JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: MCKELVIE -v- SAVE THE CHILDREN IMPACT FUND LIMITED [2024] WASC 75
CORAM: WHITBY J
HEARD: 19 MARCH 2024
DELIVERED : 19 MARCH 2024
FILE NO/S: CIV 1756 of 2023
BETWEEN: VERNA LYNETTE MCKELVIE
Plaintiff
AND
SAVE THE CHILDREN IMPACT FUND LIMITED
Defendant
Catchwords:
Wills - Proper construction of handwritten will - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Administration Act 1903 (WA)
Wills Act 1970 (WA)
Result:
Proper construction of will gifts entire estate to the plaintiff
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Plaintiff | : | B W Ashdown |
| Defendant | : | No appearance |
Solicitors:
| Plaintiff | : | Mayberry Hammond & Co |
| Defendant | : | No appearance |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Mustard v Oikonomov (Unreported, WASC, Library No 980468, 19 August 1998)
Sidle v Queensland Trustees Ltd [1915] HCA 48
Stephen Bradley Lauder as executor of the will of Elaine Kathleen Rankin v Lauder [2018] WASC 91
WHITBY J:
(This judgment was delivered extemporaneously on 19 March 2024 and has been edited from the transcript).
Introduction
Malcolm George Roberts (the deceased) died on 17 May 2022.
The deceased made a handwritten will on 3 September 2021 (the Will). The deceased named Verna Lynette McKelvie, the plaintiff, as the sole executor of his Will.
Probate of the Will was granted to the plaintiff on 17 April 2023.
The dispositive clause of the Will states:
I Give Devise and Bequeath all my real estate and personal property - including, all goods chatels (sic), motor vehicles, all my jewelry (sic) including all monies in any financial institution bank or where-ever
Provided Verna Lynette McKevie (sic) survies (sic) me by more than 30 (thirty days)
And if not then I give the residue of my real estate and personal estate to:
1.Starlight Foundation as the Executor to divide it amongst four equal charities: After paying all expenses (residual)
1.Make a Wish Foundation
2.Starlight Foundation
3.Save the Children Fund
4.Leukemia Foundation
The plaintiff, as executor of the deceased's estate, seeks an order pursuant to s 45 of the Administration Act 1903 (WA) (Administration Act) that the opening dispositive clause of the Will beginning with the words 'I Give Devise and Bequeath' be construed as a gift of all the deceased's property to the plaintiff.
The plaintiff relies upon her affidavits sworn on 14 July 2023 and 11 March 2024 in support of her application (First McKelvie Affidavit and Second McKelvie Affidavit respectively).
For the reasons that follow, I am satisfied that, pursuant to s 45 of the Administration Act, the dispositive clause of the Will beginning with the words 'I Give Devise and Bequeath' should be construed as a gift of all the deceased's estate to the plaintiff.
Position of the residual beneficiaries
The plaintiff provided the Starlight Children's Foundation, Make A Wish Foundation, Save The Children Fund, Leukaemia Foundation and the State Solicitor's Office a…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read McKelvie v Save the Children Impact Fund Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] WASC 75
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues included whether the language in the will was ambiguous enough to warrant the use of extrinsic evidence and whether such evidence could clarify the testator's intentions. The court had to consider the principle of construing a will to give effect to the testator's expressed intentions, as well as the limitations on the use of extrinsic evidence as outlined in Section 28A of the Wills Act. Additionally, the court examined the power to rectify a will under Section 50(1) of the Wills Act and whether this power was available if the will did not carry out the testator's intentions.
The court held that the language in the will was ambiguous and allowed extrinsic evidence to clarify the testator's intentions. The court found that the evidence presented was relevant to understanding the testator's property, family, and acquaintances, which aided in interpreting the will as the testator would have read it. The court concluded that the will did not carry out the testator's intentions and exercised its power to rectify the will. The court determined that the will should be rectified to reflect the testator's true intentions, as evidenced by the extrinsic evidence.
The final order of the court was to rectify the will to give effect to the testator's true intentions as evidenced by the extrinsic evidence presented. The court made an order that the will be amended to reflect the testator's intentions, ensuring that the estate was distributed according to the testator's wishes as clarified by the admissible evidence.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Section 45(1) of the Administration Act provides:45 Court may settle all questions arising in administration(1)The Court may make such order with reference to any question arising in respect of any will or administration, or with reference to the distribution or application of any real and personal estate with an executor or administrator or Public Trustee may have in hand, or as to the residue of the estate, as the circumstances of the case may require. In construing a will, the object is to ascertain the intention of the testator as expressed in the will itself. In an oft-cited passage, Lord Simon LC said in Perrin v Morgan:[8][T]he fundamental rule in construing the language of a will is to put on the words used the meaning which, having regard to the terms of the will, the testator intended. The question is not, of course, what the testator meant to do when he made his will, but what the written words he uses mean in the particular case - what are the 'expressed intentions' of the testator.[8] Perrin v Morgan [1943] AC 399, 406, cited with approval in Walsh v Sloan [2019] WASCA 107 [24] (Walsh). The Wills Act 1970 (WA) (Wills Act) contains various provisions which set govern construction of a will. Section 26(1) of the Wills Act provides:26. General rules of construction(1)Unless the contrary intention appears by the will -(a)the will is to be construed, with reference to the property comprised in it, to speak and take effect as if it has been executed immediately before the death of the testator;(b)property that is the subject of a disposition, other than the exercise of a power of appointment, that is void or fails to take effect is to be included in any residuary disposition contained in the will;(c)a general disposition of land or of the land in a particular area includes leasehold land whether or not the testator owns freehold land;(d)a general disposition of all the testator's property or of all the testator's property of a particular kind includes property over which the testator had a general power of appointment exercisable by will and operates as an execution of the power;(e)a disposition of property without words of limitation whether to a person beneficially or as executor or trustee is to be construed as passing the whole estate or interest of the testator therein;(f)a disposition of the residue of the estate of a testator, or of the whole of the estate of a testator, that refers only to -(i)the real estate of the testator; or(ii)the personal estate of the testator, is to be construed to include both the real and personal estate of the testator;(g)if any part of a disposition in fractional parts of the whole or of the residue of the estate of a testator fails, the part that fails accrues to the part that does not fail, and, if there is more than one part that does not fail, to all those parts proportionately. Section 28A of the Wills Act provides:28A. Use of extrinsic evidence to clarify will(1)In proceedings to construe a will, evidence, including evidence of the testator's intention, is admissible to the extent that the language used in, or other content of, the will renders the will or any part of the will –(a)meaningless; or(b)ambiguous on the face of the will; or(c)ambiguous in the light of the surrounding circumstances.(2)Evidence of a testator's intention is not admissible to establish any of the circumstances referred to in subsection (1)(c).(3) Nothing in this section prevents evidence that is otherwise admissible at law from being admissible in proceedings to construe a will.(4)This section applies to the will of any person dying on or after the day on which section 22 of the Wills Amendment Act 2007 comes into operation, whether the will was made or executed before, on or after that day, but does not apply to the will of a person who died before that day.