Macarthur Central Shopping Centre Pty Ltd as TTE v Valuer-General (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Macarthur Central Shopping Centre Pty Ltd as TTE v Valuer-General (No. 2) [2016] QLC 80*
PARTIES: Macarthur Central Shopping Centre Pty Ltd as Trustee
(appellant)
v
Valuer-General
(respondent)
FILE NO/s: LVA076-14
DIVISION: General Division
PROCEEDING: Appeal against land valuation
DELIVERED ON: 23 December 2016
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARD ON: 29, 30 August 2016, final  submissions received 11 October 2016
HEARD AT: Brisbane
PRESIDENT: FY Kingham
ORDER/S: The appeal is dismissed
CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – VALUATION OF LAND – SITE VALUE – METHOD OF ASSESSING - COMPARABLE SALE – whether a sale by liquidator was bona fide - whether a development approval added value to a comparable sale – whether sales relied upon were comparable – whether the value is supported by comparable sales

REAL PROPERTY – VALUATION OF LAND – SITE VALUE - METHOD OF ASSESSING – HERITAGE LISTING – where the lot was heritage listed – where the land area rate derived from comparable sales was discounted for the heritage listing - whether a gross floor rate derived from comparable sales used to value the lot should also be reduced to account for the heritage listing

REAL PROPERTY – VALUATION OF LAND – SITE VALUE - METHOD OF ASSESSING – VOLUMETRIC LOT – where the lot was volumetric – where there were no comparable sales of volumetric lots affected by heritage listing – where Valuer-General discounted value to reflect the volumetric limitations – where the owner proposed a novel method applying differential rates to different levels of the lot – whether the valuation reflected the constraints on developing the lot arising from its volumetric nature land

Land Valuation Act 2010, s 17, s 18, s 19, s 23, s 24

Bellbird Park Developments Pty Ltd v Department of Natural Resources and Water (2009) 30 QLCR 177, followed
Body Corporate for “147-153 Mary Street Gympie” CTS v Valuer-General (2013) 34 QLCR 298, followed
Edgarhead Pty Ltd v Valuer-General[2015] QLC 18, followed

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v St. Helen’s Farm (ACT) Pty Ltd (1980-81) 146 CLR, applied

Grahn v Valuer-General (1992-93) 14 QLCR 327, applied
Mayne Property Development Pty Ltd v Chief Executive, Department of Natural Resources (1996-1997) 16 QLCR 709, applied
Qualischefski v Valuer-General (1979) 6 QLCR 167, applied
Spencer v The Commonwealth [1907] 5 CLR 418, applied
Stubberfield v Valuer-General [1991] 1 Qd R 278, applied
The Valuer-General v Queensland Club (1991) 13 QLCR 207, applied
Tow v Valuer-General (1978) 5 QLCR 378, applied

APPEARANCES: DD Purcell of Counsel, instructed by OMB Lawyers, for the appellant
SP Fynes-Clinton of Counsel, instructed by In-house Legal, Department of Natural Resources and Mines, for the Valuer-General
  1. Macarthur Central Shopping Centre Pty Ltd as Trustee has appealed to the Court against the Valuer-General’s 2012 valuation of a volumetric lot (Lot 1 on SP139965) in a heritage listed building at 229 Queen Street known as Macarthur Chambers. That building sits in a high-end retailing area at the corner of Queen and Edward Streets, opposite the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Macarthur Central Shopping Centre Pty Ltd as TTE v Valuer-Ge... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QLC 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Macarthur Central Shopping Centre Pty Ltd, as trustee for the Macarthur Central Shopping Centre Trust, appealed a decision by the Valuer-General concerning the valuation of a shopping centre site. The dispute involved the assessment of the site's value, including issues of comparable sales, the impact of a development approval, and the effect of the site's volumetric and heritage listing status. The case was heard in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales.

The central legal issues before the court were whether a sale by a liquidator could be considered bona fide, the extent to which development approval added value to a comparable sale, and the appropriateness of using certain sales as comparables. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the land area rate derived from comparable sales should be discounted for the heritage listing of the lot, and whether a gross floor rate should also be adjusted accordingly. Another issue was whether the volumetric constraints of the lot were adequately reflected in the valuation, and whether a proposed novel method of applying differential rates to different levels of the lot was appropriate.

The court found that the sale by the liquidator was not bona fide due to the circumstances surrounding the sale. The development approval did not add value to the comparable sales as it was not the primary factor in those sales. The court also determined that the sales relied upon were not entirely comparable due to differences in the sites' conditions and constraints. Regarding the heritage listing, the court upheld the discount applied to the land area rate but found that the gross floor rate should also be reduced to account for the heritage listing. The court rejected the owner's proposed novel method, stating that the discount applied by the Valuer-General sufficiently reflected the volumetric constraints of the lot.

The final orders of the court included a reduction in the site value to reflect the volumetric constraints and heritage listing, but not in the manner proposed by the owner. The court upheld the Valuer-General's approach, with specific adjustments to account for the heritage listing. The appeal was partially successful, with the court ordering a reassessment of the site value in accordance with its findings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Macarthur Central Shopping Centre Pty Ltd as TTE (the appellant) challenged the valuation of their property conducted by the Valuer-General under the Property Law Act 1974 (NSW). The property in question is a volumetric lot located in Macarthur, which is heritage-listed. The appellant argued that the Valuer-General's assessment of the property's value did not adequately reflect certain factors, including the volumetric nature of the lot, the heritage listing, and the impact of these factors on the comparability of sales. The appellant submitted that the Valuer-General did not properly discount the value derived from comparable sales to account for the volumetric limitations and heritage listing of the lot. The appellant proposed an alternative method of valuation, applying differential rates to different levels of the volumetric lot. The Valuer-General argued that the valuation appropriately reflected the constraints on developing the lot arising from its volumetric nature and heritage listing.

This case came before the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales. The matter was initially heard in the Land and Environment Court, with the appellant lodging an appeal against the Valuer-General's valuation under section 64D of the Property Law Act 1974 (NSW). The appellant argued that the valuation did not adequately reflect the volumetric nature of the lot and the impact of the heritage listing on the comparability of sales. The appellant also proposed an alternative method of valuation, which the Valuer-General opposed. The case was heard by the Land and Environment Court, which considered the arguments of both parties and the evidence presented.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether a sale by liquidator was bona fide and if it was a suitable comparable sale for the purpose of assessing the value of the property.
2. Whether development approval added value to a comparable sale and if it should be considered in the valuation of the property.
3. Whether the sales relied upon by the Valuer-General were comparable to the subject property and if they adequately supported the assessed value.
4. Whether the value derived from comparable sales should be discounted to account for the volumetric nature of the lot and the heritage listing.
5. Whether a gross floor rate derived from comparable sales used to value the lot should also be reduced to account for the heritage listing.
6. Whether the proposed alternative method of valuation by the appellant, applying differential rates to different levels of the volumetric lot, should be adopted in the assessment of the property's value.

Held
1. The court concluded that the sale by the liquidator was bona fide and constituted a suitable comparable sale for the purpose of assessing the value of the property.
2. The court found that development approval did add value to a comparable sale and that this should be considered in the valuation of the property.
3. The court held that the sales relied upon by the Valuer-General were not comparable to the subject property and did not adequately support the assessed value.
4. The court determined that the value derived from comparable sales should be discounted to account for the volumetric nature of the lot and the heritage listing.
5. The court ruled that a gross floor rate derived from comparable sales should also be reduced to account for the heritage listing.
6. The court rejected the proposed alternative method of valuation by the appellant, applying differential rates to different levels of the volumetric lot, and upheld the Valuer-General's assessment of the property's value.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the bona fide nature of the sale by the liquidator, considering whether the sale reflected true market conditions. It found that the sale met the criteria for a bona fide transaction, thereby affirming its use as a comparable sale in assessing the property's value. Regarding the impact of development approval on the value of comparable sales, the court applied established principles that development approvals often enhance property value and should be factored into valuation assessments. This led to the conclusion that the value of comparable sales was indeed influenced by development approvals.

Further, the court analysed the comparability of the sales cited by the Valuer-General to the subject property, focusing on whether these sales adequately reflected the market value of the property in question. The court noted significant differences in the nature of the properties and the market conditions at the time of sale, leading to the conclusion that the sales were not suitable for directly supporting the assessed value.

The court then addressed the volumetric nature of the lot and the impact of the heritage listing on its value. It acknowledged the constraints imposed by the volumetric nature of the lot and the heritage listing, and applied the principle that such factors should be considered in discounting the value derived from comparable sales. The court upheld the Valuer-General's decision to discount the value but found that the gross floor rate derived from comparable sales should also be adjusted to account for the heritage listing.

Lastly, the court considered the appellant's proposed alternative valuation method, which involved applying differential rates to different levels of the volumetric lot. Despite acknowledging the novelty of this approach, the court concluded that it did not adequately reflect the constraints on developing the lot and upheld the Valuer-General's assessment method. The decision established that while volumetric and heritage constraints should be considered in property valuation, the method of valuation must be consistent with established principles and supported by comparable sales.