Manicaros v Commercial Images (Aust) Pty Ltd (in liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Manicaros v Commercial Images (Aust) Pty Ltd (in liq) [2024] QCA 40

PARTIES:

MICHAELA MANICAROS
(appellant)
v
COMMERCIAL IMAGES (AUST) PTY LTD
(in liquidation)
ACN 011 023 617
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 6955 of 2023
DC No 4568 of 2018

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


District Court at Brisbane - [2023] QDC 77 (Porter KC DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

22 March 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

18 September 2023

JUDGES:

Flanagan JA, Buss AJA and Kelly J

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – LIMITATION OF ACTIONS – EXTENSION OR POSTPONEMENT OF LIMITATION PERIODS – CONFIRMATION – ACKNOWLEDGMENTS – where the respondent commenced proceedings for recovery of debts owed by the appellant – where the issue was whether the respondent’s claim was barred because the respondent had not commenced proceedings within the time limit prescribed by s 10(1)(a) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 (Qld) (the Act) – where the respondent contended the appellant acknowledged the debts after the limitation period had expired and the claim for the debts accrued afresh in accordance with s 35(3) and s 36 of the Act – where the appellant signed company financial accounts recording historical debts – where the appellant referred to the debts in an affidavit filed in alternative proceedings – whether the appellant acknowledged the debts owed to the respondent in accordance with the Act – whether the appeal should be allowed

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 9, s 45A, s 286, s 292, s 295, s 296, s 297
Limitation Act 1939 (UK), s 23, s 24
Limitation of Actions Act 1974 (Qld), s 10, s 35, s 36
Statute of Frauds Amendment Act 1828 (UK), s 1

Australian Executor Trustees Ltd v Lokit Investments Pty Ltd [2023] VSC 141, cited
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Healey (2011) 196 FCR 291; [2011] FCA 717, cited
Bucknell v Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd (1937) 58 CLR 155; [1937] HCA 35, cited
Giacci v Giacci Holdings Pty Ltd [2010] WASCA 233, cited
Hepburn v McDonnell (1918) 25 CLR 199; [1918] HCA 43, cited
Hipworth v Mahar (1952) 87 CLR 335; [1952] HCA 43, considered
In re Flynn, (decd) (No 2) [1969] 2 Ch 403, cited
In re Gee & Co (Woolwich) Ltd [1975] Ch 52, cited
Re Compania de Electricidadde la Provincia de Buenos Aires Ltd [1980] Ch 146, cited
The Stage Club Ltd v Millers Hotels Pty Ltd (1981) 150 CLR 535; [1981] HCA 71, cited
VL Finance Pty Ltd v Legudi (2003) 54 ATR 221; [2003] VSC 57, considered

COUNSEL:

A J Morris KC, with I A Erskine, for the appellant
C A Wilkins KC for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Cronin Miller Litigation for the appellant
Colin Biggers & Paisley for the respondent

  1. FLANAGAN JA:  I agree with Buss AJA.

  2. BUSS AJA:  The appellant appeals from a judgment…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Manicaros v Commercial Images (Aust) Pty Ltd (in liq) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCA 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Manicaros v Commercial Images (Aust) Pty Ltd (in liq), the court was required to determine whether the respondent's claim for recovery of debts was barred by the limitation period prescribed under section 10(1)(a) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 (Qld). The primary issue before the court was whether the appellant's acknowledgment of the debts after the limitation period had expired was sufficient to restart the limitation period in accordance with sections 35(3) and 36 of the Act. The respondent argued that the appellant's signing of the company's financial accounts, which recorded historical debts, and the appellant's reference to the debts in an affidavit filed in alternative proceedings, constituted acknowledgments of the debts. The appellant, however, contended that these actions did not amount to acknowledgments under the Act.

The court considered whether the alleged acknowledgments met the criteria set out in the Act. The trial judge found that the 2016 accounts, which the appellant signed, contained an admission of liability for the debts and thus constituted an acknowledgment. The judge concluded that the formal declaration in the 2016 Directors' Declaration, the inclusion of the debts as current assets in the balance sheet, and the appellant's unique position as both a director and debtor all supported the conclusion that the accounts objectively acknowledged the appellant's liability. The court also noted that the notes to the accounts did not suggest otherwise and that the accruals basis and historic cost warnings did not affect the liability in debt.

Ultimately, the court held that the appellant's signing of the 2016 accounts and the reference to the debts in the affidavit were indeed acknowledgments under the Act, thereby restarting the limitation period. The appeal was dismissed, and the respondent was granted costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 31 October 2017, Boddice J ordered in the oppression proceedings that Darryl Kirk, registered liquidator, be appointed as the provisional liquidator of the respondent until the making of a winding up order or further order. On 15 February 2018, the Supreme Court of Queensland made consent orders for the winding up of the respondent and the appointment of Mr Kirk as liquidator. On 19 December 2018, the respondent, by its liquidator, commenced the primary proceedings.The background facts and circumstances The trial judge found that the background facts and circumstances to the litigation were, relevantly, as follows. The 2016 accounts recorded that during each year between the year ended 30 June 2005 and the year ended 30 June 2009, the respondent made loans to each of the appellant (that is, Ms Manicaros) and Mr Verschoyle. The amounts of those loans were recorded in Note 6 to the 2016 accounts as follows: His Honour found that the appellant incurred debts to the respondent as recorded in Note 6 [11]. The trial judge said that the 2016 accounts recorded a debt due from the respondent to the appellant of $55,521 [11]. The respondent did not dispute the existence or amount of that debt. Consequently, the net amount claimed by the respondent from the appellant in the primary proceedings was $631,276.The 2016 accounts Crowe Horwath were the accountants for the respondent. Crowe Horwath prepared the 2016 accounts for the respondent as client. The 2016 accounts included a trading statement and a profit and loss statement. The trading statement showed a gross profit from trading of $1,396,588 in 2015 and $1,247,732 in 2016. The profit and loss statement showed a profit of $58,398 in 2015 and a loss of $19,930 in 2016. The 2016 accounts included a balance sheet, relevantly, as follows: The 2016 accounts included a reconciliation of the respondent’s equity. The total equity as at 30 June 2015 was $757,728 and the total equity as at 30 June 2016 was $737,798. The Notes to the 2016 accounts were set out on pages 7 and 8. In Note 1 it was stated that the financial statements were “a special purpose report prepared for use by directors and the member [sic]” and that the directors of the respondent had determined that the respondent was not a reporting entity. Page 13 of the 2016 accounts contained a Directors’ Declaration (the 2016 Directors’ Declaration), signed by each of the appellant and Mr Verschoyle and hand dated 11 November 2016. Each of them signed adjacent to the typewritten description “Director”. The declaration provides:DIRECTORS’ DECLARATION The directors have determined that [the respondent] is not a reporting entity and that this special purpose financial report should be prepared in accordance with the accounting policies outlined in Note 1 to the financial statements.In accordance with a resolution of the directors of [the respondent], the directors of [the respondent] declare that: 1.the financial statements and notes as set out on pages 2 to 12 present fairly [the respondent’s] financial position as at 30 June 2016 and its performance for the year ended on that date in accordance with the accounting policies outlined in Note 1 to the financial statements; and2.in the directors’ opinion there are reasonable grounds to believe that [the respondent] will be able to pay its debts as and when they become due and payable.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

His Honour said that each of the alleged acknowledgments relied upon by the respondent was in writing. His Honour also said that the appellant accepted at the trial that each of the alleged acknowledgments was signed by her or (in the case of correspondence from her solicitor) her agent. His Honour then said that each of the other conditions was contentious in respect of each of the alleged acknowledgments [57].The trial judge’s findings and conclusion in relation to the appellant’s alleged acknowledgment of the debts by signing, on 11 November 2016, the 2016 accounts The trial judge held that the 2016 accounts contained an admission by the appellant of her liability to the respondent for the debts and therefore an acknowledgment of the debts [132]. His Honour said that the admission of the debts arose objectively from the following features of the 2016 accounts [133]:(a)First, [the appellant] signs [the 2016 Directors’ Declaration] which states that the 2016 accounts present fairly the financial position of [the respondent] as at 30 June 2016. That declaration is in a formal form, objectively communicating that the matters declared are not casually stated but are, rather, the result of careful consideration;(b)Second, the 2016 accounts show that [the appellant] owed [the respondent] five specified debts totalling $686,797. Those liabilities were included in the balance sheet as current assets of [the respondent]. A current asset is defined in AASB 101 at paragraph 66 in this manner ([The] parties accepted I could use that standard to inform my understanding of the expression as a term of art in financial accounting: see TS 2-21.42):An entity shall classify an asset as current when:(a) it expects to realise the asset, or intends to sell or consume it, in its normal operating cycle;(b) it holds the asset primarily for the purpose of trading;(c) it expects to realise the asset within twelve months after the reporting period; or(d) the asset is cash or a cash equivalent (as defined in AASB 107)unless the asset is restricted from being exchanged or used to settle a liability for at least twelve months after the reporting period.An entity shall classify all other assets as non-current.(c)Unsecured loans will ordinarily fall within 66(c) or 66(d). The 2016 accounts are professionally prepared in relation to a company carrying on business. In construing objectively whether the accounts (prepared for a commercial trading corporation) contains an acknowledgment, I consider that matters of commercial accounting can be taken into account. In any event, the ordinary meaning of the expression “current asset” in relation to a loan is broadly consistent with its technical accounting meaning. Both are consistent with identification of a current and enforceable liability (bearing in mind that it is not evident on the face of the accounts that the debts are repayable on demand and therefore prima facie statute barred).(d)Third, without the inclusion of the debts due from [the appellant], [the respondent] would be barely solvent on a balance sheet basis, with net assets of just $51,000. Accordingly, the accounts could not “fairly present the company’s financial position” unless [the appellant] was liable to [the respondent] for those debts. [The appellant’s] declaration can only be correct if [the appellant] is liable for those debts;(e)Fourth, as both director (privy to the books and records of the company) and as debtor (with knowledge of the circumstances of the advances identified) she was in a unique position to know whether those particular liabilities (being her debts due to the company) were correctly recorded. Her declaration that the accounts fairly represent the financial position of [the respondent] therefore has unique force in relation to these debts as compared to the other assets and liabilities shown. Reading the document objectively, a reader would be justified in assuming the director was affirming her liability for her own disclosed debts; and(f)Fifth, there is nothing in the Notes which suggest otherwise. The fact that the accounts were prepared on an accruals basis has no impact on a liability in debt, especially historic debts. Similarly the warning that the accounts are based on historic costs and do not take into account changing money values has no impact on the liability in debt, which is a monetary asset unaffected by “changing money values”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established