Mane Market Pty Ltd v Temple No. Scgrg-96-2017 Judgment No. S6986

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

MANE MARKET PTY LTD & ORS v TEMPLE
[1998] SASC S6986

Civil

Debelle J

  1. The plaintiffs allege that the defendant has acted in breach of a Mareva injunction ordered by this court.  They have made three applications each of which seeks, among other orders, the issue of a Registrar’s summons for contempt.  To put the applications in context, I set out the factual background.

  2. In this action, which was commenced on 4 October 1996, the plaintiffs claim damages from the defendant for alleged breaches of his duties both as a director and an employee of the plaintiff companies.  The Statement of Claim includes allegations that the defendant misappropriated an amount in excess of $700,000. 

  3. On 30 January 1997 the plaintiffs obtained an ex parte interim order for a Mareva injunction restraining the defendant from dealing in any way with his assets.  After argument on 20 February 1997 a fresh interlocutory order with a Mareva injunction was made until further order.  The injunction restrains the defendant and his wife and any company, trust or other entity owned or controlled by them from disposing of and dealing in or removing out of South Australia any property or interest in property.  The order is couched in very wide terms.  The order lists several named assets and operated in respect of any beneficial interest of the defendant and his wife in any trust.  The order was served on the defendant on 7 March 1997.

The First Application

  1. The defendant had an interest in a trust called “The Temple Weeks Trust”.  On 20 April 1998 the defendant by deed assigned his interest in the trust in consideration of the payment of $50,000.  The sum of $50,000 has been paid to the defendant.  He has used the money to pay for various household and other expenses and to repay a loan made by his parents.  The plaintiffs’ first application, which is dated 1 June 1995, is for an order that the defendant’s action in assigning his interest in the trust is in breach of the Mareva injunction ordered on 20 February 1997 and for an order that a Registrar’s summons for contempt should issue.  The defendant admits the breach of the order but denies that he has acted in contempt of the order.  The contempt is denied on the ground that the breach was not contumacious.

  2. When determining whether a Registrar’s summons should issue, the court is exercising a screening function somewhat similar to that exercised by a magistrate in committal proceedings in respect of a criminal offence.  To make an order that a Registrar’s summons should issue, the court must be satisfied that there is sufficient evidence which, if accepted, would prove the contempt.  When determining whether there is sufficient evidence, it must be remembered that there is no longer any distinction between civil and criminal contempts.  All contempts should be punished as if they are quasi-criminal in character:  Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union v Mudginberri Station Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 98 at 109,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mane Market Pty Ltd v Temple No. Scgrg-96-2017 Judgment No.... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6986
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Mane Market Pty Ltd v Temple, the plaintiffs alleged that the defendant breached a Mareva injunction ordered by the court. The plaintiffs made three applications seeking, among other orders, the issue of a Registrar’s summons for contempt. The first application concerned the defendant’s assignment of his interest in The Temple Weeks Trust. The defendant admitted the breach but denied acting in contempt, arguing that the breach was not contumacious. The court found that it was not appropriate to determine whether the breach was contumacious at that stage. The court found that there was sufficient evidence to justify the issue of a Registrar’s summons for contempt.

The second application concerned the defendant’s withdrawal of $7,000 from a telephone betting account at the Totalizator Agency Board (TAB) on 1 February 1997. The defendant admitted the withdrawal but denied that it was in breach of the injunction. The court found that there was prima facie evidence of a breach of the injunction and ordered the issue of a Registrar’s summons for contempt.

The third application concerned the failure of Southern Hotels Pty Ltd to produce a telephone betting withdrawal slip which was the subject of a subpoena. The defendant’s solicitors had been in possession of a copy of the slip for some time but had not sought to inspect the original. The court found that there was a prima facie case for the issue of a Registrar’s summons for contempt in respect of the destruction of the withdrawal slip.

The defendant applied to vary the terms of the Mareva injunction to enable him to pay his legal fees and ordinary living expenses. The defendant had admitted a breach of the Mareva injunction and there were facts which justified the issue of a Registrar’s summons for contempt in respect of the other two alleged breaches. However, the court exercised its discretion to hear the defendant’s application, with certain conditions. The court considered the principles of procedural fairness and the defendant’s right to conduct his defence, notwithstanding the alleged contempt. The court also considered the defendant’s gambling activities and the need to prevent dissipation of his assets in that way. The court remitted the matter for enquiry by a master as to how much should be allowed for living expenses and legal expenses.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established