McIntyre v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

McIntyre v Commissioner of Police [2021] QDC 163

PARTIES:

PATRICIA ANN MCINTYRE

(appellant)

v

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

(respondent)

FILE NO:

D64/2021

DIVISION:

Appellate

PROCEEDING:

Appeal pursuant to s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld)

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court at Maroochydore

DELIVERED ON:

30 July 2021 (orders)

3 August 2021 (reasons)

DELIVERED AT:

Maroochydore

HEARING DATE:

26 July 2021

JUDGE:

Long SC, DCJ

ORDER:

1.   The appeal is allowed

2.   It is ordered that only the following variations be made to the orders made in the Magistrates Court at Maroochydore on 13 April 2021:

(1)   All orders requiring that the defendant pay ‘Restitution’ are set aside; and

(2)   In respect of the orders made consequently to the revocation of the probation order made on 21 September 2020:

(a)   each term of six months imprisonment be varied to four months imprisonment; and

(b)  each order for suspension of the term of imprisonment (including that of one month imprisonment for the offence of stealing) is set aside.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE OF MAGISTRATE – where the appellant committed and was sentenced in respect of 17 offences and a breach of a probation order in the Magistrates Court– where the Magistrate ordered terms of imprisonment and payment of compensation–  whether the Magistrate appropriately considered the making of compensation orders – whether the Magistrate failed to appropriately have regard to the effect and impact of the sentencing orders and the principle of totality – whether the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive in the circumstances

LEGISLATION:

Justices Act 1886, ss 222, 223
Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, ss 9, 35, 48, 351

State Penalties Enforcement Act 1999

CASES:

AB v The Queen (1999) 198 CLR 111
Bugmy v the Queen (2013) 249 CLR 571
Commissioner of Police v Al Shakarji [2013] QCA 319
Forrest v Commissioner of Police [2017] QCA 132
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118
Hili  v The Queen (2010) 242 CLR 520
House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499
McDonald v Queensland Police Service [2018] 2 Qd R 612
Merrin v Commissioner of Police; Merrin & Anor v Commissioner of Police [2012] QCA 181
Monsell v Commissioner of Police [2020] QDC 250
Powell v Chief Executive Officer of Australian Customs Service [2016] QCA 313
Pullen v O’Brien [2014] QDC 92
R v Ferrari [1997] 2 Qd R 472
R v Flint [2015] QCA 275
R v Kendrick [2015] QCA 27
R v Margaritis; Ex-parte Attorney-General (Qld) [2014] QCA 219
R v Matauaina [2011] QCA 344
R v Pham (2015) 256 CLR 550
R v Shillingsworth [2002] 1 Qd R 527
R v Silasack [2009] QCA 88
Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott (2016) 90 ALJR 679
Teelow v Commissioner of Police [2009] 2 Qd R 489
Tierney v Commissioner of Police [2011] QCA 327
White v Commissioner of Police [2014] QCA 121
Wieland v QPS [2020] QDC 292

COUNSEL:

LA Ygoa-McKeown for the appellant

SOLICITORS:

Lumme Rynderman Legal for the appellant

Office…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McIntyre v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QDC 163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of McIntyre v Commissioner of Police, the appellant, McIntyre, appealed against the sentence imposed by the Magistrate in the Magistrates Court. McIntyre was sentenced in respect of 17 offences and a breach of a probation order, resulting in terms of imprisonment and payment of compensation. The legal issues before the court were whether the Magistrate appropriately considered the making of compensation orders, whether the Magistrate failed to appropriately have regard to the effect and impact of the sentencing orders and the principle of totality, and whether the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive in the circumstances. The court held that the Magistrate had erred in making the compensation orders, as there was no present apparent capacity of the defendant to meet the compensation orders, and no cogency of evidence as to any future expectation of such capacity. The court also held that the Magistrate had failed to have regard to the relevant principles in having regard to the impact of the compensation obligation on the appellant's prospects of rehabilitation.

The court further held that the Magistrate had not appropriately considered the principle of totality in imposing the sentence. The Magistrate had ordered imprisonment terms of six months for each offence, which the court considered to be manifestly excessive in the circumstances. The court varied the imprisonment terms to four months for each offence, and set aside the orders for suspension of the terms of imprisonment. The court also set aside all orders requiring the defendant to pay restitution. The appeal was allowed, and the orders made in the Magistrates Court were varied as set out in the court's orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed

2. It is ordered that only the following variations be made to the orders made in the Magistrates Court at Maroochydore on 13 April 2021:

(1) All orders requiring that the defendant pay ‘Restitution’ are set aside; and

(2) In respect of the orders made consequently to the revocation of the probation order made on 21 September 2020:

(a) each term of six months imprisonment be varied to four months imprisonment; and

(b) each order for suspension of the term of imprisonment (including that of one month imprisonment for the offence of stealing) is set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Neither is the submission that the sentencing Magistrate placed “inadequate weight on the applicant’s antecedents” apt to properly engage the appropriate principles, as noted above in the passage from House v R. The Magistrate did not fail to have regard to those antecedents, in any event. What she said was:“I have, of course, been given, in exhibit 5, the Palmwoods Medical Centre mental health treatment plan. It does not really take me very far, to be honest. It indicates that you have got some problems of anxiety and depression which a vast majority of people seem to be having these days as well. You were given some medication. There was a bit of a social history and certainly you have had some difficult times in your life, but not the worst one I have seen and certainly not the best one, but it was, and nothing in there really makes – gives me any reason for why you would have gone down this crazy track of behaviour. You had certainly managed to cut down your alcohol of your own volition, and certainly your general behaviour in what was marked did not – other than the anxiety symptoms and maybe some sleeping pattern problems, there is nothing in this report at all that would suggest to me that there are any significant matters that I should take into account in regard to that.”[30]And as has already been noted, she otherwise specifically noted the appellant’s circumstances and that she had started a mental health plan as a considerations of some importance in imposing the period of two years imprisonment. [30]D3.31-44.Conclusion Consistently with established authority,[31] the respondent sought and placed before the Court, evidence of the understandable desire of the beneficiaries of the compensation orders, for them not to be set aside, as a means of providing opportunity for them to be heard on the issue, and sought to advocate against those orders being set aside. None of those victims sought to be further heard in the matter. However and in the circumstances where, as was acknowledged by the Magistrate, the defendant had no present apparent capacity to meet the compensation orders, and where there could be no reality of expectation that she would in the future have such capacity, I am driven to the conclusion that the Magistrate erred in not heeding the submissions of each of the parties before her and in making the compensation orders, so as to leave open only a bare hope of recovery in the future when there was an absence of cogency of evidence as to any such expectation. In particular, it is clear that she has also failed to have regard to the relevant principles to be applied in having regard to the impact that such an obligation was likely to have upon the appellant in the future and her prospects of rehabilitation. Moreover, the remaining difficulty is the absence of sufficient circumstances to provide any appropriate basis for the making of any such compensation orders.[31]R v Matauaina [2011] QCA 344, at [25], R v Ferrari [1997] 2 Qd R 472, at 479.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established