McKay v Commissioner of Main Roads [No 7]

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read
JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CIVIL
CITATION : McKAY -v- COMMISSIONER OF MAIN ROADS
[No 7] [2011] WASC 223 (S)
CORAM : BEECH J
HEARD
:  19 OCTOBER - 20 NOVEMBER 2009,
19 JULY - 16 SEPTEMBER 2010, 15 OCTOBER,
25 OCTOBER - 5 NOVEMBER 2010,
29 NOVEMBER - 2 DECEMBER 2010;
24 NOVEMBER 2011
DELIVERED 
:  1 SEPTEMBER 2011
SUPPLEMENTARY 
DECISION 
:  2 DECEMBER 2011
FILE NO/S 
:  CIV 1558 of 2007
BETWEEN  : RODERICK DOUGLAS McKAY

KATHLEEN GLENYS McKAY

Plaintiffs

AND

COMMISSIONER OF MAIN ROADS

First Defendant

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING
COMMISSION

Second Defendant

Catchwords:

Costs - Compensation for land taken for a public work - Whether ordinary costs rules apply - Whether O 66 r 1(1)(a) applies - Whether appropriate to identify the party who was 'successful' - Approach to be taken to costs discretion in valuation cases - Relevance of Calderbank offer - Whether Calderbank offer can lead to party-party costs only if the rejection of the offer was unreasonable - Appropriate costs orders

[2011] WASC 223 (S)

Legislation: 

Land Administration Act 1997 (WA), s 223(3), s 223(9)

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 66 r 1

Result:

Defendants pay plaintiffs' costs to 16 October 2009

Plaintiffs pay defendants' costs after 16 October 2009

Category: A

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiffs : Mr P M McGowan & Mr C J Graham
First Defendant : Mr K M Pettit SC & Ms F B Seaward
Second Defendant : Mr K M Pettit SC & Ms F B Seaward

Solicitors:

Plaintiffs : Cornerstone Legal
First Defendant : State Solicitor for Western Australia
Second Defendant : State Solicitor for Western Australia

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Amaca Pty Ltd (formerly James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd) v Patricia Margaret Hannell as Executor of the Estate of David Richard Hannell (Dec) [2007] WASCA 158 (S)

AMP Capital Investors Ltd v Transport Infrastructure Development Corporation

(No 3) [2007] NSWLEC 724

AMP Capital Investors Ltd v Transport Infrastructure Development Corporation

[2008] NSWCA 325; (2008) 163 LGERA 245

[2011] WASC 223 (S)

Banno v Commonwealth of Australia (1993) 45 FCR 32
Bowen v Alsanto Nominees Pty Ltd [2011] WASCA 39 (S)
Calderbank v Calderbank [1976] Fam 93
Cerini v The Minister for Transport [2001] WASC 309 (S)
Clifford and Shire of Busselton [2007] WASAT 89 (S)
Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225

Constantino v Roads and Traffic Authority (NSW) (No 2) [2005] NSWLEC

209; (2005) 144 LGERA 224

County Securities Pty Ltd v Challenger Group Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2008]

NSWCA 273

Den Hoedt & Anor v Barwick [2006] WASCA 196
Dobb v Hacket (1993) 10 WAR 532
Duvall v Godfrey Virtue & Co (a firm) [2001] WASCA 163
Elite Protective Personnel Pty Ltd & Anor v Salmon [2007] NSWCA 322

Filip Yakas v Roads and Traffic Authority of New South Wales (No 2) [2004]

NSWLEC 589; [2004] 139 LGERA 116

Flotilla Nominees Pty Ltd v Western Australian Land Authority [2003] WASC

122 (S); (2003)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McKay v Commissioner of Main Roads [No 7] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] WASC 223 (S)
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of McKay v Commissioner of Main Roads [No 7] involves a dispute regarding the compensation for land taken for a public work. The plaintiffs, McKay, claimed that the costs awarded to them were inadequate, and they sought a review of the costs decision. The Commissioner of Main Roads, acting as the defendant, argued that the costs awarded were appropriate and that the plaintiffs' claims were excessive. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, Australia.

The primary legal issues in the case were whether the ordinary rules of costs applied in this context, whether the Calderbank offer was relevant to the costs discretion, and if so, how it should be considered. The court also needed to determine the appropriate approach to the costs discretion in valuation cases and whether the rejection of the Calderbank offer was reasonable.

The court found that the ordinary rules of costs did not necessarily apply in this context, and the Calderbank offer was relevant to the costs discretion. The court held that if a claimant recovers a sum in excess of what was offered by the resuming authority, it should be considered as having succeeded on the core issue of the proceedings. However, a Calderbank offer in an amount that exceeds the judgment sum does not give rise to a presumptive entitlement to indemnity costs. The court also found that the rejection of the Calderbank offer by the plaintiffs was reasonable, and little weight should be given to the offer in the exercise of the costs discretion.

The court ordered that the defendants pay the plaintiffs' costs to 16 October 2009, and the plaintiffs pay the defendants' costs after 16 October 2009.

Orders

Orders of the court

Defendants pay plaintiffs' costs to 16 October 2009

Plaintiffs pay defendants' costs after 16 October 2009

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The plaintiffs rely on a statement by Osborn J in Murdesk Investments Pty Ltd v Roads Corporation [2007] VSC 175; (2007) 155 LGERA 13 [26] that if a claimant recovers a sum in excess of what was offered by the resuming authority it should be considered as having succeeded on the core issue of the proceedings, so that an entitlement to It was common ground that, at least in some circumstances, a Calderbank offer may be relevant to the costs discretion. The plaintiffs submit that: The defendants' primary submissions are that: Alternatively, the defendants submit: A Calderbank offer in an amount that exceeds the judgment sum does not give rise to a presumptive entitlement to indemnity costs: [31]. I do not accept either of propositions (1) and (2). I think acceptance of this view is implicit in what Jenkins J said in Mercer [40], about which I will say more shortly. I turn to the question of the weight to be given to the offer in the exercise of the costs discretion. The plaintiffs submit that little weight should be given to the Calderbank offer given: I begin with the question of the duration of the offer. I respectfully agree with these general observations. The plaintiffs rely heavily on these observations. It is clear that each case is to be judged on its own circumstances. It can be seen from these cases that: The plaintiffs submit that ten days was not a reasonable time for consideration of the offer, taking into account: I turn to the plaintiffs' contention that they acted reasonably in rejecting the offer. I will say more about matters bearing on the reasonableness of the plaintiffs' rejection of the offer in the next section of these reasons. I have already found that the defendants' offer: Acceptance by the court of the defendants' valuers opinion was not necessary (although sufficient) for such an outcome. For these reasons, I would order that the plaintiffs pay the defendants' costs after the Calderbank offer. For these reasons, assuming no weight were given to the Calderbank offer, I would have ordered that: