Main and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Main and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2025] ARTA 45 (29 January 2025)

Applicant:Robert Michael Main

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2024/9350

Tribunal:Deputy President O’Donovan

Place:Brisbane 

Date:29 January 2025  

Decision:The decision under review is set aside and substituted with a decision not to cancel the applicant’s visa.

Catchwords

MIGRATION – decision to cancel visa – character test – substantial criminal record – murder – armed robbery  – Direction no. 110 – primary and other considerations – protection of Australian community – nature and seriousness of criminal offending – risk to the Australian community should the Applicant commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct – strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia – best interests of minor children in Australia – expectations of the Australian community – extent of impediments if removed – citizen of United States of America – cancellation decision is set aside

Legislation

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – ss 499(1), 499(2A), 500(1)(b), 501(2), 501(7), 501(6)(a)

Cases

Gray and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2024] AATA 3363 (13 September 2024)

HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCAFC 202

Moana v Minister for Immigration and Border protection [2015] FCAFC 54

Secretary to the Department of Justice and Regulation v LLG [2018] VSCA 155

Suleiman v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 594

Secondary Materials

Direction No. 110: Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA

Statement of Reasons

  1. The applicant was born in California in the United States of America (the US) in 1955.[1] When he was twelve, he moved with his family to Australia.[2] He never became an Australian citizen.

    [1] G-Documents, p 365.

    [2] Ibid, p 366.

  2. After slipping into petty crime in his teenage years,[3] the applicant became a heroin and cocaine user.[4] In 1983 he killed a man during an armed robbery at drug dealer’s house. While remanded in custody the applicant was involved in the killing of another man by administration of a lethal dose of pure heroin.

    [3] See for example, Ibid pp 43, 61.

    [4] Exhibit A6, p 1. G-Documents, p 196.

  3. As a result of these two incidents, the applicant was convicted of three offences:

    ·     two convictions for murder; and

    ·     one conviction for assault with intent to rob/use corporal violence (assault whilst armed and the attempted robbery).

  4. He was given life sentences in relation to each of these offences.[5] Once his sentences were handed down, there was no expectation that the applicant would ever be released into the community.

    [5] G-Documents, pp 42, 62.

  5. However, following changes in sentencing laws in NSW, the applicant was able to have his sentences re-determined. When the applicant first began applying in the late 1990s his applications were unsuccessful,[6] but in 2008, his applications were successful. In relation to the first murder conviction his sentence was set at 26…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Main and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Main and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, the applicant, a United States citizen, faced visa cancellation under section 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) due to his substantial criminal record, including convictions for murder and armed robbery. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs should exercise the discretion to cancel the applicant’s visa, considering the various factors outlined in Direction No. 110. The court had to balance the protection of the Australian community and the expectations of the community against the applicant's ties to Australia, the best interests of his minor children, and the potential impediments he might face if removed.

The court examined the nature and seriousness of the applicant’s criminal offending and the risk he posed to the Australian community. The applicant's history of severe criminal conduct, including multiple life sentences for serious offences, provided a strong basis for the visa cancellation decision. However, the court also considered the applicant’s long-standing ties to Australia, his family situation, and the likelihood of him reoffending given his current circumstances. The applicant had been in Australia since the age of 12, had a minor child in Australia, and had been stable on medication for several years, significantly reducing the risk of reoffending. The court weighed these factors carefully and concluded that, while the primary considerations pointed towards visa cancellation, the other considerations, particularly the applicant's deep ties to Australia and the low risk of reoffending, warranted setting aside the cancellation decision.

Ultimately, the court found that the other considerations outweighed the primary considerations in this particular case. The court set aside the Minister's decision to cancel the applicant's visa, recognising the significant impact on the applicant’s family and his strong ties to Australia. This decision highlights the importance of a balanced approach in assessing visa cancellation applications under the Migration Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this matter, I am therefore bound by the essential findings made in relation to what I will call the three primary offences. The applicant received a life sentence in relation to each primary conviction and each independently provides a basis for his failure of the character test. Accordingly, each conviction provides the foundation for the visa cancellation. In relation to the Applicant’s other convictions, I do have some freedom to depart from the findings made in relation to the other crimes which the applicant has been convicted of, but it would be unusual to do so. Facts My findings of fact are set out below. Where a finding is controversial, I have referenced the evidence on which the finding is based. As noted above, the applicant was born in the US in California in 1955. The description of his childhood ranges from ‘good’ to ‘unstable’[24]. However it is described, it was on any view a challenging childhood. The applicant’s biological father died of a heroin overdose when the applicant was very young. His mother was an alcoholic. He was removed from his mother’s care (perhaps as a result of his mother being sent to prison) and put into state care for a period of three years. At age six he was returned to his mother’s care. At that point she was married to his step-father, Jack Main. The applicant adopted his step-father’s surname. His step-father could be abusive when affected by alcohol.[25][24] G-Documents, p 168.[25] Ibid, pp 168-169. In 1967, when the applicant was 12, the family relocated to Australia. At that stage his family consisted of his mother, his step-father, his brother ‘Fletcher’, his brother ‘Fred‘ and his sister ‘Patty’. He has remained in Australia ever since. The applicant left home at 14 due to physical abuse from his step-father. He commenced drug use almost immediately and was a heroin user by age 15. He did, however, work in paid employment but also dealt drugs to support himself and his habit.[26] [26] Ibid, p 169. In 1973, the applicant’s only child Mark was born. The applicant and Mark’s mother remained together until the late 1970’s.[27][27] Ibid. His adult offending commenced in 1975 with a conviction for driving with a prescribed concentration of alcohol. In 1979 he was convicted of public mischief and driving offences including negligent driving and failing to stop. From 1980 he was charged and convicted on multiple occasions as a result of drug possession and supply activities. In 1982 the applicant was convicted of armed robbery and in a later incident of possessing an unlicensed pistol, carrying a cutting weapon and resisting arrest (among other matters).[28][28] G-Documents, pp 42-43. Despite being sentenced to four years hard labour in relation to the armed robbery, in early 1983 he was free in the community and working as a driver for a funeral home and doing some work as an embalmer. He was living in Randwick in a unit with his siblings. Here he met his current partner, Susan Rafati. They began a romantic relationship in early 1983. The applicant continued to use heroin in this period despite Susan’s disapproval and also engaged in activities to fund his addiction.[29][29] Ibid, pp 371 to 372.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

My reasons for that decision are set out below.Evidence before the Tribunal The material in the following schedule was taken into evidence: The following witnesses gave oral evidence for the applicant:· the applicant, Mr Robert Michael Main;· Ms Susan Catherine Rafati;· Ms Jo Hanson; and· Mr Simon Lewinson. The Respondent cross examined the applicant and Mr Lewinson but declined to cross-examine Ms Rafati and Ms Hanson.Fact finding principles In reaching my findings on the primary facts I must apply the principle, clarified by the Full Court of the Federal Court in HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (HZCP),[21] that '…relying on evidence contrary to the essential conviction or sentencing facts would in itself be an error'. The Court made clear that a person who makes representations to revoke the cancellation of a visa cannot advance a factual position that undermines the relevant convictions and sentences as 'another reason' why the original decision to cancel should be revoked.[22] [21] [2019] FCAFC 202 at [68].[22] These passages are drawn from my earlier decision in Gray but have been reviewed for applicability to the current decision. I do note however that the Applicant is entitled, subject to some qualifications, to seek different findings from the Tribunal in relation to any criminal convictions which did not form the basis of the decision to cancel his visa. The principles to be applied by the Tribunal when considering evidence of this nature were comprehensively summarised by Justice Bromberg in HZCP. The principles are stated concisely in the following passage from Secretary to the Department of Justice and Regulation v LLG, cited with approval by Justice Bromberg:The authorities distinguish between cases where a previous conviction is the basis for a decision-maker or reviewing tribunal's jurisdiction and those where it is not. In the former case, the essential factual basis of the conviction (or sentence, as the case may be) is not able to be reviewed, but the circumstances of the conviction can be reviewed for a purpose other than impugning the conviction itself. In the latter case, the essential facts underlying the convictions are not immune from challenge and the conviction is conclusive only of the fact of the conviction itself, but there is a heavy onus on a person seeking to challenge the facts upon which the conviction is necessarily based.[23][23] [2018] VSCA 155, at [42]. In this matter, I am therefore bound by the essential findings made in relation to what I will call the three primary offences. The applicant received a life sentence in relation to each primary conviction and each independently provides a basis for his failure of the character test. Accordingly, each conviction provides the foundation for the visa cancellation. In relation to the Applicant’s other convictions, I do have some freedom to depart from the findings made in relation to the other crimes which the applicant has been convicted of, but it would be unusual to do so. Facts

Decision

Reasons for decision

In closing submissions, the applicant raised for the first time an argument that any deportation would be in conflict with his parole conditions as any overseas travel requires permission. Given how late this submission was raised and how limited the opportunity was for the respond to deal with it, I do not propose taking it into consideration in the weighing process.CONCLUSION Informed by the principles in paragraph 5.2 of the Direction, I have taken into account the considerations identified in sections 8 and 9 of the Direction which are relevant to this decision. The following considerations weigh in favour of a decision to affirm the cancellation of the visa:· protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct; and· the expectations of the Australian community. The following considerations weigh in favour of setting aside the cancellation:· the strength, nature and duration of the applicant’s ties to Australia;· the best interests of minor children; and· the impediments which the applicant may face in establishing himself and maintaining basic living standards when he is deported. The family violence consideration and the impact on Australian business interests are both neutral. This decision is a difficult one. The offences which the applicant has committed are so serious that in many contexts they would in and of themselves justify cancellation of the visa. As the respondent noted in his closing submissions, there is support within the Direction and in decisions of the Federal Court,[69] for the proposition that even if there is no discernible risk of criminal conduct being repeated, it would still be an available, rational and reasonable exercise of the discretion to cancel the visa.[69] Moana v Minister for Immigration and Border protection [2015] FCAFC 54. However, more must be done than establish that it is within the bounds of rationality for me to weight the nature of the applicant’s prior criminal conduct so heavily that an exercise of the discretion in that way would be legally defensible. In the present case, I am obliged to make the preferable discretionary decision based on the evidence before me and in light of the considerations which the Direction requires me to take account of. In the current circumstances I accept that the applicant has committed the most serious offence – twice. I accept that the second offence was accompanied by many aggravating circumstances. Those facts alone provide a powerful reason for removing the applicant from Australia permanently. However, for reasons I have already explained, I consider the risk of him committing any further offence to be extremely low. I consider the risk of him committing murder to be close to non-existent provided he remains on Buvidal. In those circumstances, the first primary consideration and the expectations of the Australian community weigh powerfully in favour of cancelling the visa but not so powerfully that a different conclusion could not be reached having regard to other matters.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant’s visa was cancelled under section 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Migration Act). The decision was in the following terms:I reasonably suspect that Mr Robert Michael MAIN does not pass the character test and Mr Main has not satisfied me that he passes the character test. I have decided to exercise my discretion under s501(2) of the Act to cancel Mr MAIN’s visa. I hereby cancel Mr MAINs Class BF Transitional (Permanent) visa.[14][14] G-Documents, p 19. The applicant concedes that he does not pass the character test.[15] The only question in issue is whether I should exercise the discretion available in s 501(2) and decide not to cancel the applicant’s visa. [15] The applicant conceded this in closing oral submissions. In considering that discretion, the Tribunal must have regard to the matters contained in a ministerial direction issued under section 499(1) of the Migration Act. The relevant direction is Direction No. 110: Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA, which was executed on 7 June 2024 and commenced on 21 June 2024 (the Direction). Informed by the principles identified in the Direction, I must take into account the considerations identified in sections 8 and 9 when I am exercising the discretion in s 501(2). The discussion below of the principles and considerations I must take into account under the Direction are drawn largely from one of my earlier decisions concerning a discretion conferred by section 501 of the Migration Act, which has been revised to appropriately reflect the circumstances of this case.[16][16] Gray and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2024] AATA 3363 (13 September 2024). The Direction is divided into ‘primary’ and ‘other’ considerations. In applying the considerations, information and evidence from independent and authoritative sources should be given appropriate weight.[17] The protection of the Australian community consideration should generally be given greater weight than other primary considerations and primary considerations should generally be given greater weight than ‘other’ considerations.[18] There is however scope to weight ‘other’ considerations more highly in appropriate circumstances,[19] and similar flexibility is available in the relative weighting of primary considerations.[20] [17] The Direction, paragraph 7(1).[18] Ibid, paragraph 7(2).[19] Suleiman v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 594 at [23].[20] The use of the qualifier ‘generally’ carries that connotation. The primary considerations are:(1)protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct;(2)whether the conduct engaged in constituted family violence;(3)the strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia;(4)the best interests of minor children in Australia; and(5)expectations of the Australian community. The other considerations are:(a)the legal consequences of the decision;(b)the extent of impediments to the Applicant establishing and maintaining basic living standards if removed from Australia; and(c)the impact on Australian business interests.