Madafferi v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Madafferi v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 581

IMMIGRATION – Spouse visa – Decision of the AAT – Decision of the Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs – Whether Minister’s decision involved an error of law – Whether the Minister observed procedures required by the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – Whether Minister’s decision involved an improper exercise of power – Whether the Minister’s decision involved actual bias – Whether the Minister’s decision was based on no evidence

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) Pt 8, ss 499, 501, 501A

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)

Migration Regulations 1993 (Cth) Sched 4

Lam v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 1226 followed

Lau v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 698 at [29] applied

Aksu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 514 at [10] and [34] discussed

Damanik v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 771 at [10] followed

Tuli v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 271, 94 FCR 526 at [277] followed

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Anthonypillai [2001] FCA 274 at [38] applied

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia [2001] HCA 17 applied

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 at 272 applied

FRANCESCO MADAFFERI v THE MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

V839 OF 2000

MARSHALL J
MELBOURNE
18 MAY 2001


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V839 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

FRANCESCO MADAFFERI
APPLICANT

AND:

THE MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 MAY 2001

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs, including reserved costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V839 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

FRANCESCO MADAFFERI
APPLICANT

AND:

THE MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE:

18 MAY 2001

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 26 October 2000, the applicant, Mr Madafferi, made an application for an Order of Review of a decision of the respondent Minister pursuant to Part 8 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) and s 39B(1A)(c) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). Ultimately, however, Mr Madafferi relied only on Part 8 of the Act. The Minister made the relevant decision on 18 October 2000. In this decision the Minister personally refused an application made by Mr Madafferi in July 1996 for a permanent visa as a spouse of an Australian citizen. The applicant filed an amended application adding further grounds of review on 7 March 2001.

    FACTUAL BACKGROUND

  2. Mr Madafferi was born on 10 January 1961 in the Republic of Italy and is an Italian citizen. He first entered Australia on 17 November 1977 on a visitor entry permit valid for three months. He stayed for twelve months, leaving Australia…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Madafferi v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affai... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 581
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Madafferi sought judicial review of the Minister’s refusal to grant him a permanent spouse visa. The central issue was whether the Minister's refusal of Mr Madafferi's visa was lawful and justified under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). The court examined the Minister's decision-making process, focusing on whether he acted within his statutory powers, took into account relevant considerations, and made a decision free from bias and error. The court scrutinised the Minister’s reasons for decision, particularly his assessment of Mr Madafferi’s character, the impact of his criminal history, and whether the refusal was in the national interest.

The court found that the Minister exercised his discretion lawfully under s 501A(2)(a) of the Act. The Minister reasonably suspected Mr Madafferi did not pass the character test due to his substantial criminal record and misleading conduct regarding his criminal history. The court upheld the Minister’s conclusion that refusal of the visa was in the national interest, considering the seriousness of Mr Madafferi’s crimes, the outstanding warrant for his arrest in Italy, and the potential deterrent effect on others with criminal backgrounds. The court rejected claims of bias and error, finding that the Minister considered all relevant factors and made a reasoned decision. The Minister’s discretion to refuse the visa was upheld as he balanced Mr Madafferi’s family ties against the need to protect the Australian community.

The court dismissed the application and ordered Mr Madafferi to pay the Minister’s costs, including reserved costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs, including reserved costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 26 October 2000, the applicant, Mr Madafferi, made an application for an Order of Review of a decision of the respondent Minister pursuant to Part 8 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) and s 39B(1A)(c) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). Ultimately, however, Mr Madafferi relied only on Part 8 of the Act. The Minister made the relevant decision on 18 October 2000. In this decision the Minister personally refused an application made by Mr Madafferi in July 1996 for a permanent visa as a spouse of an Australian citizen. The applicant filed an amended application adding further grounds of review on 7 March 2001.FACTUAL BACKGROUND Mr Madafferi was born on 10 January 1961 in the Republic of Italy and is an Italian citizen. He first entered Australia on 17 November 1977 on a visitor entry permit valid for three months. He stayed for twelve months, leaving Australia on 30 November 1978. Mr Madafferi entered Australia for a second time on 21 October 1989 on a visitor entry permit valid for six months. He overstayed his visa and has remained thereafter in Australia. He married an Australian citizen on 26 August 1990. He and his wife have three children under ten years of age and Mrs Madafferi is pregnant with their fourth child. On 5 July 1996, officials of the Minister’s Department arrested Mr Madafferi for overstaying his visa. Mr Madafferi was released from custody after his brother paid a $10,000.00 surety. On 12 July 1996, Mr Madafferi applied for a spouse visa in order to remain in Australia. By letter dated 3 June 1997, the Minister’s Department advised Mr Madafferi that his application for a spouse visa had been rejected. Mr Madafferi was advised that he failed to satisfy Public Interest criterion 4001(2) of Schedule 4 to the Migration Regulations (1993) because a delegate of the Minister was not satisfied that Mr Madafferi was of good character within the meaning of s501 of the Act. On 17 June 1997, Mr Madafferi applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“AAT”) for a review of the delegate’s decision. Due to various reasons that are not material to this proceeding, the AAT did not determine the review until 7 June 2000. On 7 June 2000, the AAT set aside the delegate’s decision to refuse Mr Madafferi a spouse visa and remitted the matter to the Minister for consideration in accordance with a direction that Mr Madafferi not be refused a spouse visa on character grounds “solely on the basis of information presently available to the [Minister]”. By letter dated 24 July 2000, a delegate of the Minister gave notice to Mr Madafferi of the Minister’s intention to consider a refusal of a spouse visa under s501A of the Act. On 18 October 2000, the Minister personally decided to refuse Mr Madafferi’s application for a visa. That action was taken in reliance of s501A(2)(a) of the Act. On 21 December 2000, the Minister provided a statement of reasons for his decision to refuse Mr Madafferi a spouse visa. The Minister’s reasons for decision are central to the current reasons for judgment and have been quoted at large. The Minister’s statement held:“1. I, Philip Maxwell Ruddock, Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs exercised my discretion under section 501A(2)(a) of the Migration Act 1958 (‘the Act’),to set aside the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of 7 June 2000 (‘the original decision’) and made a decision to refuse the permanent visa of Mr Francesco Madafferi on 18 October 2000.2. Section 501A(2) of the Act states that:‘The Minister may set aside the original decision and:(a) refuse to grant a visa to the person; or (b) cancel a visa that has been granted to the person;if:(c) the Minister reasonably suspects that the person does not pass the character test (as defined by section 501); and(d) the person does not satisfy the Minister that the person passes the character test; and(e) the Minister is satisfied that the refusal or cancellation is in the national interest.’3. Before exercising my discretion to set aside the original decision and making a decision to refuse the visa, I had formed a reasonable suspicion, under section 501A(2)(c), that Mr Madafferi did not pass the character test, due to the fact that in 1984 he was convicted of the crime of ‘attempted extortion’ and was sentenced to 24 months imprisonment. I also took account of the fact that Mr Madafferi was convicted on four other occasions in 1980 and 1982, receiving sentences of 22, 30, 8 and 36 months imprisonment, and that he was sentenced in absentia in 1986 and 1993, and as a result, has a current arrest warrant in Italy, where he faces an outstanding sentence of 4 years 8 months and 6 days.4. ‘Substantial criminal record’ is defined in subsection 501(7) of the Act. A person has a substantial criminal record for the purposes of section 501(7) if, amongst other things, they have been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of at least 12 months, or have been sentenced to a number of terms of imprisonment totalling at least 24 months, or have been acquitted of an offence due to insanity or unsoundness of mind and have spent time in a facility or institution. A person with a substantial criminal record does not pass the character test (section 501(6)(a) of the Act). Furthermore, in dealing with officers of my Department, Mr Madafferi has presented false and misleading information concerning his criminal history. Accordingly, I found that he was not a person of good character by reason of his general conduct.5. In accordance with section 501A(2)(d), Mr Madafferi was unable to satisfy me that he passed the character test pursuant to section 501(6)(a) because he has a substantial criminal record as defined in section 501(7)(c) and because of his general conduct in attempting to mislead Australian immigration authorities. I was not satisfied from the submissions of Mr Madafferi's legal advisers, that his general conduct as a parent and business person outweighs that conduct.6. I then considered whether it was in the national interest for Mr Madafferi's visa to be refused. I took into account the comments provided by Mr Madafferi's legal representatives that there is nothing to suggest that removing Mr Madafferi from Australia would be in the national interest and that Mr Madafferi's input into Australian society has been, and continued to be beneficial. I also considered Mr Madafferi's criminal background and his past and present general conduct. I noted that the Italian authorities have issued a warrant of arrest for Mr Madafferi and that Mr Madafferi faces an outstanding sentence of 4 years 8 months and 6 days in Italy. I also considered the effect on Australia's 'reputation' and 'good name' in the international community should Mr Madafferi be allowed to remain. On balance, I found that due to the seriousness of Mr Madafferi's convictions and his outstanding warrant of arrest and sentence in Italy, it would be in the national interest to refuse his visa.7. In exercising my discretion to refuse Mr Madafferi's permanent visa, I took into account all matters referred to in the document titled ‘Issues For Consideration’ accompanied by a Minute signed by Dario Castello, Assistant Secretary, Border Control Branch dated 13 October 2000, including evidence of Mr Madafferi's criminal history in Italy. I also had regard to comments submitted by Mr Madafferi's legal representatives on 15 August 2000 in response to a notice of intention to consider the possible refusal of his visa under section 501A(2)(a). 8. I also proceeded in accordance with the Government's view on serious crimes as set out in my General Direction number 17 – ‘Direction Under s 499 Visa Refusal and Cancellation Under section 501 of the Migration Act’ (‘my Direction’). I still consider that my Direction properly indicates how I consider the powers and functions of the kind here under consideration should be exercised. In accordance with this I gave consideration to three primary considerations and other considerations. 9. I gave primary consideration to the protection of the Australian community, taking into account the seriousness and nature of Mr Madafferi's conduct and the likelihood that the conduct may be repeated. 10. I noted that Mr Madafferi has been convicted of a number of serious offences involving repeated acts of violence, attempted extortion, illegal possession of narcotics and receiving stolen property. In accordance with my Direction, I consider in particular offences involving violence against the person, drug related offences and attempted extortion to be very serious offences.11. I also considered Mr Madafferi's general conduct. I took into account the fact that Mr Madafferi has twice overstayed the validity of his visitor visa and that in his dealings with the Department, Mr Madafferi has repeatedly either denied his criminal record or attempted to provide misleading information with regard to his criminal history. I noted that the AAT gave no weight to Mr Madafferi overstaying his visa. I also noted that in relation to Mr Madafferi providing false information to the Department, Deputy President Blow commented that many people in Mr Madafferi's situation would also behave in a similar manner. However, in keeping with the Government's attitude in these matters as outlined in my Direction, I considered Mr Madafferi's conduct to be very serious.12. I also considered the likelihood that the conduct may be repeated (including any risk of recidivism). I took into account the fact that the Italian authorities have issued a warrant of arrest which required Mr Madafferi to serve a consolidated sentence of 4 years, 8 months and 6 days imprisonment in respect of various unserved and previously suspended sentences.13. I noted that Mr Madafferi has continued to present false or misleading information to the Department and the AAT and that Deputy President Blow acknowledged that Mr Madafferi is still prepared to resort to dishonesty when it suits him.14. I took into account the comments submitted on behalf of Mr Madafferi by his legal representatives, including the fact that Mr Madafferi has not been convicted of any offences in Australia. Taking all of the above into consideration, I assessed that there is a low to moderate risk that Mr Madafferi may re-offend.15. In giving primary consideration to the protection of the Australian community I also gave consideration to whether the refusal of Mr Madafferi's visa and his removal from Australia would be a deterrent to other non‑citizens. I noted that the case has received public attention, particularly within the Italian-Australian community and found that the refusal of Mr Madafferi's visa could have deterrent value for others with criminal background who contemplate a permanent stay in Australia. I also found that the refusal would send a strong message to others who contemplate crimes against the Migration Act. I gave these factors considerable weight.16. I also gave primary consideration to the expectations of the Australian community. In accordance with the Government's view expressed in my direction, I considered that the Australian community expects non-citizens to obey Australian laws while in Australia including the migration laws. I took into account that Mr Madafferi has resided in Australia since 1989 and has an Australian citizen wife and three Australian-born children. I also noted that a petition comprising 1343 signatures of members of the general community and the Italian-Australian community was submitted by Mr Madafferi's legal representatives expressing support of Mr Madafferi's application. I assessed that given the seriousness of Mr Madafferi's offences, and the fact that he has an outstanding warrant for his arrest in Italy, the Australian community would expect Mr Madafferi's visa to be refused and Mr Madafferi to be removed from Australia. 17. In exercising my discretion to refuse Mr Madafferi's visa I also gave primary consideration to the best interests of his three children, aged four, seven and nine.18. I noted that all the children were born in Australia. I also noted that Mr Madafferi's wife, stated that she and the children would remain in Australia if Mr Madafferi was refused a visa. I took into account the psychological report from Ms Syndon Barabash, Consulting Psychologist and Family Therapist, that the family was a close‑knit one and that the children demonstrated an obvious caring for their parents and each other. I also noted that all members of Mr Madafferi's family supported these comments.19. I considered that while separation from their father may cause the children to suffer, this did not diminish the seriousness of Mr Madafferi’s crimes and general conduct with regard to Australia's migration laws.20. While in the normal course it is in the best interests of the child to be brought up in a stable household with both parents, I have balanced this view with the need to protect the Australian community from persons who commit serious offences.21. In reaching my decision to refuse Mr Madafferi's visa I also took into account other considerations such as Mr Madafferi's ties to the Australian community. I took into account the fact that Mr Madafferi's wife and children are Australian citizens. I noted that Mr Madafferi also has two brothers and one sister who reside in Australia, with whom he remains in close contact.22. I also considered that the refusal of Mr Madafferi's visa may result in him not being able to provide financial assistance to his wife and children in Australia.23. I took into account the comments from Ms Barabash, Consulting Psychologist and Family Therapist who noted that Mr Madafferi regrets the shortcomings of his youth and that Mr Madafferi can only be described as someone with a flawed adolescence, who chose to change the patterns of his life. I also gave consideration to Mr Madafferi's recent good conduct including his employment history. I took into account the references attesting to Mr Madafferi's good character from his employees, business associates, friends and relatives. However, I also considered the outstanding warrant for Mr Madafferi's arrest in Italy and the sentence which he has not served, as well as his general conduct with regard to migration matters. On balance, I found that the seriousness of Mr Madafferi's crimes outweighed the hardship that he and his family may suffer should his visa be refused.24. I noted that Mr Madafferi's legal representatives pointed out Australia's obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. In particular, I considered Article 23.1 which states that ‘the family is the natural and fundamental group of society and is entitled to protection by society and the State’, and considered Australia's obligation to ensure the unity the family as one of the considerations. I gave this consideration moderate weight.25. In deciding to exercise my discretion to refuse Mr Madafferi permanent residence, I found that the protection of the Australian community, particularly having regard to the nature and seriousness of the offences, and the expectations of the Australian community, outweighed the other relevant considerations referred to above.26. As I was not satisfied that Mr Madafferi passed the character test and I considered that refusal was in the national interest, and taking into account all the matters raised in the subsection, I exercised my discretion to set aside the original decision and made a decision to refuse his visa under section 501A(2)(a).’

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Hurley also relied on statements made by the Minister in 1997 to the effect that any non-citizen who had been in prison for 12 months or more should not be allowed to reside permanently in Australia. In light of the recent High Court judgment Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia [2001] HCA 17, where an identical submission was rejected, reliance can no longer be placed on the Minister’s 1997 statements to support a claim of bias. NO EVIDENCE OR OTHER MATERIAL Mr Hurley submitted that the Minister’s decision was based on particular facts that did not exist. It was alleged that such facts were critical to the making of the decision in circumstances where there was no other evidence or material to justify the making of the decision. The first of those alleged facts was that the Italian authorities had issued a warrant of arrest for Mr Madafferi under which he faced an outstanding sentence of four years, eight months and six days in Italy. The correct analysis under Italian law was said to be that the outstanding sentences will expire on 19 May 2002, and that when the Minister made his decision the actual outstanding sentence was only one year, eight months and six days. In response, Mr Tracey submitted that the Minister emphasised the Italian warrant to indicate that it represents “unfinished business” with respect to past events in Italy. I agree. I do not consider the fact that Mr Madafferi faced a shorter sentence than that of four years, eight months and six days would impact upon the Minister’s ultimate decision. The fact remained that he faced a prison sentence if he returned to Italy. An outstanding prison sentence was “other evidence or material” which justified the making of the decision. Mr Hurley also submitted that there was no evidence for the Minister to conclude that Mr Madafferi had lied about his criminal history. It was contended that Mr Madafferi disclosed his convictions in his application for a spouse visa in 1996. However, there was ample material available to the Minister to show that Mr Madafferi had repeatedly denied his criminal record or attempted to provide misleading information to officers of the Minister’s department. Mr Hurley next contended that no evidence existed to justify the respondent’s comments on ‘protection of the Australian community’ and on the ‘public attention’ Mr Madafferi’s case had received by the Italian-Australian community. Neither of these submissions holds any substance. What is considered necessary to protect the Australian community will largely depend on value judgments. Even though the Minister found there was only a “low to moderate risk that Mr Madafferi may re-offend”, it was open to the Minister, after having regard to the “nature and seriousness” of Mr Madafferi’s offences, to consider that protection of the Australian community was a relevant factor in coming to his conclusion. Nor can it be denied that Mr Madafferi’s case has come to the attention of the Italian-Australian community, and indeed the Australian community at large, following substantial press coverage of his circumstances after the AAT decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MARSHALL J
I also do not consider, contrary to Mr Hurley’s contention, that when the Minister made a decision under s501 of the Act he was exercising legislative power. On the contrary, the Minister was exercising an administrative discretion. Submission regarding the Primary Decision being based on an Error In response to Mr Hurley’s contention that the primary decision was based on an error, Mr Tracey submitted that while the Minister’s decision was activated by the existence of the AAT decision, beyond that the AAT decision played no role. I agree with that submission. The Minister is not required to consider whether the decision of his delegate or the decision of the AAT was correct. He looks afresh at the application for the visa by reference to matters referred to in s501A of the Act. Therefore, any errors made by the delegate or the AAT are immaterial. Consequently, it does not matter if the visa application form provided to Mr Madafferi was inappropriately worded or whether Mr Madafferi was in fact engaged to be married before he entered Australia the second time.ACTUAL BIAS Mr Hurley contended that the Minister was affected by actual bias in coming to his decision. Reliance was placed upon par 15 of the Minister’s reasons of 21 December 2000 and especially the Minister’s statement that:“… [the] refusal of Mr Madafferi’s visa could have deterrent value for others with criminal background who contemplate a permanent stay in Australia.” It was submitted that part of the Minister’s reasons disclose that he formed the view that no person with a criminal background can ever obtain a visa to permanently stay in Australia. I do not consider that submission fairly or accurately reflects the Minister’s view. The Minister has a clear and obvious discretion as to whether to grant visas to persons who have a criminal background. Mr Madafferi’s criminal background was never in issue and it was open to the Minister to deny Mr Madafferi a visa on this basis. However, it is clear from the Minister’s reasons, which cover a broad range of issues and consider Mr Madafferi’s personal circumstances in detail, the Minister was not just applying a pre-formulated policy regarding persons with criminal backgrounds. Mr Hurley also relied on statements made by the Minister in 1997 to the effect that any non-citizen who had been in prison for 12 months or more should not be allowed to reside permanently in Australia. In light of the recent High Court judgment Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia [2001] HCA 17, where an identical submission was rejected, reliance can no longer be placed on the Minister’s 1997 statements to support a claim of bias. NO EVIDENCE OR OTHER MATERIAL Mr Hurley submitted that the Minister’s decision was based on particular facts that did not exist. It was alleged that such facts were critical to the making of the decision in circumstances where there was no other evidence or material to justify the making of the decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MARSHALL J

Full text does not contain this section.