Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd v Kedron Caravans Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

DESIGNS ACT 2003



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF DESIGNS WITH REASONS

Re:Request for revocation by Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd of Australian design number 201912935 in the name of Kedron Caravans Pty Ltd

Delegate:

Nicholas Barbey

Representation:

Requestor: Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd

Owner: Kedron Caravans Pty Ltd

Decision:

2022 ADO 1

Request for revocation of a design under section 51 of the Designs Act 2003 (Cth) – insufficient evidence that a person other than the registered owner is an entitled person in relation to Australian design number 201912935 – registration of design not revoked.

Background

  1. This decision concerns a request for revocation of Australian design number 201912935 (‘Design’) on grounds relating to entitled persons under s 51 of the Designs Act 2003 (Cth) (‘Act’).

  2. The Design was filed on 20 May 2019 and registered on 30 June 2019 (‘Application’). Reproduced below are its relevant details:

    Design number:            201912935

    Owner:Kedron Caravans Pty Ltd (‘Owner’)

    Designer:David Gall

    Product name:              Caravan

    Representations:[1]       

[1] The full set of representations of the Design are reproduced in Annexure A to this decision.

Statement of Newness and Distinctiveness (‘SoND’):  

The newness of this product is the ability to fit / retrofit into a standard wind-up hatch 14-inch square recess of a caravan or RV to now pressurise the internal cabin with an integrated high volume fan to draw air through a flow tested filter for a positive pressure to resist dust entry through gas vents, and the distinctiveness is a complete new unique design that allows the owner to internally access the replacement filter via a drop swing door to change out or wash their air filter when required.

  1. On 11 July 2019, Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd (‘Requestor’) requested revocation of the registration of the Design based on grounds relating to entitled persons (‘Request’). The Requestor claimed that it was an entitled person in relation to the Design. The Request stated:    

    The design application 201912935 submitted by Kedron Caravans, is false as this is a direct copy of what we have been selling to the market for approximately the last 2 years. We have evidence of Kedron approaching us earlier in the year looking for information regarding our CP700 Carafan Sahara caravan pressuriser. We also have evidence of a leint [sic] we sold to who took it to Kedron for installation. They would have seen the unit then and copied it. They submitted an application to IP Australia under false information and copy infringement. Lyons has since sent Kedron a legal warning to “Cease and Desist Copy Infringement” for the Lyons Carafan Sahara pressuriser.

    Lyons has design documents, marketing material, customer invoices, images and manufacturing documentation to prove the unit was origianlly [sic] designed, invented and distributed [to] the market well before Kedron was aware of the unit. We can also show evidence that Kedron approached us for information and falsely misled IP Australia…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd v Kedron Caravan... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ADO 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd lodged a request for the revocation of Australian design number 201912935 registered in the name of Kedron Caravans Pty Ltd. Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd claimed that the design was a direct copy of a design it had previously developed and distributed to the market. It further alleged that Kedron Caravans Pty Ltd had approached it seeking information about the design. In light of these circumstances, Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd submitted that it was an entitled person in relation to the design. The central issue for determination was whether Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd was an entitled person in relation to the design. The Delegate of the Registrar of Designs considered the evidence filed by the parties. In particular, the Delegate examined the history of the development of the design in question and compared the visual features of the design with those of the design alleged to have been copied. The Delegate found that the evidence did not support the proposition that the design in question was a direct copy of the design alleged to have been copied. The Delegate found that there were significant visual differences between the two designs and that the alleged similarities were not sufficient to establish that Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd was an entitled person in relation to the design. Accordingly, the request for revocation was unsuccessful and the registration of the design was not revoked.

Background

Background to the litigation

Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd (Lyons) filed a request for revocation of Australian design number 201912935 (Design) on the grounds that it was an entitled person to the Design. The Design was filed on 20 May 2019 and registered on 30 June 2019 by Kedron Caravans Pty Ltd (Kedron). Lyons claimed that Kedron's design infringed upon its own caravan air pressurisation unit design, referred to as the Carafan. Lyons argued that Kedron had access to the Carafan and that the Design was a direct copy of the Carafan. Lyons provided evidence including design documents, marketing material, customer invoices, images, and manufacturing documentation to support its claims. Kedron contested the revocation request, and the matter was referred to a delegate of the Registrar of Designs for determination.

On 11 July 2019, Lyons submitted a request for revocation of the Design's registration to the Designs Office. The Designs Office informed Kedron of the request and sought clarification as to whether it would be contested. Kedron responded that it would be contesting the request. The Designs Office invited both parties to file evidence and/or written submissions. Lyons filed Evidence in Support (EIS) followed by Evidence in Answer (EIA) from Kedron. Lyons then filed Evidence in Reply (EIR). An oral hearing was not requested, and neither party filed written submissions. The matter was allocated to Nicholas Barbey, a delegate of the Registrar of Designs, for determination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was Lyons or any other person an entitled person in relation to the Design at the time of its registration under section 51 of the Designs Act 2003 (Cth)?
2. Did the evidence provided by Lyons establish that Kedron was not an entitled person to the Design at the time of its registration?

Held
1. The Delegate concluded that Lyons Airconditioning Services (WA) Pty Ltd (Lyons) or any other person was not an entitled person in relation to the Design at the time of its registration under section 51 of the Designs Act 2003 (Cth).
2. The Delegate found that the evidence provided by Lyons did not establish that Kedron Caravans Pty Ltd (Kedron) was not an entitled person to the Design at the time of its registration.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Delegate considered the evidence provided by both parties to determine whether Kedron was the sole entitled person to the Design at the time of its registration. The Delegate examined the definition of an "entitled person" under section 5 of the Act, which includes the designer of the design or a person who derives title from the designer. The Delegate noted that Lyons bore the burden of proving that someone other than Kedron was an entitled person or that Kedron was not an entitled person at the time of registration.

The Delegate assessed Lyons' evidence, which included declarations from Lyons' employees and correspondence between Lyons and Kedron. Lyons argued that Kedron had actual knowledge of and direct access to Lyons' Carafan product, which was on the market before the Design was registered. Lyons also contended that the Design was a "direct copy" of the Carafan, implying that Lyons' employees designed the Design.

However, the Delegate found that the evidence did not support Lyons' claims. The Delegate observed that there were significant visual differences between the Carafan and the Design, and the evidence did not establish that Lyons' employees designed the Design. The Delegate also noted that the similarities between the two designs could be attributed to the designer considering the prior art base, including the Carafan, as allowed under the Act.

Furthermore, the Delegate highlighted that the evidence provided by Lyons was inconsistent and did not form a unified representation of the Carafan. The Delegate concluded that Lyons had failed to prove that any of its employees were the designers of the Design or that they were otherwise entitled to proprietorship of the Design.

Based on the evidence before the Delegate, it was not satisfied that Lyons or any other person was an entitled person at the time of the Design's registration. Consequently, the Request for revocation was unsuccessful, and the registration of Australian design number 201912935 was not revoked. The Delegate's decision was based on the lack of sufficient evidence to establish that someone other than Kedron was an entitled person to the Design at the time of its registration.