Mahon v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeal: Criminal)

MAHON v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

[2024] SASC 147

Reasons for Decision of the Honourable Justice Stanley 

12 December 2024

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA – APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE – SENTENCE MANIFESTLY EXCESSIVE OR INADEQUATE

CRIMINAL LAW – PARTICULAR OFFENCES – DRIVING OFFENCES – SENTENCE

This is an appeal against sentence. The appellant pleaded guilty to the offence of driving while unauthorised to do so following a licence disqualification for drug driving contrary to s 74(2ac) of the Motor Vehicles Act 1959 (SA). On 25 October 2023 the appellant was sentenced to a term of imprisonment of two months and three days after the reduction of 30 per cent of a notional sentence of three months for his guilty plea. He was also sentenced for other offending at this time not subject to appeal.

The appellant drove an electric scooter which had been modified.  Its pedals were removed.  As a result of this modification the vehicle fell to be classified as a motorcycle attracting all the standards, regulations and licensing requirements to operate on South Australian roads.

The appellant submitted the sentence handed down by the magistrate was manifestly excessive. He contended that the offending had two features which made it a less serious example of such offending. Namely, the nature of the vehicle used and the belief held by the applicant that he was not committing an offence. The appellant submitted the absence of any reference to these features in the sentencing remarks of the magistrate indicated a failure to consider them.

The respondent submitted inter alia that the appeal ought to be dismissed as it was out of time and the sentence imposed was within the discretionary range available in sentencing this offender for this offence. The respondent contended that the unusual features of the offending were swamped by countervailing factors relating to the seriousness of the offence.

Held:

1.      The failure of the sentencing magistrate to refer to the unusual features of the offending in his      remarks suggests strongly that he failed to consider it. This was a process error.

2.      The circumstances of the subject offending were so unusual as to render it unlikely the      appellant would commit an offence in these circumstances again. Accordingly, the need for     personal deterrence was absent on this occasion. As a result, the sentence imposed was   manifestly excessive. This was an outcome error.

3.      The appellant is granted an extension of time to appeal against the sentence handed down on        25 October 2023 for Count 1 on MCCRM-22-2403.

4.      The appeal is allowed.

5.      The sentence imposed on the appellant on 25 October 2023 is set aside and the appellant is resentenced to time served.

6.      The certificate of record on MCCRM-22-3403 contains a clerical error and is to be corrected        to reflect a sentence of 2 months and 3 days and the imposition of a 1 year disqualification…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mahon v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mahon v Commissioner of Police was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appellant, Mr Mahon, appealed against the sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court for driving offences. The central dispute was whether the sentence was manifestly excessive or inadequate. Mr Mahon argued that the magistrate failed to consider unique aspects of his case, leading to an inappropriate sentence.

The legal issues before the court involved determining whether the sentence imposed by the magistrate contained a process error, where the magistrate failed to consider relevant factors, and whether this led to an outcome error, resulting in a sentence that was manifestly excessive. The court also had to consider whether it should interfere with the sentence despite finding an error, and if so, what an appropriate sentence should be.

The court found that there was both a process error, as the magistrate failed to consider the unusual circumstances of Mr Mahon's offending, and an outcome error, as the sentence was manifestly excessive given these circumstances. The court concluded that because of these errors, it was necessary to resentence Mr Mahon. Given the time already served and the nature of the offence, the court deemed that the requirements of an appropriate sentence had been met. The court also directed corrections to the Certificate of Record to accurately reflect the sentence imposed.

The final orders included allowing the appeal against the sentence, correcting the Certificate of Record to accurately reflect the sentence imposed, and granting an extension of time to the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, the respondent submitted that even if the Court found an error in the sentence imposed by the magistrate it may refrain from interfering with the sentence if not of the view that another sentence should be passed.[12] [12] Kentwell v The Queen [2014] 252 CLR 601 at [43].Consideration It can be accepted that generally terms of immediate imprisonment will be imposed for contraventions of s 74(2ac). It can also be accepted that generally the imposition of an immediate term of imprisonment for repeated offending of the kind committed by this appellant would be expected. His criminal record generally would justify a sentence which emphasised the need for personal deterrence. However, this offending did not match the usual circumstances of such offending. The submission made before the magistrate that the appellant was unaware that he required a driver’s licence in order to ride the scooter on a public road because the pedals had been removed seems to me to be entirely plausible. This was such an unusual feature of the offending, it took it out of the generality of such offences, that the failure of the magistrate to mention it in his sentencing remarks suggests strongly that he failed to consider it. This was a process error. The circumstances of the subject offending were so unusual as to render it unlikely that the appellant would commit an offence in these circumstances again. Accordingly, the general need for personal deterrence was absent on this occasion. As a result, the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive. This was an outcome error. Having found both a process error and an outcome error had occurred, it was necessary to resentence the appellant. This was not the kind of situation contemplated in Kentwell v The Queen[13] where the appeal court would decline to intervene notwithstanding the finding of error in sentencing by the court below. [13] Kentwell v The Queen (2014) 252 CLR 601. In all the circumstances I considered that the requirements of an appropriate sentence for this offender, and in particular this offending, had been met by the time the appellant had already served. This was particularly so given that I allowed the appeal on 8 May 2024 and the appellant had been in custody in respect of this and other offending relating to driving disqualified since 25 October 2023. In the circumstances the respondent accepted that if the appeal was to be allowed an extension of time should be granted. The parties also agreed that the Certificate of Record in the Magistrates Court should be corrected. The Certificate of Record on MCCRM-22-003403 recorded the terms of imprisonment on Count 1 as one month and 24 days imprisonment but the transcript of remarks set out that the sentence imposed comprised a term of imprisonment of two months and three days and a one-year disqualification from holding a driver’s licence. The overall head sentence on the court record was correct but the penalty recorded for this charge was incorrect. I directed that this error be corrected.