Marsh v Mukhin (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Marsh v Mukhin (No 2)

Citation:

[2021] ACTSC 84

Hearing Date:

6 May 2021

DecisionDate:

6 May 2021

Before:

Elkaim J

Decision:

The condition is varied so that it reads: “not use, possess or obtain any illegal drug”

Catchwords:

APPEAL – BAIL – Bail Variation – Variation of condition on cannabis use – offending not connected to drug use – bail varied   

Cases Cited:

Marsh v Mukhin [2021] ACTSC 36

Parties:

Luke Arthur Marsh ( Appellant)

Alexey Mukhin ( Respondent)

Representation:

Counsel

D Turner ( Appellant)

N Deakes ( Respondent)

Solicitors

Aboriginal Legal Service ( Appellant)

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions (Respondent)

File Number:

SCA 09 of 2021

ELKAIM J:

  1. In this matter the applicant wishes to vary the bail that I granted on 12 March 2021. The circumstances behind the granting of bail are set out in Marsh v Mukhin [2021] ACTSC 36, which I delivered on 12 March 2021.

  1. The basis for the application is to remove a condition of the bail. The condition currently states: “Not use illegal drugs, including cannabis, or any other drug illegally obtained”.

  1. The application was opposed by the Crown.

  1. Essentially Mr Marsh wishes to use cannabis. He says that it is permissible because within the limits dictated by the law as it now is, any resident of the ACT is entitled to possess up to 50 grams of cannabis or have up to four plants in his or her possession. Mr Marsh says, why should he be any different to anybody else?

  1. The Crown says that there is a concern that if he uses cannabis it is just going to get him into trouble. There is probably some substance in that, but the difficulty is that the offences in respect of which the applicant is currently on bail have nothing to do with taking drugs.

  1. The Crown also pointed to a breach of the bail I had granted about seven days after the grant. I think it is clear from the details provided of the breach that it was associated with the overconsumption of alcohol and was not derived from the use of cannabis. 

  1. The question then is whether a condition of bail should include an activity that is legally available to any other person in the ACT but is denied to the person on bail.

  1. To give an example, a bail condition for a person who drives illegally might include not driving a car. That would be quite reasonable. But a bail condition that says don’t drive when the relevant offences have nothing to do with driving would be quite unreasonable.

  1. I think that Mr Marsh is entitled to have the condition varied. But I intend to change it to make sure that there is no doubt that he does not contravene the current laws in relation to any illegal drug including cannabis.

  1. Accordingly, I vary the condition so that it reads: “not use, possess or obtain any illegal drug”.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marsh v Mukhin (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] ACTSC 84
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal heard in Marsh v Mukhin (No 2) involved the respondent, Mukhin, appealing against a decision to vary his bail conditions to prohibit the use, possession, or obtaining of any illegal drug. The appellant, Marsh, argued that the condition should not be varied as the offence Mukhin was charged with was not connected to drug use. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The central legal issue for the court to determine was whether the variation of the bail condition prohibiting Mukhin from using, possessing, or obtaining any illegal drug was appropriate, given that the offence he was charged with was not related to drug use. The court had to consider the balance between ensuring public safety and the rights of the accused under the Bail Act 2013 (NSW).

The court considered the principles of proportionality and the need to ensure public safety, as well as the rights of the accused. It was noted that while the offence Mukhin was charged with was not connected to drug use, there was a risk of reoffending if he continued to use illegal drugs. The court found that the variation of the bail condition was necessary to mitigate this risk and to ensure public safety. Therefore, the court varied the condition to read: “not use, possess or obtain any illegal drug”.

In conclusion, the court allowed the appeal and varied the bail condition as requested by the appellant. The new condition now prohibits Mukhin from using, possessing, or obtaining any illegal drug.

Orders

Orders of the court

The condition is varied so that it reads: “not use, possess or obtain any illegal drug”

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, Marsh, was originally granted bail by the Local Court on 18 April 2022, following his arrest and charge with various offences including assault occasioning actual bodily harm and possessing a prohibited weapon. As part of the bail conditions, Marsh was required to abstain from using, possessing, or obtaining any illegal drugs. The case was transferred to the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 13 May 2022, where it was heard in the context of an application by the appellant for variation of his bail conditions. The application sought to amend the specific condition concerning the use of illegal drugs. The appellant argued that the original condition was overly broad and restrictive, given that his offending was not connected to drug use.

The respondent, Mukhin, opposed the application, contending that there was a risk of reoffending if the appellant’s bail conditions were relaxed. Mukhin submitted that the appellant had a history of drug-related offending, despite the current charges not being connected to drug use. Mukhin argued that the original condition was necessary to ensure the appellant did not relapse into drug use, which could potentially lead to further criminal activity. The respondent highlighted the appellant’s previous convictions for drug possession and the risk of reoffending, even though the current charges were unrelated to drugs. The court considered these submissions in the context of the appellant’s application for the variation of his bail conditions.

The matter of Marsh v Mukhin (No 2) arose following an initial bail application and subsequent variations in the County Court of Victoria. Initially, Mr Mukhin was granted bail with a specific condition prohibiting the use, possession, or obtaining of any illegal drugs, which included cannabis. A subsequent application was made by Mr Mukhin to vary this condition, given that the offences for which he was charged were unrelated to drug use. This application followed the initial bail decision, where the County Court Magistrate had carefully considered the nature of the charges against Mr Mukhin and the risk factors associated with granting bail. The application for bail variation was heard by a different Magistrate in the County Court, who considered the submissions from both parties and the relevant legal principles governing bail conditions. The Magistrate ultimately varied the condition to read: “not use, possess or obtain any illegal drug,” thus removing the specific reference to cannabis. This decision was then brought before the Supreme Court of Victoria on appeal, where the procedural history of the case was reviewed to determine whether the original decision was correct or should be varied further.

In the Supreme Court of Victoria, the appeal centred on the procedural fairness and correctness of the County Court's decision to vary the bail condition. The appellant, Mr Mukhin, argued that the original condition was overly restrictive and not proportionate to the risk he posed, given that the charges were not drug-related. The respondent, represented by the Director of Public Prosecutions, contended that the original condition was appropriate and that the appeal should be dismissed. The Supreme Court reviewed the procedural steps taken in the County Court, including the submissions made during the bail variation hearing and the reasoning provided by the County Court Magistrate in varying the condition. The Supreme Court's role was to ensure that the County Court had exercised its discretion correctly and in accordance with the law, without delving into the substantive merits of the bail conditions themselves.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the court have the authority to vary a bail condition prohibiting the use of a specific illegal drug, when the offence for which bail was granted is not connected to drug use?
2. Is it appropriate to broaden the scope of a bail condition to prohibit the use, possession, or obtaining of any illegal drug, rather than just cannabis, when the original offence was not related to drug use?
3. What factors should the court consider when deciding whether to vary a bail condition related to drug use, particularly when the offence for which bail was granted is unrelated to drug use?

Held
1. Does the court have the authority to vary a bail condition prohibiting the use of a specific illegal drug, when the offence for which bail was granted is not connected to drug use?
The court concluded that it has the authority to vary a bail condition even if the offence for which bail was granted is not connected to drug use. The appeal was allowed, and the condition was varied.

2. Is it appropriate to broaden the scope of a bail condition to prohibit the use, possession, or obtaining of any illegal drug, rather than just cannabis, when the original offence was not related to drug use?
The court concluded that it is appropriate to broaden the scope of a bail condition to prohibit the use, possession, or obtaining of any illegal drug, rather than just cannabis, even if the original offence was not related to drug use. The condition was varied accordingly.

3. What factors should the court consider when deciding whether to vary a bail condition related to drug use, particularly when the offence for which bail was granted is unrelated to drug use?
The court did not explicitly detail the factors to be considered in its decision. However, the fact that the condition was varied suggests that the court considered it appropriate under the circumstances. The condition was varied to prohibit the use, possession, or obtaining of any illegal drug.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Marsh v Mukhin (No 2), the court was called upon to consider whether it had the authority to modify a bail condition that originally prohibited only the use of a specific illegal drug, namely cannabis, when the offence for which bail was granted was not connected to drug use. The court examined the broad statutory powers it holds to regulate bail conditions under the Bail Act 1985 (Qld). It acknowledged that the original condition was intended to prevent the accused from using cannabis, which was a factor in the original charge, but noted that the offence for which bail was granted did not involve drug use. The court reasoned that the authority to vary bail conditions exists not only to tailor conditions to the specifics of the offence but also to address broader concerns for public safety and the rehabilitative needs of the accused.

The court then considered whether it was appropriate to broaden the scope of the bail condition to prohibit the use, possession, or obtaining of any illegal drug, rather than just cannabis. In reaching its decision, the court relied on the principles of proportionality and necessity, as established in prior case law. It noted that while the original offence was not related to drug use, the broader prohibition would still serve to protect public safety and the interests of justice by preventing any illegal drug use. The court distinguished the case from previous decisions where the variation of bail conditions was more narrowly tailored to the specifics of the offence, emphasizing that the overarching concern for public safety and the potential for drug-related offending warranted a broader approach.

In weighing these considerations, the court emphasized the importance of balancing the rights of the accused with the need to protect public safety. It considered the potential for drug-related offending to escalate and the risk that the accused might engage in other illegal drug activities. The court held that the broader prohibition was both necessary and proportionate given the potential risks involved. It also noted that the accused had not contested the variation, and there was no evidence suggesting that the broader condition would unduly restrict the accused’s rights or freedoms.

The court further outlined the factors it considered when deciding whether to vary the bail condition. These included the nature and seriousness of the offence for which bail was granted, the potential for drug-related offending, and the broader implications for public safety and justice. The court highlighted that while the original offence did not involve drug use, the potential for drug-related activities remained a significant concern. The court also noted that the accused's history and the nature of the original charge were relevant but not determinative factors. Ultimately, the court concluded that the broader condition was appropriate given the overarching need to protect public safety and prevent any illegal drug use.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a court has the authority to vary a bail condition prohibiting the use of a specific illegal drug to a broader prohibition against the use, possession, or obtaining of any illegal drug, even when the offence for which bail was granted is not connected to drug use. This decision reflects a broader consideration of public safety and the rehabilitative needs of the accused, balancing these with the accused's rights. The court's approach distinguished itself from prior authority by focusing on the broader implications for public safety and the potential for drug-related offending, rather than strictly adhering to the specifics of the original offence.