McDonald v AMP Financial Planning Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

McDonald v AMP Financial Planning Pty Limited [2018] QSC 195

PARTIES:

LEANNE YVONNE MCDONALD

(plaintiff)

v
AMP FINANCIAL PLANNING PTY LIMITED ABN 89 051 208 327

(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 1927 of 2018

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

28 August 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

4-8 June; 11 June 2018

JUDGE:

Douglas J

ORDER:

That the plaintiff’s claim be dismissed and the existing injunction be dissolved.  Further submissions shall be heard in respect of the form of the order and costs.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – INTERPRETATION OF MISCELLANEOUS CONTRACTS AND OTHER MATTERS – where the plaintiff was a financial advisor licensed to provide financial advice and sell the defendant’s financial products pursuant to a contract – where the defendant alleged that the plaintiff did not comply with her obligations under the contract – where the defendant was entitled to terminate the contract without notice if the plaintiff breached a material obligation – where the defendant was entitled to terminate the contract by giving not less than 90 days’ notice if the plaintiff breached an obligation capable of remedy and did not remedy that breach within 14 days of receiving notice of the breach – where the defendant terminated without notice – whether breach of an obligation capable of remedy could give rise to an ability to terminate without notice – whether the defendant was entitled to terminate without notice

CORPORATIONS – FINANCIAL SERVICES AND MARKETS – FINANCIAL PRODUCTS – GENERALLY – where the plaintiff was a financial advisor licensed to provide financial advice and sell the defendant’s products pursuant to a contract – where the plaintiff’s obligations under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) were incorporated into the contract – where the defendant alleged that the plaintiff did not comply with her obligations under ss 946A, 961B and 961J of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – where the defendant terminated the contract without notice – whether the plaintiff complied with her obligations under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – whether the plaintiff was entitled to terminate

ESTOPPEL – ESTOPPEL BY CONDUCT – ACT, OMISSION OR ASSUMPTION – REPRESENTATION GENERALLY – GENERALLY – where the plaintiff was a financial advisor licensed to provide financial advice and sell the defendant’s financial products pursuant to a contract – where, in accordance with that contract, the plaintiff was audited on a yearly basis – where those audits indicated that the plaintiff was complying with her obligations – where the defendant terminated the contract without notice for breach of obligations – whether the audits represented to the plaintiff that she was complying with her obligations – whether the defendant was estopped from terminating the contract for breach of those obligations

ESTOPPEL – ESTOPPEL BY DEED OR CONVENTION – ESTOPPEL BY CONVENTION – GENERALLY – where the plaintiff was a financial advisor licensed to provide financial advice and sell the defendant’s financial products…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McDonald v AMP Financial Planning Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QSC 195
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of McDonald v AMP Financial Planning Pty Limited, the plaintiff, a financial advisor, sought to challenge the termination of her contract with the defendant, AMP Financial Planning Pty Limited (AMPFP). The primary dispute centred around whether AMPFP was entitled to terminate the contract without providing the required 90 days' notice, and whether the plaintiff had indeed breached her obligations under the contract and relevant statutory provisions. The court was tasked with determining whether the termination was justified under the contract terms, whether the plaintiff was estopped from challenging the termination due to past conduct and representations, and whether the plaintiff was entitled to an injunction to prevent the immediate termination.

The key legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the contract's termination clauses, the applicability of estoppel principles, and the appropriateness of granting an injunction. The plaintiff argued that the defendant was estopped from terminating the contract without notice due to past audits indicating compliance and the defendant's failure to terminate in similar past instances. Additionally, the plaintiff contended that the contract's requirement for 90 days' notice applied even if a breach was capable of remedy but not remedied within 14 days. The court needed to assess whether the audits and past conduct could indeed estop AMPFP from relying on its strict legal rights and whether the contract allowed for termination without notice under the circumstances.

The court found that AMPFP was entitled to terminate the contract without providing 90 days' notice. The reasoning was that the contract allowed for immediate termination if a material obligation was breached. The court determined that the plaintiff's breaches were of a material nature and thus justified immediate termination. The court also found that the plaintiff was not estopped from AMPFP terminating the contract because the past audits and conduct did not create a sufficient representation or assumption that the plaintiff would not be terminated for future breaches. The court held that estoppel did not apply as the past conduct did not amount to a clear and unequivocal representation that termination would not occur for future breaches. Furthermore, the court did not grant the injunction as it found that the termination was justified under the contract terms.

The final orders of the court were that the plaintiff's claim be dismissed and the existing injunction be dissolved. The court scheduled further submissions to address the form of the order and the allocation of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

That the plaintiff’s claim be dismissed and the existing injunction be dissolved. Further submissions shall be heard in respect of the form of the order and costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

To deal with the issues that were litigated, which included arguments that the defendant was estopped from relying on its strict legal rights under the AR Agreement, it is necessary to set out some of the history of the dealings between the parties, particularly the nature of the training provided to the plaintiff, how her performance and that of Create FS were audited and the procedures used to terminate her engagement. BackgroundThe plaintiff’s training and experience By the time of the events associated with this dispute the plaintiff had considerable experience as an authorised representative of AMPFP. It provided many online and other resources to assist her with her continuing professional development.[9] She had no issue with her technical or product knowledge.[10] She had received a number of awards from the defendant for her work.[11] AMPFP characterised those awards, however, as ones relating to her skill in sales and marketing rather than in respect of compliance with her contractual and statutory obligations. [9] T 1-85/5; Ex 2 vol 14 p 6071.[10] T 1-85/36 - T 1-86/32.[11] T 1-20/25-34.Auditing by the defendant The plaintiff’s compliance with her contractual and statutory obligations was reviewed by AMPFP’s auditors at approximately annual intervals.[12] The audit conducted on 28 October 2016 was preceded by a calendar invitation and email from the auditor stating that: “[A]n impartial evaluation of compliance processes is critical for a business to ensure it is meeting its regulatory and licensee requirements. Perhaps more importantly, an effective audit will determine potential underlying issues, or causes of those issues which is a necessary step to prevent reoccurrence and to ultimately providing quality advice to clients …”.[13][12] Ms McDonald’s first affidavit at para 103.[13] Ex 2 vol 3 p 984. That message was repeated the next year for the audit conducted by Mr Ben Gillespie in June 2017.[14] The plaintiff said that she believed that if she continued to maintain her client files in the same manner as those the subject of audits (subject to the correction of any errors identified by the defendant) then she was complying with all regulatory and AMPFP licensee requirements.[15] Because she believed those things she said she did not take any steps to alter her processes and practices in relation to her clients’ files other than in the manner identified by the defendant during the audits.[16] She said that on a number of occasions her file notes were described by an auditor as more than satisfactory.[17] [14] Ex 2 vol 3 p 987.[15] Ms McDonald’s first affidavit at para 126.[16] Ms McDonald’s first affidavit at para 127.[17] See paras 115 of Ms McDonald’s first affidavit. For the normal audits in 2015, 2016 and 2017 Create FS received “B” ratings, said to demonstrate a good level of understanding and application of “quality advice principles overall, with some areas for improvement identified”.[18] Ms McDonald believed that any errors identified during the audits were not of a type which could or would result in the termination of the AR Agreement or her authorisation.[19] [18] Ex 2 vol 14 pp 5759, 5768, 5777.[19] Ms McDonald’s first affidavit at para 125.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There were further exchanges between the plaintiff and the defendant’s representatives, including an email from Ms Innes on 23 November 2017 in which she said that part of her recommendation to the “Adviser Issues Panel”, should she be retained, would be to arrange an “Advice Process Improvement Manager” to attend her office and provide training on how to improve her current processes.[66] The Adviser Issues Panel was a committee in the defendant’s organisation tasked with making the decision about what to do in respect of the plaintiff’s authorisations as a consequence of the show cause notice and her response to it.[67] [66] See Ms Innes’s first affidavit, ex JMI-13 at p 168.[67] See Ms Innes’s first affidavit at para 31.Decision to terminate Before the Adviser Issues Panel met, Ms Innes compiled an issue assessment document for it which attached the plaintiff’s response. It did not attach the 600 pages of documents the plaintiff had provided to Ms Innes to justify her response to the show cause letter.[68] Mr McDonell, one of the panel members, requested two of the annexures to the plaintiff’s response to the show cause notice but otherwise relied on an assessment of those annexures undertaken by others.[69] [68] See Ms Innes’s first affidavit, ex JMI-17.[69] Affidavit of Mr McDonell at paras 8 and 12; T 4-66/16. Ms Innes had provided her investigation report to the panel. In it she referred to the non-provision of ongoing service issues that had been marked as being high risk in eight client files, a further six files where best interest duty issues had been marked as being high risk and one file where she outlined the non-provision of an appropriate advice document, again marked as being high risk.[70][70] Affidavit of Jessica Marie Innes sworn 27 February 2018 at para 34. At its meeting on 25 January 2018 the panel agreed to revoke the applicant’s authorisations and terminate the agreements between her and the defendant with immediate effect.[71] At a further meeting of the panel on 8 February 2018 it also resolved that the plaintiff’s conduct constituted a serious compliance concern which warranted reporting to the regulator, namely the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (“ASIC”).[72] [71] Affidavit of Ms Innes at para 35.[72] Affidavit of Ms Innes at para 41. It was those files which were examined in detail in these proceedings in respect of the amended further and better particulars of the defence contained in ex 1. The particulars identified six named client couples where the allegation was that the plaintiff breached her best interests duty to them by not giving advice which was in their best interests. There were a further 10 cases set out in those particulars where the defendant alleged that, for 10 named clients or couples, the plaintiff failed to comply with the requirements of reg 7.7.09 of the Corporations Regulations 2001 and ASIC’s Regulatory Guide 175 by using a review note template to record reviews with and the giving of financial advice to those clients instead of an ROA or a statement of advice (“SOA”) pursuant to s 946C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“the Act”) or s 946B as substituted by reg 7.7.10AE.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.