Marny and Anor and Garnett and Anors

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MARNY AND ANOR & GARNETT AND ANORS [2014] FamCA 247
FAMILY LAW – Costs against unsuccessful applicant for orders to restrain his former solicitors – Order made – Costs sought on an indemnity basis – Refused – Costs also sought against the solicitors who acted for the unsuccessful applicant – Application refused.
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)

Burns & Caldwell & Anor (Costs) [2011] FamCAFC 84
Fitzgerald (as child representative for A) Legal Aid Commission of Tasmania v Fish and Anor (2005) 33 Fam LR 123
Jane v Bob Jane Corporation & Anor (No 2) [2013] VSC 467
Knight v FP Special Assets Ltd [1992] HCA 28; (1992) 174 CLR 178
Lemoto v Able Technical Pty Ltd & Ors [2005] NSWCA 153; (2005) 63 NSWLR 300
Magro (1989) FLC 92-005
McGillivray and Mitchell [1998] FamCA 96
McMillan and McMillan (2000) 26 Fam LR 653
Muldoon and Carlyle [2012] FamCAFC 135
Prantage and Prantage [2013] FamCAFC 105
Ridehalgh v Horsfield [1994] 3 All E R 848
White Industries (Qld) Pty Ltd v Flower & Hart (a firm) (1998) 156 ALR 169

APPLICANT: Mr Marny
RESPONDENT: Mr Garnett
FILE NUMBER: MLF 3444 of 2006
DATE DELIVERED: 15 April 2014
PLACE DELIVERED: Melbourne
PLACE HEARD: Melbourne
JUDGMENT OF: Cronin J
HEARING DATE: By way of written submissions

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANTS: Ian Waller SC & Justin Mereine
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANTS: C Lawyers
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENTS: D A Klempfner, Colin Biggers & Paisley for G and G Lawyers and Mr Garnett
R McCormick for Mr B
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENTS: G Lawyers

Orders

  1. That the husband pay the costs of the applicant solicitors in relation to the application for their disqualification by agreement and in default of agreement as assessed.

  2. That the application by the applicant solicitors for costs against Mr Garnett and G Lawyers is dismissed.

IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment by this Court under the pseudonym Marny and Anor & Garnett and Ors has been approved by the Chief Justice pursuant to s 121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT MELBOURNE

FILE NUMBER: MLF 3444  of 2006

Mr Marny and Anor

Applicants

And

Mr Garnettarnett and Ors

Respondents

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 26 February 2014, I dismissed the application of Mr B in which he sought that Mr Marny and C Lawyers (“the solicitors”) be restrained from continuing to act for other respondents in substantive proceedings before the Court.  The details of those other respondents do not matter here save that, it was then foreshadowed that costs applications would be filed seeking orders not only against the husband but also his solicitors (Mr Garnett and G Lawyers).

  2. The orders I made provided for the costs applications to be by way of submission supported by such evidence as the parties saw fit and for the determination to be made in chambers.

  3. I have read the affidavit material which mainly underpinned the submissions of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marny and Anor and Garnett and Anors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FamCA 247
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Family Court of Australia considered an application for costs following the dismissal of an earlier application by Mr B seeking to restrain his former solicitors, Mr Marny and C Lawyers, from acting for other respondents in substantive proceedings. The respondents to the costs application were Mr Marny, C Lawyers, Mr Garnett, and G Lawyers. The court was asked to determine whether costs should be awarded against Mr Marny and C Lawyers, and whether costs should be awarded against Mr Garnett and G Lawyers.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether there were circumstances justifying a departure from the usual rule that each party bears their own costs, as stipulated by section 117 of the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth), and if so, what factors under section 117(2A) should be considered. A further issue was whether the costs awarded against Mr Marny should be on an indemnity basis, and whether any costs order should be made against Mr Garnett and G Lawyers.

The court found that there were justifiable circumstances to depart from the usual rule and award costs against Mr Marny. This was primarily due to his delay in bringing the application, which had been foreshadowed over several years but was only formally commenced when the substantive litigation was nearing trial. The court reasoned that such delay could be seen as a tactical weapon, causing prejudice to the opposing parties. However, the court refused to award costs on an indemnity basis against Mr Marny, citing the Full Court's decision in *Prantage and Prantage* which held that indemnity costs are a significant departure from the norm and require special or unusual features. The court also dismissed the application for costs against Mr Garnett and G Lawyers, finding that they did not act for Mr Marny in the manner previously submitted.

Consequently, the court ordered that Mr Marny pay the costs of Mr Marny and C Lawyers in relation to the application for their disqualification, to be agreed or assessed. The application by Mr Marny and C Lawyers for costs against Mr Garnett and G Lawyers was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Mr. Marny and Mr. Garnett, both of whom have engaged solicitors, C Lawyers and G Lawyers, respectively, in ongoing litigation before the Family Court of Australia. Mr. Marny filed an application seeking to restrain his former solicitors, C Lawyers, from continuing to act for other respondents in the substantive proceedings. He also sought costs against his former solicitors, Mr. Garnett, and G Lawyers. The application was dismissed by Cronin J on 26 February 2014. Subsequently, C Lawyers filed a submission seeking costs against Mr. Marny and G Lawyers on an indemnity basis, which was opposed by Mr. Marny and G Lawyers. The case centres around the principle that each party should bear their own costs unless there are justifiable circumstances to depart from this principle, as stipulated in Section 117 of the Family Law Act 1975. The solicitors argued that Mr. Marny had delayed in bringing his application, despite having multiple opportunities to object to his former solicitors acting against him, and that he was wholly unsuccessful in his application. Cronin J agreed that there were justifiable circumstances to make an order for costs against Mr. Marny, primarily due to the delay in bringing the application and his awareness of the principles involved. However, the Court found that the case did not warrant an order for indemnity costs against Mr. Marny, adhering to the well-established principle that such orders are a significant departure from the norm and are only justified in exceedingly rare situations. Additionally, the Court dismissed the application for costs against Mr. Garnett and G Lawyers, finding no evidence of improper or unreasonable conduct on their part in bringing the application on behalf of Mr. Marny.

The matter of Marny and Anor v Garnett and Anors came before the Family Court of Australia as an application for costs against the unsuccessful applicant, Mr Marny, and his former solicitors, Mr Garnett and G Lawyers. The application followed the dismissal of Mr Marny's application seeking to restrain his former solicitors from acting against him in other proceedings. Mr Marny and his solicitors sought costs on an indemnity basis against Mr Garnett and G Lawyers, as well as against Mr Garnett personally. The case was argued through written submissions, with the Court receiving affidavits and further submissions from all parties. The Court's decision focused on whether there were justifiable circumstances to order costs against Mr Marny and whether such costs should be on an indemnity basis. The Court also considered whether Mr Garnett and G Lawyers were liable for costs due to any alleged improper conduct. Ultimately, the Court found that while there were justifiable circumstances to order costs against Mr Marny, these should be assessed rather than on an indemnity basis. The Court further determined that there was no basis to hold Mr Garnett or G Lawyers liable for costs due to any alleged misconduct.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Are there justifiable circumstances to make an order for costs against the husband?
2. Should an order for indemnity costs be made against the husband?
3. Is there a basis to make an order for costs against Mr Garnett and G Lawyers for their conduct in bringing the application on behalf of the husband?

Held
1. There are justifiable circumstances to make an order for costs against the husband. The court held that the husband had slept on his rights and when cautioned about bringing the application, chose to pursue the relief unsuccessfully. Therefore, an order for costs against the husband is justified.
2. An order for indemnity costs should not be made against the husband. The court found that the husband's case was not completely without merit and he was not wholly unsuccessful. Therefore, an indemnity costs order is not appropriate in this case.
3. No order for costs should be made against Mr Garnett and G Lawyers for their conduct in bringing the application on behalf of the husband. The court held that there was no evidence to show that Mr Garnett and G Lawyers acted improperly or unreasonably when bringing the application. Therefore, no costs order should be made against them.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Family Court of Australia in Marny and Anor and Garnett and Anors [2014] FamCA 247 considered the issue of costs in relation to unsuccessful applications in family law proceedings. The court considered whether there were justifiable circumstances to make an order for costs against the husband, whether an order for indemnity costs should be made against the husband, and if there was a basis to make an order for costs against Mr Garnett and G Lawyers for their conduct in bringing the application on behalf of the husband.

The court found that there were justifiable circumstances to make an order for costs against the husband. The husband had delayed bringing his application for several years despite being aware of the potential conflict of interest. The court held that the husband had slept on his rights and was unsuccessful in his application, which justified the exercise of discretion against him. The court also considered the matters set out in s 117(2A) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) and found that the husband's lack of success was a significant factor. However, the court acknowledged that the husband had not been wholly unsuccessful and accepted that some of his arguments had merit.

The court declined to make an order for indemnity costs against the husband. The Full Court of the Family Court had established that indemnity costs were a very great departure from the normal standard and should only be awarded in exceedingly rare situations. The court found that there were no special or unusual features in this case to justify an order for indemnity costs. The court emphasized that the usual rule in this jurisdiction was that each party should bear their own costs and that the high costs incurred in litigation should be considered when exercising discretion.

The court also refused to make an order for costs against Mr Garnett and G Lawyers for their conduct in bringing the application on behalf of the husband. The court held that there was no evidence of improper or unreasonable conduct on the part of Mr Garnett and G Lawyers. The court noted that lawyers should not be deterred from pursuing their client's interests by fear of incurring a personal liability to their client's opponents. The court adopted a cautious approach and avoided drawing conclusions in hindsight against solicitors who act for litigants who do not convince courts.

In summary, the court found justifiable circumstances to make an order for costs against the husband but declined to make an order for indemnity costs. The court also refused to make an order for costs against Mr Garnett and G Lawyers for their conduct in bringing the application on behalf of the husband. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in family law proceedings, the court may make an order for costs against an unsuccessful applicant if there are justifiable circumstances, but indemnity costs should only be awarded in exceedingly rare situations. The court should exercise caution when making orders for costs against lawyers acting for unsuccessful litigants.