McKenzie and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

McKenzie and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation) [2016] AATA 271 (29 April 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2014/6723

Re

Aleisha McKenzie

APPLICANT

And

K & S Freighters Pty Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall

Date 29 April 2016
Place Perth

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and, in substitution therefor, decides that the Respondent is liable to pay compensation to the Applicant in accordance with Section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (“SRC Act”) in respect of a stress related injury sustained on the 12 August 2014.

The matter is remitted to the Respondent for assessment of the amount payable to the Applicant on the basis of this decision.

Pursuant to section 67(8) of the SRC Act, the Tribunal orders that the costs of these proceedings incurred by the Applicant be paid by the Respondent in accordance with section 6.9 of the Tribunal’s Guide to the Workers’ Compensation Jurisdiction.

...............[sgd]............................................

Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – Applicant severely injured her colleague while driving a forklift at work – Applicant suffered stress related injury as a result of injury – whether Applicant denied compensation because her conduct resulted from her own serious and wilful misconduct pursuant to section 14(3) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – Applicant found not to have engaged in serious and wilful misconduct – Applicant entitled to compensation for her injury - decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – sections 6(3) and 14(3)

Workplace Health and Safety Act 2011 (Cth)

CASES

Frederick Charles Adams and Australian Postal Corporation [1993] AATA 355

Karim v Poche Engineering Services Pty Ltd [2013] NSWWCCPD 24

Kemp and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd [2011] AATA 312

Re Roberston and CSR Shipping [2001] AATA 325

Sawle v Macadamia Processing Co Pty Ltd [1999] NSWCC 26

Geoffrey William Vines v Australian Securities and Investment Commission [2007] NSWCA 126

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall

FACTS

  1. The Applicant in these proceedings, Ms Aleisha McKenzie, aged 35, was employed by the Respondent, K&S Freighters Pty Ltd (“K&S Freighters”), between 2006 and 2014.  Ms McKenzie is currently unemployed and receives Centrelink benefits. 

  2. On 12 August 2014, Ms McKenzie was involved in an accident at work while she was driving a forklift on K&S Freighters’ premises in Kewdale, Western Australia.  It is not disputed that Ms McKenzie hit a colleague, Mark Warren, while driving the forklift and that Mr Warren suffered a serious leg fracture.

  3. As outlined by Ms McKenzie’s representative before this Tribunal in a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 1 February 2013, Ms McKenzie claims she left the premises about an hour after the accident as she was “shaken and upset”.

  4. On 13 August 2014, Ms McKenzie saw Dr Jeff Veling. On 19 August 2014, Ms McKenzie was seen by Dr Simon O’Connell. On 20 August 2014, Ms McKenzie was seen by Dr Rachel Harris. 

  5. Ms McKenzie…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McKenzie and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 271
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision to refuse compensation to Aleisha McKenzie, the applicant, who suffered a stress-related injury following a workplace accident. The applicant was driving a forklift at K&S Freighters when she collided with a colleague, Mark Warren, who walked into her path. The applicant immediately administered first aid and called for an ambulance. Subsequently, the applicant experienced significant stress and was booked off work, lodging a compensation claim for a psychological injury. Her employer subsequently dismissed her for gross misconduct, which she contested.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant's conduct in driving the forklift constituted "serious and wilful misconduct" under section 14(3) of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (SRC Act), thereby disentitling her to compensation. This required the Tribunal to determine if the applicant had failed to follow safe forklift driving procedures, driven with an obstructed view, or refused a drug test, and if any such actions amounted to serious and wilful misconduct.

The Tribunal found that the applicant was entitled to compensation. It reasoned that while the applicant's view was restricted by the pallets on the forklift, she was still able to see ahead and to the side. Furthermore, the colleague who was injured had walked into a designated exclusion zone and had seen the forklift and heard its horn. The Tribunal also noted the lack of a spotter and the applicant's location within the warehouse. Crucially, the Tribunal found no evidence that the applicant had intentionally accepted a risk or engaged in wilful misconduct. The allegations regarding the drug test were also unsubstantiated, with no record of a properly scheduled or offered test.

Accordingly, the Tribunal set aside the decision under review and substituted a decision that K&S Freighters was liable to pay compensation to Ms McKenzie under section 14 of the SRC Act for a stress-related injury sustained on 12 August 2014. The matter was remitted to K&S Freighters for assessment of the amount payable.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This report reads as follows:…BackgroundAccording to Aleisha, on the 12th August 2014, she was driving a forklift at her workplace, K&S Freighters, when a co-worker, Mark Warren, walked into her path. Aleisha did not see him as her vision was restricted by the pallets on the forklift. She was also not expecting to have to look out for pedestrians as there was supposed to be an exclusion zone around her. The forklift struck Mark and he was physically injured in the accident. Aleisha immediately jumped off the forklift, called for help and then administered First Aid as best she could. She also called an ambulance and once it came she smoked a cigarette in the rest area to try to calm herself, while talking to some of the staff. After giving a statement she went home as she was not feeling well. She drove herself home, very slowly as she was in a state of shock and nobody offered to take her. She received no calls from work to find out if she had arrived home safely. The following day, she was booked off work by her doctor for a week and she sent a text to inform the office of this. In a series of missed communications, Aleisha was not aware that the drug test that she had agreed to take on the day of the accident was scheduled for that day. Once she was aware of it, despite requesting that it be rescheduled, she was accused of refusing to take it. Aleisha became extremely stressed dealing with all of this and was booked off work for another week and she lodged a compensation claim for workers' stress, whereafter she returned to work under a rehabilitation progamme. Aleisha was dismissed from work on the 16th of September. The reason given was Gross Misconduct. Aleisha contested this and legal proceedings ensued.…Symptoms Experienced…Aleisha says she is having a lot of difficulty sleeping and is constantly tired. She feels depressed and sad and has no desire to get out of bed. She says she is hypervigilant, anxious, intolerant, has poor concentration and feels unbalanced. She said she still has flashbacks to the accident, nightmares and dreams about death. She has sickening feelings of guilt about the accident, even though Mark Warren, the man who was struck by the forklift she was driving had told her it was not her fault and that he should not have walked out in front of her. She has withdrawn and isolated herself, tending to stay at home far too much. The only times she gets out is to take her dog for a walk, to visit her mother and to attend appointments.…CausationAleisha said that before the accident at work on 12th August 2014, she used to have a positive, can-do attitude but is now suffering from all the symptoms mentioned above. Apart from experiencing symptoms of Post Traumatic Stress related to the accident itself, she feels that she has been treated very badly by her employers, who, in her opinion, failed in their duty of care to her. Immediately after the accident, nobody came to her assistance. She organised all the first aid to Mark, as best she could and once he had been tended to she was left feeling shocked, emotional and fragile. Nobody inquired about how she was feeling, she was not offered a lift home and nobody tried to contact her to find out how she was or if she had got home safely. She believes that her employers, namely Kaye Evans from HR and Trevor Phyllis, the Union recruiter, blame her entirely for the accident, despite there being clear indications that K&S Freighters failed to enforce the Health and Safety Procedures they should have, as evidenced by the Safety Alert prepared by Ken McCullum, which resulted in an immediate improvement notice by Comcare. Her immediate boss, Ed Hartman, is supportive of her, however he was not there at the time and so does not seem to have any influence on her case. She also feels that she had been bullied and harassed from the start because she has never been interested in becoming part of the TWU.….Report of Dr Gemma Edwards-Smith, Consultant Psychiatrist, dated 9 October 2015

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Prior to the hearing both parties submitted a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions. Written closing submissions were received on 15 March 2016 from Ms McKenzie, through Mr Mullaly. Written submissions were then received on 22 March 2016 from K & S Freighters, through Mr Wallace. Finally, written submissions in reply were received from Ms McKenzie, through Mr Mullaly, on 29 March 2016. NON-MEDICAL EVIDENCE Ms McKenzie’s Application for Review of Decision, dated 29 December 2014 (T2 at 4) In her Application for Review of Decision, Ms McKenzie states that she applied to the AAT because:The applicant suffered an injury at work on or about the 12th August 2014.The injury suffered was a psychological injury due to stress.The applicant has incurred medical expenses and lost time from work and continues to be unfit for work.The employer has refused compensation and following an internal review made on the 31st October 2014 continues to refuse compensation.The applicant seeks a review of the decision to refuse compensation as she considers that the employer has incorrectly applied the law to the circumstances of her injury.Statement of Ms McKenzie dated 12 August 2014 (T7 at 19) Ms McKenzie made a written statement shortly after the workplace accident involving the forklift occurred. This statement reads as follows:Before the actual incident I was unloading a 20' container under the awning to put stock in to the warehouse. Whilst I was doing this I noticed my driver (Tony) had entered the yard to collect the next order to deliver. Then I proceeded inside with stock from container with the idea of grabbing the next 2 pallets for Tony's truck after he parked in front of the awning, I have then gone and grabbed the pallets and began to proceed back out of the warehouse, sounding my horn as required, Tony has parked and I headed towards his truck to put the pallets on. Then I hit something and a couple of seconds later I saw that I had hit someone and saw Mark lying on the ground in pain. I immediately reversed the forklift backwards and got straight off to see how Mark was. Mark has said get help and I immediately ran to the office to grab someone. I yelled someone help no one came to aid immediately so then I ran to the lunch room and got Joshua Copley and he ran over with me to assist immediately, everyone began to follow suit after that. After establishing that Mark was responding accordingly I decided to dial 000 and arranged to get an ambulance out straight away. After that I checked with Mark if he needed anything & how his pain was. 15 minutes later ambulance still hadn't arrived so I called 000 again to find out their whereabouts and had to wait until they arrived, approx 45 minutes after incident Ambulance arrived and attended to Mark and took him to hospital.Approximate time of incident 13:40 pmMy forklift tyres were approx 15cm off the ground. I had 2 pallets on at the time weighing 2.4tonne total.I was travelling at a slow speed.Mark was walking at the time towards his truck which was beside the container that I was unloading. He had left the lunchroom and was walking diagonally towards his cabin.The direction I was heading towards Tony's truck put him out of my line of sight. [sic]Letter from K & S Freighters to Ms McKenzie dated 13 August 2014 (T9 at 24)

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the circumstances, the Tribunal finds that Ms McKenzie is entitled to compensation as per section 14 of the SRC Act for a stress related injury that occurred on 12 August 2014 when the forklift she was driving hit her colleague, Mark Warren. DECISION For the reasons outlined above, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and, in substitution therefor, decides that K&S Freighters is liable to pay compensation to Ms McKenzie in accordance with Section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 in respect of a stress related injury sustained on the 12 August 2014. The matter is remitted to K&S Freighters for assessment of the amount payable to the Ms McKenzie on the basis of this decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This request, prepared for Ms McKenzie by Workclaims Australia, reads as follows:We are the Industrial Agents representing Aleisha McKenzie (the worker)). We attach a copy of her written authority.She has instructed us to send you a request for re-consideration in writing including the reasons for the request.In reference to paragraph 9 of the terms of the Determination, a Statement of Reasons and a Notice of Rights, we respond to the claims as follows:•“That you failed to follow safe forklift driving procedures – driving forward with two pallets on the forklift obstructing your view.”The worker was not a regular forklift operator although she had her forklift license her everyday role was that of a HR truck driver. The stacking of two pallets on the forklift may be less than ideal but no evidence has been produced to prove that the worker was able to reverse the forklift as she did not have a spotter. Also she was in the warehouse area and not in the yard. There was no requirement in the circumstances where she did have forward vision (albeit restricted), was working in the warehouse and there was no staff member to spot for her.•“In driving with an obstructed view you failed to see the worker until you had collided with him, causing him injury.”Although the worker had a less than ideal view the co-worker was negligent in failing to keep a safe look out as he walked in front of the worker and was in a no go zone. The worker could clearly see a person over the 2 pallets but she was focussed on her own driver who was not directly to the front but to the side. The injury was a result of both parties not one.•“Immediately after the incident you were requested to attend a drug test - to which you initially agreed but then refused and made comment that you wouldn’t as you considered you may fail it due to taking substance on Saturday.”The worker denies stating she took any substances the Saturday before the drug test. There is no record of the drug test being booked in or scheduled at a clinic and therefore no real offer, acceptance or decline to take the proposed drug test. For this to have any relevance to the workers compensation claim, the employer would need to prove that the accident occurred because of the worker's use of prohibited drugs. No such evidence exists.•“You failed to attend and/or respond to a message from the Company related to a further request to attend a drug test on Wednesday.”The worker was sent a message in the form of a letter to her old postal address where she used to live at home. Given the nature of the message and urgency to respond the HR department should have called or ensured that she received the letter by hand. There was CCTV footage at the old address where the letter was delivered, and this shows the person coming and going and making no attempt to knock on the door.•“The company has considered your responses to the above issues and have determined that your actions as unacceptable workplace behaviour as unsafe forklift driving and failure to take a drug test when requested following a serious incident.”This is a workplace accident which resulted in injury from the negligence of both parties, it was not malicious or intent of injury towards the fellow worker. It should be deemed as a workplace accident with a formal warning and OHS training to rectify it. There is a clearly lack of safety training provided and enforced by the manager of this workplace, otherwise this incident would not have occurred. The employer has a duty of care to provide a safe system of work, correct protective clothing and competent employees. The alleged drug test is hearsay and there is no evidence of an offer, acceptance or decline of this drug test on record at a clinic or at work. The letter setting the test for 1.20pm on the 13th August 20l4 was not received by the worker in time to attend. The worker notified the office of this and asked for or another appointment but nothing more was heard from the employer.In reference to paragraph 13 of the terms of the Determination, a Statement of Reasons and a Notice of Rights, we respond to the claims as follows:II.“That Ms McKenzie appreciated the risk which was being undertaken by driving her forklift forward with a load that obstructed her view.”The worker's view was not obstructed as she was still able to see ahead and to the side. III.“Ms McKenzie unreasonably and voluntarily decided to drive the forklift forward while loaded that obscured her view.”The worker did not voluntarily or unreasonably decide to drive the forklift while her view was obscured. She was able to see well over the pallets. She was on a high seat and she is tall enough to have a good view. The lack of staff to spot for her in a reverse situation and her location in the warehouse made it safe to proceed as she did.IV.l am satisfied driving a forklift forward while loaded and obscuring her view presented an abnormal risk.In the circumstances of this yard it was not an abnormal risk. The gentleman who was knocked down was not allowed to be in that area. He conceded that he saw the forklift and heard its horn. The risk was not higher than normal. It may appear to be abnormal because of what happened but the test is before the worker drives the forklift. At that time the risk was not more than normal.In reference to paragraph 14 of the terms of the Determination, a Statement of Reasons and a Notice of Rights, we respond to the claim as follows:II. Ms McKenzie was aware that driving her forklift forward with a load that obstructed her view was directly against the “K and S guidelines for Forklift Operations” Where it states under 3.5 – Safe Driving Practices- Never proceed forward with a load obstructing your vision – proceed slowly in reverse”There was no requirement in the circumstances where she did have forward vision (albeit restricted), was working in the warehouse and there was no staff member to spot for her.III. In doing so, Ms McKenzie accepted a risk of injury and intentionally adopted a practice that could lead to an accident involving a known risk of injury.There is no evidence that the worker intentionally accepted the risk or intentionally adopted a practice which could lead to a known risk of injury. The driving was safe, she could clearly see over the top of the pallets and to the side so there was no known risk of injury.IV. Misconduct is serious if it significantly increases the likelihood of injury.The worker's driving did not increase the likelihood of injury. She could see where she was going. Her attention was focused on her own driver with whom she had to make eye contact. The injured worker was in a no-go zone.V. Ms McKenzie’s deliberate actions of driving her forklift forward with a load that obscured her view significantly increased the likelihood of injury.The worker’s driving did not increase the likelihood of injury. She could see where she was going. Her attention was focused on her own driver with whom she had to make eye contact. The injured worker was is a no-go zone.VI. Injury was caused by serious and wilful misconduct of Ms McKenzie.There is no logical connection between the conduct involved and a finding of serious and wilful misconduct as being the cause of the accident. There is simply no evidence to establish misconduct and certainly no evidence to establish any wilful act. The use of the term wilfulness in the section requires some deliberate conscious act on the part of the worker. If she had continued to drive forward if someone had called out to her to stop and she heard that call but proceeded anyway that would be wilful. The employer's investigation failed to establish any element of intent or wilfulness.There is absolutely no evidence to support the case officer’s finding that:1. The worker was guilty of serious and unlawful misconduct: s14(3)2.The worker voluntarily unreasonably submitted to an abnormal risk of injury: s6(3)Accordingly we seek a re-consideration of the decision and a finding that the worker is entitled to workers compensation.Statement of Reasons of K & S Freighters dated 31 October 2014 (T23 at 74) – the “Reconsideration Decision”