Mantle v The Body Corporate for Coronation Gardens

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CITATION: Mantle & Anor v The Body Corporate for Coronation Gardens [2019] QCATA 17
PARTIES:

SUE MANTLE

and

ROGER MANTLE

(appellants)

v

THE BODY CORPORATE FOR CORONATION GARDENS CTS 24610

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S: APL106-18
ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S: APL1087-2017
MATTER TYPE: Appeals
DELIVERED ON: 19 February 2019
HEARING DATE: 11 February 2019
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Member Roney QC
ORDERS: The appeal is dismissed.
CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – RIGHT OF APPEAL – WHEN APPEAL

LIES – ERROR OF LAW – where s 289(2) of the Body Corporate Community Management Act 1997 (Qld) allows a person aggrieved by an Adjudicator‘s order to appeal on a question of law to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal – what is error of law – whether there was an error of law

REAL PROPERTY – STRATA AND RELATED TITLES – MANAGEMENT AND CONTROL –

BYLAWS – whether committee acted reasonably in denying lot owner’s application – whether body corporate acted reasonably in seeking enforcement of contravention notice concerning non compliant painting of premises

Body Corporate Community Management Act 1997 (Qld), s 276, s 289, s 290, s 559, s 168, s 169, s 182-188

Ainsworth & Ors v Albrecht & Anor (2016) 261 CLR 167; [2016] HCA 40

Albrecht v Ainsworth & Ors [2015] QCA 220

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v HREOC [1997] FCA 1311; (1997) 150 ALR 1

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Appellants: Self-represented
Respondent: Pamela Whitcombe, Ronald Griffiths and Nicole Pearson

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. The Appellants are owners of lot 50 (Unit 40) at Coronation Gardens at Paradise Springs Avenue Robina on the Gold Coast. In 2016 they had the exterior of their Unit repainted to colours of their own choosing. The colours they chose are conservative and sympathetic to the colours used on adjoining and other units in the complex. They were not, however, the colours which the Body Corporate had determined were to be applied to all of the residences in the complex and they were not precisely the same colours in some respects as appeared on trim and other features of other residences in the complex, which had adopted the colours which the Body Corporate had determined were to be applied to all of the residences in the complex. It would seem to be a case which proves Plato’s proposition that beauty lies in the eyes of the beholder.

  2. By-Law 20.1 for the scheme states that ‘No person is to ... undertake any ... painting

    ... on any Lot unless that ... undertaking is first approved in writing by the Body Corporate.’

  3. The approved colours which the Body Corporate had specified at Coronation Gardens for external areas of private residential lots such as the Appellants’ were two colours that must be used in combination: a lighter cream colour for the main surfaces and a contrasting darker mustard colour on areas such as pillars, cross beams and trims. The approved products are either Taubmans / Dulux…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mantle v The Body Corporate for Coronation Gardens and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCATA 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mantle v The Body Corporate for Coronation Gardens concerns a dispute between a lot owner and the body corporate concerning the painting of premises. The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal had to determine whether there was an error of law in the adjudicator's decision. The key issue was whether the lot owner's opposition to the painting proposal was unreasonable, and if the adjudicator and the Court of Appeal erred in their assessments of this issue. The High Court's decision in Ainsworth & Ors v Albrecht & Anor provided a critical framework, clarifying that the test for unreasonableness is not whether all relevant circumstances were considered, but whether opposition to a proposal was unreasonable given the potential appropriation of common property and alterations to its features.

The court examined the reasoning behind the adjudicator's decision and found that she had addressed the wrong question, focusing on the reasonableness of the decision rather than the reasonableness of the opposition. This misstep led to an erroneous conclusion that the lot owner's opposition was unreasonable. The Court of Appeal also erred by not recognising that opposition based on valid concerns could not be deemed unreasonable. The High Court's guidance in Ainsworth underscored the need for a nuanced approach to assessing opposition, considering the potential impacts on common property and the privacy of lot owners.

The appeal was dismissed, reaffirming the importance of correctly applying the legal test for unreasonableness in disputes under the Body Corporate Community Management Act 1997 (Qld). The court's decision emphasised that opposition to a proposal should not be deemed unreasonable merely because it raises legitimate concerns, particularly when it involves significant alterations to common property. This ruling provides clarity for future cases involving lot owner opposition and the assessment of reasonableness by adjudicators and tribunals.

Orders

Orders of the court

The appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the judgement of the majority in the High Court in Ainsworth & Ors v Albrecht & Anor (2016) 261 CLR 167, what was said at [51]-[53] was as follows:The reliance by the Court of Appeal and by the first respondent in this Court upon the judgments in Waters v Public Transport Corporation was misplaced. That case was concerned with the duty of a decision-making body to reach a reasonable decision taking into account competing considerations. A lot owner voting his or her opposition to a motion is not a decision-maker of this kind. The adjudicator's task under Item 10 of Sched 5 is not to determine whether the outcome of the vote of the general meeting of the Body Corporate was a reasonable balancing of competing considerations, but whether the opposition of lot owners to the proposal was unreasonable. Given that the adjudicator's concern with s 94(2) led her to address the wrong question, namely whether the Body Corporate's decision was reasonable, her ultimate conclusion was inevitably affected by an error of law. The same error infected the approach of the Court of Appeal. Once the Court of Appeal accepted, as it did, that the grounds of opposition to the proposal considered by the adjudicator raised questions in respect of which reasonable minds may differ as to the answer, it is impossible to see how opposition to the first respondent's proposal based on those grounds could be found to be unreasonable. (emphasis added) That conclusion by the High Court serves to emphasise that the test for unreasonableness is not whether someone objectively considered all relevant circumstances, except perhaps in the context of there being a duty on a decision- making body to reach a reasonable decision taking into account competing considerations. Moreover committees, like bodies corporates, generally have their own interests to consider and that informs the way in which their decisions are to be Hence as the majority the High Court said in Ainsworth at [55]:It is no light thing to conclude that opposition by a lot owner to a resolution is unreasonable where adoption of the resolution will have the effect of: appropriating part of the common property to the exclusive use of the owner of another lot, for no return to the body corporate or the other lot owners; altering the features of the common property which it exhibited at the time an objecting lot owner acquired his or her lot; and potentially creating a risk of interference with the tranquillity or privacy of an objecting lot owner. In the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was correct to hold that the adjudicator erred in law in reaching that conclusion; and the Court of Appeal erred in concluding otherwise. The ultimate finding of the Adjudicator was as follows:[74] This is an unfortunate dispute. I note that there is no material before me to suggest that the respondents acted under anything but an honest mistaken belief that they had received approval to do what they did. Having then acted upon that honest belief, at some effort and expense, it is not surprising that they resisted the remediation requests.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established