MATHESON and LOCAL GOVERNMENT STANDARDS PANEL

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: LOCAL GOVERNMENT ACT 1995 (WA)

CITATION:   MATHESON and LOCAL GOVERNMENT STANDARDS PANEL [2020] WASAT 26

MEMBER:   DR B DE VILLIERS, MEMBER

HEARD:   5 FEBRUARY 2020

DELIVERED          :   4 MARCH 2020

FILE NO/S:   CC 1158 of 2019

BETWEEN:   JULIE CHRISTINE MATHESON

Applicant

AND

LOCAL GOVERNMENT STANDARDS PANEL

Respondent

ATTORNEY­GENERAL OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Intervener


Catchwords:

Local Government Standards Panel - Conduct of councillor - Writing of letter to newspaper - Decision by local government council to exclude public from meeting - Referring to incorrect sub-section to exclude public - Use of word 'paranoid' to describe actions of fellow councillors - Right to freedom of political communication

Legislation:

Local Government (Rules of Conduct) Regulations 2007 (WA), reg 7(1)(b)
Local Government Act 1995 (WA), s 5.23(1), s 5.23(2), s 5.23(2)(e)(iii), s 5.110(6), s 5.125
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), 2 29(3)(a), s 31

Result:

Review successful
Decision set aside

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : AP Rumsley
Respondent : N/A
Intervener : E Negus

Solicitors:

Applicant : In Person
Respondent : N/A
Intervener : State Solicitor's Office

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

King and Local Government Standards Panel [2018] WASAT 42

Lange v Australian Broadcasting Corporation (1997) 189 CLR 520

R v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal; Ex parte Hardiman (1980) 144 CLR 13

Ryan and Local Government Standards Panel [2009] WASAT 154

Treby and Local Government Standards Panel [2010] WASAT 81

Yates and Local Government Standards Panel [2012] WASAT 59

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Background

  1. This proceeding concerns a review of a decision dated 27 March 2019 by the Local Government Standards Panel (Panel). The Panel found on 27 March 2019 that Councillor (Cr) Julie Christine Matheson (the applicant) had committed a minor breach of reg 7(1)(b) of the Local Government (Rules of Conduct) Regulations 2007 (WA) (LG Regulations) when she wrote a letter to the (Subiaco) Post, a community newspaper, on 8 September 2018 (Letter), in which she criticised the Council of the City of Subiaco (City or Council) and members of the Council for their conduct which she described as 'paranoia'. 

  2. A complaint about the applicant was lodged by Cr Jodi Mansfield.  The applicant was ordered by the Panel on 8 July 2019 to apologise and is now seeking a review of both the decisions.

  3. The applicant and the Attorney­General of Western Australia (Intervener) agree that the circumstances of the matter are unique and not easily comparable to other decisions determined under the LG Regulations. 

  4. Much of the hearing focused on the word 'paranoia' used by the applicant in the Letter to describe the workings and conduct of the Council and the decision of the Council at its meeting on 28 August 2018 (Meeting), to exclude the public from discussions of an agenda item concerning a planning matter. 

  5. The applicant says that in the context of events that preceded the writing of the Letter the use of the word 'paranoia' was reasonable, whereas the Intervenor says that, regardless of the context in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MATHESON and LOCAL GOVERNMENT STANDARDS PANEL and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] WASAT 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Matheson and Local Government Standards Panel dealt with a dispute concerning the conduct of a local government councillor, Matheson, who had written a letter to a newspaper. The Local Government Standards Panel had found Matheson's conduct to be unsatisfactory and issued a public reprimand. Matheson appealed this decision. The nature of the dispute involved the interpretation of the Local Government Act 1993 and the application of the implied freedom of political communication to the actions of a local government councillor.

The central legal issues were whether Matheson's use of the word 'paranoid' to describe the actions of fellow councillors constituted improper conduct under the Local Government Act and whether her actions were protected by the implied freedom of political communication. The court had to consider whether the restriction on Matheson's conduct was reasonable and necessary to maintain public order, decorum, and efficiency in local government.

The court reasoned that the right to freedom of political communication, while significant, is not absolute and can be subject to reasonable restrictions. The court held that Matheson's use of the word 'paranoid' was an expression of frustration in the context of robust political debate, which is expected in local government. However, the court found that her choice of words was not reasonable in the circumstances and exceeded what was acceptable in maintaining public order and decorum. The court also noted that Matheson had acted within the bounds of her duties by drawing attention to the incorrect legal basis used by the council to exclude the public from a meeting. The appeal was dismissed, upholding the Panel's decision.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal be dismissed and that the decision of the Local Government Standards Panel to issue a public reprimand to Matheson be upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The question arose in the hearing whether the constitutional right to implied freedom of political communication can be relied upon as an absolute justification of the Letter. There is no need to provide an in depth discussion of the matter of Lange v Australian Broadcasting Corporation (1997) 189 CLR 520. In Treby the relevancy of the principles of freedom of political communities was discussed in detail within the context of the legislation pursuant to which this proceeding is determined; Treby at [43]-[54]. Relevantly for purposes of this proceeding is that the right to freedom of political communication is not absolute; it does not confer personal rights; and reasonable restrictions may be imposed on whatever freedom of political communication exists at the level of local government. The Tribunal follows Treby at [53] when it is concluded that:… For present purposes, it suffices to say that even if the implied freedom of political communication applies to communications of the present kind, reg 7(1)(b) does not need to be construed in a manner different from the ordinary and natural construction outlined above, in order to operate consistently with the implied freedom. When considering whether detriment had been intended or suffered, it is noted that detriment is not to be limited to actual loss or injury suffered. Detriment includes non-financial loss, humiliation, embarrassment, and harassment; Yates and Local Government Standards Panel [2012] WASAT 59 at [71] and Ryan and Local Government Standards Panel [2009] WASAT 154 at [32]. In order for a finding to be made the conduct must either have been intended for a person to suffer detriment or for the person making the statement to be recklessly indifferent that detriment was probable or likely as a consequence of the conduct. The parties accept that a councillor has a two-pronged duty ­ a duty towards fellow councillors and a duty towards the public. Although courtesy and respect are essential in the interaction with fellow councillors, it is also accepted that public office and public interest require robust debate, public ventilation of differences and scrutiny of policies. Respecting decisions of a Council does not equate with necessarily agreeing with the merit of those decisions. Even after a vote on a matter had been taken, a councillor could explain to his or her electorate why he or she disagreed and continues to disagree with that decision; that is a part of the usual democratic processes. In this case the applicant had discharged her duties towards the Council and towards the public. The question is whether in her choice of words she exceeded what is reasonable when she displayed her frustration to the public in the Letter by using the word 'paranoia'. The applicant had discharged her duty towards the Council by repeatedly drawing the attention of the CEO; the Mayor; and fellow councillors to the incorrect reliance on sub­section 5.23(2)(e)(iii) of the LG Act as the basis upon which the public was to be excluded from the discussion of agenda item C1.13. She sent two emails to the CEO prior to the Meeting, and received no response to those emails; she raised her concern during the Meeting in response to which council nevertheless voted to rely on sub-section 5.23(2)(e)(iii) of the LG Act to exclude the public; she opposed the confirmation of the minutes on 4 September 2018 and again on 18 September 2018, in response to which the Council regardless confirmed the minutes on 16 October 2018.