Manolo Blahnik Worldwide Limited v Estro Concept Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

Federal Court of Australia

Manolo Blahnik Worldwide Limited v Estro Concept Pty Limited [2020] FCA 1561

File number: NSD 609 of 2020
Judgment of: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 29 October 2020
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for preliminary discovery pursuant to r 7.22 and r 7.23 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – whether prospective applicant has sufficient information to decide whether to commence a proceeding against prospective respondent – application allowed
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2, ss 18, 29

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), s 120

Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth), r O 15A r 6 (repealed)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), rr 7.22, 7.23

Cases cited:

BCI Media Group Pty Ltd v Corelogic Australia Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1556

Bonham v Iluka Resources Ltd (2017) 252 FCR 58

Dallas Buyers Club LLC v iiNet Ltd (2015) 245 FCR 129

E D Oates Pty Ltd v Edgar Edmondson Imports [2012] FCA 607

Hooper v Kirella Pty Ltd (1999) 96 FCR 1

McFarlane as Trustee for the S McFarlane Superannuation Fund v IOOF Holdings Limited [2018] FCA 692

ObjectiVision Pty Ltd v Visionsearch Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1087

Optiver Australia Pty Ltd v Tibra Trading Pty Ltd (2008) 169 FCR 435

Pfizer Ireland Pharmaceuticals v Samsung Bioepis AU Pty Ltd (2017) 257 FCR 62

Quanta Software International Pty Ltd v Computer Management Services Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 969; (2000) 175 ALR 536

Siemens Industry Software Inc v Telstra Corporation Limited [2020] FCA 901

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Trade Marks
Number of paragraphs: 95
Date of hearing: 4 August 2020
Counsel for the Prospective Applicant: Mr C McMeniman
Solicitor for the Prospective Applicant: DLA Piper Australia
Counsel for the Prospective Respondent: Mr A D B Fox
Solicitor for the Prospective Respondent: ClarkeKann Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 609 of 2020
BETWEEN:

MANOLO BLAHNIK WORLDWIDE LIMITED

Prospective Applicant

AND:

ESTRO CONCEPT PTY LIMITED ACN 169 608 548

Prospective Respondent

order made by:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 October 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to r 7.23 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Rules), the prospective respondent is to give discovery to the prospective applicant of documents that refer to, relate to or record:

(a)in respect of each of the Goods supplied to the prospective respondent by Codimark Projects Pty Ltd (Supplier) (Goods Received):

(i)the style, colour-way and size (including but not limited to photographs) of the Goods Received;

(ii)the quantity of the Goods Received; and

(iii)the unit price that the prospective respondent has paid, or is required to pay, to the Supplier for the Goods Received; and

(b)in respect of each of the Goods that the prospective respondent has sold to its customers (Goods Sold):

(i)the style, colour-way and size (including but not limited to photographs) of the Goods Sold;

(ii)the quantity of the Goods Sold; and

(iii)the unit price that each of the prospective respondent’s customers…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Manolo Blahnik Worldwide Limited v Estro Concept Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1561
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Manolo Blahnik Worldwide Limited v Estro Concept Pty Limited, the plaintiff sought an order for preliminary discovery of documents and examination of the defendant under rules 7.22 and 7.23 of the Federal Court Rules 2011. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant had supplied and sold goods bearing the "MANOLO BLAHNIK" brand without authorisation. The court was required to decide whether the plaintiff had provided sufficient information to warrant the discovery of documents and the examination of the defendant's proper officer.

The court considered the evidence provided by Mr Autore, who had disclosed the identity of the supplier. The plaintiff argued that Mr Autore's evidence lacked detail and should be cross-examined. However, the court held that the plaintiff had not tested the evidence by attempting to contact the supplier. As a result, the court was not satisfied that the plaintiff was unable to ascertain the identity of the supplier of the disputed products. The court rejected the plaintiff's application for examination of the defendant's proper officer. However, the court granted the plaintiff's application for discovery of certain documents related to the goods supplied by the defendant's supplier and the goods sold by the defendant.

The court ordered that the defendant provide documents that refer to, relate to or record the style, colour-way and size, quantity, and unit price of the goods supplied by the supplier and sold by the defendant. The parties were required to agree on the dates for the filing and service of a list of documents and the manner of inspection of the discovered documents. The court also ordered that the parties provide submissions on the costs of the provision of the discovery and the proceeding. Unless a party requested an oral hearing, the question of costs would be determined on the papers.

The court held that once it was satisfied of the matters in rule 7.23(1), it retained a discretion as to whether it would order discovery by the prospective respondent of documents of the kind set out in rule 7.23(1)(c)(i). The court considered the evidence provided by Mr Autore and held that the plaintiff had not tested the evidence by attempting to contact the supplier. As a result, the court was not satisfied that the plaintiff was unable to ascertain the identity of the supplier of the disputed products. However, the court granted the plaintiff's application for discovery of certain documents related to the goods supplied by the defendant's supplier and the goods sold by the defendant. The court also ordered that the parties provide submissions on the costs of the provision of the discovery and the proceeding. Unless a party requested an oral hearing, the question of costs would be determined on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to r 7.23 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Rules), the prospective respondent is to give discovery to the prospective applicant of documents that refer to, relate to or record:

(a) in respect of each of the Goods supplied to the prospective respondent by Codimark Projects Pty Ltd (Supplier) (Goods Received):

(i) the style, colour-way and size (including but not limited to photographs) of the Goods Received;

(ii) the quantity of the Goods Received; and

(iii) the unit price that the prospective respondent has paid, or is required to pay, to the Supplier for the Goods Received; and

(b) in respect of each of the Goods that the prospective respondent has sold to its customers (Goods Sold):

(i) the style, colour-way and size (including but not limited to photographs) of the Goods Sold;

(ii) the quantity of the Goods Sold; and

(iii) the unit price that each of the prospective respondent’s customers have paid for the Goods Sold.

2. For the purposes of Order 1, the term “Goods” shall mean:

(a) the Disputed Products as defined in paragraph 16 of the affidavit of Natalie Lauren Caton sworn on 1 June 2020 and filed in this proceeding by the prospective applicant; or

(b) goods, including but not limited to shoes, that bear the name, mark or brand “MANOLO”, “BLAHNIK” or “MANOLO BLAHNIK”.

3. The parties are to agree on the dates for the filing and service of a list of documents in accordance with r 7.25 of the Rules and the manner of inspection of the discovered documents. If the parties cannot agree on either of those matters, liberty is given to any party to relist the proceeding on three days’ notice for further orders.

4. Within 14 days of the date of these Orders, the prospective applicant is to file and serve any submissions, not exceeding three pages in length, in relation to the question of the costs of the provision of the discovery the subject of Order 1 and of this application.

5. Within 28 days of the date of these Orders, the prospective respondent is to file and serve its submissions, not exceeding three pages in length, in relation to the question of the costs of the provision of the discovery the subject of Order 1 and of this application.

6. Unless a party requests that there be an oral hearing, the question of costs of the provision of the discovery the subject of Order 1 and of this application will be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

To the extent that Manolo Blahnik wished to put in doubt estimates provided by Mr Autore in relation to quantities of “MANOLO BLAHNIK” branded products received or sold by it, it remained open to Manolo Blahnik to refer me to the competing evidence that it submitted was available and to make appropriate submissions. To that end, there was nothing in the evidence relied on by Manolo Blahnik that, on its face, undermined the estimates provided by Mr Autore and which might be put to him. To the extent that Manolo Blahnik wished to submit that Mr Autore’s evidence was lacking in detail, that was a matter that could be put by way of submission based on the evidence and did not, in my opinion, require cross-examination. Conclusion I will make orders in accordance with these reasons. The parties agreed that I should reserve on the question of costs, which I understood to be both in relation to the costs of the provision of the discovery by Estro pursuant to r 7.23 of the Rules and the costs of the proceeding. Accordingly, I will also make orders requiring the parties to provide submissions on those questions. Unless either party indicates to the contrary, those questions will be determined on the papers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Once the Court is satisfied of the matters in r 7.23(1), it retains a discretion as to whether it will order discovery by the prospective respondent of documents of the kind set out in r 7.23(1)(c)(i): see r 7.23(2) of the Rules.ConsiderationRelief sought under r 7.22 of the Rules Manolo Blahnik seeks an order pursuant to r 7.22 of the Rules that Estro by its proper officer attend before the Court for examination about the description of all persons or entities that have supplied it with, in effect, the Disputed Products or other goods bearing the MB Trade Marks or the “MANOLO”, “BLAHNIK” or “MANOLO BLAHNIK” name or brand and that it produce documents which refer to, relate to or record the identity and contact information of those entities. This order is sought despite Mr Autore now providing the identity of the Supplier. Manolo Blahnik submits that the information about the identity of the Supplier is given by someone who is a consultant and not Estro’s proper officer who it says would be its sole director, secretary and shareholder as disclosed in a search of Estro obtained from the Australian Securities and Investments Commission in evidence before me, Niral Patel. Estro submits that there are other reasons why I would not accept Mr Autore’s evidence (see [80] below), that he has not been frank with the Court and that the only way that Manolo Blahnik will truly know the identity of Estro’s supplier(s) is by seeing documents which identify its or their name(s) and to have Estro’s proper officer examined on that issue. Mr Autore has a relatively detailed knowledge of Estro’s business and has disclosed the name of the Supplier. Manolo Blahnik accepts the evidence of the identity of the Supplier but submits that, even if it had made inquiries of the Supplier, it may only be one of a number of sources from whom Estro received the Disputed Products. While there may be other aspects of his evidence that are not satisfactory (as described at [82] below), I would not reject the whole of Mr Autore’s evidence. In particular, I am not persuaded that there is any proper basis to reject his evidence in relation to the identity of the Supplier. There is simply no evidence that there is more than one supplier. In that regard, Manolo Blahnik has not tested the evidence provided by Mr Autore as to the identity of the Supplier by, for example, attempting to contact the Supplier. In short, given the disclosure of the identity of the Supplier, and notwithstanding the lack of precision in other aspects of Mr Autore’s evidence, it cannot be said that Manolo Blahnik is unable to ascertain the identity of the supplier of the Disputed Products. Accordingly, I am not satisfied that the order sought by Manolo Blahnik pursuant to r 7.22 of the Rules should be made.Relief sought under r 7.23 of the Rules Manolo Blahnik seeks an order pursuant to r 7.23 of the Rules that Estro give discovery of five categories of documents that relate to the relationship between Estro and its supplier and the extent of the “MANOLO BLAHNIK” branded stock held and sales of such goods made by Estro (see [4] above).