LZPS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

LZPS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2024] AATA 92 (31 January 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2023/1105, 2023/1106, 2023/1107

Re:LZPS

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndMSPS

JOINED PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member D. J. Morris

Date:31 January 2024

Place:Melbourne

The decision under review, which is the refusal by the Social Security and Child Support Division of the Tribunal under s 92 of the Child Support (Registrationand Collection) Act 1988 to extend time for a First Review, in relation to the decision of the Child Support Registrar not to extend time for consideration of objections to three decisions made on 24 November 2021, is itself affirmed.

..........................[SGN]..............................................

Senior Member D. J. Morris

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – extension of time – provisions in AAT Act regarding extending time not applicable in this case – applicant seeks review of First Review decision of Tribunal to affirm a decision not to extend time to make an application to the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Tribunal – party joined as her interests identified as being affected – is it reasonable in all the circumstances to extend time – relevant factors – Tribunal decides not to extend time

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Englezos v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2023] FCA 31

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member D. J. Morris

31 January 2024

  1. On 24 November 2021 the Child Support Registrar (‘the Registrar’) made three decisions to refuse the Applicant’s request for an extension of time to object to three decisions made by the Registrar: a decision made on 9 December 2017 to apply a provisional income for LZPS of $49,071 for the 2016-17 financial year; a decision made on 9 March 2019 to apply provisional income for LZPS of $50,076 for the 2017-18 financial year; and a decision made on 6 June 2020 to apply a provisional income for LZPS of $51,151 for the 2019-20 financial year. These will be referred to as the original decisions.

  2. LZPS asked the Tribunal to review the Registrar’s refusal to extend time and, on 14 February 2023, the Social Services and Child Support Division (‘First Review’) refused to grant the extension of time, echoing the refusal decision.

  3. LZPS applied to the General Division of the Tribunal for review of the First Review decision.

    HEARING

  4. The application was heard on 16 November 2023. LZPS represented himself and made submissions. Ms Kathryn Lieschke, a seconded lawyer working for Services Australia, represented the Registrar.

  5. LZPS is the father of two minor children, who will be called ‘LM’ and ‘OM.’ The Tribunal formed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LZPS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 92
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) of a decision by the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Tribunal to refuse an extension of time. The applicant, LZPS, sought to challenge original decisions made by the Child Support Registrar concerning his adjusted taxable income for several financial years, which formed the basis for child support assessments. The Registrar had made initial decisions based on available information, and subsequent decisions were made to apply updated income figures from the date of notification, as permitted by the *Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989*. LZPS later provided updated income information, leading to further Registrar decisions.

The primary legal issue before the AAT was whether it was reasonable in all the circumstances to grant LZPS an extension of time to make an application to the Tribunal, notwithstanding that decisions not to extend time at first review are generally not subject to second review. The Tribunal was required to consider the relevant factors in determining whether to exercise its discretion to extend time, and whether the applicant had demonstrated a sufficient reason for the delay in seeking review of the Registrar's decisions.

The Tribunal reasoned that decisions made by a Member of the Tribunal at first review not to extend time are procedural and discretionary, and therefore not typically reviewable under s 43(1) of the *Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975*. However, the Tribunal accepted that it had jurisdiction to consider the applicant's request. The Tribunal found that LZPS had been properly notified of the Registrar's decisions and his right to seek review, and that he had chosen not to act on these notifications. The Tribunal considered LZPS's assertion that he had lost the relevant letters and that they were not ready until sent by post, but found this implausible given his own correspondence acknowledging receipt of the letters. The Tribunal concluded that LZPS had rested on his rights and that the Child Support Agency was entitled to believe the decisions should stand in the absence of any indication of an intention to challenge them.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision of the First Review Member not to extend time.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal also took into account the Registrar’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and written submissions from the Applicant.BACKGROUND As mentioned above, the Applicant is the father of two minor children, LM who was born in 2011 and OM who was born in 2014 (TD, p 72). On 9 December 2017 the Registrar made a decision that LZPS’s adjusted taxable income for the 2016-2017 financial year was $49,071 (being an amount equal to two-thirds of the annual Male Total Average Weekly Earnings (‘MTAWE’) figure), pursuant to s 58 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (‘Assessment Act’) in circumstances where a tax assessment had not been issued for the last relevant financial year. This was original decision one. On 19 February 2019, the Registrar was notified of a PAYG payment summary showing taxable income for LZPS of $3,516 for the 2016-2017 financial year (TD, pp 74 and 77). The same day the Registrar decided to apply the income to the 2016-2017 financial year but only for the period from 19 February 2019 to 19 April 2019 because, pursuant to s 58A of the Assessment Act, the updated income could only be applied from the date of notification. On 9 March 2019, the Registrar decided that LZPS’s adjusted taxable income for the 2017-2018 financial year was $50,076 (being an amount equal to two-thirds of the annualised MTAWE figure) for the period from 20 April 2019 to 19 July 2020 (TD, p 85). Again, this decision was made pursuant to s 58A of the Assessment Act in a case where a tax assessment had not been issued for the last relevant financial year. This was original decision two. On 21 November 2019 LZPS provided the Registrar with updated income of $7,187 for the 2017-2018 financial year (TD, pp 96 and 106). The same day the Registrar decided to apply the income to the 2017-2018 financial year but only from 21 November 2019 (the date of notification) to 19 July 2020. On 6 June 2020, the Registrar decided that LZPS’s adjusted taxable income for the 2019-2020 financial year was $51,151 (being an amount equal to two-thirds of the annualised MTAWE figure) for the period 20 July 2020 to 19 October 2021 (TD, p 108). Again, this decision was made pursuant to s 58A of the Assessment Act in a case where a tax assessment had not been issued for the last relevant financial year. This was original decision three. On 23 December 2020, the Registrar was notified of a PAYG payment summary which showed the taxable income for LZPS for the 2019-2020 financial year was $16,072 (TD, p 122). The same day the Registrar decided to apply the income to the 2019-2010 financial year but only from 23 December 2020 (the date of notification) to 19 October 2021. On 19 October 2021 LZPS provided an income tax declaration of $16,074 for the 2019-2020 financial year which the Registrar accepted.PROCEDURAL Ordinarily, decisions made by Social Services and Child Support Division of this Tribunal at First Review not to extend time in relation to an application are not reviewable at Second Review. That is because such decisions are procedural in nature and a Member of the Tribunal is making a decision applying the provisions of s 29(7) of the AAT Act and exercising his or her discretion as to whether or not it is reasonable in all the circumstances to extend time. They are not decisions under s 43(1) of the AAT Act to affirm, set aside or vary a reviewable decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal accepts that the relationship between the Applicant and the Other Party had deteriorated. but this audiotape is evidence of a domestic argument, not one that amounts to satisfying a definition of domestic violence.Notification of the refusal decisions The problem for the Applicant is that he asserted that he asked the Child Support Agency only to deal with him by post. That is self-evidently not the case. He actually asked for communications to be in writing, i.e. by either email or post. This is reflected in a letter from Services Australia to LZPS on 2 June 2021 which relevantly states:I have not tried to contact you by telephone out of respect for your request for contact with us to be in writing only. Underlining that the Applicant was content to be contacted by email is the positive evidence in his 25 November 2021 in which he writes (with file numbers redacted):I acknowledge receipt of the following letters:Extension of Time Decision Refused - $47,504.00Extension of Time Decision Refused - $50.076.00Extension of Time Decision Refused - $51,151.00Extension of Time Decision Refused - $49,071.00Open exchange of information The Tribunal is satisfied that LZPS was properly notified of the outcome of his objections and his entitlement to seek review, but that he chose not to act. In this respect, he rested on his rights. The Child Support Agency and MSPS were entitled to believe, in the absence of any indication from the Applicant that he intended to challenge the decisions, that the decisions should stand. I am further satisfied there is positive evidence that LZPS received notification of the various decisions. His earlier assertion that he required correspondence only to be mailed was rightly withdrawn by him during the hearing, because the evidence is clear that he was responsive to emails, consistent with his request for communications to be in writing (but not necessarily sent by post). After the hearing leave was given for both the Applicant and the Other Party to lodge written submissions. I observe that a large amount of the contents of the submissions lodged by LZPS and then responded to by MSPS traverse matters relating to the care of the children, disputes before the courts and the historical nature of the break-up of their relationship. While no doubt of great importance to them, these points are not relevant to the Tribunal in considering whether or not to extend time. In his post-hearing submissions dated 18 October 2023, LZPS relevantly said:…the letters relevant to the refusal by Service Australia to grant me an extension of time were not ready (and actually lost) until sent by via post mail. The Tribunal finds this implausible, given the Applicant himself wrote explicitly that he had received the several letters advising of the decisions to refuse to extend time. If he did not read them in detail, then that is his responsibility. If he lost them, but did not follow up for a substantial temporal period, then that is not a valid reason to exercise the discretion to extend time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal considered whether it was reasonable in all the circumstances to extend the time for the Applicant to make an application to the Social Services and Child Support Division. The decision highlighted that such decisions are inherently procedural and involve the Tribunal exercising its discretion under s 29(7) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). The Tribunal noted that while the relationship between the Applicant and the Other Party had deteriorated, this alone did not constitute a compelling reason to extend time. The Tribunal found that the deterioration of their relationship, while relevant, did not satisfy the definition of domestic violence, and thus, did not warrant an extension of time.

The Tribunal also examined whether the deteriorated relationship should be considered a relevant factor in the decision to extend time. The Tribunal concluded that the deterioration of the relationship, though significant, did not meet the threshold for being a relevant factor. The Tribunal focused on the procedural aspect of the decision, emphasizing that the extension of time is not typically granted based on personal relationship issues but rather on procedural fairness and the merits of the application.

Further, the Tribunal considered the Applicant's request for written communications only. It was noted that the Applicant had acknowledged receipt of several emails and had responded to them, indicating that he was indeed receiving and engaging with written communications. The Tribunal found that the Applicant's request for written communications did not preclude the Child Support Agency and the Member of the Social Services and Child Support Division from sending notifications via email, which the Applicant had confirmed receiving.

The Tribunal evaluated the Applicant's assertion that he did not receive or read the letters regarding the refusal of his extension of time requests. The Tribunal found this assertion implausible given the Applicant's explicit acknowledgment of receipt of the letters in his written submissions. The Tribunal emphasized that if the Applicant did not read the letters in detail, that was his responsibility. The Tribunal also found the Applicant's assertion that the letters were lost to be unconvincing, particularly given that he did not follow up on this matter for a substantial period.

Finally, the Tribunal assessed whether the assertion that the letters were lost should be considered a relevant factor in deciding whether to extend time. The Tribunal found this assertion to be unpersuasive and not a valid reason for extending time. The Tribunal underscored that if the Applicant had lost the letters but did not take steps to follow up for an extended period, it was not a justifiable reason to exercise the discretion to extend time.

In summary, the Tribunal decided not to extend time based on the procedural nature of the decision, the lack of compelling evidence that the deteriorated relationship warranted an extension, the Applicant's acknowledgment of receiving written communications, and the implausible nature of the assertions regarding the loss of letters. The ratio decidendi is that the Tribunal will not extend time based on deteriorated personal relationships, unsubstantiable claims of non-receipt or loss of correspondence, and the Applicant's failure to follow up on such claims in a timely manner.