Martino v The Mac Services Group Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Martino v The Mac Services Group Limited [2009] FCA 546

DISCOVERY – categories of discoverable documents in proceeding involving patent –where documents potentially relevant to question of inventive step under s 7(2) and (3) of Patents Act 1990 (Cth) – whether Court has power under O 15 to order discovery of limited categories of documents not necessarily satisfying criteria in O 15 r 2(3)

Held: order for discovery made – Court has power to order discovery in accordance with limited categories proposed.    

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 7, s 18
Federal Court Rules O 15 rr 2, 3, 8, 15, O 29 r 2, O 35, r 10A

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Advanced Medical Institute Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 366 cited
Aveling v UBS Capital Markets Australia Holdings Ltd [2005] FCA 415 cited
Egglishaw v Australian Crime Commission (No 2) (2009) 253 ALR 354 cited
TheCompagnie Financiere et Commerciale du Pacifique v The Peruvian GuanoCo (1882) 11 QBD 55 referred to

FRANCESCO ANTONIO MARTINO v THE MAC SERVICES GROUP LIMITED (ACN 003 657 510) 

SAD 45 of 2008

BESANKO J
27 MAY 2009
ADELAIDE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SAD 45 of 2008

BETWEEN:

FRANCESCO ANTONIO MARTINO
Applicant

AND:

THE MAC SERVICES GROUP LIMITED (ACN 003 657 510)
Respondent

JUDGE:

BESANKO J

DATE OF ORDER:

27 MAY 2009

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant give discovery of all documents in its possession, custody or control in the categories listed below:

Category 1:

All documents that will be relied upon by the claimant to support the claim of patent infringement.

Category 2:

All documents that disclose, describe or note buildings and/or transportable structures that have a frame connected to and extending around a plurality of elongate beams where said frame is adapted to support a side wall of the building or structure.

This request is limited to documents that fall within (a)(i) of the definition of ‘prior art base’ in Schedule 1 to the Patents Act 1995, i.e. documents publicly available before 28 April 2003, and documents that describe or disclose buildings and/or transportable structures that were made before 28 April 2003 and which fall within (a)(ii) of the said definition.

Category 4:

Documents that disclose, describe or note buildings and/or structures that have or had the following features:

(i)        at least two elongate spaced apart load-supporting I-beams disposed parallel to the longitudinal axis;

(ii)       each I-beam having a top flange and bottom flange connected  by a web and respective front and rear ends;

(iii)      a plurality of elongate beams extending laterally across the top flange of both I-beams adapted to support a floor of the building or structure.

(iv)      a pair of spaced apart longitudinal channels extending through the web of each I-beam for engagement with forks of a forklift for lifting the building or structure.

This request is limited to documents that fall within (a)(i) of the definition  of ‘prior art base’ in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martino v The Mac Services Group Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 546
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Martino v The Mac Services Group Limited involved a dispute concerning patent infringement. The applicant, Martino, alleged that the respondent, The Mac Services Group Limited, had infringed several claims of a patent related to a transportable building and its chassis. The patent, numbered AU 2003227102, was alleged to have been published on 23 November 2004, with a priority date of 28 April 2003. Martino accused the respondent of infringing claims 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 12, and 13 of the patent. The respondent, in turn, sought orders for discovery of specific documents and for the separation of issues concerning the patent’s validity and infringement from any claims for pecuniary relief.

The court had to determine several legal issues. The first issue was whether to impose an order for the applicant to discover documents in seven specific categories. The applicant opposed this request. The second issue was whether to order that certain issues be decided separately from and prior to any claim for pecuniary relief, as requested by the respondent. The parties had agreed on this point.

The court decided that the order for discovery should be made without adding qualifications based on O 15 r 2(3). It rejected the applicant’s submissions that certain categories were too wide or should be limited to specific types of buildings. The court found the categories appropriately formulated. It also decided that the questions of patent validity and infringement should be determined separately from any claims for pecuniary relief. The court ruled that no costs order should be made in favour of the respondent due to the reformulation of categories by the respondent.

The final orders made by the court required the applicant to provide documents in the specified categories and mandated that the issues of patent validity and infringement be decided before any claim for pecuniary relief. There was no order regarding the costs of the respondent’s notice of motion.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant give discovery of all documents in its possession, custody or control in the categories listed below:

Category 1:

All documents that will be relied upon by the claimant to support the claim of patent infringement.

Category 2:

All documents that disclose, describe or note buildings and/or transportable structures that have a frame connected to and extending around a plurality of elongate beams where said frame is adapted to support a side wall of the building or structure.

This request is limited to documents that fall within (a)(i) of the definition of ‘prior art base’ in Schedule 1 to the Patents Act 1995, i.e. documents publicly available before 28 April 2003, and documents that describe or disclose buildings and/or transportable structures that were made before 28 April 2003 and which fall within (a)(ii) of the said definition.

Category 4:

Documents that disclose, describe or note buildings and/or structures that have or had the following features:

(i) at least two elongate spaced apart load-supporting I-beams disposed parallel to the longitudinal axis;

(ii) each I-beam having a top flange and bottom flange connected by a web and respective front and rear ends;

(iii) a plurality of elongate beams extending laterally across the top flange of both I-beams adapted to support a floor of the building or structure.

(iv) a pair of spaced apart longitudinal channels extending through the web of each I-beam for engagement with forks of a forklift for lifting the building or structure.

This request is limited to documents that fall within (a)(i) of the definition of ‘prior art base’ in Schedule 1 to the Patents Act 1995, i.e. documents publicly available before 28 April 2003, and documents that describe or disclose buildings and/or transportable structures that were made before 28 April 2003 and which fall within (a)(ii) of the said definition.

Category 5:

Inventors books, inventors notes, and all other documents created during the time of inventing and that relate to the invention claimed in AU2003227102 or PCT/AU2003/000947

Category 6:

All documents that fall within (a)(i) of the definition of ‘prior art base’ in Schedule 1 to the Patents Act 1995, i.e. documents publicly available before 28 April 2003, and documents that describe or disclose buildings and/or transportable structures that were made before 28 April 2003 and which fall within (a)(ii) of the said definition listed or referred to in patent search reports pertaining to the applicant’s invention claimed in AU2003227102, whether they be search reports of a Patent Office, or by a patent attorney firm or patent search company and all such reports which list or refer to matter falling within the definition of ‘prior art base’.

This category is limited to documents that disclose buildings or structures that have or had the following features:

(i) a longitudinal chassis or frame including two elongate spaced apart load-supporting I-beams disposed parallel to the longitudinal axis;

(ii) each I-beam having a top flange and bottom flange connected by a web and respective front and rear ends;

(iii) a plurality of elongate beams extending laterally across the top flange of both I-beams adapted to support a floor of the building or structure.

Category 7:

All documents describing or disclosing a building described in the background to the invention section of AU2003227102 or PCT/AU2003/000947 including specifically buildings (rectangular or otherwise) which prior to the priority date were lifted by crane as described in the background to the invention and that were made before April 28 2003.

2. Pursuant to O 29 r 2 of the Federal Court Rules, the following questions be decided separately from and prior to any question of pecuniary relief for infringement of Australian Patent No 2003227102 (the “patent”):

(1) the question of the validity of the patent as raised in the respondent’s Cross-Claim for revocation of the patent;

(2) the question of alleged infringement of the patent by the respondent as raised in paragraphs 1-6 of the applicant’s Amended Statement of Claim as read with the Particulars of Infringement.

3. There be no order as to the costs of the respondent’s notice of motion dated 20 February 2009.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The notice of motion issued by the respondent seeks two orders. The first order is that the applicant discover all documents in his possession, custody or power, in seven categories of documents. The documents are said to be relevant to the respondent’s invalidity claim. The application for that order is opposed by the applicant. The second order sought in the notice of motion is that, under O 29 r 2 of the Federal Court Rules, the issues relating to the invalidity claim and the infringement claim be decided separately from and prior to the claim for pecuniary relief. The parties are agreed that the second order should be made.Background The patent relates to a transportable building and chassis therefor. It is alleged by the applicant that the complete specification of the patent was published and became open to public inspection on 23 November 2004. The priority date for the patent is 28 April 2003. The following statement is made in the patent specification:“The present invention relates to a transportable building and in particular to a transportable building including a chassis that can be engaged by a forklift to lift the building for either loading or unloading from a truck or for attaching wheeled axles to the chassis.” In his Amended Application, the applicant alleges that the respondent has infringed claims 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 12 and 13 of the patent. Those claims are in the following terms:“1.A transportable building having a longitudinal chassis said chassis including: two elongate spaced apart inner load-supporting I-beams disposed parallel to a longitudinal axis of said chassis, each I-beam including a top and bottom flange connected by a web, each of said I-beams having respective front and rear ends; a plurality of elongate beams extending laterally across said top flange of both I-beams and adapted to support a floor of said transportable building; a front member and a rear member connected normal to and across the respective front and rear ends of said I-beams;a frame connected to and extending around the plurality of elongate beams, said frame adapted to support side walls of said building;a pair of spaced apart parallel longitudinal channels extending through said web of both said I-beam, said channels adapted to be engaged by forks of a forklift for lifting said transportable building.…3.A transportable building as in any one of the above claims wherein said chassis is made from steel.4.A transportable building as in any one of the above claims wherein said elongate beams are tubular beams having a rectangular cross-section.5.A transportable building as in any one of the above claims wherein each said longitudinal channel includes a plurality of spaced apart stiffening plates extending laterally across said channel.6.A transportable building as in any one of the above claims wherein extending between each said I-beams and said front and rear members are a plurality of bracing members.7.A transportable building as in claim 1 wherein said elongate beams and said front and rear members are welded to said I-beams.…12.A transportable building as in any one of the above claims wherein said channels are positioned adjacent said top flange of said I-beams.13.A transportable building as in any one of the above claims wherein the width of said chassis is adapted to be smaller than the width of a conventional road-train.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BESANKO J
The respondent submitted that I could, if I considered it appropriate, add the criteria in O 15 r 2(3) as a limitation on the categories. The applicant submitted that this would not be appropriate, and I accept this submission. I have reached the conclusion that an order for discovery in terms of the categories should be made and there is no reason to complicate the matter by adding a qualification in terms of O 15 r 2(3). The applicant submitted that Category 2 was too wide and that I should add to it the integers of the claims identified in Category 4. The applicant submitted that that would then make one or other of Categories 2 or 4 otiose. I reject this submission. I think both Categories 2 and 4 are sufficiently material or relevant to be the subject of orders. Finally, the applicant submitted that the reference in Categories 2, 4 and 6 to buildings or buildings and/or structures was too wide and the categories should be restricted to transportable buildings and/or transportable structures. I reject this submission. The question is one of degree and it is not suggested that the question of whether there is an inventive step is necessarily so confined. I think the formulation of the categories is appropriate as it presently stands.Conclusion I will make orders that the applicant make discovery of documents in accordance with the categories identified earlier in these reasons. I will also make an order that, pursuant to O 29 r 2, the following questions be decided separately from and prior to any question of pecuniary relief for infringement of Australian Patent No 2003227102 (the “patent”):1.The question of the validity of the patent as raised in the respondent’s Cross-Claim for revocation of the patent;2.The question of alleged infringement of the patent by the respondent as raised in paragraphs 1-6 of the applicant’s Amended Statement of Claim as read with the Particulars of Infringement. There should be no order as to the costs of the respondent’s notice of motion. Although the respondent has achieved a measure of success on the discovery application, the correspondence exhibited to the affidavits establishes that the respondent has, on a number of occasions, reformulated the categories and, even on the hearing of submissions, the respondent reformulated certain categories by adding substantial qualifications.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BESANKO J

Full text does not contain this section.