Macks v Tucker & Ors & QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

MACKS v TUCKER & ORS & QBE INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LTD (NO 2)

[2006] SASC 350

Judgment of The Honourable Justice White

21 November 2006

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT

Applications by plaintiff and first and second defendants for the trial of certain issues in the proceedings before the trial of other issues - Supreme Court Rules 1987, r 75.02 - discussion of relevant principles.

Held:  applications dismissed.

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 249; Supreme Court Rules 1987 r 75.02, referred to.
Rivers v Rivers (2002) 220 LSJS 74; FAI General Insurance Co Ltd (In Liq) v Sherry & Ors (2002) 225 LSJS 141; Warman International Ltd v Dwyer (1995) 182 CLR 544; Chan v Zacharia (1984) 154 CLR 178; Duke Group Ltd (In Liq) v Arthur Young (No 2) (1991) 4 ACSR 355, applied.
Gartside v England Revenue Commissioners [1968] AC 533; Gerhardy v South Australian Auxillary to the British and Foreign Bible Society Inc (1986) 44 SASR 195; Dwyer v Ross (1992) 34 FCR 463; Official Receiver in Bankruptcy v Schultz (1990) 170 CLR 306; Re Buckle (1969) 15 FLR 460; Cirillo v Citicorp (2004) 236 LSJS 24; Re Burton; Wily v Burton & Ors (1994) 126 ALR 557; Nichols to Nixey (1885) 29 Ch D 1005; Rogers v Baillieu Bullock Wilkinson Pty Ltd (1981) 28 SASR 594; Duke Group Limited (In Liq) v Alamain Investments Limited (In Liq) [2006] SASC 33, considered.

MACKS v TUCKER & ORS & QBE INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LTD (NO 2)
[2006] SASC 350

Civil

  1. WHITE J: This is a decision on applications pursuant to r 75.02 of the Supreme Court Rules 1987 (“SCR”) for the trial of certain issues in the proceedings before the trial of other issues.

  2. The first and second defendants (“the Tucker defendants”) initially sought an order that one issue of fact be tried in advance of the substantive trial, and, in the event that that issue of fact was decided adversely to them, that certain questions of law then be decided.  That application was opposed by the plaintiff.  After the argument on the application had been substantially completed, the Tucker defendants applied for, and were given leave to amend their application so as to seek the determination, in advance of the substantive trial, of further questions of law.  The application in its amended form was also opposed by the plaintiff.  The application of the Tucker defendants was not opposed by the third and fourth defendants, but was not supported by the third party. 

  3. In his application, the plaintiff seeks an order that the action proceed to trial on the question of liability only, and that the issues of damages and compensation not be tried until after the determination of that question.  The plaintiff’s application was opposed by all other parties apart from the third party.

    The Parties

  4. The late James…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Macks v Tucker & Ors & QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] SASC 350
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Macks v Tucker & Ors & QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd (No 2) involved the plaintiff bringing claims against Mr Tucker and the second defendant, with QBE Insurance being an insurer of Mr Tucker who had denied his claim for indemnity. The plaintiff alleged that Mr Tucker's conflicts of interest, breaches of fiduciary duty, and breaches of retainer caused the deceased's estate to suffer loss, or that Mr Tucker had profited from his retainer by the deceased and his estate. The plaintiff further alleged that Mr Tucker's dealings with the Anak No 1 Trust, a discretionary trust of which Anak Limited was the trustee, resulted in losses or an entitlement to equitable compensation. Additionally, the plaintiff alleged that Mr Tucker's conduct in relation to other matters, such as the transfer of the deceased's late father's estate, his action in taking proceedings against the estate, and his participation in a transaction involving the sale of Aboriginal paintings, resulted in losses or an entitlement to equitable compensation.

The legal issues that the court was required to decide in this case included whether the questions raised by the Tucker defendants should be determined in advance of the trial of the remaining issues, in accordance with the Supreme Court Rules 1987, rule 75.02. The court also needed to consider whether it was appropriate to determine preliminary questions when the facts were in dispute or, at least, not settled, and whether there were countervailing considerations that should be taken into account.

In reaching its decision, the court considered the principles discussed and elaborated in later cases, which emphasised the inappropriateness of courts determining preliminary questions when the facts were in dispute or, at least, not settled. The court also considered the prospect that the determination of a preliminary issue may dispose of a substantial issue in an action, or at least narrow substantially the area of dispute, as a factor that may warrant an order for a preliminary determination of issues. However, the court found that it would not be appropriate if the factual basis for the determination was unsettled. The court further considered the countervailing considerations, including the fact that the plaintiff's allegations with respect to the Anak transactions were not entirely separate and discrete from other allegations in the Further Amended Statement of Claim.

Ultimately, the court decided that it was not appropriate to determine the questions raised by the Tucker defendants in advance of the trial of the remaining issues. The court found that there were countervailing considerations that should be taken into account, including the fact that evidence concerning the Anak transactions would be relevant to, and admissible in, the trial relating to the remaining transactions. The court therefore denied the applications by the plaintiff and the Tucker defendants for the trial of certain issues in the proceedings before the trial of other issues.

The final orders of the court were that the applications by the plaintiff and the Tucker defendants for the trial of certain issues in the proceedings before the trial of other issues were dismissed. The court found that it was not appropriate to determine the questions raised by the Tucker defendants in advance of the trial of the remaining issues, and that there were countervailing considerations that should be taken into account. The court emphasised the inappropriateness of courts determining preliminary questions when the facts were in dispute or, at least, not settled, and found that it would not be appropriate if the factual basis for the determination was unsettled.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The third party is an insurer of Mr Tucker. It has denied his claim for indemnity in respect of the plaintiff’s claims.Background Circumstances The plaintiff’s claim is that by reason of Mr Tucker’s conflicts of interest, breaches of fiduciary duty, and breaches of a retainer, the estate of the deceased has suffered loss. In the alternative, the plaintiff alleges that even if the estate has not suffered an actual loss, Mr Tucker or the second defendant has profited from opportunities which his retainer by the deceased and his estate provided, and claims that he should account to the estate for the benefits which he has thereby obtained. Because of the nature of the application with which I am now dealing, it is neither necessary, nor desirable, for me to recount the circumstances alleged by the plaintiff in detail. I do so only to the extent to which I consider it necessary for the determination of the present application. The plaintiff alleges losses, or an entitlement to equitable compensation, resulting from Mr Tucker’s dealings in relation to a discretionary trust known as the Anak No 1 Trust of which a Jersey company Anak Limited (“Anak”) is the trustee. The questions which the Tucker defendants seek to have determined in advance of others have their basis in the plaintiff’s allegations with respect to Mr Tucker’s dealings in relation to Anak and the Anak No 1 Trust. I will refer to these dealings as “the Anak transactions”. The plaintiff also alleges losses, or an entitlement to equitable compensation, resulting from conduct by Mr Tucker in relation to other matters. These are the transfer by the deceased, three days before his death, of his late father’s estate to the second defendant; his action in 1996 in taking proceedings in the District Court against the estate to recover monies said to be owed to him by the deceased; his participation in a transaction involving the sale of Aboriginal paintings in which both he and the deceased had a beneficial interest, to Medolan Limited (a company in which it is said that Mr Tucker, or persons associated with him, had an interest); and the further sale of the paintings on the same day to a third party for a higher price than was paid by Medolan Limited. I emphasise that these matters are allegations only at this stage.The Anak Transactions Anak administered two trusts: the Anak No 1 Trust and the Anak No 2 Trust. Broadly speaking, the Anak No 1 Trust related to the deceased and his family, and the Anak No 2 Trust to Mr Tucker and his family. Matheson Trust Company (“Matheson”) acted as the trustee of both Anak Trusts. As at the date of death of the deceased (11 December 1990) the shares in Anak were held by Matheson. 10 of the 12 shares in Anak were held on behalf of the Anak No 1 Trust and the other two shares were held on behalf of the Anak No 2 Trust. It is alleged that as at 11 December 1990, and for a number of years before that, the deceased and Mr Tucker exercised effective control of Anak as the directors of Anak (who were employees of Matheson) were accustomed to act according to their directions.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

These principles have been discussed and elaborated in later cases.[12] All the cases have emphasised the inappropriateness of courts determining preliminary questions when the facts are in dispute or, at least, not settled. Although the prospect that the determination of a preliminary issue may dispose of a substantial issue in an action, or at least narrow substantially the area of dispute, may be sufficient in some cases to warrant an order for a preliminary determination of issues, it will not be appropriate if the factual basis for the determination is unsettled.[13][12] FAI General Insurance Co Ltd (In Liq) v Sherry and Ors [2002] SASC 431 at [38]; (2002) 225 LSJS 141 at 148; Duke Group Limited (In Liq) v Alamain Investments Limited (In Liq) [2006] SASC 33 at [24]-[26].[13] FAI General Insurance Co Ltd (In Liq) v Sherry and Ors [2002] SASC 431 at [38]; (2002) 225 LSJS 141 at 148.Countervailing Considerations Although I consider that the Tucker defendants have made a persuasive case for the determination of the questions identified by them in advance of the trial of the remaining issues, there are a number of countervailing considerations. In the first place, the plaintiff’s allegations with respect to the Anak transactions are not entirely separate and discrete from other allegations in the Further Amended Statement of Claim. Instead, the plaintiff alleges that Mr Tucker engaged, in effect, in a course of conduct of which the Anak transactions form part. The Further Amended Statement of Claim contains an allegation that at the time of his death the deceased was indebted to Mr Tucker or to the second defendant arising from an advance of about GBP£116,000 by Mr Tucker in the period between 31 July 1987 and 16 October 1987. It alleges that that debt was assigned by Mr Tucker to the second defendant on or about 2 October 1989 and was repayable with interest at the rate of 14 per cent per annum. Mr Tucker was aware, it is said, that the death of the deceased and his bankruptcy put at significant risk the prospect of recovery of that debt. The Anak transactions which had the effect of removing assets from the Anak No 1 Trust and putting them in entities controlled by Mr Tucker or interests associated with him were implemented as part of his objective to obtain recovery of that debt. So also (so the plaintiff claims) were the other transactions pleaded by the plaintiff in the Further Amended Statement of Claim. Thus the plaintiff submitted that the conduct attributed to Mr Tucker in relation to the Anak transactions will also be relevant to the assessment of his motives, objectives and conduct in relation to the other transactions. Accordingly, evidence concerning those transactions will be relevant to, and admissible in, the trial relating to the remaining transactions. In this respect it is relevant to note that some of the conduct said to comprise the Anak transactions was contemporaneous in a broad sense with other conduct pleaded by the plaintiff.