason for making the order reinstating SAM was the pooling order. That is, if no pooling order was to be made then the reinstatement of SAM served no purpose. However, by the time of the hearing of the appeal that position had seemingly changed in that SAP and SAM had commenced the proceeding contemplated by Mr Morgan at the time of the hearing before the primary judge and described at [179] below. Thus, in the event that McMillan is successful in setting aside the order made by the primary judge pursuant to s 579E(1) of the Corporations Act, it does not follow that the balance of the orders, going to the reinstatement of SAM, ought to be set aside. They are not the subject of any ground of appeal and there is utility in them remaining on foot. Mr Morgan, SAM and SAP (collectively respondents) have filed and served a notice of contention on which they seek leave to rely. They contend that the primary judge refrained from finding whether SAM and SAP were jointly liable to McMillan for one or more debts or claims and that his Honour should have found that they were so jointly liable. McMillan opposes the grant of leave and, if leave is granted, the relief sought in the notice of contention. BACKGROUND The following facts are, for the most part, taken from the Reasons. SAP and SAM operated a colour printing business, initially from premises in Rydalmere and, from about late 2013, from premises in Condell Park. From at least the time that SAP and SAM moved the printing business to Condell Park: (1)the business had about 80 staff, all of whom were employees of SAP;(2)SAM owned, or had rights over, printing presses manufactured by, among others, Heidelberg Graphic Equipment Limited; and (3)SAM had provided security over certain of its assets to Heidelberg and other suppliers of material, namely BJ Ball Pty Limited and KW Doggett & Co Pty Ltd. Those companies subsequently entered into a form of merger and became Ball & Doggett Pty Ltd.