Egglishaw v Australian Crime Commission (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Egglishaw v Australian Crime Commission (No 3) [2009] FCA 1027

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – challenge to summons issued under s 28(1) of the Australian Crime Commission Act 2002 (Cth) and subsequent examination – whether summons invalid because determination accompanying summons as required by s 28(2) was not a facsimile copy of the relevant determination – whether invalid because summons did not indicate that applicant had to appear “as a witness” and stated that applicant was to appear before “an” examiner and not “the” examiner – whether invalid because summons failed to comply with s 29A(3) by not setting out rights and obligations in s 29B(3) and (4) in addition to those in s 29B(1) and (2) – whether examination unlawful because examiner failed to record in writing reasons for issuing summons before he issued the summons

Held: application dismissed – copy of determination provided complied with Act – evident that applicant was to appear as witness – summons was issued by examiner and returnable before him – s 29A(3) only requires a statement setting out the rights and obligations of a person served or otherwise given a summons by the Commissioner or an examiner – validation of summons under Australian Crime Commission Amendment Act 2007 (Cth) applies to examination pursuant to summons.

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – challenge to notice to produce issued under section 29 of the Australian Crime Commission Act 2002 (Cth) and production of DVDs pursuant to notice –whether invalid because notice referred to determination of incorrect date – whether invalid because notice failed to comply with s 29A(3) by not setting out rights and obligations in s 29B(3) and (4) in addition to those in s 29B(1) and (2) – whether invalid because notice did not indicate person to whom production was to be made – whether production unlawful because, even if notice did indicate person to whom production was to be made, DVDs were not produced to that person – whether invalid because notice required production of documents “forthwith” – whether production unlawful because examiner failed to record in writing reasons for issuing notice before he issued the notice

Held: application dismissed – s 29 does not require reference to determination – s 29A(3) only requires a statement setting out the rights and obligations of a person served or otherwise given a summons by the Commissioner or an examiner – word “produce” in s 29(1) does not require production directly to person specified in notice – requiring production “forthwith” not unreasonable – validation of notice under Australian Crime Commission Amendment Act 2007 (Cth) applies to production pursuant to notice.

Australian Crime Commission Act 2002 (Cth) ss 7C, 28, 29, 29A, 29B
Australian Crime Commission Amendment Act 2007 (No 168 of 2007) (Cth) Sch 10
Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 3E
Customs Act 1901 (Cth) s 234(e)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) s 264
Judiciary Act 1901 (Cth) s 39B

National Crime Authority Act 1984 (Cth) s 28
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Egglishaw v Australian Crime Commission (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1027
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Egglishaw brought an action against the Australian Crime Commission (ACC) seeking declarations and an injunction in relation to the validity of a summons and a notice to produce documents. The applicant, Egglishaw, contended that the summons and the notice to produce were invalid due to certain procedural defects, including the failure of the examiner to record reasons for issuing the summons before it was served. The ACC denied any procedural defects and argued that the summons and notice to produce were valid and lawful.

The court was required to determine whether the summons and the notice to produce were valid under the Australian Crime Commission Act 2002 (ACC Act). Specifically, the court had to examine whether the procedural requirements, such as the necessity for the examiner to record reasons in writing before issuing the summons, were complied with. Additionally, the court had to interpret the statutory provisions and determine whether the failure to comply with these requirements rendered the summons and the notice to produce invalid.

The court held that all of Egglishaw's grounds for challenging the summons and the notice to produce were without merit. The court found that the statutory requirement for the examiner to record reasons for issuing the summons did not necessitate that the record be made before the summons was issued, but rather that it be made as soon as practicable. Since the examiner had recorded his reasons on 2 February 2004, shortly after issuing the summons on 27 January 2004, this complied with the statutory requirement. The court also rejected the applicant's other arguments regarding the form and content of the summons and the notice to produce, finding that they did not affect the validity of these documents.

As a result, the court dismissed the proceeding and ordered Egglishaw to pay the ACC's costs of the proceeding. This decision underscores the importance of adherence to statutory requirements but also allows for some flexibility in their application, provided the essence of the legislative intent is met.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent its costs of the proceeding.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant alleges that the respondent committed various breaches of the ACC Act and that that led to the alleged invalidity and unlawfulness. The respondent denies any breaches of the ACC Act, or in the alternative, denies that the alleged breaches led to the alleged invalidity or unlawfulness. The respondent did not argue that there are discretionary reasons for refusing the declarations.The facts The applicant did not call any oral evidence. His case consisted of 13 documents which he tendered. One of the exhibits was an affidavit sworn by Mr Ian Andrew on 17 May 2006. Mr Andrew was a member of the staff of the Commission in 2004. His affidavit sets out in chronological order the history of the matter. The respondent’s case consisted of an affidavit of Mr David Bruce Hellings. Mr Hellings was a member of the staff of the Commission. He was cross-examined at length by counsel for the applicant and, in due course, I will set out my findings in relation to his evidence. In terms of the facts, the starting point is an authorisation and determination made by the Board of the Australian Crime Commission (“the Board”) at a meeting of the Board held on 13 May 2003. The authorisation and determination was called the “Australian Crime Commission Special Investigation Authorisation and Determination (Money Laundering and Tax Fraud) 2003” and the authorisation was expressed to be valid until 31 May 2004. I will refer to this as the 2003 authorisation and determination. It is common ground between the parties that the Board resolution making this authorisation and determination was passed at a Board meeting held on 13 May 2003 (see CC Pty Ltd v Australian Crime Commission (2007) 159 FCR 282). It appears that on 15 May 2003, the Chair of the Board signed a copy of the authorisation and determination, mistakenly asserting that it was made by resolution of the Board on 15 May 2003. The 2003 authorisation and determination was varied by a determination made by the Board by resolution passed on 4 December 2003. The determination was called the “Australian Crime Commission – Operations and Investigations (Participants) Determination 2003”. I will refer to this as the 2003 variation. Under the ACC Act, the Board may authorise in writing an investigation and may determine in writing that the investigation is a special investigation (s 7C(1)(c) and (d) and (3)). It may also determine in writing the class or classes of persons who are to participate in such an investigation (s 7C(1)(e)). In the 2003 authorisation and determination, the classes of persons to participate in the investigation were specified in Schedule 2 of the document. The purpose and effect of the 2003 variation was to make changes to the classes of persons who were to participate in the special investigation. After setting out certain preliminary matters, clause 4 of the 2003 variation stated:“4. Classes of persons to participate in operation(1)For paragraph 7C(1)(e) of the Act, the classes of persons to participate in the intelligence operation, or the investigation into a federally relevant criminal activity, to which an Instrument mentioned in Schedule 1 applies are the classes mentioned in Schedule 2.(2)For the avoidance of doubt, a provision in an Instrument mentioned in Schedule 1 that specifies the classes of persons to participate in the operation or investigation to which the Instrument relates is revoked and replaced by this Determination.Schedule 1Instruments amended by this Determination (section 4)…2.Australian Crime Commission Special Investigation Authorisation and Determination (Money Laundering and Tax Fraud) 2003…Schedule 2Classes of persons (section 4)1.The CEO.2.Each person who is:(a)a member of the staff of the ACC; and(b)identified in writing by the CEO, or a delegate of the CEO, as a person whose duties include providing services in relation to ACC operations and investigations.3.Each person who is:(a)an officer or member of the staff of any of the following agencies:(i)an agency of which a Board member is head (other than the CEO) in his or her capacity as a Board member;(ii)the Australian Taxation Office;(iii)AUSTRAC;(iv)the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs;(v)the New South Wales Crime Commission;(vi)the Queensland Crime and Misconduct Commission; and(b)identified in writing by the head of that agency, or a delegate of that head, as a person whose duties include providing services in relation to ACC operations and investigations.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Significant amendments were made to s 28 by the Australian Crime Commission Amendment Act 2007 (No 168 of 2007). I will refer to that Act as the 2007 Amendment Act. As a result of the 2007 Amendment Act, s 28 read as follows:“28 Power to summon witnesses and take evidence(1)An examiner may summon a person to appear before an examiner at an examination to give evidence and to produce such documents or other things (if any) as are referred to in the summons.(1A)Before issuing a summons under subsection (1), the examiner must be satisfied that it is reasonable in all the circumstances to do so. The examiner must also record in writing the reasons for the issue of the summons. The record is to be made:(a) before the issue of the summons; or(b) at the same time as the issue of the summons; or(c) as soon as practicable after the issue of the summons.(2)A summons under subsection (1) requiring a person to appear before an examiner at an examination must be accompanied by a copy of the determination of the Board that the intelligence operation is a special operation or that the investigation into matters relating to federally relevant criminal activity is a special investigation.(3)A summons under subsection (1) requiring a person to appear before an examiner at an examination shall, unless the examiner issuing the summons is satisfied that, in the particular circumstances of the special ACC operation/investigation to which the examination relates, it would prejudice the effectiveness of the special ACC operation/investigation for the summons to do so, set out, so far as is reasonably practicable, the general nature of the matters in relation to which the person is to be questioned, but nothing in this subsection prevents an examiner from questioning the person in relation to any matter that relates to a special ACC operation/investigation.(4)The examiner who is holding an examination may require a person appearing at the examination to produce a document or other thing.(5)An examiner may, at an examination, take evidence on oath or affirmation and for that purpose:(a)the examiner may require a person appearing at the examination to give evidence either to take an oath or to make an affirmation in a form approved by the examiner; and(b)the examiner, or a person who is an authorised person in relation to the ACC, may administer an oath or affirmation to a person so appearing at the examination.(6)In this section, a reference to a person who is an authorised person in relation to the ACC is a reference to a person authorised in writing, or a person included in a class of persons authorised in writing, for the purposes of this section by the CEO.(7)The powers conferred by this section are not exercisable except for the purposes of a special ACC operation/investigation.(8)A failure to comply with any of the following provisions does not affect the validity of a summons under subsection (1) of this section:(a)subsection (1A) of this section, in so far as that subsection relates to the making of a record;(b) subsection (2) of this section;(c)section 29A, in so far as that section relates to a summons under subsection (1) of this section.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

BESANKO J
The applicant’s fifth ground of challenge to the notice to produce is that the notice was invalid because the examiner did not record in writing his reasons for issuing the notice until after the notice was issued. This ground raises the same matters as are raised in relation to the same ground with respect to the summons. For the same reasons, I reject this ground of challenge (at [55]-[66]).Conclusion All grounds of challenge to both the summons and the notice to produce fail and the proceeding must be dismissed. The applicant must pay the respondent its costs of the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BESANKO J

Under the ACC Act, the Board may authorise in writing an investigation and may determine in writing that the investigation is a special investigation (s 7C(1)(c) and (d) and (3)). It may also determine in writing the class or classes of persons who are to participate in such an investigation (s 7C(1)(e)). In the 2003 authorisation and determination, the classes of persons to participate in the investigation were specified in Schedule 2 of the document. The purpose and effect of the 2003 variation was to make changes to the classes of persons who were to participate in the special investigation. After setting out certain preliminary matters, clause 4 of the 2003 variation stated:“4. Classes of persons to participate in operation(1)For paragraph 7C(1)(e) of the Act, the classes of persons to participate in the intelligence operation, or the investigation into a federally relevant criminal activity, to which an Instrument mentioned in Schedule 1 applies are the classes mentioned in Schedule 2.(2)For the avoidance of doubt, a provision in an Instrument mentioned in Schedule 1 that specifies the classes of persons to participate in the operation or investigation to which the Instrument relates is revoked and replaced by this Determination.Schedule 1Instruments amended by this Determination (section 4)…2.Australian Crime Commission Special Investigation Authorisation and Determination (Money Laundering and Tax Fraud) 2003…Schedule 2Classes of persons (section 4)1.The CEO.2.Each person who is:(a)a member of the staff of the ACC; and(b)identified in writing by the CEO, or a delegate of the CEO, as a person whose duties include providing services in relation to ACC operations and investigations.3.Each person who is:(a)an officer or member of the staff of any of the following agencies:(i)an agency of which a Board member is head (other than the CEO) in his or her capacity as a Board member;(ii)the Australian Taxation Office;(iii)AUSTRAC;(iv)the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs;(v)the New South Wales Crime Commission;(vi)the Queensland Crime and Misconduct Commission; and(b)identified in writing by the head of that agency, or a delegate of that head, as a person whose duties include providing services in relation to ACC operations and investigations.” The fact of the 2003 variation is significant in terms of the issues in this proceeding, but the precise details of the changes effected by the 2003 variation are not. On 27 January 2004, an examiner under the ACC Act issued a summons to the applicant under s 28(1) of the ACC Act. The summons had three documents attached to it, namely, a copy of the 2003 authorisation and determination (Annexure A), a schedule of documents and other things to be produced by the applicant (Annexure B) and a Statement of Rights and Obligations under s 29B of the Australian Crime Commission Act 2002 and Explanatory Notes (Annexure C). I will mention some matters about the summons which are relevant to the applicant’s grounds for alleging that it is invalid. First, the summons states that the Commission “is conducting a special investigation pursuant to a determination of its Board, a copy of which is annexed to this summons as Annexure A”. As I have said, a copy of the 2003 authorisation and determination was annexed to the summons as Annexure A. The summons did not have a copy of the 2003 variation annexed to it. Secondly, the summons states that the applicant is required “to attend at level 2, 383 Latrobe Street, Melbourne, on 17 February 2003 at 10.00 am before an Examiner at an examination to be held for the purposes of the above-mentioned special investigation to give evidence in relation to” his knowledge of, and involvement with, a number of topics which are listed in the summons. The summons refers to an Examiner, not the Examiner and it does not state that the applicant is summoned to give evidence as a witness. Thirdly, Annexure C to the summons sets out the rights and obligations in s 29B(1) and (2) of the ACC Act, but does not set out the rights and obligations conferred or imposed by s 29B(3) and (4) of the ACC Act. Finally, it is common ground between the parties that the examiner did not produce a record in writing of his reasons for the issue of the summons until after the summons had been issued. The plea in the respondent’s defence is that the examiner recorded his reasons regarding the summons under s 28 of the ACC Act on 2 February 2004.