Marley New Zealand Ltd v Icon Plastics Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Marley New Zealand Limited v Icon Plastics Pty Ltd

[2007] FCA 851

MARLEY NEW ZEALAND LIMITED, THE MARLEY COMPANY (NZ) LIMITED AND MARLEY TILE S.A. v ICON PLASTICS PTY LTD (ACN 071 392 366)
VID 319 OF 2007

GORDON J
10 MAY 2007
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 319 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

MARLEY NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
First Applicant

THE MARLEY COMPANY (NZ) LIMITED
Second Applicant

MARLEY TILE S.A.
Third Applicant

AND:

ICON PLASTICS PTY LTD (ACN 071 392 366)
Respondent

JUDGE:

GORDON J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 MAY 2007

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

UPON the applicants, by their counsel, each UNDERTAKING to the Court to abide by any order the court may make as to damages in the event that the court should subsequently be of the opinion that the respondent sustained any damages by reason of the undertakings given by the respondent, which the applicants ought to pay,

THE RESPONDENT, by its counsel, UNDERTAKES to the Court, without admission of liability, that it will not, until the trial of the action or further order:

1.Sell, offer for sale or supply any product supplied to it by the First Applicant (Marley New Zealand Limited) pursuant to the Marley Rainwater (Gutter, Gutter Fittings and Downpipe Fittings) Supply and Distribution Agreement made between it and Marley New Zealand Limited dated 30 June 2003.

2.Sell, offer for sale or supply any product manufactured by it pursuant to the Marley Surface Drainage Licence and Supply and Distribution Agreement made between it and Marley New Zealand Limited dated 30 June 2003.

3.Use Registered Trade Mark No. 316866 for the word STORMCLOUD, or any other deceptively similar trade mark (which “Cloudburst” is not) as a trade mark in relation to building products for rainwater systems including plastic gutters, gutter fittings or downpipes, or goods or services of the same description (the Rainwater Products).

4.Use Registered Trade Mark No. 285191 for the word MARLEY, or any other deceptively similar trade mark as a trade mark in relation to the Rainwater Products.

5.Use the name “Classic”, or any other deceptively similar name, in relation to the Rainwater Products made from PVC.

6.        Represent that it is entitled or permitted to:

(a)       supply or sell;

(b)       manufacture;

(c)       act as an authorised distributor for,

any products by reference to the names Marley, Stormcloud or, in the case of Rainwater Products made from PVC, Classic.

THE RESPONDENT, by its counsel, ALSO UNDERTAKES to the Court, without admission of liability, that it will:

1.On or before 15 May 2007, send a copy of a letter sent by registered mail or courier to every company, firm or person to which it has supplied product by reference to the Marley, Stormcloud or Classic names, care of the person or persons at the company or firm concerned with whom it has had dealings since 1 July 2006, addressed by title and/or name,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marley New Zealand Ltd v Icon Plastics Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 851
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Marley New Zealand Limited, the applicant, sought an interlocutory injunction against Icon Plastics Pty Ltd, the respondent, to prevent the respondent from infringing the applicant’s registered trademarks and from supplying or selling products under the names "Stormcloud" and "Classic" in relation to rainwater systems. The dispute arose from Icon Plastics’ continued use of the aforementioned trademarks and product names after the termination of their supply agreements with Marley New Zealand. The application was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether there was a serious question to be tried and whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of an interlocutory injunction. The court needed to determine whether the applicant had demonstrated that Icon Plastics’ actions constituted trademark infringement and whether an injunction was necessary to prevent irreparable harm or unjust enrichment to Marley New Zealand. The court also had to consider the impact of the proposed injunction on Icon Plastics and its customers.

The court found that Marley New Zealand had established a serious question to be tried regarding trademark infringement and the use of deceptive trade names. The court also concluded that the balance of convenience favoured the grant of an interlocutory injunction because damages would not be an adequate remedy for the infringement of the trademarks and the unauthorised use of the product names. The court emphasised the importance of protecting registered trademarks and the potential for consumer confusion resulting from Icon Plastics' actions. The court also noted that the proposed injunction would not significantly inconvenience Icon Plastics or its customers.

The court ordered Icon Plastics to cease selling, offering for sale, or supplying any products supplied by Marley New Zealand under the Marley Rainwater Supply and Distribution Agreement or manufactured by Icon Plastics under the Marley Surface Drainage Licence and Supply and Distribution Agreement. Icon Plastics was also restrained from using the trademarks "Stormcloud" and "Marley" or any deceptively similar trademarks in relation to rainwater products. Additionally, Icon Plastics was prohibited from using the name "Classic" or any deceptively similar name in relation to PVC rainwater products. The court further required Icon Plastics to notify their customers of the injunction and to provide records of their sales and supply of rainwater products to Marley New Zealand and the court. Icon Plastics was also required to provide Marley New Zealand with a copy of any proposed advertising materials related to the sale or supply of rainwater products.

The court set a detailed timetable for the filing of pleadings, discovery, and trial, and referred the matter to mediation. The court reserved the issue of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

UPON the applicants, by their counsel, each UNDERTAKING to the Court to abide by any order the court may make as to damages in the event that the court should subsequently be of the opinion that the respondent sustained any damages by reason of the undertakings given by the respondent, which the applicants ought to pay,

THE RESPONDENT, by its counsel, UNDERTAKES to the Court, without admission of liability, that it will not, until the trial of the action or further order:

1. Sell, offer for sale or supply any product supplied to it by the First Applicant (Marley New Zealand Limited) pursuant to the Marley Rainwater (Gutter, Gutter Fittings and Downpipe Fittings) Supply and Distribution Agreement made between it and Marley New Zealand Limited dated 30 June 2003.

2. Sell, offer for sale or supply any product manufactured by it pursuant to the Marley Surface Drainage Licence and Supply and Distribution Agreement made between it and Marley New Zealand Limited dated 30 June 2003.

3. Use Registered Trade Mark No. 316866 for the word STORMCLOUD, or any other deceptively similar trade mark (which “Cloudburst” is not) as a trade mark in relation to building products for rainwater systems including plastic gutters, gutter fittings or downpipes, or goods or services of the same description (the Rainwater Products).

4. Use Registered Trade Mark No. 285191 for the word MARLEY, or any other deceptively similar trade mark as a trade mark in relation to the Rainwater Products.

5. Use the name “Classic”, or any other deceptively similar name, in relation to the Rainwater Products made from PVC.

6. Represent that it is entitled or permitted to:

(a) supply or sell;

(b) manufacture;

(c) act as an authorised distributor for,

any products by reference to the names Marley, Stormcloud or, in the case of Rainwater Products made from PVC, Classic.

THE RESPONDENT, by its counsel, ALSO UNDERTAKES to the Court, without admission of liability, that it will:

1. On or before 15 May 2007, send a copy of a letter sent by registered mail or courier to every company, firm or person to which it has supplied product by reference to the Marley, Stormcloud or Classic names, care of the person or persons at the company or firm concerned with whom it has had dealings since 1 July 2006, addressed by title and/or name, such letter to be in the form set out in Schedule A to these undertakings and orders.

2. On and after the date of this order, keep records and provide those records to the Applicants and to the Court following a direction from the Court to do so, which records must comprise the following particulars of the Respondent’s sale or supply of Rainwater Products in the course of the conduct of any business conducted, or to be conducted by the Respondent:

(a) the name and contact details of each person to whom the Respondent sells or supplies any Rainwater Products;

(b) a description of all Rainwater Products sold or supplied to each person referred to in paragraph (a) and the date(s) on which each of those products was sold or supplied;

(c) all sums received by the Respondent for or in respect of the sale or supply of any of the products referred to in paragraph(a)and the date of receipt of each sum.

3. The Respondent provide to the solicitors for the Applicants a copy of any form of brochure, pamphlet or advertising which the Respondent proposes to provide to retailers in relation to the sale or supply of Rainwater Products sold or supplied by reference to the Cloudburst trade mark not less than three business days before the Respondent provides it to retailers.

THE COURT ORDERS AS FOLLOWS:

1. By 4pm on 14 May 2007, the Applicants file and serve any amended application and any amended statement of claim.

2. By 4pm on 18 May 2007, the Respondent file and serve its defence and any cross claim.

3. By 4pm on 23 May 2007, the Applicants file and serve any Reply and Defence to Cross-Claim.

4. By 4pm on 25 May 2007, the parties exchange categories of discoverable documents.

5. By 4pm on 5 June 2007, the parties file and serve lists of documents and give inspection from 9am on 6 June 2007.

6. By 4pm on 8 June 2007, the Applicants file and serve any further affidavits upon which they intend to rely at trial and give notice to the Respondent as to which existing affidavits, or parts of affidavits, they intend to rely upon at trial.

7. By 4pm on 15 June 2007, the Respondent file and serve any further affidavits upon which it intends to rely at trial and give notice to the Applicants as to which parts of the affidavit of Mike Duskovic dated 3 May 2007 they intend to rely upon at trial.

8. By 4pm on 22 June 2007, the Applicants file and serve any affidavits in reply only to the affidavits referred to in paragraph 7 above.

9. The matter be referred to mediation pursuant to Order 72, such mediation to be conducted between 14 June 2007 and 29 June 2007.

10. By 4pm on 3 July 2007, the Applicants file and serve a paginated Court Book.

11. By 4pm on 6 July 2007, the parties file and serve any notices of objections to evidence.

12. By 4pm on 13 July 2007, the parties file and serve contentions of law and fact.

13. The matter be set down for trial to commence on 16 July 2007 at 9.30 am for a duration of not more than five days.

14. Liberty to apply on 48 hours written notice.

15. Costs be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

The principles applicable to the grant of interlocutory injunction were not in dispute: is there a serious question to be tried and secondly, does the balance of convenience favour the grant of an injunction because either damages would be an inadequate remedy or because it is otherwise just in all the circumstances: Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 618 at 622-623 cited with approval by Gummow and Hayne JJ in Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill [2006] HCA 46 at [65]-[72]; and Hurst (by her next friend) (Gail Smith) v State of Queensland [2006] FCAFC 151 at par 20ff (per Ryan, Finn and Weinberg JJ). SUMMARY OF THE FACTS AND ISSUES Before proceeding to consider Marley’s complaints and the form of the interlocutory relief sought by Marley, it is necessary to set out a summary of what, on the evidence as it now stands, is said to be the factual basis of the various claims. Prior to June 2003, Icon was called Marley Plastics Pty Ltd and was associated with at least some of the applicants. The shares in Icon were sold to its present owners in June 2003. From that date until 31 December 2006, Icon imported from Marley New Zealand Limited (“Marley NZ”) and sold “Stormcloud” and “Classic” PVC guttering. The imported products were also sold by Icon by reference to the name “Marley”. Both “Marley” and “Stormcloud” were and remain registered Trade Marks owned by Marley NZ and used by them in relation to various building products [Resps Subs, par 2.1]. Marley NZ supplied the “Stormcloud” and “Classic” PVC guttering to Icon pursuant to two agreements: the Marley Rainwater (Gutter, Gutter Fittings and Downpipe Fittings) Supply and Distribution Agreement dated 30 June 2003 between Icon and Marley NZ (“the Rainwater Agreement”) and the Marley Surface Drainage Licence Supply and Distribution Agreement dated 30 June 2003 between Icon and Marley NZ. Also, until 31 December 2006, Icon was entitled to sell the products supplied by Marley under and by reference to the names “Classic” and “Stormcloud” pursuant to a “Trade Name Licence and Product Warranty Agreement” between Marley NZ and Icon. I will refer to these agreements as the “Marley Agreements”. Although pursuant to the Marley Agreements, Marley sold to Icon and Icon purchased from Marley the “Stormcloud” and “Classic” PVC guttering, Icon in fact manufactured other component parts for the “Stormcloud” and “Classic” PVC guttering systems (for example downpipes, downpipe fittings and elbows) from moulds that it owned. Icon sold these component parts to Marley NZ and to customers in Australia. Both the Marley supplied products and the Icon supplied products used a common product code system. The product codes commenced with the prefix “1” followed by a two, three or four letter and / or number code. Each product had its own part number. For example, the 2.9 meter length of “Stormcloud” Gutter Spouting manufactured by Marley and supplied to Icon had the part number “1MS1.2.9”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GORDON J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GORDON J